Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be glad that the Down Syndrome abortion appeal was defeated

904 replies

Fififafa · 25/11/2022 12:30

A woman with DS has twice tried and failed to get the courts to outlaw abortion beyond 24 weeks for foetuses with DS. Under current legislation for England, Wales and Scotland, there is a 24-week time limit for abortion, unless "there is a substantial risk that if the child were born it would suffer from such physical or mental abnormalities as to be seriously handicapped", which includes Down's syndrome.
I read that she has is being supported by some religious group.

I’m glad that the appeal was lost. This is a personal decision that every woman has the choice and the right to make. What Heidi Crowter et al are doing, is fighting to remove that choice from women. AIBU?

OP posts:
Miss03852 · 27/11/2022 12:20

Sometimes it's a case of the parent does not want a child with DS and that's not to say the child would not lead a happy life with another family

🤦‍♀️ Yeah because there are queues of people trying to adopt DS kids. And the situation would be 100x worse if this law was to be enacted.

whumpthereitis · 27/11/2022 12:17

JustAnotherManicMomday · 27/11/2022 11:53

All I'm saying is if you know the diagnosis and decided to carry on with the pregnancy then you shouldn't be able to change that decision later unless the prognosis is more severe. I think if the baby would survive and have a chance at life then shouldn't they be allowed to live. Sometimes it's a case of the parent does not want a child with DS and that's not to say the child would not lead a happy life with another family. At the very least this should be offered in a separate facility. Think about it this way.. you have 3 women on a ward, one has aborted their baby due to the child's health condition or possible condition at 39 weeks gestation,another has just delivered their stillborn child at 37 weeks gestation whilst a woman has delivered a baby at 29 weeks who is fighting for life in nicu. All mums are on the same ward.

Yet they’re all individuals, whose circumstances are also individual, whose treatment is, you guessed it, individual. Why does it matter what other women around them are doing? Why should X’s decision about her pregnancy have any impact on the care Y receives?

Circumstances are dynamic. They can change. What is feasible at 20 weeks may not be at 26 weeks. Thank fuck women in these horrible situations aren’t subject to your opinions.

Cuppasoupmonster · 27/11/2022 12:10

@JustAnotherManicMomday how many disabled children have you adopted?

Miss03852 · 27/11/2022 12:03

RodiganReed · 27/11/2022 10:11

What is your evidence for that please?

I have a lifetime (so 30 plus years) of experience in the disabled community (personal and professional) and I can tell you with authority that it is crammed full of empathetic, wise women who do not in any way fit your description. Because of their struggles many become real matriarch figures and are enormously supportive of other parents including those with non disabled children.

There's some right bullshit on this thread.

Did you not read the part where I said I think it’s my opinion!

And you’ll never find evidence of crab mentality as it’s not something people admit even to themselves. I’m sure the people you know cope well but a lot struggle and are unhappy, most people would not choose to be in that situation, and I question people who know how difficult it is trying desperately to force others into that situation involuntarily.

JustAnotherManicMomday · 27/11/2022 11:58

How is it OK to abort the 39 weeks gestation baby whilst trying to save the 29 week. That 29 week baby could also have severe complications and health conditions in life due to being premature. Their needs to be more clarity regarding criteria and what is considered a good quality of life.

Sockwomble · 27/11/2022 11:54

I am betting that anyone who thinks the abortion appeal should not have been defeated does not provide practical support for families who have severely disabled adult children particularly where there is challenging behaviour. In my experience they do not want to think about side of things and how awful the provision is from health and social care.

JustAnotherManicMomday · 27/11/2022 11:53

All I'm saying is if you know the diagnosis and decided to carry on with the pregnancy then you shouldn't be able to change that decision later unless the prognosis is more severe. I think if the baby would survive and have a chance at life then shouldn't they be allowed to live. Sometimes it's a case of the parent does not want a child with DS and that's not to say the child would not lead a happy life with another family. At the very least this should be offered in a separate facility. Think about it this way.. you have 3 women on a ward, one has aborted their baby due to the child's health condition or possible condition at 39 weeks gestation,another has just delivered their stillborn child at 37 weeks gestation whilst a woman has delivered a baby at 29 weeks who is fighting for life in nicu. All mums are on the same ward.

CaveMum · 27/11/2022 11:35

The other problem with a time limit limitation is it does not take into account a change in the woman’s circumstances.

Example - Mary is happily married with 2 children under 5, at her 20 wk scan she discovers that the foetus has a condition which, whilst not incompatible with life, will need high levels of care for the rest of his/her life. She talks with her husband and they agree to go ahead with the pregnancy.

