Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New job alarm bells

107 replies

Winterwonderlandisicy · 25/11/2022 10:53

I’ve recently been offered a new job after my ftc ended. I have some concerns about the new job.

I was told the job was working from home but on the contract it states the place of work is location X . This is 2 hours drive each way from where I live.

Also included in the contract was a clause for clawing back the recruitment fee plus VAT in the event I leave. This is about £15,000.

In addition I was sent a medical questionnaire with about 50 highly invasive questions on it. There was also an added threat that if you don’t disclose everything and they find out you will be disciplined or dismissed.

I’m worried about this because I have a disability and I get the feeling the questioning at a later date will be highly intrusive.

The employer then decided to google me and found I’d done some work during the Covid period when my employer couldn’t afford to pay me, work was on hold and I was furloughed. The director said this was a conflict of interest and raised it with the recruiter.

The work which I did for a temp basis was over 2 years ago and the paperwork which was visible in public domain clearly indicated that this work was no longer being undertaken. The company were also told I was made redundant during Covid and this was agreed with former employer during Covid.

The director did not check the paperwork before making a serious accusation. It felt like I was being stabbed in the back before I’ve even started.

Would all these things raise alarm bells with you?

I’m at final interview stage for another job. The interview is next week. This is using another agent. The company has been told I have a job offer and if they want to offer I will need to know within 72 hours max. I’ve worked with this company historically for 6 years so stand in a good position.

YANBU - alarm bells are ringing don’t take the job

YABU - take the job

OP posts:
NotAnotherCrisis · 26/11/2022 11:11

Walk away.

TiaraBoo · 26/11/2022 11:09

Agree with others saying never heard of a recruitment fee being clawed back! A sign on bonus or paying for you to do a Masters- yes.
If you’re WFH, then contract should say that.
The company asking all the medical questions, they’re probably a separate company hired for that sort of thing.

good luck!

littlefireseverywhere · 26/11/2022 11:02

Yes, don’t take it , good luck for Monday

Han99 · 26/11/2022 11:00

Winterwonderlandisicy · 25/11/2022 10:53

I’ve recently been offered a new job after my ftc ended. I have some concerns about the new job.

I was told the job was working from home but on the contract it states the place of work is location X . This is 2 hours drive each way from where I live.

Also included in the contract was a clause for clawing back the recruitment fee plus VAT in the event I leave. This is about £15,000.

In addition I was sent a medical questionnaire with about 50 highly invasive questions on it. There was also an added threat that if you don’t disclose everything and they find out you will be disciplined or dismissed.

I’m worried about this because I have a disability and I get the feeling the questioning at a later date will be highly intrusive.

The employer then decided to google me and found I’d done some work during the Covid period when my employer couldn’t afford to pay me, work was on hold and I was furloughed. The director said this was a conflict of interest and raised it with the recruiter.

The work which I did for a temp basis was over 2 years ago and the paperwork which was visible in public domain clearly indicated that this work was no longer being undertaken. The company were also told I was made redundant during Covid and this was agreed with former employer during Covid.

The director did not check the paperwork before making a serious accusation. It felt like I was being stabbed in the back before I’ve even started.

Would all these things raise alarm bells with you?

I’m at final interview stage for another job. The interview is next week. This is using another agent. The company has been told I have a job offer and if they want to offer I will need to know within 72 hours max. I’ve worked with this company historically for 6 years so stand in a good position.

YANBU - alarm bells are ringing don’t take the job

YABU - take the job

Like others have said. The office location shouldn't be a problem. My job is now WFH but base is a town an hours drive away. It just means I can't claim expenses to get there but I can to any other sites. I actually don't even have a parking pass or security pass for the front door or that sire where as I do for two others. But the other things are alarm bells. I'd hold out for another role. In this climate it won't take long.

IlonaRN · 26/11/2022 10:54

My contract at my new place of work states that the contracted place of work is the office (in London), but the usual place of work is Home.
This is so that they don't have to pay my travel expenses when I go in to the office.

Brightstarowl · 26/11/2022 10:42

All this before you've even started?

You're not going to be treated well here, work related stress here you come!

Walk away.

Primula200 · 26/11/2022 10:41

Sounds grim and uncaring and punitive... There will be a better job and I don't see anyone being kind to you if your disability comes to the fore. Trust that you are worth more and deserve better treatment. To start a job with so much fear for your job security and feeling vulnerable would be much deeper stress for you. Do you need that? If walking away means a bit less money I'd do it. Your wellbeing and privacy matter more.

zingally · 26/11/2022 10:32

The fact that you've made this post - you already know the answer. Walk away.

Bearthepooh · 26/11/2022 10:24

I'm a recruiter and that fees bit is absolute rubbish, we wouldn't work with a client like that. Red flag, avoid!

Pinkclouds80 · 26/11/2022 10:20

This is the Jeffrey Dahmer of jobs, definitely trust your gut.

