Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tiger parenting

209 replies

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:14

I see a kid each week for tutoring. Chinese family, kid is Y8.

He's told me his parents love him and only hit him if he has been very bad. I've asked him to talk to his school counsellor but he said no, he's ok. I told him it's not allowed in this country for parents to hit kids. And that he can call Childline or NSPCC. But he doesn't want his parents to get in trouble.

If I report then I will never see him again and the situation doesn't change. Any advice?

OP posts:
Tekkentime · 25/11/2022 08:53

NerrSnerr · 25/11/2022 08:47

Does this mean that a child has to put up with abuse if it has purpose and not for 'abuse's sake'.

Yes and i'm sure he would agree and he will do the same when he's a parent, you live in a UK centric bubble. It's not nice but it's the reality.

NerrSnerr · 25/11/2022 08:51

learning.nspcc.org.uk/training/child-protection-tutors

OP, the NSPCC offer safeguarding training for tutors, probably worth the investment.

It's not just qualified teachers who have a responsibility to the young people they work with and with all the high profile child abuse cases it's scary how the message still isn't getting through.

SkinnyFatte · 25/11/2022 08:49

Not RTFT, so forgive me if the conversation has moved on.

I'd speak to the NSPCC. Let them take it forward as they see fit.

If you lose this boy as a client as a result, then so what? Your conscience is clear. You have tried to safeguard him.

morecookes · 25/11/2022 08:47

FiveMins · 25/11/2022 08:27

Responding differently to violence or neglect or abuse to a child because of ethnicity was a huge issue in the awful Victoria Climbie case. At the time I worked with a lot of refugees and we were very aware of a level of violence in some cultures not acceptable in others (the UK in the 1970s and before were horrific too-I have friends who were caned in primary school). Victoria's death was meant to led to a change in reporting irrespective of cultural differences.
Always, always, always report. Why has this child told you? Is it because he just wants to talk? Unlikely.

Any which way it's not your judgement to make you pass on the information always. This could be the tip of the iceberg.

I have had children disclose information in front of their parents and I've told them I'm going to have to pass on to social services. It's fucking shit to do but so so necessary. There might be lots of snippets of information that school have and this be the tipping point. I have worked on several serious case reviews where children have been murdered by their parents and everybody always thinks that the bit of information they have wasn't that relevant but when you pile it all together it is.
I also works near Rochdale when the poor girls were being multiply raped. Because the girls were poor and working-class and because of fear of being accused of racism the outcomes were terrible.

I can't believe this is still even being considered.

I think the whole scared of being accused of racism is complete bullshit, its a cover for overworked and downright incompotent social workers who basically don't give a shit about kids from poor or troubled backgrounds. Its used as a defence for dealing with kids from ethnic minorities or working class children.

It happens time after time.

Like this case, a complete fucking failure from GP's, Social workers , top to bottom:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-63749813

NerrSnerr · 25/11/2022 08:47

Tekkentime · 25/11/2022 08:44

I wouldn't, things will get worse for the boy. In asian culture, it's not seen as abuse for abuse's sake, it's seen as correcting the child.

People have too much faith in safeguarding systems.

Does this mean that a child has to put up with abuse if it has purpose and not for 'abuse's sake'.

kittensinthekitchen · 25/11/2022 08:46

How old is this kid? 12?

He has asked you for help. That's why he told you. You've said he and his friends think it's normal, yet he told you? That's him wanting help.

Surely you have a safeguarding policy in place?

morecookes · 25/11/2022 08:44

Waterfallgirl · 25/11/2022 08:17

I’m a bit lost OP. You keep talking about reporting to school, but as a ‘Professional’ ( I assume you are a teacher) you have duties and procedures to follow around safeguarding. Reporting to school or NSPCC - whilst they are routes to go down - are really those for non professionals who don’t know the procedures.
Use your local authority reporting systems/Mash/LADO.
I know it’s hard, but the best for this child.

A large number of tutors are just graduates, or even A level students who have paid for DBS check and signed up with an agency or tutor company.

I know a few who drifted into it for a bit of cash on top of their jobs, while many are teachers, many are not and do not know anything about safegaurding.

So you can't assume OP is a teacher.

Tekkentime · 25/11/2022 08:44

I wouldn't, things will get worse for the boy. In asian culture, it's not seen as abuse for abuse's sake, it's seen as correcting the child.

People have too much faith in safeguarding systems.

BigScreen · 25/11/2022 08:40

This isn't strick parenting, it's abuse.

When a kid tells you something it's because they don't know how to make it stop and wants you to do the 'grassing up'.

Flutterbybudget · 25/11/2022 08:39

McCoysCheese · 25/11/2022 08:12

The NSPCC anonymous form isn't working unfortunately. I suppose I can call his school.

It's not important to me that it's this particular kid, no, I'd have concerns about any kid being helped correctly in this situation. The cultural background is not meaningless. Some posters get this but most of you are rudely parroting the one size fits all solution.

I’ve spoken to the headteacher and safeguarding officer at my local school on several occasions about concerns I’ve had regarding a couple of pupils. Obviously they won’t tell you anything, and that’s always been my starting point - “I’m not asking for information but I am concerned about x,y,z and need this to be flagged up by someone who can help if there needs to be any intervention”
And that intervention isn’t always direct. It may be through a PHSE lesson, opening a discussion in a group about how the students would react if a friend told them about a similar situation. Believe that the professionals actually ARE professionals, and not ham fisted amateurs who use a sledge hammer to crack a nut.

Fleurdaisy · 25/11/2022 08:35

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:27

It's normal in his culture to be disciplined in this way. He and his friends talk about it and accept it.

It might be normalised in his culture but that doesn’t make it right.
The child is in the UK, has disclosed abuse to you and I am sure you are obliged to report it.
I would call local SS and report to duty social worker.

MGMidget · 25/11/2022 08:35

That is a very tricky dilemma because if you have a duty to report and dont there could be repercussions for you later. However, I think it could be worse for him if you report it given there doesnt seem to be a sufficient reason to remove him from the family from what has been revealed. The repercussions for him could be worse (eg being sent abroad to other family members where there are no laws against hitting for discipline and or being beaten or punished in other ways for telling so he gets the message to say nothing in future). Given there have been some high profile examples of failings in social services in far more severe cases than this and where there were multiple warnings I think he wont be protected but more likely exposed to repercussions from reporting this. He probably wants a confidante and he may open up to you over time about worse abuses or tell you if things escalate but there is a risk he may clam up if its reported. I dont see a good solution to be honest.

Malbecfan · 25/11/2022 08:27

Some people seem to be interpreting the situation differently from me. Apologies if I'm wrong but I understand the OP to be a private freelance tutor NOT a schoolteacher. If the OP was a teacher in school, their safeguarding training has been woeful and needs addressing urgently. However, as a private tutor, I am not sure if there is any mandatory requirement for up to date training, and this is where I assume the OP is. So to lambast them for asking, is a bit unfair, although I think that anyone working with children should have level 2 training in safeguarding at least bi-annually.

Having made those assumptions, OP, I think you should contact the DSL at the child's school as a matter of urgency. As others have stated, it is the small pieces of the jigsaw that help them see the overall picture. The threshold for help is sadly really high, but it may be that the school can help support this student without making it obvious where the information has come from. I have raised concerns about a child in the past in a similar situation when I was contacted by an external tutor that I knew from a different setting. I had a conversation with our then DSL who took it very seriously and said he would add it to his evidence.

FiveMins · 25/11/2022 08:27

Responding differently to violence or neglect or abuse to a child because of ethnicity was a huge issue in the awful Victoria Climbie case. At the time I worked with a lot of refugees and we were very aware of a level of violence in some cultures not acceptable in others (the UK in the 1970s and before were horrific too-I have friends who were caned in primary school). Victoria's death was meant to led to a change in reporting irrespective of cultural differences.
Always, always, always report. Why has this child told you? Is it because he just wants to talk? Unlikely.

Any which way it's not your judgement to make you pass on the information always. This could be the tip of the iceberg.

I have had children disclose information in front of their parents and I've told them I'm going to have to pass on to social services. It's fucking shit to do but so so necessary. There might be lots of snippets of information that school have and this be the tipping point. I have worked on several serious case reviews where children have been murdered by their parents and everybody always thinks that the bit of information they have wasn't that relevant but when you pile it all together it is.
I also works near Rochdale when the poor girls were being multiply raped. Because the girls were poor and working-class and because of fear of being accused of racism the outcomes were terrible.

