Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not see my parents very near to Christmas as my Dad always talks about my weight

141 replies

DriedApricotss · 25/11/2022 07:30

Inspired by another thread.

I have been working on my very poor personal boundaries this year and have basically been distancing myself from relationships where I feel things are toxic or stale / feel I am the only one putting the effort in, etc. My life is quieter but freer and lighter and I feel so much better about things. In the future I will be looking for more balanced friendships.

My AIBU is that my parents and dad in particular is always making comments about my weight and what I eat. I am probably three stone overweight but in my defense, one of my children has been very ill this year so I haven't been able to leave the house to go out exercising as in the past. Even then my dad would make comments about food and weight etc.

As this year has been so tough with my daughter's illness, my husband and I have decided to have a quiet Christmas just the five or us, he, I and our three girls. I did suggest meeting up with my parents on christmas eve as I have had them around to my house for the past 3 Christmases and I didn't want to hurt their feelings however their response to meeting up for christmas eve was to go there for a salad on christmas eve as you shouldn't have two days in a row eating too much. When I suggested meeting up on christmas eve I hadn't even suggested meeting to eat, a quick hi in a town in between our homes would have been enough for me!

All this talk about eating/ what you eat / what not to eat is really starting to put me off seeing them. I find is so offensive. I am five foot 8 and a size 16, I have been slimmer in the past but I have never been mega skinny. It just makes me feel that my dad can't accept me as I am if that makes sense. With my work on my boundaries wirh toxic situationships this year, this scenario with my dad has become more apparent.

How shall I handle this? I have asked him not to comment about my weight before and he stops briefly and then goes back to talking about it. I spend ages working out what to wear before going to see them as I know my dad will be looking at me. I know they must speak about my weight behind my back. It has taken the joy out of taking the kids to see them. Tia x

OP posts:
xogossipgirlxo · 25/11/2022 09:21

They sound miserable. You don't even need to make an excuse not to see them. Just say no. If they ask why, tell them you don't need to hear comments about your weight and diet, don't leave any window open for questions etc. It's not a discussion, it's just the information. For your own sake. I hope you have a lovely Christmas with your kids.

Wheredoallthepensgo · 25/11/2022 09:17

Trulyweird1 · 25/11/2022 07:46

What an unpleasant thing to do / say to anyone, never mind his daughter ,
It struck me while ready your op that you used the phrase ‘ in my defence..’
OP you do not need to defend or apologise to anyone . None of us are perfect, and most of us have shit going on. Your Dad is an incredibly lucky man if he is perfect with a perfect life.
So don’t waste your angst on him. He’s not pleasant and he’s failing you as a father, and potentially your daughters as a grandfather. That’s on him.

I agree.

Readinginthesun · 25/11/2022 09:13

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 25/11/2022 07:51

Its such a boomer thing to obsess about what people eat it really is! They’re so judgy. Is if boredom? Were they not ‘allowed’ by society to be overweight when they were younger so are enraged by the current acceptance that people can be overweight and it’s ok? I find it such a weird attitude.

But I see you OP. I can totally relate. And it’s a sad situation.

Yet another thing us “ boomers” are responsible for !?
Sick of the ageism on MN .

PorridgewithQuark · 25/11/2022 09:07

DriedApricotss · 25/11/2022 08:32

I agree talkingmorenonsense. 100 per cent.

Question: none of this makes sense to me, really. Someone uptrend said that my dad knew what he is doing. What is my dad getting out of criticising my weight and telling me what to eat? Is it him trying to find something to criticise me for? As otherwise I'm doing okay? Or is it some kind of control? As I don't really need him / them anymore? I will never understand where this behaviour comes from.

It could be any of those things.

My mum constantly puts people down to big herself up. Weight is her absolute favourite topic. She criticises parenting and then immediately compares it to her rose tinted version of how much better she parented as a "lesson" or example.

Tbh I only managed to make her stop by calling her out in a way that was very close to the bone and made her cry, but it was that or let her continue the constant drip, drip, drip around my children.

