Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tiger parenting

209 replies

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:14

I see a kid each week for tutoring. Chinese family, kid is Y8.

He's told me his parents love him and only hit him if he has been very bad. I've asked him to talk to his school counsellor but he said no, he's ok. I told him it's not allowed in this country for parents to hit kids. And that he can call Childline or NSPCC. But he doesn't want his parents to get in trouble.

If I report then I will never see him again and the situation doesn't change. Any advice?

OP posts:
BogRollBOGOF · 25/11/2022 07:58

When I have had a disclosure, my responsibility is to pass it on. I am not responsible for what happens beyond that point. My legal and moral duty is to pass it on.
The safeguarding leads and people/ agencies are the better trained professionals. They may already have parts of a jigsaw.

Anything the parents do beyond that is their responsibility.

If anything horrific happened, my piece in the jigsaw is to have passed it on, not to have fretted through multiple scenarios.

Tubiemum · 25/11/2022 07:55

This reply has been withdrawn

Message withdrawn - posted on wrong thread

Lemonandlime123 · 25/11/2022 07:42

Are you serious? I can't believe you are asking this. You shouldn't be working with children.

NatalieIsFreezing · 25/11/2022 07:35

Is there a reason for not wanting to follow clear safeguarding instructions for this child in particular, or would you ignore them for all children in the same situation?

Flutterbybudget · 25/11/2022 07:24

What you need to remember is that you can get advice from professionals anonymously.
I wouldn’t be reporting a case of “serious child abuse” in this instance, as you don’t have enough information to base that accusation on. But I would be ringing the NSPCC or going into the school to speak to the safe guarding officer. They ARE professionals, who will not be sending the police around to demand answers or tearing children from their homes.
They will be more aware of the cultural implications than the vast majority of the white British public, and will approach the situation very carefully. What they will not do, is “spook” the family and risk the child being sent abroad to relatives, because it’s a known risk. What do you have to lose by ringing them anonymously and asking for advice?

maryrosa · 25/11/2022 07:19

As a fellow tutor, it worries me that there are tutors out there who are not up to date on their safe-guarding training - it's clear on the procedure for dealing with a disclosure.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 25/11/2022 07:18

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 23:12

The easiest thing to do is to report it but I don't know if that is the best thing to do.

Going via his school means that he stays in a better situation of still having someone that he trusts to talk with, at least and maybe I can talk with the parents too.

Get over yourself!

You are not a saviour here who is the only one who has cultural sensitivity.

You will speak to the parents! How is that any different to the school speaking to them.

You don't know all the information here. You are making massive assumptions. He could be being smacked, not illegal but frowned upon, or he could be beaten with a belt. Both are covered by 'hit'. You have no way of finding out.

I wonder if this is your first disclosure and you feel flattered he has chosen you. And this is clouding your judgement.

GreenOxide · 25/11/2022 07:15

You have to report. What happens thereafter and if it meets thresholds or not is not for you to decide.

You sound far too wound up in the drama of it as have a hero complex or are scared of losing income, else why have you not done the right thing already.

maryrosa · 25/11/2022 07:06

Please report this concern to the safe-guarding officer at the child's school. They will take it from there.

LolaSmiles · 25/11/2022 07:03

I suppose I'm asking for advice that looks at the big picture rather than the small one.

Some of you get it, the cultural influence IS relevant and school safeguarding IS likely to make things worse not better.

He didn't ask me to keep it secret but he also vehemently said no to my suggestion that he talk to the school counsellor.
He might not want to talk to the school counsellor, but he chose to speak to you, presumably because he sees you as a safe adult.

Part of being a safe adult is having an ounce of professionalism and following safeguarding.

It isn't your job to weigh up what you think might or might not happen with other professionals.
It's not your job to decide that a child's cultural background makes a difference on whether you report a child being harmed.
It is not your job to investigate, speak to the parents or the uncle.
It isn't your job to keep quiet whilst a child is being harmed.

It sounds like this is either a wind up thread, or you're putting yourself on a pedestal and happy to ignore basic safeguarding training in favour of being the cool teacher who is in the know

Clarice99 · 25/11/2022 07:01

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 23:32

The kid himself does not want to report it though, does he have a right to be heard about that?

