Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New job alarm bells

107 replies

Winterwonderlandisicy · 25/11/2022 10:53

I’ve recently been offered a new job after my ftc ended. I have some concerns about the new job.

I was told the job was working from home but on the contract it states the place of work is location X . This is 2 hours drive each way from where I live.

Also included in the contract was a clause for clawing back the recruitment fee plus VAT in the event I leave. This is about £15,000.

In addition I was sent a medical questionnaire with about 50 highly invasive questions on it. There was also an added threat that if you don’t disclose everything and they find out you will be disciplined or dismissed.

I’m worried about this because I have a disability and I get the feeling the questioning at a later date will be highly intrusive.

The employer then decided to google me and found I’d done some work during the Covid period when my employer couldn’t afford to pay me, work was on hold and I was furloughed. The director said this was a conflict of interest and raised it with the recruiter.

The work which I did for a temp basis was over 2 years ago and the paperwork which was visible in public domain clearly indicated that this work was no longer being undertaken. The company were also told I was made redundant during Covid and this was agreed with former employer during Covid.

The director did not check the paperwork before making a serious accusation. It felt like I was being stabbed in the back before I’ve even started.

Would all these things raise alarm bells with you?

I’m at final interview stage for another job. The interview is next week. This is using another agent. The company has been told I have a job offer and if they want to offer I will need to know within 72 hours max. I’ve worked with this company historically for 6 years so stand in a good position.

YANBU - alarm bells are ringing don’t take the job

YABU - take the job

OP posts:
lieselotte · 25/11/2022 14:42

Couldyounot · 25/11/2022 11:46

Lot of "not feeling it" features here, OP. Personally I'd not join these people. I had a job about 10 years ago where I ignored a number of red flags at the outset - it did not end well, put it that way 😬

I agree.

I think the WFH thing is quite normal, I've had two jobs where I have worked from home, but then my contract has been changed (more hours, temp to perm type thing) and they've put "full time in the office" in the new contract and it's had to be changed.

Trying to claw back the recruitment fee is cheeky and not normal.

If you don't feel comfortable about the health thing, that is enough on its own.

Googling you is normal, but I can't see what the issue was with doing a bit of work while in furlough. People have to earn a crust and the furlough money wasn't enough for a lot of people.

I'd look for a different job OP.

Elreychalino · 25/11/2022 14:38

I'm not an employment law person so won't comment on that but seems like if you have one offer - and another close interview situation you would also find another job quite quickly probably anyway.

Dixiechickonhols · 25/11/2022 14:38

I’d trust your gut and reject.

XmasElf10 · 25/11/2022 14:26

I am fully homebased and a line manager for a large EU team.

  1. The location of your workplace in the contract is enforceable. It doesn't matter if they verbally say you can work from home. If the contract says your work location is X office then they can ask you to work from X office full time. If I got a vibe from an interview I'd likely accept a contract with an office location and the verbal agreement to work from home flexibly as needed for a small percentage of my time but |I'd be aware that flexibility could be withdrawn. All the remote workers in my team (including me) have my home as work location. This is my 4th remote contract and every one has listed my place of work as home.

  2. Recruitment bonuses are often on a "pay it back if you leave within a year" basis but terms should be clear. No way would I sign a contract that required me to pay back my own recruitment costs if I leave. I WANT to be able to leave. Normally the probation period allows me to leave within 2 weeks (my normal notice is 3 months) so I would refrain from spending any recruitment bonus in that time and be ready to leave if I didn't like the place.

  3. The medical questionnaire is pretty normal but points 1 & 2 would be 100% no-gos for me. I'm not sure I'd even argue - I'd just go somewhere else. If this is the sort of contract they are offering then I'd assume they are shit to work for.

BuryingAcorns · 25/11/2022 14:14

Angelofthenortheast · 25/11/2022 11:36

Don't accept the offer. Accusations like this so early on are a definite indication that more stuff like this is to come because the bosses aren't doing their essential jobs.

You'll waste months, just keep applying for other jobs if you can

I think this. You need to be very careful they don't 'hire' you for two months and then decide not to continue for some spurious reason, and not pay you as they are clawing back the recruitment fee.

Look for a company that respects and trusts its workforce.

bringincrazyback · 25/11/2022 14:05

Red flags everywhere. I'd be passing on this one, OP.

fairydust11 · 25/11/2022 13:54

Don’t take the job. I had a similar situation where there were serious alarm bells for a role I had been verbally offered - although different to yours. I backed out of signing the contract as my gut instinct was screaming at me that it wasn’t right.
I’m so glad I did.
You know it’s not right, it sounds horrendous - if they’re like this already, then that’s a taster of what they would be like as employers.
Trust yourself, there are better roles out there. Good luck.

ilovebrie8 · 25/11/2022 13:53

Hell no, follow your gut but I’d not touch this job. The recruitment clause is a no no never ever seen that. Never mind the other things I think you know this is something you shouldn’t touch ...imagine once you are working for them.

Justthisonce12 · 25/11/2022 13:51

Winterwonderlandisicy · 25/11/2022 11:26

The recruiter told me these clauses are becoming more common however I was told by another recruiter that he has never seen it.

I have been using recruiters on a weekly basis for the last 25 years, and never once has that clause been included because you cannot charge an employee, a recruitment fee it’s illegal.

Justthisonce12 · 25/11/2022 13:48

Every single time throughout my life, when I have ignored my gut instinct, it has bitten me extremely firmly on the arse. All of your senses are telling you to not accept that role. You have other options and you know what even if you didn’t i’d still be saying, don’t take that role..

billy1966 · 25/11/2022 13:29

Absolutely listen to your gut that is rightly screaming at you not to take this job.