It was the weight/ food thing I called her out on because I have two siblings with eating disorders and she constantly states that this is absolutely not her fault and invites / seeks agreement and reassurance about it. Usually everyone tells her how wonderful she is and how she couldn't have done anything different, but the truth is that she has always been very, very keen to constantly comment on everyone's weight with open judgement (constantly praising slimness as a great personal virtue as well as a lot of schadenfreude and shaming of fatness). She was also incredibly controlling about food and constantly parading her own dieting in front of us as children and most of all as teens. So I'm not so sure it isn't partly her fault tbh, though of course eating disorders are complex and there's more to it.

Anyway I put up with it for three and a half decades, but finally snapped when she started that directly addressing my daughter.

It enabled me to address other things as they came up in future years (for example her prioritising including a relative's dog after it bit my toddler and caused a ragged wound over her grandchild) - the culture in our family has always been that she "has a heart of gold" and nobody should upset her. She loves to use the phrase "family harmony" to shut down any disagreement or uncomfortable discussion.

Now she tells everyone she's afraid of me because I make her cry.

MistyRock · 25/11/2022 09:07

whyhere · 25/11/2022 08:25

Just a small point (and I do understand - my mother was the same): at 5ft 8 you are not 3 stone overweight if you wear a size 16. Please don't let others' nonsense skew your picture of yourself 😘

Agreed. You can't be very big at a size 16 at 5ft 8in. I doubt you're big at all. I bet you look lovely.

Itisbetter · 25/11/2022 09:07

I wouldn’t cut him out or get enormously invested in changing him. Personally I’d meet them in a pub/cafe with the kids or take them for a cold walk on the beach/woods and a cup of coffee afterwards. Exchange presents give them a kiss and have a lovely Christmas.

bumblingbovine49 · 25/11/2022 09:00

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 25/11/2022 08:54

Carry on calling it out.
I did with my mother a few years ago.
"Never again are you to talk about my weight or I will just stop speaking to you"
Christ knows why I didn't do it years ago.

Absolutely. Well done.

bumblingbovine49 · 25/11/2022 08:59

No don't say that. Just don't go and as a PP said, if you see him after Christmas and he comments again ( which he will) just use the ' body shaming is not acceptable to me, line every time he mentions weight and then leave. You absolutely need to stay calm when you say it though. If you do this enough he will stop with the comments.

He will no doubt complain you are being too sensitive and that he just cares about you but as long as he stops commenting to your face that may help your visits and relationship.

As to his comments just being because he cares that is a load of bull. One careful private conversation about your weight with an offer to help and be supportive if you ever choose to lose weight is caring . Constantly pointing out how you are overweight in public is being a dick

hobbledyhoy · 25/11/2022 08:58

I understand where you're coming from OP I've had similar experience but more so when younger, there were always comments on weight and fixations on how much or what I was eating. Comments about skipping meals and what a good idea it was. When I look back now it's actually quite horrifying.
Nothing has been said for years ( I was a chubby child and overweight adult but lost the weight) but I do think as a PP poster said a lot of this ridiculous behaviour is wrapped up in social embarrassment and their children being a visible representation of their parenting success.
It's bloody awful and you have my sympathy. I would focus on looking after yourself and your family and doing something nice at Christmas. You deserve it.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 25/11/2022 08:54

Carry on calling it out.
I did with my mother a few years ago.
"Never again are you to talk about my weight or I will just stop speaking to you"
Christ knows why I didn't do it years ago.

Stripedbag101 · 25/11/2022 08:54

My parents are exactly like this!! I have had counselling.

you are absolutely right to have boundaries. I have been changing the subject on food and weight for years and either they don’t get the hint or still believe they need to ‘subtly’ let me know I need to lose weight. They constantly talk about cutting down and what weight they are and what they should and shouldn’t eat while giving me meaningful looks.

i have an earring disorder / I wonder why!!!

