Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tiger parenting

209 replies

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:14

I see a kid each week for tutoring. Chinese family, kid is Y8.

He's told me his parents love him and only hit him if he has been very bad. I've asked him to talk to his school counsellor but he said no, he's ok. I told him it's not allowed in this country for parents to hit kids. And that he can call Childline or NSPCC. But he doesn't want his parents to get in trouble.

If I report then I will never see him again and the situation doesn't change. Any advice?

OP posts:
Carbon12 · 24/11/2022 22:59

@BuryingAcorns that is awful advice.

You can only be his confidante until he says something that puts himself or someone else in danger.

The child has already said he is being hit, I can't imagine what he's going through that he hasn't said aloud.

SunshinePlease101 · 24/11/2022 22:59

Hmm it’s a very tricky situation. It isn’t black and white actually and culture is very important in this context.

Let’s say you inform the school/social services.

The likely scenarios are:

  1. SS talk him and his family and give them advice about physical punishment as I doubt he’d meet the threshold for a court order to be removed. His parents flip out and he never speaks of it again or gets sent back to China.
  2. He is removed from his parents and gets placed into foster care. Likely to be a white British foster family too. He is now in the care system, away from his family, friends and culture. Psychological damage and trauma will be caused to both him and his family. He may even be ostracised by the Chinese community. The care system is also not particularly caring either.

But 1 is the likely scenario contrary to mumsnet belief the threshold to remove children is incredibly high due to the outcomes I stated in option 2. Removal of children is the last resort because being in the care system does not have great outcomes for children.

TheOrigRights · 24/11/2022 22:59

Report it please.

LateMumma · 24/11/2022 22:58

I'm struggling with this one OP. Presumably you've undergone safeguarding training, so you know that you not only have a duty of care, but a legal obligation to report. I understand your reticence, it's an incredibly difficult position to be in. But you have no choice here. Please safeguard this child.

BuryingAcorns · 24/11/2022 22:55

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:46

I know I have a duty of care.

But informing his school may make things worse not better.

He told me because he is in a safe place with me I suppose.

Maybe just continue to be his confidante. Tell him if it ever troubles him, he can talk to you about it. If he ever wants you to talk with them or any other adult about it, you will. Tell him you don't think it is right.

At DC's school there was a Chinese boy whose parents were overly strict. The school called them in an lectured them that bright children thrive better in a culture of calm kindness and told them the stress of the beatings would lower not raise his grades. Things improved after that according to DC. You could have a word with them to that effect.

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:53

Maybe I talk to the parents?

Or to his uncle who is less traditional in his parenting?

OP posts:
BuryingAcorns · 24/11/2022 22:52

This is really tricky OP. I know someone who works in a children's home who has raised two girls brought in by SS because of a father who was overly strict by our standards (culture is relevant here. Some cultures still hit children, just as we were hit in 1970s.) They were frightened of their father but were also high achieving children academically. By the time they left the care system they had been raised in a very lax way (care home staff not allowed to restrain them if they choose to go out at night etc) and had lost interest in school work. Swapped one evil for another. Not sure which would have helped them have a better life, long term.
Obviously I'm not suggesting they should have stayed with a father who beat them but the alternative is hardly an obviously better solution.

northernlola · 24/11/2022 22:50

I understand your concern about it not being handled well. But what do you propose as an alternative? You never tell anyone, so as not to break his trust? And so the tutoring continues.

How will that stop him getting hit!?

Icecreamandapplepie · 24/11/2022 22:47

If he's more terrified of being sent away and that would be a possibility here, the surely at his age you'd have to take his opinion into account.

I only say that with the knowledge that little to nothing would be done if you did report it.

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:46

I know I have a duty of care.

But informing his school may make things worse not better.

He told me because he is in a safe place with me I suppose.

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 24/11/2022 22:45

Grow up.

A kids told you they are being abused. You have to report it.

There is no room for debate over stuff like this.

Carbon12 · 24/11/2022 22:43

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:27

It's normal in his culture to be disciplined in this way. He and his friends talk about it and accept it.

It doesn't matter. You have a duty of care.

I'd be interested to know how the topic came up.

Did he just randomly confide in you without you expecting it?

Or did you ask questions?

Either way, things like this cannot be kept confidential and you should have told that to your student.

gogohmm · 24/11/2022 22:42

Smacking is still legal in England and Northern Ireland btw

Again not condoning it

gogohmm · 24/11/2022 22:40

Whilst yes ethnicity is irrelevant it does add context because in some cultures corporal punishment is still commonplace and is not seen as bad. I personally never smacked my children, nor was I smacked by my parents but I know people who did, it wasn't illegal either (within parameters). I'm not condoning violence, I'm just pointing out the mum may not realise it's not good parenting

Honeynutcheerios · 24/11/2022 22:39

I know someone who was in a very similar situation. They told the school. The child’s parents came in and the child was terrified and denied it happened. The parents raised merry hell at the school. Nothing happened. The child was probably still abused. I think there’s unlikely to be a happy ending here

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:38

He volunteered that it was normal among his Chinese friends to be treated in this way, I didn't ask.

OP posts:
McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:37

I don't trust that social services would communicate effectively with the parents or that the kid would be in a safer situation afterwards.
His parents have said before now that they would send him to relatives abroad and he's afraid of that. He loves his parents and they love him but they are strict.

OP posts:
Changechangychange · 24/11/2022 22:35

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:27

It's normal in his culture to be disciplined in this way. He and his friends talk about it and accept it.

How do you know what this child and his friends talk about, if you just see him for weekly tutoring?

northernlola · 24/11/2022 22:32

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:26

If I speak to his school and they speak with him he will deny it and know I've betrayed his trust.
If I speak to the parents they will stop bringing him to me.
In both cases he loses out.

Yes, then there's the other, correct option where you report it immediately and he doesn't lose out because he is safeguarded properly. I find your position very concerning.

Familydilemmas · 24/11/2022 22:31

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:27

It's normal in his culture to be disciplined in this way. He and his friends talk about it and accept it.

I work in safeguarding with many cultures. Social services go by what is acceptable in our country regardless of the families culture. It is not acceptable here in the U.K. and the family need to change their practice. End of. Social services will speak to parents and the child and explain that. You then speak to parents and discuss how you have a duty of care to their child to report concerns but would love to continue tutoring him now it’s been explained. Then it’s their choice.

LunaTheCat · 24/11/2022 22:28

How utterly utterly heartbreaking! You need to report. It’s not your call to make other than report. Awful for you too.

Albatrossss · 24/11/2022 22:28

I’d anonymously report it so you can keep seeing him and anonymously send the parents articles about Jennifer pan and this video fb.watch/g-GpjMOh1f/

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:27

It's normal in his culture to be disciplined in this way. He and his friends talk about it and accept it.

OP posts:
DimSumAndGT · 24/11/2022 22:27

You do need to report but chastising children this way is seen as acceptable in many Chinese households. I say this as someone who is Chinese and was chastised like this. I have not hit my own children just in case anyone is wondering but compared to my sons friends was much stricter.

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:26

If I speak to his school and they speak with him he will deny it and know I've betrayed his trust.
If I speak to the parents they will stop bringing him to me.
In both cases he loses out.

OP posts: