Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not see my parents very near to Christmas as my Dad always talks about my weight

141 replies

DriedApricotss · 25/11/2022 07:30

Inspired by another thread.

I have been working on my very poor personal boundaries this year and have basically been distancing myself from relationships where I feel things are toxic or stale / feel I am the only one putting the effort in, etc. My life is quieter but freer and lighter and I feel so much better about things. In the future I will be looking for more balanced friendships.

My AIBU is that my parents and dad in particular is always making comments about my weight and what I eat. I am probably three stone overweight but in my defense, one of my children has been very ill this year so I haven't been able to leave the house to go out exercising as in the past. Even then my dad would make comments about food and weight etc.

As this year has been so tough with my daughter's illness, my husband and I have decided to have a quiet Christmas just the five or us, he, I and our three girls. I did suggest meeting up with my parents on christmas eve as I have had them around to my house for the past 3 Christmases and I didn't want to hurt their feelings however their response to meeting up for christmas eve was to go there for a salad on christmas eve as you shouldn't have two days in a row eating too much. When I suggested meeting up on christmas eve I hadn't even suggested meeting to eat, a quick hi in a town in between our homes would have been enough for me!

All this talk about eating/ what you eat / what not to eat is really starting to put me off seeing them. I find is so offensive. I am five foot 8 and a size 16, I have been slimmer in the past but I have never been mega skinny. It just makes me feel that my dad can't accept me as I am if that makes sense. With my work on my boundaries wirh toxic situationships this year, this scenario with my dad has become more apparent.

How shall I handle this? I have asked him not to comment about my weight before and he stops briefly and then goes back to talking about it. I spend ages working out what to wear before going to see them as I know my dad will be looking at me. I know they must speak about my weight behind my back. It has taken the joy out of taking the kids to see them. Tia x

OP posts:
Stripedbag101 · 25/11/2022 15:34

Oh my goodness well done! Brilliant result.

please call them out if they don’t respect this boundary

DriedApricotss · 25/11/2022 15:26

It has really helped hearing all your comments so thank you:)

OP posts:
DriedApricotss · 25/11/2022 15:24

I think my dad does have a low key eating disorder and is obsessed with staying lean and fit. That's great and that's up to him but as per pp posts on this thread, I have to think of my three girls and what they are seeing and picking up on. Yes I do enjoy food but I'm not excessive most of the time. I could have exercised more this year if one of our daughters hadn't been so ill for most of it. I have spoken to my parents today to say we won't be coming for a meal on christmas eve as the kids wouldn't enjoy salad then and also we were going to stay at home in our pyjamas over Christmas eating whatever we felt like. There was silence on the other end of the phone then mum said 'good for you, good for you all' which was nice. I also then took the opportunity to tell them over the phone that the girls had picked up on the fact dad kept mentioning my weight and could they not bring it up again. Again, silence to begin with then mum said 'of course, we understand.' I said I wouldn't ever want my three daughters to think it was acceptable for anyone to talk about their bodies. We talked about other things but am giving you the edited highlights as they relate to the OP.

Thanks MN for the solidarity today, I doubt my dad will keep to the rule as I've asked before but maybe it will sink in more as I've brought my daughter's into it? We will see and time will tell x

OP posts:
Snnowflake · 25/11/2022 14:54

underneaththeash · 25/11/2022 07:42

I think you're being a bit oversensitive, he's probably worried about you..
Next time he mentions it just say "Dad, I know I'm a bit overweight, but you going on about it all the time really doesn't help. I'll sort it after Christmas. Can we just enjoy ourselves."

I don’t think it’s that - I would guess it’s something from the past, most likely his past and childhood. It’s v unusual for a man to comment. And 5’8” and size 16 sounds fine to me.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 25/11/2022 13:54

just that when there are people who make comments to like this, it’s regularly people from this particular era

You've got some back up for that assertion that it's boomers (detestable phrase) who regularly make these comments, of course.

And particular era? you make it sound like the bloody Bronze Age.

WinterLobelia · 25/11/2022 13:45

My parents are the same and I am also 3 stone overweight. I am seeing them at the end of March (they live abroad) and I responded to my thoughts of them coming by immediately returning to my bulimia. I always cut my clothes tags out as my mother will literally go into my laundry basket to look at what size I am.

So I am following this thread with interest as well.

Just as a funny aside, last time they were here my mother made a comment about how good it is the DCs take after their dad (long and thin) and not me and my autistic 10 year old son drew himself up to full height and boomed in an exceptionally loud and carrying voice; 'WE WILL HAVE NO BODY SHAMING IN THIS HOUSE'.

Love him. Grin

MistyRock · 25/11/2022 13:38

BloodAndFire · 25/11/2022 10:07

Don't do this. It's really unhelpful. I'm 5 ft 8 and I would be very big at a size 16. She hasn't said her weight (and doesn't need to) but she knows herself better than random strangers do.

Op seems to have a very clear perspective on her own weight issues so it is unhelpful and unsupportive to say "you're not fat". She knows she's fat.

The point is that the way her family treat her is not ok.

