Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I a fraud?/Are you a fraud?

64 replies

Toastandavocado · 24/11/2022 22:50

AIBU for feeling like a fraud? Just watched the late night news article on Iran and the poor wee children murdered over the last month. It made me feel sick.

Then thought of the World Cup and the poor human rights and poor migrant workers who have died (and their families) and I said I wasn’t going to watch it because of these human rights violations.

Anyway, I work in education and all the kids are watching it, there’s no discussion around why the shouldn’t watch it and I’ve found myself watching some of it.

I still feel disgusted by the whole thing. What’s wrong with us? I genuinely believe most of us feel the same collective responsibility to human life, and doing the right thing. Why do we turn a blind eye? Why don’t we feel more confident to say, fuck you, if this was my child, I’d want the weight of the world behind it… and I feel like that’s what we should give, ie do not watch the World Cup… etc etc… little bits of support… to build a wave of change.

I truly believe I’m a fraud… and I’m sad to think this is the majority of the population too, and we want to change it, we just don’t know how 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
GardenDesigns · 25/11/2022 01:37

Toastandavocado · 25/11/2022 01:34

Why are you even commenting then? Strange

Are you implying no one should comment on a thread unless agreeing with it? If you want an echo chamber, best to just write a diary

KittieDaley · 25/11/2022 01:36

No-one thinks the world is fair. The trouble is, unless we're in a position of real power, we can't do much about it. You could spend your whole life fretting over injustice, or you could be like most people and wonder what to have for dinner tonight.

Toastandavocado · 25/11/2022 01:34

Why are you even commenting then? Strange

OP posts:
GardenDesigns · 25/11/2022 01:32

Frostycarrot · 25/11/2022 01:22

Not watching it doesn’t help any of the people in need - how could it?
the only people I know who are boycotting are people who probably wouldn’t watch much anyway, it’s hardly a sacrifice for them really and it’s certainly not something helpful for the world
they’re also not doing anything about the women and girls struggling in this country, human trafficking, homelessness, food poverty, our government being corrupt, our royal family supporting nonces or any of the other big issues
and these boycotters are happy to buy things and have connections with other countries with questionable human rights.
but at least they feel better about themselves jumping on this particular bandwagon for a few weeks, until they forget in jan.

Indeed.. I doubt the OP has ever attended or watched a football match in her life so no great loss she is " boycotting it". No reply to my question on if she boycotts countries that have engaged in war crimes and their matches strangely enough. 💩

GardenDesigns · 25/11/2022 01:29

Toastandavocado · 25/11/2022 01:27

It’s a worldwide event, getting worldwide coverage, how could a collective response to boycotting it (that translates to money) possibly get a point heard 🤷‍♀️… as you were 🙄

because most people watching the world cup aren't random virtue signallers on mumsnet - they're men generally who watch it. As you were.

GardenDesigns · 25/11/2022 01:28

Toastandavocado · 25/11/2022 01:22

I don’t watch the Tour de France, Garden 🪴🤷‍♀️

surprisesports.com/opinion/most-watched-sports-events-in-the-world/ Think you need to update your stats

Toastandavocado · 25/11/2022 01:27

It’s a worldwide event, getting worldwide coverage, how could a collective response to boycotting it (that translates to money) possibly get a point heard 🤷‍♀️… as you were 🙄

OP posts:
Frostycarrot · 25/11/2022 01:22

Not watching it doesn’t help any of the people in need - how could it?
the only people I know who are boycotting are people who probably wouldn’t watch much anyway, it’s hardly a sacrifice for them really and it’s certainly not something helpful for the world
they’re also not doing anything about the women and girls struggling in this country, human trafficking, homelessness, food poverty, our government being corrupt, our royal family supporting nonces or any of the other big issues
and these boycotters are happy to buy things and have connections with other countries with questionable human rights.
but at least they feel better about themselves jumping on this particular bandwagon for a few weeks, until they forget in jan.

Toastandavocado · 25/11/2022 01:22

I don’t watch the Tour de France, Garden 🪴🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
GardenDesigns · 25/11/2022 01:17

I'm sure the most popular and most watched event on the planet can handle a virtue signalling bore on mumsnet (the OP) informing us all she isn't watching an event on a tv ( which she probably is anyway).

Do you boycott all British shows and American sporting events OP from 2 countries that illegally invaded Iraq killing people 20 years ago .. thought not.

Toastandavocado · 25/11/2022 01:14

Just heartbreaking… and we all turn a blind eye 👏

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 25/11/2022 01:09

80% of the Qatari population is migrant workers. They have their passports taken away from them so they can't leave even if they want to.

It was also claimed that the country would be welcoming and inclusive to fans. They lied. They know they can lie because they have the money and power to get away with it.

