Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be glad that the Down Syndrome abortion appeal was defeated

904 replies

Fififafa · 25/11/2022 12:30

A woman with DS has twice tried and failed to get the courts to outlaw abortion beyond 24 weeks for foetuses with DS. Under current legislation for England, Wales and Scotland, there is a 24-week time limit for abortion, unless "there is a substantial risk that if the child were born it would suffer from such physical or mental abnormalities as to be seriously handicapped", which includes Down's syndrome.
I read that she has is being supported by some religious group.

I’m glad that the appeal was lost. This is a personal decision that every woman has the choice and the right to make. What Heidi Crowter et al are doing, is fighting to remove that choice from women. AIBU?

OP posts:
RodiganReed · 25/11/2022 13:47

Peedoffo · 25/11/2022 13:16

Heidi Crowter is the acceptable face of downs syndrome that's presented to the media. She's high functioning. You cannot predict what the presentation will be. Many people with downs syndrome have severe behavioural challenges , doubly incontinence need 24/7 care and will live in care homes or secure services. Many won't ever be able to work or talk. Heidi is very lucky and I get annoyed with the DS lobby who only ever present the best case scenario. The others get forgotten.

Parenting a disabled child is very difficult and that choice is for parent to decide. Our support systems for disabled children are awful over here.

It's not the DS lobby behind this case, it's the Christian right. The UK's Downs Syndrome Association for example did not come out in support.

MintyFreshOne · 25/11/2022 13:46

Demigo · 25/11/2022 13:35

This. I’m delighted my child, who has Down syndrome, exists.

I’m not interested in limiting women’s reproductive rights or choices.

There’s, as ever, a lot of ableism on this thread that makes difficult reading. You can support women’s rights, disagree with Heidi, and also recognise that the vast majority of people with DS and their families have good quality lives. But it’d be easier with better access to support and less assumptions and ableism!

Downs Syndrome is vanishingly rare in countries with the best support systems. People just don’t want a child with this condition and no amount of support or funding is going to change that. When you only have one or two children, you want them to be as healthy as possible. It’s unfair, but that’s life (so to speak)

Summerfun54321 · 25/11/2022 13:46

I’m so glad we live in a country that recognises the complexity of these heartbreaking issues and agree that improved support to families with disabled children is by far the preference to removing choice.

MyPurpleHeart · 25/11/2022 13:45

Its up to the mother and no one else. No one makes this decision lightly and anyone judging just doesn't fucking understand

Cherrytree77 · 25/11/2022 13:43

Fantastic news. I know it would be a heartbreaking decision I hope I never have to face - I have friends who have severely disabled children and that's the rest of their life now as a carer and all the worry that comes with that. There was a post here last week of a woman caring for an adult child with disabilities and reading it was eye opening.

fancyacuppatea · 25/11/2022 13:43

CoastalWave · 25/11/2022 12:33

24 weeks is more than enough bloody time to realise you don't want a baby imo.

Think its disgraceful you can abort at all past 16 weeks but there you go.

Oh piss off.
You have no idea how life changes when you find your unborn child has a disability. I do.

I am 100% behind full-term abortion in the case of severe abnomalities and disabilities.

It is ALWAYS the right of the mother to choose.

antelopevalley · 25/11/2022 13:41

Demigo · 25/11/2022 13:35

This. I’m delighted my child, who has Down syndrome, exists.

I’m not interested in limiting women’s reproductive rights or choices.

There’s, as ever, a lot of ableism on this thread that makes difficult reading. You can support women’s rights, disagree with Heidi, and also recognise that the vast majority of people with DS and their families have good quality lives. But it’d be easier with better access to support and less assumptions and ableism!

Further tests mean that most babies with DS alongside many other issues are aborted. So most of the DS children born these days do tend to be more high functioning.
Children and adults with severe disabilities can have a good quality of life. But it can also destroy families. I find it hard enough having two DC and a DH with a genetic disorder and they are nowhere near having a severe disability. But it still has a negative impact on them and me.

