Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not see my parents very near to Christmas as my Dad always talks about my weight

141 replies

DriedApricotss · 25/11/2022 07:30

Inspired by another thread.

I have been working on my very poor personal boundaries this year and have basically been distancing myself from relationships where I feel things are toxic or stale / feel I am the only one putting the effort in, etc. My life is quieter but freer and lighter and I feel so much better about things. In the future I will be looking for more balanced friendships.

My AIBU is that my parents and dad in particular is always making comments about my weight and what I eat. I am probably three stone overweight but in my defense, one of my children has been very ill this year so I haven't been able to leave the house to go out exercising as in the past. Even then my dad would make comments about food and weight etc.

As this year has been so tough with my daughter's illness, my husband and I have decided to have a quiet Christmas just the five or us, he, I and our three girls. I did suggest meeting up with my parents on christmas eve as I have had them around to my house for the past 3 Christmases and I didn't want to hurt their feelings however their response to meeting up for christmas eve was to go there for a salad on christmas eve as you shouldn't have two days in a row eating too much. When I suggested meeting up on christmas eve I hadn't even suggested meeting to eat, a quick hi in a town in between our homes would have been enough for me!

All this talk about eating/ what you eat / what not to eat is really starting to put me off seeing them. I find is so offensive. I am five foot 8 and a size 16, I have been slimmer in the past but I have never been mega skinny. It just makes me feel that my dad can't accept me as I am if that makes sense. With my work on my boundaries wirh toxic situationships this year, this scenario with my dad has become more apparent.

How shall I handle this? I have asked him not to comment about my weight before and he stops briefly and then goes back to talking about it. I spend ages working out what to wear before going to see them as I know my dad will be looking at me. I know they must speak about my weight behind my back. It has taken the joy out of taking the kids to see them. Tia x

OP posts:
MsRosley · 25/11/2022 10:26

Your parents are toxic and the weight comments are absolutely shit. But you know this. Well done for working on yourself, OP, and your boundaries. It can be a difficult and lonely path when you find you can no longer tolerate other people's crappy behaviour, but you are absolutely doing your best by yourself and your own children, who will absorb your example.

In your position, I would message them saying how you feel about the constant insensitive comments about your weight, and that you will no longer tolerate it. Tell them that you will get up and leave - or ask them to leave - if it continues. Then follow through with that warning if they ignore it.

Nobody has the right to treat you this way. The fact that it's your parents is doubly hurtful.

BloodAndFire · 25/11/2022 10:23

FictionalCharacter · 25/11/2022 10:18

Just what I was thinking.
And his behaviour isn’t him being worried about her. She isn’t morbidity obese! Most likely he likes women to be slim and believes that women must conform accordingly. Or maybe he has, or has had, an eating disorder. The Christmas Eve salad is pretty abnormal.

The OP hasn't said how much she weighs. A size 16 is pretty big (and very vague, could mean anything really).

She doesn't need to be told that it's OK because she isn't really fat. You don't know that. She says she is, and she presumably knows.

The point is that her parents shouldn't be putting her down because of it, NOT that it's OK because she "isn't fat".

Luckyducker · 25/11/2022 10:22

When I started reading this I thought you must be massive and your dad was finding it hard watching your eat yourself to death and was trying to help. But 5 foot 8 and size 16 is nothing out of the ordinary. There is a good chance you don't even look overweight. They may have eating issues themselves and are letting that effect you. Don't let them.

FictionalCharacter · 25/11/2022 10:18

whyhere · 25/11/2022 08:25

Just a small point (and I do understand - my mother was the same): at 5ft 8 you are not 3 stone overweight if you wear a size 16. Please don't let others' nonsense skew your picture of yourself 😘

Just what I was thinking.
And his behaviour isn’t him being worried about her. She isn’t morbidity obese! Most likely he likes women to be slim and believes that women must conform accordingly. Or maybe he has, or has had, an eating disorder. The Christmas Eve salad is pretty abnormal.

Readinginthesun · 25/11/2022 10:17

And @Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble one of the ( many) reasons my 30 something year old DD dumped her 30 something year old BF was because he made constant digs about her weight ( she is a perfect size 12) . So please less of the blame the boomers .

AuntieEntity · 25/11/2022 10:16

I'm low contact with my mother for this exact reason, and I pulled her up on comments like this a few weeks ago. Even at my slimmest she would caution me about gaining weight. I am 5' 8 and a size 18 currently, but I'm probably fitter than I've ever been, ironically, and I honestly think that she hates it because I'm healthy(ish) but not adhering to her idea of what healthy is.

I hope you do stay at home for Christmas, and in the New Year I'd think about reducing your contact even further. Your daughters don't need to internalise that message, or to see their Mum being emotionally abused.

Best of luck OP.

PopcornAndPeanutsAndChocolateAndTea · 25/11/2022 10:13

I'd be doing massive faux yawns once he starts gearing up
And if he asks why you're yawning so much tell him it's because he's fucking boring saying the same thing to you every time you see him
(Obviously leave out the swearing if your girls are there)

But I'm a sarcastic mare so 🤷‍♀️ 🤣

Artygirlghost · 25/11/2022 10:12

I had this as well with my parents.

Little comments about what I should and should not eat (they seem horrified that I could eat bread for example) because I would get fat.

Also a few comments about whatever clothes or shoes I was wearing making my ''ankles look big''...

I have never been overweight in the slightest and have been a size 12 most of my life (and still am at 52).

I ended up almost starving myself when I was in my teens.

One of the many reasons I no longer have contact with them. it was just part of the lifelong pattern of being controlling and destroying my self-esteem.

Readinginthesun · 25/11/2022 10:09

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 25/11/2022 09:46

I am in no way saying boomers are responsible, just that when there are people who make comments to like this, it’s regularly people from this particular era. Clearly the majority of people from this era are not like this at all. That’s not what I’m saying. But look at all of those who also have relatives like this - it’s not their sister or brother who’s saying it, it’s their mum or grandparents. There must be something about growing up in that era that made these commenters think it’s acceptable to comment - and it’s not.

“ growing up in that era “

Good grief - and you say you aren’t judging ??

Luredbyapomegranate · 25/11/2022 10:08

Congratulations on your newly firm boundaries!

Don't put up with this for the sake of your daughters as well as yourself. See them the week before for a cup of tea or something.

The only thing to do with your Dad's comments is to pull him up every single time. 'Dad - I won't listen to you making comments about my weight/health/appearance. I am fine the way I am and I don't need your input. Talk about something else.' If you can tell he's gearing up for it 'Dad are you about to make a comment about my weight/health/appearance? if so, don't - I am fine the way I am, and I don't need your input. Talk about something else' I would find a really standard sentence structure that you use every single time. If he says 'oh but I just want to...' just repeat 'I don't need your input. Talk about something else.' - it will be awkward for you at first, but it will very quickly get much more awkward for him. The broken record technique often does work.

If he doesn't toe the line, then I would sit him down and tell him that if this doesn't stop, you will be seeing much less of them, as you don't want to hear this, and you certainly don't want your daughters to.

I don't think it's worth speculating on why your dad does it. It sounds like it is most likely that he thinks it is good to be fit and thin, and that it he thinks it reflects badly on him that you aren't, and feels angry with himself about that, which he directs into anger at you. He might be trying to make himself feel big by making you feel small, but that seems less likely.

thebabessavedme · 25/11/2022 10:07

@Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble Its not being a 'boomer' that makes people behave like this, its being an arsehole, arseholes are around in every age group, usually quite easy to find, they are nasty, bullying, rude and are looking for any sort of power trip they can have at someone elses expense, the OPs DF sounds like an insecure nasty git who is jealous of his lovely dd and the successful adult life she has made for herself and cant cope with the fact that he is now pretty insignificant to her.

BloodAndFire · 25/11/2022 10:07

MistyRock · 25/11/2022 09:07

Agreed. You can't be very big at a size 16 at 5ft 8in. I doubt you're big at all. I bet you look lovely.

Don't do this. It's really unhelpful. I'm 5 ft 8 and I would be very big at a size 16. She hasn't said her weight (and doesn't need to) but she knows herself better than random strangers do.