Toastandavocado · 25/11/2022 01:02

Change, any imbalance of money sadly seems to lead to corruption on some level. Your “unease” is justified because there is an imbalance of power. I can only try to empathise with the individuals who are at the mercy of a system that does not support their human rights and the poor families who have lost loved ones.

OP posts:
changeme4this · 25/11/2022 00:57

I find myself in conflict of another aspect of the World Cup and that particular sport(because of a direct association with someone involved in it) and to me its the inbalance of money and what it goes to pay for...

The best way I can explain my unease, for want of a better word, is the sport itself attracts some of the poorest of nations and people. Yet businesses/entities and/or individuals (I am being deliberately vague for a reason) associated with it, are some of the wealthiest and yes/yes they work for it and deserve compensation for their efforts, but so do the poorer nations and people who are supporters/players/volunteers behind the sport at grass roots level who struggle for funding or payment.

I totally agree that this isn't the only sport, it is just a personal example for me as I know what a particular entity's renumeration package is... and its eye watering.

Toastandavocado · 25/11/2022 00:52

Really interesting Ilovesooty, always comes down to money. So sad, and even more of a reason why we should be having the conversations with our children/younger generation as to why watching this is morally corrupt. Perhaps if the teams are “hot” or eat avocados or pistachios we can give them a free pass when they’re killing women for showing their hair or hundreds of migrant workers die while building stadiums. It’s like the Hunger Games…supported by the scarily entitled 🙄

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 25/11/2022 00:45

I believe that as soon as Qatar bribed their way to hosting this tournament England should have refused to send a team there, as should all the major teams in Europe.

I haven't watched any of the tournament. It shouldn't be held there at all. The migrant worker deaths, the fact that criticism of the government is a criminal offence, the potential death sentence for homosexuality, the treatment of women - all are good reasons not to send teams there.

However this is all about money. The government is cosying up to Qatar as our North Sea reserves diminish. Qatar is the third largest property owner in London. They also invest heavily in companies used every day by millions of people - eg Sainsburys and Barclays.

Toastandavocado · 25/11/2022 00:30

You sound utterly ridiculous… full stop ✋

OP posts:
Toastandavocado · 25/11/2022 00:28

I don’t think not eating avocados 🥑 or pistachios would make much of a political point, however I think collectively boycotting major sporting events would. Globalisation is here to stay, human rights violations should not be an acceptable part of that.

OP posts:
Keyansier · 25/11/2022 00:26

Toastandavocado · 24/11/2022 23:43

From memory Saudi had a number of goals against them disallowed. They had a tiny percentage of possession and two fantastic goals, which would have made for an exciting game. Japan, another ‘exciting’ game. Great football or great tournament?, nope. To be fair, if I was a Japanese or Saudi supporter I’d think otherwise, but as a female I’d be much more concerned about my human rights, or my daughter’s human rights than a ‘lucky’ game of football.

You sound absolutely ridiculous trying to argue otherwise, as I thought you might..

Knulp · 25/11/2022 00:24

If you like avocados, then it is quite likely you have been eating Mexican produce, not a country with a great human rights record, you probably own or have bought something from China, again, some questions there.

The truth of the matter is, if you were to boycott every country with questionable records, you would be hard pressed to buy or own anything.

Everything is tainted, religion, countries, corporations, political parties, the list goes on, so what exactly does giving up watching football achieve if your going to eat a Mexican avocado in the morning, drive your car to work bristling with Chinese technology, whilst munching Iranian pistachios..

Toastandavocado · 25/11/2022 00:15

To me it sounds like these poor women and children and migrant workers not having a voice and having no one to stand with them, alongside them, and give them a voice… even if it means in tiny ways, of ‘opting out’ of not watching major sporting events, having the conversations with our children as to why we don’t support these events, and why we don’t watch them. Being collectively responsible for our actions to be morally accountable. How do you imagine the not collectively standing up?

OP posts:
BosaNova · 25/11/2022 00:06

How do you imagine that collective standing up you keep talking about?

Because to me it sounds kind of like how we excused invasions and destabilisation of regions...

Toastandavocado · 24/11/2022 23:56

Of course I did. I don’t have a specific vendetta to this particular sporting event… I’m questioning all our morals on not standing up (collectively) to clear human rights violations. It seems strange that you’d even ask that, unless of course that is your own country?

OP posts:
VeniVidiWeeWee · 24/11/2022 23:52

@Toastandavocado

And did you object when the world cup was in Russia, or the Olympics in China?

Or many other sporting events in countries with dubious civil rights record?

Toastandavocado · 24/11/2022 23:47

What quote?

OP posts: