Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be glad that the Down Syndrome abortion appeal was defeated

904 replies

Fififafa · 25/11/2022 12:30

A woman with DS has twice tried and failed to get the courts to outlaw abortion beyond 24 weeks for foetuses with DS. Under current legislation for England, Wales and Scotland, there is a 24-week time limit for abortion, unless "there is a substantial risk that if the child were born it would suffer from such physical or mental abnormalities as to be seriously handicapped", which includes Down's syndrome.
I read that she has is being supported by some religious group.

I’m glad that the appeal was lost. This is a personal decision that every woman has the choice and the right to make. What Heidi Crowter et al are doing, is fighting to remove that choice from women. AIBU?

OP posts:
NadjaCravensworth · 17/03/2023 19:05

HappyScotch · 16/03/2023 02:02

so fucking what?

Exactly

What's worse, a woman (probably imaginary...) having access to safe healthcare or 5 children being born to a human incubator?

IncessantNameChanger · 17/03/2023 16:08

I think as a parent of a disabled child, your perceived ability of how you would cope is 100%. There's nothing ablist or disablist about knowing what you can and can't do based on the facts available to you. It should be a personal choice free from judgement and as simple as that. Do you want to? Do you not? Nothing else.

Demigo · 17/03/2023 16:06

@pointythings yes I completely agree with you

@whumpthereitis I can see where you’re coming from, but I don’t think in general we’re suffering from a surplus of positive takes on disability. Most people, when they talk about their children, think they’re brilliant. I don’t feel obliged with my typical child to say I think they’re wonderful but also to always caveat that they have tantrums etc. I’m not balanced, I’m their mum.

Most of the advocacy groups I can think of are also fierce campaigners around education, work training, etc. I’m not convinced they’re pretending negative experiences don’t exist. I agree that abortion rights can’t be collateral damage in this but equally disability rights can’t be collateral damage of fighting for abortion rights.

JaneFondue · 17/03/2023 15:34

Does anyone know what has happened to Heidi's appeal? Still pending?

whumpthereitis · 17/03/2023 14:32

Demigo · 17/03/2023 12:06

I think there’s a lot in this. One consequence of this is the degree to which people find it hard to believe that life with a disabled child can be fulfilling and joyful, even with challenges. You see it a lot: “oh, it must be because your child is high functioning” or “it must be because you have an anti-choice agenda” or indeed “not all people with DS are like Heidi”. I once saw someone claim it was because parents of kids with DS were bitter and wanted others to suffer too (I can’t remember if that was this thread or a previous one). Whereas if someone talks about a difficult or challenging experience it’s immediately accepted as not just fact (and I’m not disputing the lived experience of those individuals) but representative of all experiences. There’s also ableism embedded in all of that - high functioning or close to normal is the best you can hope for and advocacy or even just talking about your experience must have an ulterior motive.

There’s a lot of confirmation bias going on

And arguably, THAT is a consequence of the most visible advocacy groups only presenting the positive stories. Understandably there is a desire to challenge ableism, but you cannot reasonably do so by denying women options, or by pretending negative experiences don’t exist.

pointythings · 17/03/2023 14:17

@Demigo I agree that ableism needs to be tackled hard, and that includes a complete redesign of the world we live in. One of my DC is disabled - physical health issues requiring a wheelchair, autism and mental ill health, so the full whammy. This happened in their teens, so not the same situation, but it does really open your eyes to all the ways in which this world is ableist.

However, none of that is a good reason to deny women the choice of whether or not they want to knowingly take that on. No matter what, chipping away at abortion rights is a dangerous path. And ultimately the people behind Heidi Crowter, and probably Heidi herself, are about doing just that and should be stopped. You can advocate against ableism without taking away a woman's right to choose.

Demigo · 17/03/2023 12:06

Untitledsquatboulder · 17/03/2023 08:02

@SnotRag22 I don't disagree with you at all. My point is that when you start characterising people who choose not to terminate for disability as "selfish and irresponsible" or lump all disabilities into a group marked "burden" or claim that all fetuses with the wrong number of chromosomes need to be relieved of their
lives as a kindness to prevent their suffering then that has real world consequences for the way society views and treats disabled children and adults.