I can't believe this is still even being considered.

Confusedandperplexed · 25/11/2022 08:25

HairyToity · 25/11/2022 08:21

I grew up in a household where if I was properly naughty I'd get a slap. I generally had a happy childhood and a good relationship with my parents. I'd be utterly devastated if social services had got involved, and put me in care. It's a different culture and personally I think you'd be creating more problems than solving if you reported it.

‘I think you’d be creating more problems than solving…’
thats similar to attitude taken by the hairdresser who saw Arthur Labinjo-Hughes.
not trying to be hyperbolic - hopefully this isn’t the same scale - but abuse happens in the dark.
I repeat OP
THIS BOY HAS TOLD YOU AND WANTS YOUR HELP. DO NOT LET HIM DOWN.

NerrSnerr · 25/11/2022 08:24

HairyToity · 25/11/2022 08:21

I grew up in a household where if I was properly naughty I'd get a slap. I generally had a happy childhood and a good relationship with my parents. I'd be utterly devastated if social services had got involved, and put me in care. It's a different culture and personally I think you'd be creating more problems than solving if you reported it.

Someone reporting a safeguarding concern doesn't equate to 'being put in care'

There is a chance that other children may not feel the same as you- should they put up with it just because you're fine or should someone look into it to make sure they're ok?

HairyToity · 25/11/2022 08:21

I grew up in a household where if I was properly naughty I'd get a slap. I generally had a happy childhood and a good relationship with my parents. I'd be utterly devastated if social services had got involved, and put me in care. It's a different culture and personally I think you'd be creating more problems than solving if you reported it.

NerrSnerr · 25/11/2022 08:21

I’m a bit lost OP. You keep talking about reporting to school, but as a ‘Professional’ ( I assume you are a teacher) you have duties and procedures to follow around safeguarding. Reporting to school or NSPCC - whilst they are routes to go down - are really those for non professionals who don’t know the procedures.
Use your local authority reporting systems/Mash/LADO.
I know it’s hard, but the best for this child

You have to listen to this OP. You are a professional and need to follow the correct procedure. If you're not prepared to do this you need to stop working with children.

Confusedandperplexed · 25/11/2022 08:21

One size fits all?
what exactly are you talking about?!
so basically Chinese kids should have different safeguarding help to black kids to white kids????
thats just racist.
get over yourself and report. It’s really serious.

redteapot · 25/11/2022 08:17

You need to report this asap. He is testing the waters by telling you. If you ignore it, you condone it.

Waterfallgirl · 25/11/2022 08:17

McCoysCheese · 25/11/2022 08:12

The NSPCC anonymous form isn't working unfortunately. I suppose I can call his school.

It's not important to me that it's this particular kid, no, I'd have concerns about any kid being helped correctly in this situation. The cultural background is not meaningless. Some posters get this but most of you are rudely parroting the one size fits all solution.

I’m a bit lost OP. You keep talking about reporting to school, but as a ‘Professional’ ( I assume you are a teacher) you have duties and procedures to follow around safeguarding. Reporting to school or NSPCC - whilst they are routes to go down - are really those for non professionals who don’t know the procedures.
Use your local authority reporting systems/Mash/LADO.
I know it’s hard, but the best for this child.

McCoysCheese · 25/11/2022 08:12

The NSPCC anonymous form isn't working unfortunately. I suppose I can call his school.

It's not important to me that it's this particular kid, no, I'd have concerns about any kid being helped correctly in this situation. The cultural background is not meaningless. Some posters get this but most of you are rudely parroting the one size fits all solution.

OP posts:
thewolfandthesheep · 25/11/2022 08:09

It is not your job to decide the threshold for action, your job is to report.
Some parents you could talk to, and they get that the child need a supportive an positive environment to get through life, not just school. Some might have a phd in idiocy. Rule of the thumb : it's not written on their forehead, leave it to professionals.

And also this is not tiger parenting. I don't know why you want to dress it up as that. Those who know better do better.

AuntieMarys · 25/11/2022 08:03

You should not be working with children.

faw2009 · 25/11/2022 08:02

I grew up in a Chinese household and was probably smacked twice in my whole childhood (this is the 70s!) Never for academic reasons. Just putting it out there.