Have you proof of the accusation of wrong doing?

After rejecting the job I would be formalising on paper a complaint about the accusation of dishonesty.

I would NOT let that go.

TheShellBeach · 25/11/2022 13:28

WendyWagon · 25/11/2022 13:09

Absolutely do not take this job. I had joined a company in the spring. I had been through a recruiter who basically put me (round peg) into a square hole. I didn't get a contract when I started and for the first time in my career I trusted this company to put in writing what we had agreed. They didn't. They changed the whole job. I am also disabled and as it is a autoimmune condition I didn't volunteer that information. They deliberately informed everyone of my condition. Apparently a language mistake.
I had no choice but to accept my job was cancelled or sign their shockingly inferior contract. It cost me bonus from my previous employer to join them. Les Bastards.

Wow. That's outrageous. It absolutely isn't anyone's right either to know someone else's medical history - nor to announce it to all and sundry on top of that.

Les Bastards, indeed.

TheShellBeach · 25/11/2022 13:26

The intrusive medical questions would be the decider for me.
I mean, all of it sounds difficult but no company has the right to know your whole medical history.
I would be very, very wary about taking this position.

Softplayhooray · 25/11/2022 13:22

Winterwonderlandisicy · 25/11/2022 11:26

The recruiter told me these clauses are becoming more common however I was told by another recruiter that he has never seen it.

God, run, don't walk, away!! If you're getting this blowback from them now imagine how bad it'd be when you're officially working for them! They sound bloody awful.

Winterwonderlandisicy · 25/11/2022 13:14

I’m contacting a former employee . Will report back what they say

OP posts:
WendyWagon · 25/11/2022 13:09

Absolutely do not take this job. I had joined a company in the spring. I had been through a recruiter who basically put me (round peg) into a square hole. I didn't get a contract when I started and for the first time in my career I trusted this company to put in writing what we had agreed. They didn't. They changed the whole job. I am also disabled and as it is a autoimmune condition I didn't volunteer that information. They deliberately informed everyone of my condition. Apparently a language mistake.
I had no choice but to accept my job was cancelled or sign their shockingly inferior contract. It cost me bonus from my previous employer to join them. Les Bastards.

burnoutbabe · 25/11/2022 12:59

i have never seen a crecuitment fee clawback for an employee.

Training or sign on bonus/relocation - yes - as you GET this money, then could in theory repay it.

but if you leave in a week, you'd have earned £1000 and have to repay £15k! madness. (i assume 15k is based on a £60k salary - 25% or so of annual salary is normal for recruiters in some industries)

Faultymain5 · 25/11/2022 12:43

Winterwonderlandisicy · 25/11/2022 11:26

The recruiter told me these clauses are becoming more common however I was told by another recruiter that he has never seen it.

it is not normal to claw back money from the recruiter not the talent. That is ridiculous and says a lot about their negotiation with the agency. That should be paid back on a pro Rata basis by agency or the invoice paid at the end of your probation depending on if you pass probation or leave.

where you work is important, I’ve been stung in my role by not paying attention to the contract because the advert was remote and in the office. The manager likes us in the office🤷🏾‍♀️

mention these and ride it out and fingers crossed for the other role.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 25/11/2022 12:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

DogInATent · 25/11/2022 12:36

SoapMactavish · 25/11/2022 12:26

Run like the wind.

The worst part for me is googling you and admitting to it! Seriously?!

The whole paying back your recruitment fee smacks of a workplace with a very high turnover. Which in turn rings alarm bells.

It's quite normal for employers to check out prospective new employers on:

  • LinkedIn
  • Social media
  • Google

It would be odd not to check someone out in this day and age for a £80k/year position (working on the recruitment agency fee being c. 15% of salary), it's basic due diligence.

Glittertwins · 25/11/2022 12:32

I'd play for time with the clarifications on work location etc as PPs have suggested whilst you have this next interview. Hopefully you'll get that job and can say no thanks to the current offer (which does sound pretty off)

Fruitfriend · 25/11/2022 12:31

Are the medical q's through a third party occupational health firm? If so, that's normal for a pre-employment medical. The personal info you give us read by a medic (nurse usually).
They issue a fit-for-work certificate, if you need accommodations like a special chair they define and recommend them. If your conditions can't be accommodated (ie, epilepsy in a high risk strobing environment) they will not issue a fit certificate and you won't be hired.
Either way, the employer is told one of:

Fit to work, no accommodations needed
Fit to work with reasonable accommodations
Not fit to work in this role.

They don't get any specifics and everything is confidential to the OH provider.

GloomyDarkness · 25/11/2022 12:30

I think there are a lot of possible red flags.

However first step would be to push back on things you don't like in contract and as added bonus will give you more time.

If you do have to consider them - I know it will cost money but consider seeking some legal advice - as we found when DH was being made redundant and got sent to employment lawyer - it turns out a lot of what was in his employment contract was completely unenforceable under UK law - they were waving some of the more egregious terms but solicitor just laughed and said it wasn't enforceable so of course they were.

It's is apparently fairly common occurrence - and while MN often say well it was in your contract so you have to - turns out it really does depend - so may well be worth paying for some advice before signing - if at all possible.

PorkPieForStarters · 25/11/2022 12:28

Holy moly, run for the hills and don't look back!

The only slightly ok part of all of this is the location, and even then I'd want that changed to reflect that it's a remote-working position.

Good luck with your other opportunity, from the little you've said it sounds like the better option!

SoapMactavish · 25/11/2022 12:26

Run like the wind.

The worst part for me is googling you and admitting to it! Seriously?!

The whole paying back your recruitment fee smacks of a workplace with a very high turnover. Which in turn rings alarm bells.