I think there’s a lot in this. One consequence of this is the degree to which people find it hard to believe that life with a disabled child can be fulfilling and joyful, even with challenges. You see it a lot: “oh, it must be because your child is high functioning” or “it must be because you have an anti-choice agenda” or indeed “not all people with DS are like Heidi”. I once saw someone claim it was because parents of kids with DS were bitter and wanted others to suffer too (I can’t remember if that was this thread or a previous one). Whereas if someone talks about a difficult or challenging experience it’s immediately accepted as not just fact (and I’m not disputing the lived experience of those individuals) but representative of all experiences. There’s also ableism embedded in all of that - high functioning or close to normal is the best you can hope for and advocacy or even just talking about your experience must have an ulterior motive.

There’s a lot of confirmation bias going on

Wiluli · 17/03/2023 11:20

Untitledsquatboulder · 17/03/2023 08:02

@SnotRag22 I don't disagree with you at all. My point is that when you start characterising people who choose not to terminate for disability as "selfish and irresponsible" or lump all disabilities into a group marked "burden" or claim that all fetuses with the wrong number of chromosomes need to be relieved of their
lives as a kindness to prevent their suffering then that has real world consequences for the way society views and treats disabled children and adults.

Well said

ToWhitToWhoo · 17/03/2023 11:12

CoastalWave · 25/11/2022 12:33

24 weeks is more than enough bloody time to realise you don't want a baby imo.

Think its disgraceful you can abort at all past 16 weeks but there you go.

No one has an abortion at 24 weeks because they've suddenly realized that they don't want a baby! It's either because the mother's life is in danger (and even then, by that stage you don't have an abortion; you deliver prematurely) or because the baby has a severe or fatal abnormality.

SnotRag22 · 17/03/2023 10:45

Untitledsquatboulder · 17/03/2023 08:02

@SnotRag22 I don't disagree with you at all. My point is that when you start characterising people who choose not to terminate for disability as "selfish and irresponsible" or lump all disabilities into a group marked "burden" or claim that all fetuses with the wrong number of chromosomes need to be relieved of their
lives as a kindness to prevent their suffering then that has real world consequences for the way society views and treats disabled children and adults.

In which xas, we are absolutely on the same page. And that's not something I'd ever advocate for.

RufustheSpeculatingreindeer · 17/03/2023 08:28

Iusedtobedontcall

💐

Untitledsquatboulder · 17/03/2023 08:02

@SnotRag22 I don't disagree with you at all. My point is that when you start characterising people who choose not to terminate for disability as "selfish and irresponsible" or lump all disabilities into a group marked "burden" or claim that all fetuses with the wrong number of chromosomes need to be relieved of their
lives as a kindness to prevent their suffering then that has real world consequences for the way society views and treats disabled children and adults.

SnotRag22 · 17/03/2023 07:06

@Untitledsquatboulder I only know a couple of children who have had craniosynostosis but they was diagnosed post birth. Mine both had cranio diagnosed in the womb, but it was a side effect of their spina bifida.

My point being, it isn't disingenuous to not want your baby to suffer. That is what drives the majority of late term TFMRs. It's being told the details of the diagnosis, being told the outcomes for each of the procedures and the likelihood of death at each stage. The prognosis and outcomes. The knock on effect. It's a complex and individual decision and incredibly traumatic.

Untitledsquatboulder · 16/03/2023 22:42

Oh and a kidney malformation.

Untitledsquatboulder · 16/03/2023 22:40

Craniosynostosis @SnotRag22

SnotRag22 · 16/03/2023 22:21

Iusedtobedontcall Sending love to you 💐

SnotRag22 · 16/03/2023 22:20

Untitledsquatboulder · 16/03/2023 19:01

It is. Wanting an abortion is a valid reason for an abortion. Presenting your decision as being made in the best interests of the fetus is a little disingenuous though.

What was your baby's diagnosis @Untitledsquatboulder ? I hope you don't mind my asking.

Iusedtobedontcall · 16/03/2023 21:28

I did genuinely consider the risk of childhood leukaemia and early onset dementia when I made my decision. I of course considered the impact on our lives and the impact on siblings too. I think any reason is valid and however a woman wants to frame that decision is perfectly valid too. It’s not a choice anyone wants to be faced with.

Untitledsquatboulder · 16/03/2023 19:01

FortSalem86 · 16/03/2023 18:49

I think aborting a child with down syndrome because you don't want your other children burdened with caring for their sibling when the parent dies is another perfectly valid reason for abortion.

It is. Wanting an abortion is a valid reason for an abortion. Presenting your decision as being made in the best interests of the fetus is a little disingenuous though.

ArabellaScott · 16/03/2023 18:51

Flowers Iusedtobedontcall

FortSalem86 · 16/03/2023 18:49

I think aborting a child with down syndrome because you don't want your other children burdened with caring for their sibling when the parent dies is another perfectly valid reason for abortion.

Iusedtobedontcall · 16/03/2023 18:45

I terminated last month for Downs, having not thought that I would. I found out very early because I had chosen to pay privately for a NIPT at ten weeks and I made my decision based on that, without waiting for the amniocentesis. Even then I was 12 weeks and that was because I had gone privately.
If I had gone through all the NHS tests and waited for amnio results, I would have been at least 18 weeks.

My decision was made because of the uncertainty- Downs is a spectrum and I had no way of knowing how severe it would be. The risk of early onset dementia terrified me and I didn’t want that for my daughter. The impact on our other children. I was devastated. I completely appreciate that many children with Downs live full and happy lives, but it would have been a massive gamble.

Fansandblankets · 16/03/2023 18:37

Yanbu. Very happy with the news.

I already had a child with disabilities when I fell pregnant with my 2nd child
I wanted to know for certain so had an amnio with both of my subsequent pregnancies. My sister had an abortion at 21weeks due to the baby having DS .

DS is a spectrum and can be life limiting. Not all people with DS will be as able as the young lady who brought the case.

Skydaze · 16/03/2023 18:30

As far as selfishness goes, bringing any child into the world is inherently selfish. You have a child because you want them, because they will give you the life you want, because they will make you feel fulfilled etc. The idea of an unselfish birth (ie abled) is a myth and massively harmful to anyone born 'not perfect'.

Additionally, any child born is brought into a world where they will suffer and die. Life itself is a terminal condition. We hope and believe it's worth it, but there is absolutely no guarantee whatsoever that the balance of suffering versus enjoyment in your child's life will tip the way you want it to. The babies of today - abled as well as disabled - are pretty much screwed, born into a world basically on fire, where we know they will be adults in a world of conflict, scarcer resources, and increasingly devastating natural disasters. We gamble on it being worth it because we want to - again, the idea of an unselfish birth or a suffering-free life (ie abled) is a myth and again causes huge harm to the disabled community.

Skydaze · 16/03/2023 18:14

@whatkatydid2013 I am very pro-tax, pro publicly funded initiatives and support for the disabled community. Beyond that I think our homes, cities and systems should all be designed for inclusivity, not just for the abled as they are now. I would back massive changes in those areas - from quiet hour at supermarkets for SPD individuals to elevators, ramps, wide doorways & toilet spaces for wheelchair users, to flexible work environments for people with neurodivergence, chronic fatigue and mental illnesses. Our abled society is just plain wrong in my view, it excludes and enforces misery on so many people and is a hierarchy that long needs abolishing. My sister says there's a difference between being welcoming and being truly inclusive - and we have a long long way to go on many fronts (physical disabilities and illness, mental illness, trauma, neurodivergence) to be anything more than a big fake smile and a pat on the back for trying.

Swipe left for the next trending thread