Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tiger parenting

209 replies

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:14

I see a kid each week for tutoring. Chinese family, kid is Y8.

He's told me his parents love him and only hit him if he has been very bad. I've asked him to talk to his school counsellor but he said no, he's ok. I told him it's not allowed in this country for parents to hit kids. And that he can call Childline or NSPCC. But he doesn't want his parents to get in trouble.

If I report then I will never see him again and the situation doesn't change. Any advice?

OP posts:
Cupcakegirl13 · 25/11/2022 04:17

Have you not completed even a basic safeguarding training ? This is safeguarding 101. Im a children’s social worker and without doubt you need to report this fully to your local
authority Childress services immediately.

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 25/11/2022 04:08

I meant *brow beaten of course! Unfortunate typo there.

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 25/11/2022 04:06

McCoysCheese · 25/11/2022 03:25

I suppose I'm asking for advice that looks at the big picture rather than the small one.

Some of you get it, the cultural influence IS relevant and school safeguarding IS likely to make things worse not better.

He didn't ask me to keep it secret but he also vehemently said no to my suggestion that he talk to the school counsellor.

YOU DON'T HAVE THE BIG PICTURE!

You have snippets of the whole picture, based on what a brown beaten child is telling you. He may be scared of the next steps but that doesn't mean that deep down he doesn't want or need help.

Please let go of the idea that you know better than the experts and should second guess the legal responsibilities you have.

And stop throwing racist stereotypes around to back yourself.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/11/2022 04:04

His ethnicity is not irrelevant. I say this as someone with a Chinese SiL (not in the U.K.) who was extremely strict with her now teen/early 20s and smacked - hard - a lot. It was seen as pretty normal in that culture.

In more recent years we have seen a lot of the dcs since they have been at 6th form/uni in the U.K. - they are delightful young people and not remotely ‘damaged’ as far as I can tell. This is just a statement of fact, I am not in any way condoning their DM’s parenting.

I would guess that the boy would be horrified if SS were informed, and would very likely be in serious shit with his parents for what they will see as complaining about them. Yes, I know this is very far from the desired outcome, but I’m being realistic here. I would guess that the likely outcome would be that the child would certainly not confide in such a way to another adult again.

TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 25/11/2022 04:02

Smineusername · 25/11/2022 02:03

You seem very unclear about appropriate boundaries so I do not think you should be tutoring at all.

This is a safeguarding issue so you need to immediately forward it to the relevant safeguarding officer at school. What happens after that is frankly none of your business. You are not the safeguarding officer so your opinion about what is best is irrelevant. Yes you may well lose him as a student and as a source of future revenue. In future you might wish to keep your exchanges professional and on topic so as to avoid unwanted disclosures. This would be in your students best interests as you are a tutor not a counsellor, you are not qualified to interfere in their personal life.

100%.

One of those threads which I really hope is a troll, because surely nobody actually working with children could be so neglectful of their responsibilities.

YDBear · 25/11/2022 03:37

Smacking is still legal in England. And it’s perfectly normal in Chinese families if the parents aren’t happy with kids’ grades. There’s an awful lot of talk of abuse here but both the parents and the children think of it as justified chastisement. The litmus test here would be does he resent his parents or live on fear of their behaviour towards him? It seems not. I suspect if you are making an issue of this as “abuse” and have told him so, then he bitterly regrets opening his mouth. Not because he is afraid of his parents, but because he is afraid of the damage to his family that informing others will do. Speaking as one who lived in Taiwan for over 20 years, married a Taiwanese and has a pretty good grasp of ethic Chinese family dynamics, if there’s one thing guaranteed to destroy this kid’s happiness it would be bringing “outsiders” in to adjudicate on how his parents treat him. His parents would regard this as unforgivable and he would actually probably find it very hard to forgive himself. Chinese families remind one of the Godfather: family members don’t go against them. In short, if you care about the child and he seems happy enough, keep quiet, or you will cause a world of pain and grief far more than his mother whacking his hands with a ruler when he gets a C on a test.

GivenchyDahhling · 25/11/2022 03:32

McCoysCheese · 25/11/2022 03:25

I suppose I'm asking for advice that looks at the big picture rather than the small one.

Some of you get it, the cultural influence IS relevant and school safeguarding IS likely to make things worse not better.

He didn't ask me to keep it secret but he also vehemently said no to my suggestion that he talk to the school counsellor.

@johnd2 summarised the “big picture” perfectly.

You have a “small picture”. Safeguarding laws exist so this gets put together by someone infinitely more qualified than you to form the “big picture”. You don’t get to decide based on your personal opinions on cultural stereotypes.

McCoysCheese · 25/11/2022 03:25

I suppose I'm asking for advice that looks at the big picture rather than the small one.

Some of you get it, the cultural influence IS relevant and school safeguarding IS likely to make things worse not better.

He didn't ask me to keep it secret but he also vehemently said no to my suggestion that he talk to the school counsellor.

OP posts:
GivenchyDahhling · 25/11/2022 03:17

I’m actually shocked at this OP and just how many responses are supporting their reluctance to report.

This is exactly the reason why private tutoring requires proper registration and regulation; because otherwise you get unqualified numpties without even the most BASIC understanding of safeguarding left alone with vulnerable children.