I even say ‘let’s not obsess about food and weight’. Doesn’t work!

my mum has now started on my niece. And with age it has become more intense. You are right to address this now

Soothsayer1 · 25/11/2022 08:52

I would start picking fault with his appearance every time I see him, if you do it back to him he will crumble and you'll see him for what he really is

MissEdithPilchester · 25/11/2022 08:51

Your post has a great resonance with me OP and I don't think you should waste your time trying to work out where his behaviour comes from.

My parents and grandparents frequently mentioned my weight when I was a teenager and I wasn't even that overweight (probably a stone) but because they had always been stick thin they obviously thought that I was letting the side down. Cue an eating disorder that lasted until my mid twenties and made me deeply ashamed and unhappy.

I managed to get to grips with it but my whole early adulthood was marred by feeling judged and unworthy. The worst thing was that my mum was a great cook and was simultaneously trying to feed me whilst telling me that "if I ate any more I would look pregnant".

I still have a relationship with her and she has never discussed this and tbh I can't be bothered to bring it up as she's in her 80s and quite frail. However it does make my feelings towards her complicated.

My 16 year old DD is slightly overweight and I have consciously never spoken about her weight or made negative comments about my appearance or hers. She's a wonderful and compassionate girl and I want to build her confidence not destroy it.

I think you are right to draw your boundaries, particularly if you have daughters as remarks about appearance and weight can be so damaging, particularly at a time when you are developing your sense of self as a teenager.

I have often wondered whether people who throw these remarks around have any idea of the damage they do.

My advice would be to enjoy Christmas with your own lovely family and let your dad deal with the consequences.

PorridgewithQuark · 25/11/2022 08:46

Thehop · 25/11/2022 07:33

Don’t go. Your daughters don’t need to hear that shit and neither do you.

Exactly this. If you don't do it for yourself, do it for your daughters, because they will absorb your dad's messaging unconsciously.

DrNo007 · 25/11/2022 08:44

I’ve been both skinny and slightly (not much) overweight and my dad used to comment on/criticise both. I unsuccessfully asked him not to do it but that had no effect. So the next time he did it I replied listing his ‘body faults’ (beer gut, big nose, double chin etc). I ended, ‘see how it makes you feel?’ He was very taken aback and never criticised my appearance again. Sometimes the only language these people understand is their own.

However I am the first to admit that the tactic that worked was to sink to the same level as him. So the more mature way is to do what PPs have suggested and just tell him you won’t be seeing him again unless he promises not to comment on your weight—and sticks to it.

CurlsandSwirls · 25/11/2022 08:43

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn on the user's request.

rookiemere · 25/11/2022 08:41

DriedApricotss · 25/11/2022 08:32

I agree talkingmorenonsense. 100 per cent.

Question: none of this makes sense to me, really. Someone uptrend said that my dad knew what he is doing. What is my dad getting out of criticising my weight and telling me what to eat? Is it him trying to find something to criticise me for? As otherwise I'm doing okay? Or is it some kind of control? As I don't really need him / them anymore? I will never understand where this behaviour comes from.

I think there are a couple of things going on.

Firstly women used to be regarded primarily for their ornamental value, so being overweight would be seen as a very bad thing indeed.

Secondly I think it was possibly drummed into a certain age group that being overweight was the worst thing you could possibly do for your health- obviously smoking and drinking were more acceptable in those days, so I think there is a genuine health concern going on and I do worry a bit <and I'm overweight myself > that we've gone a bit too far in the other direction because being severely overweight is a health concern.

Finally it's a matter of social standing. My DF was embarrassed to have a fat daughter. He told me off age 11 for ordering a dessert in front of my Aunt and Uncle ( very critical of overweight people) because I was fat - happy to order one for himself mind. Another friend's attitude to food is totally screwed up because her DF lined his DDs up and weighed them on a weekly basis.

Sounds like you've got a really healthy perspective on it though OP.

PiggyInTheLidl · 25/11/2022 08:39

DriedApricotss · 25/11/2022 08:32

I agree talkingmorenonsense. 100 per cent.