PifandHercule · 26/11/2022 10:10

I work in HR and may be able to provide a bit of insight.
The 15K training cost clause tells
me the company has had a lot of new joiners leave relatively quickly. This has a financial impact and instead of getting to the bottom of the reasons new hires don’t stay for longer and fix whatever toxic culture they have in place, they try to recoup the costs of onboarding and training.
The invasive health questionnaire also points towards the fact that the company seems to think that once hired, they own you!
Such a controlling culture, if I was you I would RUN AWAY before you get sucked in.

CrabbitBastard · 26/11/2022 09:52

The definition of disability is a legal one, not a medical one, so there is no legal obligation for you to complete a medical questionnaire and if they try to force you to do one, or punish you for not doing so, it would be disability discrimination. The choice is yours, not theirs.
The only way they can establish if you are disabled or not, is to take you to court or tribunal and have that court or tribunal decide - because its a legal definition, not a medical one.
Conversations about adjustments at work should be led by you, not them but even if you do not share or disclose, they still have a legal responsibility to make their place of work accessible and inclusive.
I would also be royally pissed off about the £15,000 claim back thing and the change of location.
You should get onto the recruiter and question all the above.

blondieminx · 26/11/2022 09:48

There were so many things to feel uncomfortable about in your OP - but always trust your gut instinct.

the medical but is ringing huge clanging alarm bells for me!

Frazzled2207 · 26/11/2022 09:44

Just seen your update sorry- yeah run a mile now.

best of luck with the interview for the second job.

Frazzled2207 · 26/11/2022 09:41

I’m a recruiter and have never ever heard of a company charging an individual recruitment fees if they leave. That alone would be enough of a red flag for me.

the wfh thing not so much as I know companies have been slow to standardise
new contracts since wfh became standard.

Winterwonderlandisicy · 26/11/2022 09:27

@Dontjudgeme101 - thank you so much . I will come back and update you all .

OP posts:
Dontjudgeme101 · 26/11/2022 09:24

Fingers crossed for Tuesday op.🤞🏿💐💐

Winterwonderlandisicy · 26/11/2022 09:21

WendyWagon - so sorry to hear. I hope you have found a nice new employer and they are looking after you.

I will meet the other company on Tuesday and report back.

OP posts:
WendyWagon · 26/11/2022 07:15

@Winterwonderlandisicy good morning and good luck for Monday.
I think that companies that place restrictions on people are chancers. You don't want to work for this shower so 'let it go'. There was something off with my new employers in the spring (8 meetings /Saturday teams). I, like you was worried I would be unemployed post redundancy. It makes you 'rabbit in headlights' nervous. Were they being cautious? No they were shits. After receiving their dodgy contract I knew they were up to something. I introduced them to a multiple million pound business relationship. They ended my employment with little official notice and no pay off. They cost me £125k.
As I said my earlier post I am disabled and they made a point of walking everywhere for sodding hours. Plus their lift at HO was broken. Five floors up I needed to climb. Just inconsiderate bastards.
Never take a job because you are desperate. Think Bridget Jones. I will be off to Marks on the food Isle if I can't get something new. Life is too short to be bullied via a contract and you don't even work there yet. Let us know how you get on.

Winterwonderlandisicy · 25/11/2022 21:25

I spoke to the former employee who I know first hand is a model employee. He told me I would be under a magnifying glass, micro managed, cut off from the team as they are not London based and under pressure from a very demanding project which was a nightmare to get too.

He worked there 1.5 years and met the boss once. No team events or parties or gatherings. When he resigned they took £500 from his salary and totally ignored him like he didn’t exist.

The other company has come back to me and im meeting all the big wigs on Monday so fingers crossed I don’t screw it up.

I have major anxiety about the job. I really need the second one to come through 😢

I was made redundant during Covid and can’t afford to be out of a job again. I’m single and I have no support .

OP posts:
Winterwonderlandisicy · 25/11/2022 21:20

Thank you much for all your feedback and comments.

nobody has reviewed the company. They have given themselves a 5/5 on google.

OP posts:
fourquenelles · 25/11/2022 15:53

Recruitment is very much a 2 way process. You are "interviewing" the company just as much as they are "interviewing" you. If you don't feel comfortable at this stage politely decline.

HumourReplacementTherapy · 25/11/2022 15:14

Winterwonderlandisicy · 25/11/2022 13:14

I’m contacting a former employee . Will report back what they say

Look on glassdoor too

Monkeybutt1 · 25/11/2022 14:57

Should have said that had the business address 🙄

Monkeybutt1 · 25/11/2022 14:55

I took a "WFH" role the had the business address as my place of work, fast forward 6 months and I'm expected to start going on the office twice a week, it's not in my contract that I'm a remote worker so have no rights.
I now work for someone else with a WFH contract.

Swipe left for the next trending thread