Op seems to have a very clear perspective on her own weight issues so it is unhelpful and unsupportive to say "you're not fat". She knows she's fat.

The point is that the way her family treat her is not ok.

Iamthewombat · 25/11/2022 10:02

What’s with the salad on Christmas Eve? It blows my mind.

Do they think that they are introducing you to the radical new concept of salad? Which you wouldn’t have encountered previously. Then as soon as you taste it you will always choose it in preference to, er, all other types of food?

Do they plan to invite you for salad on every day during the Christmas period, so that you will be too full of lettuce to eat anything nice?

I’m really glad that you turned that offer down! Enjoy the Quality Street and pigs in blankets.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 25/11/2022 10:01

DogsDryWineAndCheese · 25/11/2022 07:39

Don’t go. Who the fuck wants salad on Christmas Eve anyway?

Pigs in blankets with potato salad that has bacon bits? I'd find that Christmassy.

But, no. I have a family member who thinks it's hilarious to keep count of how many biscuits, sausages, roast potatoes, mince pies or other food items that other people eat. He even maintains a running mental total of how many mince pies people eat over the season (he asks, "How many have you eaten since…" and then keeps mentioning that back to people).

It's beyond tiresome and has never been even faintly amusing.

I'd really hoped that one good thing that would come out of the last few years would be that people would realise that they can spend Christmas at home and without being exposed to family gatherings with passive-aggressive or unpleasant relatives.

dexterslockedintheshedagain · 25/11/2022 09:55

Thehop · 25/11/2022 07:33

Don’t go. Your daughters don’t need to hear that shit and neither do you.

This. Exactly this. I'm assuming he's absolutely perfect then - ideal weight, exercises regularly, doesn't drink or smoke, etc etc.
I'm raging on your behalf.

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 25/11/2022 09:46

Readinginthesun · 25/11/2022 09:13

Yet another thing us “ boomers” are responsible for !?
Sick of the ageism on MN .

I am in no way saying boomers are responsible, just that when there are people who make comments to like this, it’s regularly people from this particular era. Clearly the majority of people from this era are not like this at all. That’s not what I’m saying. But look at all of those who also have relatives like this - it’s not their sister or brother who’s saying it, it’s their mum or grandparents. There must be something about growing up in that era that made these commenters think it’s acceptable to comment - and it’s not.

ohthehorrorthehorror · 25/11/2022 09:45

Your dad is abusive and definitely knows what he is doing with these comments.
My sister-in-law is the same. I'm probably a couple of stones overweight and she made some snarky comments to me many years ago. Coming from someone with a history of disordered eating, I could see that she was skewed in terms of body image, but she's also a nasty bitch (not the only one who thinks it - her own sons are nc with her), so I blasted her with both barrels and have only seen her on a handful of occasions in the last 25 years. Win, win!

Iknowthis1 · 25/11/2022 09:43

Is it possible that he's genuinely worried about your health?

Admittedly he's handling it very badly but it might not be about control or jealously if they don't behave like this about other things.

Alondra · 25/11/2022 09:37

DriedApricotss · 25/11/2022 07:30

Inspired by another thread.

I have been working on my very poor personal boundaries this year and have basically been distancing myself from relationships where I feel things are toxic or stale / feel I am the only one putting the effort in, etc. My life is quieter but freer and lighter and I feel so much better about things. In the future I will be looking for more balanced friendships.

My AIBU is that my parents and dad in particular is always making comments about my weight and what I eat. I am probably three stone overweight but in my defense, one of my children has been very ill this year so I haven't been able to leave the house to go out exercising as in the past. Even then my dad would make comments about food and weight etc.

As this year has been so tough with my daughter's illness, my husband and I have decided to have a quiet Christmas just the five or us, he, I and our three girls. I did suggest meeting up with my parents on christmas eve as I have had them around to my house for the past 3 Christmases and I didn't want to hurt their feelings however their response to meeting up for christmas eve was to go there for a salad on christmas eve as you shouldn't have two days in a row eating too much. When I suggested meeting up on christmas eve I hadn't even suggested meeting to eat, a quick hi in a town in between our homes would have been enough for me!