You obviously need to report a disclosure. It’s nothing to do with whether you think it will make no difference or make it worse. You have to report it.

Muddays · 25/11/2022 02:54

@McCoysCheese I think your instincts are correct here. Unless there's obvious evidence of trauma which there doesn't seem to be, then continue to be their confidant and trusted teacher.

Tigofigo · 25/11/2022 02:24

To my knowledge it's not against the law to hit a child in England.

Only to leave a mark.

He says he's only hit when he's really bad - might only be a smack on the bum twice in his life.

The police wouldn't count that as abuse, would they?

Smineusername · 25/11/2022 02:15

It's emphatically not your place to talk to his parents or other authority figures in his life - if they are indeed abusive and you explicitly or inadvertently reveal his disclosure to them you could be putting him at great risk. You should have informed the student at the point of disclosure know that you would have no choice but to report safeguarding issues

LateAF · 25/11/2022 02:13

In my experience growing up in immigrant communities, the child will deny, his parents will deny and his home life will likely be worse because of it. Easy to say report from a British cultural perspective but it would be a cold day in hell before a typical second generation immigrant child cooperated with authorities to get their parents in trouble. He’s probably already kicking himself about telling you.

Smineusername · 25/11/2022 02:03

You seem very unclear about appropriate boundaries so I do not think you should be tutoring at all.

This is a safeguarding issue so you need to immediately forward it to the relevant safeguarding officer at school. What happens after that is frankly none of your business. You are not the safeguarding officer so your opinion about what is best is irrelevant. Yes you may well lose him as a student and as a source of future revenue. In future you might wish to keep your exchanges professional and on topic so as to avoid unwanted disclosures. This would be in your students best interests as you are a tutor not a counsellor, you are not qualified to interfere in their personal life.

Boiledbeetle · 25/11/2022 01:38

@watcherintherye good question. One that probably haven't a straight forward answer. It's really time the law on this was sorted out. An adult hitting an adult is seen as abuse so i don't see how when the power differential between parent and child it's so much greater than between two adults that it is still legal to smack children.

But the OP doesn't need to make that decision on the thresholds. A child has disclosed abuse, she has to report.

antipodeancanary · 25/11/2022 01:38

Sorry to hear this op. I guess you do have to report, but it will be for your professional integrity, and likely of little help to the child as you have rightly deduced. DS had an Indian friend and similar reports were raised. She was disappeared back to India straight away. The parents remained in the UK. No one said good bye no one heard from her for seven years until she turned up on social media, now a uni student still in India. Some people had even raised with the police that they wondered if she might have been murdered. But thank God she is okay but had brought great disgrace on her parents and bore the consequences.

watcherintherye · 25/11/2022 01:27

Boiledbeetle · 25/11/2022 01:17

It becomes abuse when a child feels compelled to spill their guts to their tutor.

But it's abuse the first time you hit that child stuff what the law may say.

Oh, I agree completely, but the whole ‘smacking ok for discipline’ line is a huge get-out clause for potential abuse. I’m wondering which criteria are used to determine discipline/abuse? The leaving of a red mark, a bruise? What about the mental scars?

Boiledbeetle · 25/11/2022 01:17

watcherintherye · 25/11/2022 01:16

This is so unclear as far as the law is concerned. Smacking children with the purpose of disciplining isn’t illegal in England or N.I. When does smacking become abuse? Who decides?

It becomes abuse when a child feels compelled to spill their guts to their tutor.

But it's abuse the first time you hit that child stuff what the law may say.

watcherintherye · 25/11/2022 01:16

This is so unclear as far as the law is concerned. Smacking children with the purpose of disciplining isn’t illegal in England or N.I. When does smacking become abuse? Who decides?

Boiledbeetle · 25/11/2022 00:54

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 23:20

I think it must help him to be heard.
He was adamant that he didn't want to talk with the school counsellor.

When I think of The amount of adults that knew I was being abused as a kid who did nothing.

Yet here we are 40 years later and still the adult in the room dithers about and then does fuck all.

O P get a fucking grip. Do you're job and report.

FFS

Nowthenhere · 25/11/2022 00:24

Yes, mums and dad's can continue to discipline their children how they see fit in England and Ireland.

There's smacking and then there's beating.

Shouldershoddy · 25/11/2022 00:21

This poor child needs you to take the decision away from him …report Asap! Am not sure why you are on MN tbh .

Yogipineapple123 · 25/11/2022 00:07

OP, what advice were you hoping to get from this thread?

SignOnTheWindow · 25/11/2022 00:07

OP, you seem very sure of the action the school would take - why? Are you privy to the school's safeguarding systems?

It's not your judgement call to make.

You are breaking the law by not passing this on.

Stompythedinosaur · 24/11/2022 23:45

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 23:32

The kid himself does not want to report it though, does he have a right to be heard about that?

No, a child cannot consent to being abused.

You should not have promised to keep it confidential, bit even if you did, you still have to report it.

If he asks for help, he will feel like he is betraying his parents. But he chose to tell an adult outside the family, very likely because he knew you would not think it is ok. He is at least partly asking for help. It is just a complex situation. He needs to to be the bloody adult and take this decision out of his hands.

Honestly, I am shocked that you don't know this. It is basic, basic safeguarding.