Fast forward 4 weeks, Mary’s husband is involved in a car accident which leaves him with life changing injuries and unable to work. Mary is now faced with the prospect of caring for a disabled husband and 2 young children, as well as the new baby. With her husband losing his job they no longer have the income they anticipated and they feel they can no longer cope with the additional needs of a disabled child.

Should she be refused an abortion because she already knew about the baby’s condition?

Whilst these circumstances might be rare, they will happen to someone.

Cuppasoupmonster · 27/11/2022 11:32

RodiganReed · 27/11/2022 10:23

I agree but what I'm saying is that in my experience they are outliers, PP asserted that there's a "lot" of unconscious crab mentality in the disabled parenting community. I want to know what her evidence is for that because in my 30 plus years of experience I can only think of one birth parent who might have sympathy for this case (and one set of Christian foster carers).

Heidi and her Mum's views will be more mainstream in the US disabled community, but they're certainly not mainstream here.

Well virtually every single prominent DS parent has backed this campaign. Sarah Roberts, Maire Lea Wilson, Heidi’s mum, Claire Farrington, basically any parent with a platform that advocates for people with DS.

TimBoothseyes · 27/11/2022 10:55

JustAnotherManicMomday · 27/11/2022 09:57

Sorry but did EVERYONE MISS THE PART ABOUT IF YOU FOUND OUT AFTER THAT POINT THEN YOUVSHOULD HAVE THE OPTION IF AGREED BY MEDICAL STAFF. As in their should be a cut off point for those who are already aware of a problem with their pregnancy but for those who find out after that point they should have an option.

Being "aware of a problem" and getting absolute confirmation and a likely prognosis doesn't happen within a couple of days..you do know that right? It took 6 weeks for me to be told "there is a problem" at my 20 week scan to " I'm very sorry Tim but...." at 26 weeks. By which time the 24 week "limit" had been and gone.

pointythings · 27/11/2022 10:45

RodiganReed · 27/11/2022 10:26

I guess what I'm trying to say is that this thread risks setting up a false binary between the feminist pro-choice lobby and parents of disabled children - when in reality most of us are on the same side and it's the litigants in this case and the Christian right who are the 'opposition' for want of a better word.

I do agree with this, but this thread also shows that a lot of people either don't know or don't want to know what the reality of TMFR is and therefore why the law needs to either stay the same or change to implement equality in the direction Heidi and her people don't want.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 27/11/2022 10:40

JustAnotherManicMomday · 27/11/2022 09:57

Sorry but did EVERYONE MISS THE PART ABOUT IF YOU FOUND OUT AFTER THAT POINT THEN YOUVSHOULD HAVE THE OPTION IF AGREED BY MEDICAL STAFF. As in their should be a cut off point for those who are already aware of a problem with their pregnancy but for those who find out after that point they should have an option.

You mean, like a law saying that terminations are only legal after a certain gestation - maybe 24 weeks - in the event of there being a risk to the woman's health or a severe disability/medical condition? And because some conditions are not discovered or their severity realised until later in pregnancy, termination is legal up to the point at which a severe disability or medical condition can be discovered, assessed, the woman can make that decision or the medical facilities can be accessed for such a procedure during pregnancy?

Seems like quite a good idea, really. I wonder if anybody's ever thought of it before?

OodieBoogie · 27/11/2022 10:38

*(I'm SnotRag22)

OodieBoogie · 27/11/2022 10:37

JustAnotherManicMomday · 27/11/2022 09:57

Sorry but did EVERYONE MISS THE PART ABOUT IF YOU FOUND OUT AFTER THAT POINT THEN YOUVSHOULD HAVE THE OPTION IF AGREED BY MEDICAL STAFF. As in their should be a cut off point for those who are already aware of a problem with their pregnancy but for those who find out after that point they should have an option.

Why are you shouting? And honestly, I'd get deleted if I said what I wanted to.

You're clearly not understanding. A "cut off if you already knew" wouldn't work.

Late term TFMRs happen because the child's only option is suffering and death. Saying "Oh well you knew what you were getting into, no TFMR for you" would cause untold suffering to mothers and their babies.

Read my earlier post.
c
Lat term mpassionate inductions happen because the baby won't survive.

You find it unpalatable, you cannot fathom the depths of grief and hell that it causes the parents.

twinklystar23 · 27/11/2022 10:31

Maybe decriminalisation and a healthcare choice? Would be the way forward? Nothing that could be sensationalist/headline grabbing?