Sorry. My Mistake. You are completely right.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 25/11/2022 13:15

Tempting to simply say, "yes, I could stand to lose a few pounds. With X's illness I've not been able to leave the house in months. Any chance you could come to the house for 2 hrs a day and help me out so I could get some exercise?" Hard look...

Or, "thanks for the invite Dad but it's been a very difficult year. DH and I are exhausted and I don't feel up to endless personal comments about my weight. Let's meet somewhere nice for coffee and hot chocolate and wish each other a good Christmas"

forevercooking · 25/11/2022 13:00

Do we have the same parents op?

Except mine insist on piling me with food as they assume as I'm chubby it's because I eat too much. In reality I eat very little. I'm just a chubby human

Stripedbag101 · 25/11/2022 12:44

Dogtooth · 25/11/2022 11:11

Personally I think it would be good if we could have close enough bonds that people could say - hey, you're gaining weight, are you unhappy, how can I help? So the focus is on how someone feels and the weight is just a symptom of that.

Right now in our culture we sit back, observe the signs that someone is unhappy such as weight gain, drinking too much, relationship problems etc and judge the embodiment of the unhappiness to be the problem rather than the unhappiness that is the root cause. People demand that the signs of unhappiness are hidden, rather than trying to sort out the underlying problem.

But changing it would take a major cultural shift I guess!

I have to strongly disagree.

people who have gained weight know they have gained weight. Pointing it out will only make them feel bad and self conscious.

we can ask how someone is - and express interest and concern without commenting on their body.

on the boomer argument - I think a lot of people are now reaching an age where they are reflecting on their parents attitudes and pushing back. We are also more aware of the impacts on barbed comments.

there will be another generation of children out there experiencing this from younger parents - and in a few years they will be complaining about that generation.

DriedApricotss · 25/11/2022 11:26

Dogtooth I quite agree. In my case, it would be good to instead of jumping to food / weight someone close to my situation could see ive been under enormous strain this year with illness and worry and work. And not mention weight.

OP posts:
CruCru · 25/11/2022 11:19

I think it's about my dad wanting to be mean and piss on my parade! I don't think he likes me very much tbh. Size 16 at my height is not massive.

I agree. Size 16 for a big boned 5 ft 8 woman is not massive.

Readinginthesun · 25/11/2022 11:12

Dogtooth · 25/11/2022 11:04

I don't think boomers are any meaner than anyone else. However it's definitely true that attitudes to weight have changed, and not all boomers have moved with the times.

DD came back from her grandparents with girls annuals from the 70s recently. They have cartoons where a girl who has gained weight is joked about and called names, she decides to only eat lettuce, loses weight and gains acceptance. All presented as a neat moral tale of how to do the right thing, complete with 'fatty' nicknames etc.

Or there's one about how there are two sisters, one is slim and beautiful and one is fat and plain, so the fat one has to be the manager for the other one's international modelling career (she gets disfigured in an accident and cut down to size, but hey that's the price of vanity in the 70s :) )

My point is - this really venomous attitude to weight was commonplace a few decades back. The idea that women's bodies were there to be gawped at and discussed. Some people haven't changed. It's particularly hurtful from a parent because it suggests they don't accept you unconditionally.

So basically OP, I think you should do what makes you happy. Feel free to tell your parents you don't want to see them because their comments make you feel like shit and have zero impact on you losing weight.

Some of the most cruel , judgemental comments about weight that I have become aware of in recent times are from young men who watch too much porn and follow ( photoshopped) models on Instagram so have unrealistic ideas about the “ perfect” female body .

Dogtooth · 25/11/2022 11:11

Personally I think it would be good if we could have close enough bonds that people could say - hey, you're gaining weight, are you unhappy, how can I help? So the focus is on how someone feels and the weight is just a symptom of that.

Right now in our culture we sit back, observe the signs that someone is unhappy such as weight gain, drinking too much, relationship problems etc and judge the embodiment of the unhappiness to be the problem rather than the unhappiness that is the root cause. People demand that the signs of unhappiness are hidden, rather than trying to sort out the underlying problem.

But changing it would take a major cultural shift I guess!

Dogtooth · 25/11/2022 11:04

I don't think boomers are any meaner than anyone else. However it's definitely true that attitudes to weight have changed, and not all boomers have moved with the times.

DD came back from her grandparents with girls annuals from the 70s recently. They have cartoons where a girl who has gained weight is joked about and called names, she decides to only eat lettuce, loses weight and gains acceptance. All presented as a neat moral tale of how to do the right thing, complete with 'fatty' nicknames etc.

Or there's one about how there are two sisters, one is slim and beautiful and one is fat and plain, so the fat one has to be the manager for the other one's international modelling career (she gets disfigured in an accident and cut down to size, but hey that's the price of vanity in the 70s :) )

My point is - this really venomous attitude to weight was commonplace a few decades back. The idea that women's bodies were there to be gawped at and discussed. Some people haven't changed. It's particularly hurtful from a parent because it suggests they don't accept you unconditionally.

So basically OP, I think you should do what makes you happy. Feel free to tell your parents you don't want to see them because their comments make you feel like shit and have zero impact on you losing weight.

