Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New job alarm bells

107 replies

Winterwonderlandisicy · 25/11/2022 10:53

I’ve recently been offered a new job after my ftc ended. I have some concerns about the new job.

I was told the job was working from home but on the contract it states the place of work is location X . This is 2 hours drive each way from where I live.

Also included in the contract was a clause for clawing back the recruitment fee plus VAT in the event I leave. This is about £15,000.

In addition I was sent a medical questionnaire with about 50 highly invasive questions on it. There was also an added threat that if you don’t disclose everything and they find out you will be disciplined or dismissed.

I’m worried about this because I have a disability and I get the feeling the questioning at a later date will be highly intrusive.

The employer then decided to google me and found I’d done some work during the Covid period when my employer couldn’t afford to pay me, work was on hold and I was furloughed. The director said this was a conflict of interest and raised it with the recruiter.

The work which I did for a temp basis was over 2 years ago and the paperwork which was visible in public domain clearly indicated that this work was no longer being undertaken. The company were also told I was made redundant during Covid and this was agreed with former employer during Covid.

The director did not check the paperwork before making a serious accusation. It felt like I was being stabbed in the back before I’ve even started.

Would all these things raise alarm bells with you?

I’m at final interview stage for another job. The interview is next week. This is using another agent. The company has been told I have a job offer and if they want to offer I will need to know within 72 hours max. I’ve worked with this company historically for 6 years so stand in a good position.

YANBU - alarm bells are ringing don’t take the job

YABU - take the job

OP posts:
justanotherthrowawayname · 25/11/2022 12:25

Clawbacks for training are not unusual. A clawback for just leaving? Sounds as if they have a major staff retention issue, know it, and haven't done anything to address it.

The WFH issue is common - many employers allow you to work from home but put the base office in your contract. Which is irritating because it blocks you from the tax relief.

I understand your discomfort over the medical questions - medical screeners aren't actually that unusual, but they tend to go to a third party screening company just to check you are fit to do the job. It would be odd if it went back to the employer directly.

The googling suggests a low trust culture, which together with the clawback cause sets all kinds of alarm bells ringing.

It sounds like the shine has already started to come off this opportunity, and you haven't even started yet. Imagine how you'll feel about it one week in, when even more gloss comes away? I don't think this is a good place to work if you can avoid it, OP.

You've been through the wars previously, and I suspect another shitty job would not be great for your self-esteem. You deserve to find a much better employer for your next move.

ChilomenaPunk · 25/11/2022 12:20

I'd defininitely get the recruitment fee clause taken out.

KatherineJaneway · 25/11/2022 12:18

Heck no, I would not touch this company with a barge poll. I was in HR for years and never saw anyone try and clawback recruitment fees. Big red flag.

ICanHideButICantRun · 25/11/2022 12:14

I definitely wouldn't take that job!

SpeckledlyHen · 25/11/2022 12:11

I would either try and renegotiate that contract or walk away. The contracted office bit I find a bit awkward. I worked for a company where all individuals were aligned to their nearest office but could work from home. The work from home bit is simply a verbal agreement though and if at any time they wish to make you work from the office you are contracted to work in then they have every right to do so. And on this occasion they did. They had a large team of people all working from home and then one Friday night stated everyone had to be in the office at X location. People literally just handed their notices in that week because it was not doable for them.

I work from home, but my contract states I work from home (I specifically negotiated this). What this also means is if they want me to go to office they have to pay my expenses. The last time I went it was £150 in train fares, taxi's and parking.

Regarding the recruitment costs - that's just barmy. This should be between the company and the recruitment company - not involve you at all.

DogInATent · 25/11/2022 12:08

Walk away.
Something's not right. There's a lot of somethings not right about your post, but if you're this uncomfortable before you start then don't start.

LittleMy77 · 25/11/2022 12:06

Trust your gut and don’t take it up. I had similar red flags before starting a new job, but decided to ignore them due to me needing to change location of work.

on the first day at work, I realised what a huge mistake I’d made, and left 6 months later

Winterwonderlandisicy · 25/11/2022 12:05

Yes the discrimination was in the workplace. I’m not really able to discuss it as legal proceedings are still ongoing.

OP posts:
Frankola · 25/11/2022 12:01

Nope. Alarm bells would be ringing for me too. Particularly "clawing back your recruitment cost". Trust your instincts

DifficultGirl · 25/11/2022 11:59

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

FabFitFifties · 25/11/2022 11:56

🏃‍♀️🚩

Winterwonderlandisicy · 25/11/2022 11:55

Thank you for all your feedback .

to be honest I asked because I have had discrimination historically and I am loosing confidence and faith and trust in people generally. Perhaps becoming a bit paranoid in some respects.

OP posts:
TheDogsMother · 25/11/2022 11:54

I have been a recruiter for a very long time and I have never seen a claw back like that. The recruiter will have a scale of refund with the client, never the candidate. For that alone I would run for the hills.

CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 25/11/2022 11:54

@MilkyYay I know you're quite right. It was offered as an example of a reasonable reason why the contract might be written that way.
Not a recommendation you should accept it if that possibility would be a problem, because, as you say, it bears a risk.
In my case I'm not bothered, they won't ask me to do that in all likelihood and if they did it wouldn't be the end of the world I'm not that far away.
For op that is not the case, so would be a bad thing. But I was just saying that was one possible legitimate reason why they may have included it.

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 11:49

The only thing you said which is potentially not a problem is the work location bit. My contract states my work location is officially the office but I can work from home

Its a problem. If your place of work is the office you can be required to go there 5 days a week at their whim.

My contract literally lists my home address as my work location which is how it should be.

Southwig22 · 25/11/2022 11:48

If you're having doubts at this point already, walk away.

I would say the location thing should be fairly easily resolved through conversation - may be an error. The medical questionnaire could be pretty standard depending on the role.

The £15k recruitment costs seem massively inflated and would definitely be a concern for me - it at least indicates a high turnover.

Couldyounot · 25/11/2022 11:46

Lot of "not feeling it" features here, OP. Personally I'd not join these people. I had a job about 10 years ago where I ignored a number of red flags at the outset - it did not end well, put it that way 😬

GerbilsForever24 · 25/11/2022 11:44

On the recruitment fee, I haven't recruited anyone for a long time but from memory, the contracts I signed with recruiters said that if I hired someone they placed with me, and the person left with a certain time period, I would be able to claim back the fee I paid them or they would not charge me for help to find a replacement. Something like that. The person themselves did not feature in this at all.

The medical stuff is more complex. Some firms require this for health and safety and other reasons but there should be corresponding confidentiality etc and, from memory, you could limit what you inserted there. I'd be wanting to understand exactly what this data is being used for before filling it in.

The work from home thing is inviolate. If the contract includes info re the office, you need to respond asking for this to be changed. It is entirely possible that's the standard contract and someone just hasn't put the time into properly editing it for you. I see this quite a lot now running my own small consultancy business - - new clients will often send me a contract that is clearly the standard one they send full-time short term contractors. But those contractors are usually exclusively working for the firm, usually on a full time basis and it's just one person. While my company is providing ad hoc consultancy services, often with a range of people. I've never had any push back when I ask for the appropriate changes. I assume it's just lazy or overworked HR/procurement people who don't have the time to do the necessary thinking each time so they leave it to me.

DifficultGirl · 25/11/2022 11:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

QuinkWashable · 25/11/2022 11:39

I've had sign-on bonus and relocation expense clawbacks, but never recruitment cost clawbacks - that one is new on me. Last time I used an agency as a business, they only got all the money after the candidate had been in the position for X months anyway.

The accusations, plus this clawback would put me off entirely.

Dotjones · 25/11/2022 11:36

Also included in the contract was a clause for clawing back the recruitment fee plus VAT in the event I leave. This is about £15,000.

This alone would be a big red flag. What timescale is this for? Clearly it can't be open ended because you'll leave eventually. I'd only consider accepting this if the contract also guaranteed that they couldn't get rid of me during this period. Written as they describe it, they could decide they didn't need you, tell you to leave then hit you with a demand for £15,000.

In addition I was sent a medical questionnaire with about 50 highly invasive questions on it. There was also an added threat that if you don’t disclose everything and they find out you will be disciplined or dismissed.

This also would be a big red flag. You don't have to answer any questions on your health. There's no obligation to disclose any disabilities you may have, for example, although of course they can't make any reasonable adjustments for things they don't know.

Angelofthenortheast · 25/11/2022 11:36

Don't accept the offer. Accusations like this so early on are a definite indication that more stuff like this is to come because the bosses aren't doing their essential jobs.

You'll waste months, just keep applying for other jobs if you can

underneaththeash · 25/11/2022 11:33

Contracts can be changed.

If you want to job, say that you'd need the place of work changing to working from home as you're not able to commute for 2 hours. Also the recruitment fee needs a term attached to it - what do you consider fair? 6 months/1 year?

CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 25/11/2022 11:33

Sounds dodgier by the minute!

The company must be willing to bear some risk of the recruitment cost involved in a new employee or they have a reduced incentive to make sure it works, which is never a good thing.

BarbaraWoodlouse · 25/11/2022 11:32

Contractual clauses such as office location and claw back can be negotiated which as pointed out above will buy you time.

I’m not qualified to comment on what/when you should disclose disability considerations but I’m sure you can access great advice here or elsewhere. The questionnaire itself would not be a red flag to me.

With those issues addressed however you still seem to have doubts re the hiring manager/company. Only you know if this is a risk you want to take if the rest is resolved.

Swipe left for the next trending thread