TimBoothseyes · 25/11/2022 13:41

clpsmum · 25/11/2022 12:46

I personally feel if you don't want a baby with Down's syndrome then you shouldn't be allowed to have a baby. I know this is controversial and many will agree. But if a person doesn't want a disabled baby of any kind they shouldn't have a baby in my opinion. Disability can happen at any moment

My baby would have been blind ,deaf, unable to speak, move, fed by tube and a whole host of other things. In what world is that a "life"? Trust me if he had been a DS baby I would not have terminated at 26 weeks, but there was no way I was going to let my child live a (very) short "life" as nothing more than a living corpse. I loved him too much to inflict that horror on him.

Blossomtoes · 25/11/2022 13:38

Absolutely, not absorbs. Bloody autocorrect.

2bazookas · 25/11/2022 13:38

@bananas Downs syndrome and other fatal syndromes get tested at 12 weeks

Educate yourself.

NHS;

www.gov.uk/guidance/fetal-anomaly-screening-programme-overview#target-population'

"Screening for 11 physical conditions as part of the 20-week scan is offered to all pregnant women and takes place between 18⁺ and 20 weeks of pregnancy. Scans can be completed up to 23 weeks of pregnancy.

Blossomtoes · 25/11/2022 13:38

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 25/11/2022 13:30

When I read threads like these I can clearly see that what is happening in america is going to happen here. When women won't even stand up for other womens right to choose then there is no hope is there. I am genuinely glad that I am too old to get pregnant and need an abortion. It honestly scares me.

This. I’m in the very fortunate position of having never been pregnant without wanting to be. It absorbs horrifies me that women are being deprived of their rights across the pond and that a disabled woman is being used in a cynical attempt to do the same here. It’s scandalous.

WindsweptNotInteresting · 25/11/2022 13:38

ElephantInTheKitchen · 25/11/2022 13:29

The court case that was defeated today sought to reduce the time limit for all abortions, regardless of reason, to 24 weeks, so they're not missing the point at all.

I'm responding to all those saying that the poster who said "by 24 weeks you should know whether you want the baby" is awful, because a lot of issues aren't detected until later in the pregnancy.

There is a difference between saying 24 weeks is too high for healthy pregnancies (which is what I assume PP meant) and 24 weeks should be the limit for all pregnancies regardless of any medical issues (which I do not agree with). But that second part wasn't what I was replying to.

ElephantInTheKitchen · 25/11/2022 13:37

I'm so sorry you're going through this @georgarina

---

FWIW I have a genetic physical disability. Though I lead an independent life, I'm also completely comfortable with the idea that I might have been aborted if my parents had known.

Ironically my disability means my back is really crap and I can't do much lifting. That in itself would mean having a disabled child who couldn't walk and needed lifting a lot would be utterly impractical for me, and if I found myself in this situation it would be yet another reason to abort. I know someone with a severely disabled 7 year old who is still trying to get the council to provide a hoist, and meanwhile she's expected to lift her child despite it causing back pain (and she has a normal back!)

Funny how the pro lifers never spend their time fighting for better support for existing disabled children and parents. I'm sure that seeing the woeful lack of support has been a contributing factor for more than a few women who do choose to terminate.

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 13:37

Yanbu. The number of abortions post 24 weeks in uk is miniscule and it tends to only happen in exceptional circumstances. Some infants with severe manifestations of DS have health impacts that mean they will not survive at birth, as is the case with other serious health issues.

There are people who go into a 20 week scan at 21 weeks, to find they are carrying a foetus with for eg, brain or other major organ malformations incompatible with life outside the uterus.

These are not people choosing to end a successful pregnancy. Often they are being given the choice to bring forward an almost inevitable stillbirth or neonatal death so as to limit the risk to the mother of continuing a pregnancy

flamingogold · 25/11/2022 13:36

Privatestate1 · 25/11/2022 13:11

I think the case in point here is the fact that it’s illegal to get an abortion past 24 weeks for ‘healthy’ fetus, but for DS it’s legal right up until the baby starts moving through the birth canal, at full term (I think) thus implying that a DS baby is worth less than a ‘healthy’ baby…it is discriminatory against people with DS IMO.

The right to abort for disability would have to remain for anything other than DS so DS would become a different category of disability.

What would happen in practice, is that instead of having the results of the 12 week tests followed by CVS and then heart scans etc at 20 weeks to try and understand the extent of the issues alongside DS, the clock would be ticking.
Most people - 99%- are likely to abort as soon as possible rather than risking the time running out.

boboshmobo · 25/11/2022 13:36

I have a child with SN similar to Downs . I didn't know but I still think you should be allowed to abort right up to birth if the child is incompatible with life or will have severe SN ..

As above it's your choice !

Endlesssummer2022 · 25/11/2022 13:35

Fififafa · 25/11/2022 13:32

Sadly it appears that they are now taking their case to the Supreme Court

Why won’t she stay out of other peoples business?

Demigo · 25/11/2022 13:35

bookworm14 · 25/11/2022 13:28

I also know an adult with Down’s syndrome: my younger sibling. I am delighted they exist, but am still not in favour of restricting women’s reproductive rights.

If these campaigners actually want to improve things for people with down’s and other disabilities, they should advocate for greater support from government for disabled people and their families. Many parents of disabled children are on their knees.

This. I’m delighted my child, who has Down syndrome, exists.

I’m not interested in limiting women’s reproductive rights or choices.

There’s, as ever, a lot of ableism on this thread that makes difficult reading. You can support women’s rights, disagree with Heidi, and also recognise that the vast majority of people with DS and their families have good quality lives. But it’d be easier with better access to support and less assumptions and ableism!

aldilemonade · 25/11/2022 13:34

Some of the shit on here is outrageous giving birth to babies and watching them struggle to breath until they die is the most disgusting thing I have read on here
how dare you put shit like that on here
i am one of those awful human beings who has had to make the decision to terminate my pregnancy at 25+4 days due to my little boy having a condition that would have made his life awful
i had to go to a hospital to have a professor inject something into my babies heart and they scanned him to make sure that his heart had stopped before I had to deliver him
im not going to lie it was awful
BUT
I do not regret my decision
My son was a very much wanted baby but I was not going to be selfish enough to continue the pregnancy just to have him in my life when his life would have been very bad for him and I also had to think of my two older children.
I am sure that women who terminate a pregnancy at 24 weeks do not do it lightly and for those of you that even think that there is something wrong with you.

Endlesssummer2022 · 25/11/2022 13:33

clpsmum · 25/11/2022 12:46

I personally feel if you don't want a baby with Down's syndrome then you shouldn't be allowed to have a baby. I know this is controversial and many will agree. But if a person doesn't want a disabled baby of any kind they shouldn't have a baby in my opinion. Disability can happen at any moment

I will bet money you’ve completed your family and all of your children were born healthy. It’s like those super fertile women who are against fertility treatment for others.

AuntieEntity · 25/11/2022 13:33

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 25/11/2022 13:30

When I read threads like these I can clearly see that what is happening in america is going to happen here. When women won't even stand up for other womens right to choose then there is no hope is there. I am genuinely glad that I am too old to get pregnant and need an abortion. It honestly scares me.

Margaret Atwood always said that the terrifying thing about The Handmaid's Tale was that everything in it had happened, somewhere in the world at some point, to women. We have become complacent of our rights.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 25/11/2022 13:33

CoastalWave · 25/11/2022 12:33

24 weeks is more than enough bloody time to realise you don't want a baby imo.

Think its disgraceful you can abort at all past 16 weeks but there you go.

Then don’t YOU abort after 16 weeks then.

And everyone else can do as they see fit too

Fififafa · 25/11/2022 13:32

Bigbadfish · 25/11/2022 12:43

Incouldbt be happier at the news. I hope this woman now learns to shut up and mind her own business.

Sadly it appears that they are now taking their case to the Supreme Court

OP posts:
GloomyDarkness · 25/11/2022 13:32

this would probably end up with a lot more abortions as if women were not allowed to abort after 24 weeks, then some of them would terminate before having the full information

I was thinking this as well.

Soniastrumped · 25/11/2022 13:32

CoastalWave · 25/11/2022 12:33

24 weeks is more than enough bloody time to realise you don't want a baby imo.

Think its disgraceful you can abort at all past 16 weeks but there you go.

Amniocentesis is carried out at between 15 to 20 weeks, I was close to 20 weeks when I had mine.
It revealed a life limiting chromosome disorder plus a pretty catastrophic heart anomaly.
I terminated 2 weeks later. Fortunately I can live with myself that you are disgraced.

Perhaps educate yourself a little before judging, there are many reasons for terminations.