All this talk about eating/ what you eat / what not to eat is really starting to put me off seeing them. I find is so offensive. I am five foot 8 and a size 16, I have been slimmer in the past but I have never been mega skinny. It just makes me feel that my dad can't accept me as I am if that makes sense. With my work on my boundaries wirh toxic situationships this year, this scenario with my dad has become more apparent.

How shall I handle this? I have asked him not to comment about my weight before and he stops briefly and then goes back to talking about it. I spend ages working out what to wear before going to see them as I know my dad will be looking at me. I know they must speak about my weight behind my back. It has taken the joy out of taking the kids to see them. Tia x

What your father is doing is less important than your own boundaries. When your parents told you about a salad, it was the perfect timing for you to say I wasn't suggesting a meal. Just a visit to see you before Christmas Day".

You can't change your father. You can only change about how you deal with him.

Give them a call and say "Look, it's a bit hectic and will see you after Christmas". Next time your father mentions your weight in his home, leave the room. Don't answer, don't react. Just leave. If he is in your house, be upfront, "I don't like you talking about my weight". No apologies, no justifications.

I know it's difficult to maintain strict boundaries with the people you love but until you do, your father won't respect them.

Blondlashes · 25/11/2022 09:36

My DH has this issue with his DF. He told his parents if they mention his weight he will leave immediately. So far this is working. Although his DH has now turned his attention to DHs Brother. But DH put his boundaries up and so far it’s helpful.

Rafferty10 · 25/11/2022 09:34

op have you bluntly told your father any of how his comments make you feel?

I would say

Dad l am an adult and my weight is none of your business, it is constantly upesetting me to have these endless comments each time we meet up, and disrespectful.
Do not do it ever again, if you do l will not want to see you.

Then stop and let him digest it.

Do not make excuses for being blunt or try and soften the message.

MistyRock · 25/11/2022 09:33

I don't know why parents would do this. I would never dream of putting my son down and make him feel bad. I think putting some distance between you and them can only be a good thing. You deserve better.

DriedApricotss · 25/11/2022 09:29

I can't say I look forward to seeing my parents really. They barely saw me before I had the girls and I know if we didn't have our girls they would be very absent indeed. Next year I am going to be doing what suits me more as its clear as day that there is a lack of respect towards me. Also possibly a bit of jealousy as my girls are lovely and we have our own business and are doing okay - well enough to buy the odd takeaway pun intended double lols - and my parents always really struggled with money. The need to stick the knife in with my weight could be to take the wind out of my sails for that reason maybe, I don't know. It's a shame anyway. And puts me off caring for them as they get older as it makes for awkward conversations etc. Such a shame all round tbh.

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 25/11/2022 09:25

My Dad is like this - not with me any more, because for the last 15 years I have made sure I am never anywhere with him, that I can't leave immediately when I want to.

Any comments, any 'hilarious' jokes involving food or my size and I am gone and that typically means he's sat there by himself, which he doesn't like at all.

He does it for a variety of reasons - when I was younger, because he genuinely thought it would make me lose weight.

Then when I was older, I think he tried to use humour so people wouldn't judge HIM for having a fat daughter.

He does think he is incredibly funny - he has never been even remotely funny and age certainly hasn't improved that. His style of humour is very much 'put someone else down' and always has been, but he is also seemingly unable to see that people are giving him attention almost in shock at the nasty things he says, often about his own child/children (my sister didnt entirely escape this stuff though as she was not overweight as a child, she got off easier than I did!)

So I'd advise you to deal with it the way I have - never put yourself in a position where you cannot leave, immediately, with as little fuss or discussion as possible.

I don't have a drama about it, I don't say 'Dad, you're being vile, we've talked about this, I am leaving now' or lose my shit in any way.

I just say 'Ok time we were going, see ya later' and fuck off. And then he's left there, with no audience to play off, no reaction to be had at all, and thus.. no reinforcement for his behaviour.

Rinatinabina · 25/11/2022 09:22

It’s your time off as a family, why would you want it to be a bit shit. If you end up feeling down everytime you see them don’t see them.