He told you that he's being abused at home. If he didn't want anyone to know, he wouldn't have opened up to you.

Him telling you, a (supposed) trusted adult, he wants you to do something, he wants your help, and you are dithering about a safeguarding issue. Beyond belief!

I was physically and emotionally abused as a child. I often went to school with bruises on my body and face. No one did anything. I was surrounded by people like you. People who could have put the wheels in motion to make me safe but chose not to. My situation was decades ago, the safeguarding was not there then, so I forgive their ignorance. You have no such defence.

You have been provided with the relevant information on what action is required yet you don't want to pursue the right option; therefore, I wonder why you started this thread when you have no intention of doing the right thing to ensure the safety of the child.

Jennybeans401 · 25/11/2022 06:54

My friend is Chinese and said most Chinese parents are like this. She remembers being beaten for bad marks at school or playing her violin badly.

Having said that, it's still horrendous and you have to look at it from your professional viewpoint. You have a duty of care toward the child so you could report it and hope this might save the child in the future.

ZooMount · 25/11/2022 06:53

I don't know why so many people are assuming the OP is a teacher or has any formal safeguarding training whatsoever. Do you not realise that there is no regulation in tutoring and any Tom, Dick or Harry can start a business and call themselves a tutor?

I can see why you have reservations op, you are not wanting to make things worse for the child, but as the adult in this situation you do need to report it. Hopefully it will be resolved but like you say sadly it might not be, as the threshold needs to be high. He's not going to be removed from his home for the odd smack which is legal in this country is he? Would it even be better if he was removed from his home? Probably not. I don't smack or condone smacking but I was smacked as a child and god I'm glad no-one reported it or I wasn't taken away from my home. My life would have been a million times worse in the care system. I have a good relationship with my parents and have had a successful life. That said, you don't know if this is the odd smack or more. I don't think it's black and white. I don't think it's for you to decide though, leave that to people who have professional training in safeguarding, they will deal with this situation sensitively and properly.

Confusedandperplexed · 25/11/2022 06:49

As a teacher I am shocked by this thread.
First rule of safeguarding - you cannot offer confidentiality. YOU are the adult. YOU decide what should be passed on. YOU should contact his school.

Also he CHOSE TO TELL YOU that he was being hit. That’s a cry for help. He might not know it or even be able to articulate it. But if he tells you he’s being hit sometimes then you can bet it’s more often than that.

His ethnicity is irrelevant.

Also his parents have threatened to send him
abroad to relatives. That’s emotional abuse.

REPORT REPORT REPORT.

otherwise you are a terrible tutor. Sorry but that’s the truth. He told you. He wants help.

MargotChateau · 25/11/2022 06:42

I grew up with a second generation immigrant tiger parent and for the posters that say that it is cultural so therefore acceptable and it doesn’t do any harm because of academic achievement that’s bollocks.

I grew up feeling that maternal love was based on my achievements at school/uni/career, had a childhood where I missed out on normal holiday after school activities because I was either with a tutor or touring with my (identifying) second talent.

i think anyone would look at me and think I’m a high achiever and a success story, but inside I’m an anxious and people pleasing wreck, and can never enjoy success because I had a parent always with their eye on the next step.

I was smacked a lot, just because it’s CuLtuRal doesn’t make it right. A lot of people knew my home situation and said nothing, I wish they had, it may have given her fright enough to stop, or to be placed with my godmother or aunty.

ive had to do a lot of therapy to undo my upbringing before I started to try for children and I hope to bring up the child I’m now pregnant with a feeling of being cherished and loved irrespective of success without using smacking as a way to control with fear.

Lulu1919 · 25/11/2022 06:42

Safeguarding training would tell you to speak out for him....contact school

Buttercupmoon · 25/11/2022 06:41

Smacking is legal in this country so what the OP describes would classify as this to social services. The threshold for their involvement is very high.

MilkyYay · 25/11/2022 06:29

He says he's only hit when he's really bad - might only be a smack on the bum twice in his life.

Not condoning the hitting but this - you are all absolutely starkers if you think anything at all can or will be done about this. He will deny/parents will deny, and its unlikely the smacking or hitting is frequent or severe enough to be leaving any evidence whatsoever.