Need to watch any changes to the HRA. Or lobby to reinforce the right to a private and family life (MEDICAL) and correspondence?

whumpthereitis · 27/11/2022 10:30

JustAnotherManicMomday · 27/11/2022 09:57

Sorry but did EVERYONE MISS THE PART ABOUT IF YOU FOUND OUT AFTER THAT POINT THEN YOUVSHOULD HAVE THE OPTION IF AGREED BY MEDICAL STAFF. As in their should be a cut off point for those who are already aware of a problem with their pregnancy but for those who find out after that point they should have an option.

Or, alternately, you could just mind your own business and let women get on with making their own personal decisions.

wild concept, I know.

RodiganReed · 27/11/2022 10:26

I guess what I'm trying to say is that this thread risks setting up a false binary between the feminist pro-choice lobby and parents of disabled children - when in reality most of us are on the same side and it's the litigants in this case and the Christian right who are the 'opposition' for want of a better word.

RodiganReed · 27/11/2022 10:23

pointythings · 27/11/2022 10:13

@RodiganReed but Maire and Heidi do want other women to keep pregnancies they do not want/feel they cannot sustain. They argue for 'equality'. but you can bet that if the law changed to allow abortion to term for all, Heidi's team especially would be up in arms about it.

I agree but what I'm saying is that in my experience they are outliers, PP asserted that there's a "lot" of unconscious crab mentality in the disabled parenting community. I want to know what her evidence is for that because in my 30 plus years of experience I can only think of one birth parent who might have sympathy for this case (and one set of Christian foster carers).

Heidi and her Mum's views will be more mainstream in the US disabled community, but they're certainly not mainstream here.

pointythings · 27/11/2022 10:13

@RodiganReed but Maire and Heidi do want other women to keep pregnancies they do not want/feel they cannot sustain. They argue for 'equality'. but you can bet that if the law changed to allow abortion to term for all, Heidi's team especially would be up in arms about it.

RodiganReed · 27/11/2022 10:11

Miss03852 · 26/11/2022 23:20

And again, Maire didn’t actively choose to continue a DS pregnancy from the outset - I think she found out only a week or two before her son was born, which puts things in a different light.

I think it’s a lot of unconscious crab mentality where parents of other disabled children think “well I have to suffer so you should too!”

What is your evidence for that please?

I have a lifetime (so 30 plus years) of experience in the disabled community (personal and professional) and I can tell you with authority that it is crammed full of empathetic, wise women who do not in any way fit your description. Because of their struggles many become real matriarch figures and are enormously supportive of other parents including those with non disabled children.

There's some right bullshit on this thread.

twinklystar23 · 27/11/2022 10:01

iloveeverykindofcat for some it would be a logical extension. Just trying to anticipate gutter press headlines "but it's a babyeeee" what about trusting women who have been making their own decisions, with the support of fucking expert medical advice, FOR OVER HALF AFUCKING CENTURY @therefore it's not the fucking business of any other fucker.

Sorry for all the fucks but seriously pisses me off that we have to constantly have to look out for our rights.

JustAnotherManicMomday · 27/11/2022 09:57

Sorry but did EVERYONE MISS THE PART ABOUT IF YOU FOUND OUT AFTER THAT POINT THEN YOUVSHOULD HAVE THE OPTION IF AGREED BY MEDICAL STAFF. As in their should be a cut off point for those who are already aware of a problem with their pregnancy but for those who find out after that point they should have an option.

twinklystar23 · 27/11/2022 09:45

Bingbangbongbosh - the point that birth is what changes the status. Also has a subtle underpinning that it is the womans body and labour that is giving the gift of life to the infant. Which might be consistent in respect of other concerns such as surrogacy/womb rental & delivery.
In a lighter note, your username really sums up the point nicely!

Bingbangbongbash · 27/11/2022 08:29

BloodAndFire · 25/11/2022 14:26

All of a sudden it's as if something magical happens when it's born, and then it suddenly has all these rights

That is how law, and language, work.

Like something magical happens on your 18th birthday when you magically transform from a 'child' into an 'adult' and 'suddenly you have all these rights' - like you can vote and get married without parental consent and buy houses and stuff. Weird innit. Why do we do this stupid thing of calling it a 'child' before it's 18 when it's obviously been an 'adult' all along?

Fucking hell.

Well said.

There is also something physical that happens to change the status - birth. The foetus is expelled from the mother’s body and someone turns off its life-support system by cutting the umbilical cord. At that moment, the baby is an autonomous being, and os granted the laws and protections of a person.

iloveeverykindofcat · 27/11/2022 08:11

@twinkly We could just argue what the logical extension of denying abortion is. Mandatory kidney donation to those in need. I mean you don't need both. Men first in line to donate of course. They haven't even been donating womb time. They owe.