Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To rehome cat because of pressure on marriage

491 replies

Freshstillwater · 25/11/2022 08:25

I’ve posted about this before but I didn’t get many serious replies.

I have been married for nearly a year, and just after our wedding I adopted a cat from a charity. I did talk about this with DH first, there was some eye rolling and ‘if you must’ but it was good humoured.

Nearly a year on and it’s really difficult. The cat had fleas which bit DH, he was pretty annoyed about this. He really doesn’t like the cat, I mean, I knew he wasn’t really into animals but I misread dislike as actual neutrality.

The complaining about the cat is really getting to me, I feel like he’d be happier without the cat and me, tbh.

I am not sure what to do now.

OP posts:
audeloquipalam · 26/11/2022 17:06

To clarify: rehome - because cats don’t give a toss about their owners, not because cats or any other animal don’t matter.

Branleuse · 26/11/2022 17:05

So happy for you and your cat xx

audeloquipalam · 26/11/2022 17:03

When people say they don’t like pets that is what they mean. The person who wants a pet can choose to nuance and reinterpret every aspect of every conversation that went on throughout the arm twisting phase to convince themselves “but you said you were alright with it…” but it’s BS. Looking forwards - get rid of the cat, it’s a cat. And don’t get another pet.

HeadNorth · 26/11/2022 16:52

That is great to hear, I’m glad you’ve managed to have a productive conversation with your DH and that kitty is staying 😀

NoSquirrels · 26/11/2022 16:41

Freshstillwater · 26/11/2022 16:17

Thanks @Geville - I did have a very beneficial chat with DH about the cat. As it is, I am pleased to report the cat is staying. He appears to be flea free (the treatment from the vet does seem to have done the trick) which is a relief for him and of course for us.

Many posts on here have been extremely helpful and I am grateful for them.

Oh, great news! Glad for you, DH and the cat.

FurElsie · 26/11/2022 16:26

orangeandred · 25/11/2022 08:57

OP I can sympathise so much with this situation. We fostered a cat for a short while that I didn't actually want to do as I don't like cats. My husband really wanted to. I agreed to give it a try as it was a short term basis and if we liked it we were going to get a cat ourselves. The cat got fleas and even after it left it took us months to get rid of them from the house and a lot of money. I was actually really enjoying having the cat until the flea problem but then I felt trapped in my own home and dirty. It totally put me off even though in the grand scheme of things it wasn't a huge deal but honestly having fleas in my home really turned the situation into a nightmare for me and I can imagine your husband feels the same. Sort that problem out first and maybe things will get better. That is the only thing I can think that would help at this point

This is what I was thinking your husband might be feeling. I love cats but when we realised frontline doesn't work and we had an infestation of fleas it felt horrible, and I imagine so much worse if you don't even like cats much. I wouldn't blame him either for being wishywashy about the cat in the first place, he probably thought it wouldn't impact on him much but look at what he got! I wouldn't generalise it to him only wanting what he wants, I think you might be minimising his experience of not feeling comfortable in his own home.

Freshstillwater · 26/11/2022 16:17

Thanks @Geville - I did have a very beneficial chat with DH about the cat. As it is, I am pleased to report the cat is staying. He appears to be flea free (the treatment from the vet does seem to have done the trick) which is a relief for him and of course for us.

Many posts on here have been extremely helpful and I am grateful for them.

OP posts:
Geville · 26/11/2022 15:52

I think you've been very measured OP. You've taken a lot of criticism and taken it extremely calmly and gracefully. Very unusual on MN if I may say so!

I'm sad that you have to rehome your cat but I also think, at least for now, it's the right decision.

I do really hope that you've managed to talk to your DH and open a bigger conversation about how to apportion chores and money and hopes and dreams more easily...

All the best to you x

Walkaround · 26/11/2022 11:34

@Freshstillwater 💐I’m sorry to hear you are having to rehome your cat.

I wonder, did you see the post suggesting your dh may be reacting now to the flea treatment, rather than fleas themselves? It’s unfortunate your dh’s first cat experience was spoilt by fleas, as it is utterly miserable to feel itchy all the time, and difficult to take your mind off it. You were not unreasonable to have wanted to try, though.

We have a cat my dh didn’t really want - he succumbed because one of our children was desperate to have one. Our cat is also from Cats Protection. He is gorgeous, but it took a long time for dh to tolerate him and even longer to grudgingly become rather fond of him. He sees how much genuine pleasure the cat gives to other members of the family, which helps. I don’t think he would have done if fleas had been added to the mix! If you haven’t grown up with cats in the house, it does take some getting used to.

LadyApplejack · 26/11/2022 11:14

OK whatever. It comes across a complete rant since nothing you referenced there applies to me, and yet out of all posters you tagged ME when MY earlier reply to you "explicitly stated" I wasn't intending to make you feel bad. I'd also acknowledged that the husband might be at fault but we didn't have enough info to go on. It was a totally genuine response, but you're obviously on one. Whatever.

ChocoFudge · 26/11/2022 11:13

There's no way I would get rid of the cat. I would however consider getting rid of the husband.

If your house is infested with fleas then getting rid of the cat won't actually make any difference. I suspect your husband has become fixated on the idea of fleas and that is causing him to be itchy.

Keep the poor cat, there's no way she will be rehomed at this time of year.

burnoutbabe · 26/11/2022 11:06

Married a year but clearly together much longer. Op won't answer how long though. So most people are assuming only together a short time (but there are kids, again not clear if joint)

Foodylicious · 26/11/2022 11:02

Goodness me you have been given a hard time OP

Yes maybe in retrospect things if you hadn't got the cat you wouldn't be in this situation, but I don't think you had anyway of knowing that your DH would be so difficult and unsupportive of the unexpected problems you have face with fleas.

I'm sure you don't want any more flea advice, but we had a house cat that very occasionally ventured in to the garden with us, that ended up with fleas.
I was the bitten horribly and repeatedly and we would treat the cat and the house and it would settle for a while.
We used furniture and carpet spray as well as bombs. What worked in the end was repeating this every 2-3 months for a about 9 months.

I do think it sounds like DH is the problem.
Is he really not aware of how much his behaviour is upsetting you?
If he isn't, you need to let him know.
If he is, then you might need to think about things longer term.
Sounds like you love him very much, wpuld he be open to counselling if he knew how effected you were?

Only married a year, it shouldn't be this hard x

MangoesAndPeaches · 26/11/2022 11:01

A friend had a similar issue with her cats. A relative came to stay and his dog had fleas, which were passed on to the household and cats. Nothing worked at first, and she was told by the ver that fleas have built resistance to treatment. She was recommended Stronghold, which you can buy online and it comes from Germany. Maybe give that a try before rehoming your cat? Sorry you are going through such an stressful situation, I love my cats and would be heartbroken too if I had to re home them.

Freshstillwater · 26/11/2022 10:47

Freshstillwater · 26/11/2022 09:50

I’m absolutely done with repeatedly being told what an awful thing I did, @LadyApplejack . It is incredibly tedious going over and over the last couple of months or so endlessly and then having people show up and bark at you for not having treated the fleas and what sort of evil fucker are you for expecting your husband to put up with them? (And I’m also apparently some sort of weirdo who would be burned at the stake in the Middle Ages because our children are not relevant to a post about me, my husband and a cat.

I’m sorry if that sounds snappy but I have indicated I’d prefer for the thread not to continue. I’ve tried just being quiet and leaving it but as is evident from pages of ‘just treat the cat and get a flea bomb’ people aren’t bothering to read.

I don’t see a rant.

I explicitly say I am not being snappy.

Barking - that is how others have spoken to me.

Evil fucker - yes, I have had some posts telling me ‘you sound awful.’

’burned at the stake’ I’m sorry my attempt at wry humour was obviously lost. I did not literally mean this.

OP posts:
Freshstillwater · 26/11/2022 10:45

Thanks @HeadNorth . DH and I have to make a longish car journey where I’m going to broach the subject.

OP posts:
Freshstillwater · 26/11/2022 10:44

Thanks @Gazelda

OP posts:
HeadNorth · 26/11/2022 10:44

@Freshstillwater I've just popped on to give you a handhold as some posters are forming an unpleasant wee gang on this thread.

I don't think you should make hasty decisions about the cat as I do not think it was resolve what are obviously simmering issues in your marriage. You are dealing with the fleas, but you DH has the fleas as a cast iron reason to use the cat acquisition against you and he isn't going to relinquish that lightly.

You should never feel like a guest in your own home. For now, I would stand firm saying you are treating the flea issue and that you want to have a clear discussion about communication and compromise in your marriage that isn't derailed by him going on and on about cat fleas. I don't think rehoming your cat will address the larger issues in your relationship.

Freshstillwater · 26/11/2022 10:44

What really helps is not people saying step away (which subtly puts the blame on the OP for engaging) but people actually being supportive.

I know this sounds like I am being critical, that really is not my intention, but I am going to say it. My posts here have been polite. I have engaged. I have agreed. I have come to a solution. ‘Step away’ sounds as if I am the one who is inflaming the situation, I am not.

That is not a criticism, it’s just explaining why I’m not going to step away Smile

OP posts:
Gazelda · 26/11/2022 10:43

OP, I am not going to comment on the cat or your DH.

I'm only posting to wish you well and to say I'm sorry you're sad about the course of action you've decided to take regarding the cat. And the other unpleasant news you had yesterday. And the way in which your husband has dealt with this situation and, seemingly, other occasions where you've disagreed.

I hope things get better and happier for you.

stuntbubbles · 26/11/2022 10:40

@Freshstillwater OK. I’m stepping out then. I don’t think it’s a “bullies win” or “running away sobbing” – it’s the advice I’d give myself. To let MN froth away at itself while I went off and lived my life. Best of luck rehoming the cat.

NoSquirrels · 26/11/2022 10:39

I posted asking for advice. I have received that advice and to surmise, I was extremely naive and foolish in expecting DH to share the home with an animal he doesn’t want or like. I was unintentionally selfish.

A lot of people have said that but by no means all. A lot of other people have tried to see beneath the ‘unwanted cat foisted on unwilling man’ thing to get to the relationships issue, but that’s nearly impossible on AIBU when people see ‘CAT!!!’

I have conceded this - so why are people persisting in telling me not only this, but also that I posted in the wrong place, I didn’t include the information I should have, I did this wrong, I did that wrong?

You haven’t done anything wrong, you are not wrong, step away if it is making you feel worse not better. Post again sometime in Relationships about the ‘feeling like a guest’ issue with no mention of the cat at all.

Flowers
Freshstillwater · 26/11/2022 10:39

Thank you @Blocked and @HangryFeminist . I am going to speak to CPL now - sure I will come back to pages accusing me of all sorts and you know I can handle that, I don’t need ot wish the thread to be moved, taken down or whatever. I am an adult woman and I have faced far worse in my life than dickheads on here.

OP posts:
Freshstillwater · 26/11/2022 10:38

@stuntbubbles likewise I have no doubt you mean well, but the bullies win then. Not going to happen. I am many things but I’m not going to run away sobbing because a handful of idiots think I’m ‘ranting’ Confused

OP posts:
HangryFeminist · 26/11/2022 10:37

I’m sorry OP, the sensible posts have been lost in a sea of vicious bile. For what it’s worth I think you’ve done everything you can, and you didn’t do a bad thing. If you do decide to rehome him, take comfort in knowing he was warm, well fed and loved by you, and he will continue to be all of those things be it at the charity or a new home. I only ever go for the old, sad looking cats so someone like me will take him.

On another note, I think you perhaps need to think about individual counselling to work out if your relationship is healthy. From what you are saying, the cat is a symptom of a bigger issue for sure. 💐

Swipe left for the next trending thread