The threshold for intervention is high, this kid has got to 12 or 13 without school etc identifying issues with his home life. Smacking isn't illegal and the care system would be a thousand times worse for this child.

Op, mention it to his school.

Riu · 25/11/2022 06:20

One thing I have discovered in my years of teaching, is that a large number of parents hit their children. You need to speak to the safeguarding lead at his school. Tell your tutee that you have done so. The school will take it from there. As you are a tutor, it is very clear what you should do and this is actually quite straightforward.

472027474hg683 · 25/11/2022 06:04

You have a legal obligation to report this OP and you should do so to your local multi agency safeguarding hub. You should have their details because you work with children and should have had some safeguarding training/awareness. These cases are never easy but you cannot sit on this. Of course there is context, and you will share that when you make the phone call, but that doesn’t negate the need to escalate it. There may be concerns that children’s services are already aware of and your information could add to that.

If you aren’t prepared to follow the Keeping Children Safe in Education guidance, then I would suggest not tutoring children and young people.

assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1101454/Keeping_children_safe_in_education_2022.pdf

Scirocco · 25/11/2022 06:01

This isn't tiger parenting or a cultural thing, it's potential child abuse. A child has made a disclosure to a trusted adult, that they are being hit at home.

It's not your job to investigate or to make a judgement on what's happening and whether the child is or isn't safe at home. It's your job to report the disclosure to the appropriate services in your area.

Letsgotitans · 25/11/2022 06:00

They aren't 'strict' parents,they are abusive parents. Please do your job and report them.

Goatsanddogs · 25/11/2022 05:56

Do you know what he means by being hit? It could be a smack on the legs or a significant beating. A smack although I don’t condone any abuse, in the context of his culture might not be a red flag. Many of us were brought up with a smack for being naughty and are perfectly normal well adjusted adults, however, I am relieved that it is no longer acceptable. What I would worry about is social,services getting involved being heavy handed and turning this little boys world upside down for what might be a fairly light form of discipline.

OP could you find out a bit more…any bruises or marks showing significant heavy discipline?

JoanOfAllTrades · 25/11/2022 04:57

@McCoysCheese Surely you have a safeguarding duty of care towards this child? Also, as a teacher, are you not a mandatory reporter?

It doesn’t matter what culture this child is from, hitting children is appalling but I don’t think it’s actually illegal, as there was another thread a couple of weeks ago and there was a lady on that one, saying that she physically chastises her children and it’s allowed in the UK? Which I was very surprised at!

Also, you can report this anonymously. My daughter used to tell me about how glad she was that I didn’t hit her as her friends would be whacked with wooden spoons and the like and in the end I told her that as I was a mandatory reporter, I was supposed to report these things and it didn’t matter that I was at home and not work. She stopped telling me about these things after I said that but because I understand the mindset, I didn't report the things she told me and her friends weren’t being beaten black and blue but rather hit once and they all accepted it as normal. Plus I see them a lot and none of them are unhappy at home from what they tell me about their home lives.

In my country you have to take 6 subjects in the last 2 years of school, similar to A levels but 6. All the children from Asian (and African) backgrounds, whether China or the subcontinent all take the suicide six! So-called because these 6 subjects are the most rigorous in terms of study and exams. They are Physics, Advanced Maths, Chemistry, Biology, English and another Mathematics course. It’s having to complete the assessments, and there’s a lot of them, and getting the grades as your final grade is made up of all your grades throughout the 2 years. So constant pressure - a bit like being at university as your grade is calculated as a GPA type thing. At the same time, all children take these subjects, they are also expected to maintain jobs. So it’s not easy, but then you are told from a very young age, what the expectations are so once you reach those final years, it’s not surprise. If those same kids lived in the UK, they would be expected to take 4 A levels but at least A level grades are individual.

Just to add, I never put this pressure on my kids, I just expected them to do their best!

LokiCokey · 25/11/2022 04:19

@McCoysCheese please do some safeguarding training.
You may be correct that reporting will lead nowhere/ make it worse etc... but we have regulations for a reason and it is your duty to report.