PiggyInTheLidl · 25/11/2022 10:57

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 25/11/2022 09:46

I am in no way saying boomers are responsible, just that when there are people who make comments to like this, it’s regularly people from this particular era. Clearly the majority of people from this era are not like this at all. That’s not what I’m saying. But look at all of those who also have relatives like this - it’s not their sister or brother who’s saying it, it’s their mum or grandparents. There must be something about growing up in that era that made these commenters think it’s acceptable to comment - and it’s not.

Obviously where someone has an issue with their parents making comments, it will be older generation.

But plenty of other people make comments. Sisters. SILs. Brothers, BILS. ‘Friends’. Loads of MN threads about friends making judgey comments about weight.

You are still being judgey about a generation and what you consider them to think is OK or not.

Maybe you should consider what comments you make about others until you have thought this through a bit more.

Idontgiveashitanymore · 25/11/2022 10:55

Please don’t go, no one should be body shamed like that, no one!
if your family treat you like this then you need to walk away.
I have suffered abuse most of my life and I am nc with all them. I have family that genuinely loves me for me.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 25/11/2022 10:52

BuddhaAtSea · 25/11/2022 07:36

I would call to say Merry Christmas, we won’t be seeing you because of your behaviour around food, I have 3 daughters who don’t need to hear your constant put downs about food, it’s not healthy. See you soon.
Job done.

Great suggestion.

They are reaping what they've sown.

DriedApricotss · 25/11/2022 10:48

It's not about my size really i know that but to be honest sometimes I feel curvy and healthy and sometimes I feel fat... depending on comments etc! It does affect me when people comment about my weight. I am broad shouldered so would never be able to fit into a size 12 blouse, for example, even if very slim and have big feet so am big boned if that makes sense. I'm definitely not dainty but I don't hate the way I look. I don't think it is about that though, tbh I think it's about my dad wanting to be mean and piss on my parade! I don't think he likes me very much tbh. Size 16 at my height is not massive.

OP posts:
been and done it. · 25/11/2022 10:45

Iwantmyoldnameback · 25/11/2022 07:56

I'm a fat boomer, I mix a lot with other boomers and there is only one obsessed but weight. To be fair she has lost 12 stone so it's understandable. All the rest are various shapes and sizes and just enjoy life.

But if course everything wrong in life is down to boomers and the current weight obsession is nothing to do with social media is it?

Actually I'm one of those insidious vile snipey responsible for everything boomers and I'm seriously pissed off with reading shite like this.

OnTheBackOfMyFoot · 25/11/2022 10:41

I'm probably a bit biased as I'm recovering from a serious bout of anorexia but you should absolutely protect your daughters (and yourself) from their disordered bullshit. Eating disorder forums are full of people who often naturally sit at a slightly higher BMI and have families who couldn't resist putting them down about it and trying to control them. It sounds like you've managed to side step internalising their negative attitude to food and weight and are establishing healthy boundaries - good for you. You're setting an amazing example to your daughters.

minimalism1407 · 25/11/2022 10:39

Not at all! To be honest I’d cut off any family if they spoke to me like that. Parents or not. Would consider going ‘no contact’. You don’t need people like that in your life.

MugginsOverEre · 25/11/2022 10:29

Whiskyvodka · 25/11/2022 08:05

@DriedApricotss my dn is overweight. One day her dm said something about my dn’s weight and my dn quietly stood up, called the dc and left.
She didn’t say why but it was obvious and my dsis learned her lesson.
Thats what you do, every time.

I did the same but with phone calls. I live on the opposite end of the country to my dad. I have always desperately wanted my dad to like me. I wanted a close relationship with all my family. Sadly, mum's a complete narcissist and dad was just mean. It feels like I spent my whole childhood in tears, feeling like shit after dad would shout at me or just be really mean. It continued to adulthood and every week as the dutiful daughter, I'd phone him, he'd be mean, I'd come off the phone and cry like some pathetic wuss. It took me far too long to realise that I was holding that phone to my ear. I was calling him. I was openly inviting the nasty words.

One day I decided, no more. The second he started being horrible I'd just put the phone down. I continued this, on the phone and if meeting in person, I'd walk out and go home/back to whatever relatives I was staying with on my hometown visit.

I eventually had to stop all contact. When it started back up again a year or so later he was a different man. He kept his nasty fucking comments to himself. We never fully recovered until he was dying though.

rookiemere · 25/11/2022 10:27

People used to weigh a lot less - that's why folks are mentioning the generational thing.

If you see films of the queens coronation or people on the beach in the 60s and 70s they are all generally a lot slimmer than the average now. I was deemed to be huge and fat at school at 5ft6 and 11 stone, now in my 50s I am 12 stone and fit into most size 14s.

So my DPs probably see me as being enormous.

But the thread really isn't about is OP overweight or not, or how she looks, it's about her DF using general modern good manners not to discuss any aspect of her weight or her appearance, unless it's to say "You look lovely darling ".

SchoolQuestionnaire · 25/11/2022 10:26

Thehop · 25/11/2022 07:33

Don’t go. Your daughters don’t need to hear that shit and neither do you.

Yep.