Question: none of this makes sense to me, really. Someone uptrend said that my dad knew what he is doing. What is my dad getting out of criticising my weight and telling me what to eat? Is it him trying to find something to criticise me for? As otherwise I'm doing okay? Or is it some kind of control? As I don't really need him / them anymore? I will never understand where this behaviour comes from.

Who knows.

Maybe projecting his own anxieties, maybe he likes to exert control. Maybe he has his own demons around it all, maybe he is a bully.

How does he treat your Mum? Do they have an easy relationship and full equality? Or is she constantly trying to please him?

Softplayhooray · 25/11/2022 08:35

Just don't go to your parents for Christmas OP, enjoy with your DH and kids, relax and have fun! Your dad made his own choice to be snarky about your weight and any idiot knows that when you're an asshole to someone after they've asked you not to be, they'll want to avoid you.

PiggyInTheLidl · 25/11/2022 08:33

Well, the best thing OP is that you have strong self awareness about the lifelong behaviour of your parents and how it has affected you.

You have made such a positive effort to strengthen your boundaries around friendships etc.

It may or may not be possible to say to your Dad at some stage “I am not sure whether you are aware of the frequency with which you comment about my weight. The thing you never seem to realise is that I struggle with being an emotional eater. And that started when I was a child, precisely because I felt undermined and worthless as a result of those comments. I dare say you didn’t intend to make me feel like that, but I am telling you now. And this is your choice: listen to me and take me seriously when I say I do not want to hear any more of your opinions on food and weight. And I will not allow my children to hear it”.

And hold that boundary.

About Christmas Eve?

”haha, no way! We weren’t planning to eat anything at all on Christmas Eve, it seems so gluttonous, with a big meal the next day! No I meant we would pop round for a quick hello and bring your presents.”

Dontjudgeme101 · 25/11/2022 08:33

Good for you! I hope that your dad regrets his behaviour towards you. 💐💐

DriedApricotss · 25/11/2022 08:32

I agree talkingmorenonsense. 100 per cent.

Question: none of this makes sense to me, really. Someone uptrend said that my dad knew what he is doing. What is my dad getting out of criticising my weight and telling me what to eat? Is it him trying to find something to criticise me for? As otherwise I'm doing okay? Or is it some kind of control? As I don't really need him / them anymore? I will never understand where this behaviour comes from.

OP posts:
WimpoleHat · 25/11/2022 08:32

however their response to meeting up for christmas eve was to go there for a salad on christmas eve as you shouldn't have two days in a row eating too much.

”No thanks, mum and dad - not really what we had in mind and not much fun for the girls. If food’s a problem for you, probably better to leave meeting up until after Christmas.”

And watch them change their tune….

talkingmorenonsense · 25/11/2022 08:31

DriedApricotss · 25/11/2022 08:20

The Boomer thing is probably a red herring. My dad has always been very sporty and I think he identifies with being fit and can't understand why his daughter isn't the same. I do like feeling fitter and slimmer partly because I don't get so much bullying about my weight!

The bigger story here is probably that I'm an emotional eater because my relationship wirh my parents was not brilliant growing up. Always felt they were trying to shame me and it continues! So probably turned to food a bit. Also my shocking personal boundaries have come up from low self esteem etc. So yes I do need to distance myself and continue working on myself next year.

We won't be going there on christmas eve for a small undressed salad, I can assure you of that! Going to stick to us 5 and have a cosy few days wearing pyjamas and eating whatever we blimming well like!! Grateful our daughter is much better!!

Good for you @DriedApricotss . Have a lovely 🎄 Christmas 🎄.

talkingmorenonsense · 25/11/2022 08:29

underneaththeash · 25/11/2022 07:42

I think you're being a bit oversensitive, he's probably worried about you..
Next time he mentions it just say "Dad, I know I'm a bit overweight, but you going on about it all the time really doesn't help. I'll sort it after Christmas. Can we just enjoy ourselves."

Victim blaming! I hate when people talk about being over sensitive, to excuse appalling behaviour from others.