Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tiger parenting

209 replies

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:14

I see a kid each week for tutoring. Chinese family, kid is Y8.

He's told me his parents love him and only hit him if he has been very bad. I've asked him to talk to his school counsellor but he said no, he's ok. I told him it's not allowed in this country for parents to hit kids. And that he can call Childline or NSPCC. But he doesn't want his parents to get in trouble.

If I report then I will never see him again and the situation doesn't change. Any advice?

OP posts:
antipodeancanary · 25/11/2022 10:07

It's so easy for affluent overseas parents to remove a child from the country. DS friend never returned to school after the first allegation. As I said before, she turned up years later as an adult on social media, having been shipped back to India to live with distant family. The disgrace she brought on the family was not something they were ever going to overlook.

Stompythedinosaur · 25/11/2022 09:52

Japaneseifyouplease · 25/11/2022 09:39

Could you speak to his parents? That would be my first step. I would ask to talk to them in private and explain that something had been disclosed and you would like to hear their side of story. You can then go on to say that it's not permitted in the UK and you appreciate that their culture is different but if it is disclosed at school, social services will be informed and consequences could be quite harsh. Also a slap on the wrist is very different from regular beatings. Perhaps you could speak to the boy beforehand to gauge the level of physical punishment they are using. If it's regular beatings then it has to be reported to SS. If it's an occasional slap on the wrist etc then I would speak to them and tell them it needs to stop or they will be reported.

This is terrible advice.

Let's just say this kid is being severely abused. Speaking directly to the abuser is not going to help, it will increase the risk to him. And then there will also be no record to build up a picture. There may be information from other sources (maybe teachers have seen injuries, it a GP has been worried about family interactions). Everything need to be reported to a central point for a picture to be built up.

And if he is only being "mildly abused?" Well, I don't think reporting it makes things worse.

So report!

CarefreeMe · 25/11/2022 09:52

In England parents are allowed to smack their children and many do as part of ‘discipline’.

The fact that he’s told you about the smacking means that this isn’t your average smack on the bum for being naughty - as that would be normal to him and he wouldn’t feel the need to mention it.

Kids who are brought up with small snacks don’t go and tell people about it as it is the norm for them and they believe everyone does it - the fact that he’s reached out and told you means he’s actually screaming for help and someone to listen and take him seriously.

I would not think twice about reporting it, even if just to the school so they can report it and I wouldn’t care if that meant not seeing him or losing my weekly pay cheque because of it.

Notanotherone6 · 25/11/2022 09:51

He didn't tell you just to make small talk now, did he? If he thought it was normal, it probably wouldn't have crossed his mind to mention it. He knows it's wrong.

Come on, op. Sod ethnicity. A child is being regularly beaten and has indirectly tried to ask you for help. Please help him. Imagine if he's said this to 10 different people and he's been ignored by all of them because it's 'ok because he's Chinese'. You know it isn't.

Worst case scenario, adults can kill children.

KittieDaley · 25/11/2022 09:43

Often with the Asian cultures corporal punishment isn't considered bad and seen more like disciplining the child, so they need to be make aware this is not acceptable nor the correct way to discipline a child

This is a very arrogant assumption, and based on western values. That kind of attitude prevailed years ago when British people ruled much of the world and tried to impose their own values on other cultures. It didn't end well for native Indians or indigenous Australians.

Maybe look at today's society where many children are out of control even at primary age, before deciding that Asian culture is worse.

Jellyjunction · 25/11/2022 09:42

The legal threshold for a slap in England is it cannot leave a mark. Do you have any more info on what exactly the boy meant by being hit?

From the fact that he's mentioned it to a tutor, I expect it to be more than an occasional light smack, and I think from your comments OP you do realise that too. I am professionally involved in safeguarding and have level 3 training. The law says you have to report.

To all those quoting cultural circumstances, you should read the Laming report on Victoria Climbie's death.

It says 'Every organisation concerned with the welfare and
protection of children should have mechanisms in place to ensure equal access to services of the same quality, and that each child, irrespective of colour or background, should be treated as an individual requiring appropriate care (p3 46). '

Here's a quote from a paper than references it:

"The
Laming Report, which suggested that some
professionals’ practice might have been affected
because of their fear of being accused of racism. As
the Counsel to Inquiry noted:

Race can affect the way people conduct themselves…
Fear of being accused of racism can stop people acting
when otherwise they would. Fear of being thought
unsympathetic to someone of the same race can change
response (p346).
This point relates to the one about training. Perhaps
one reason why professionals are fearful is that they feel
inadequately trained or prepared to work with families
from all ethnic backgrounds. So, instead, they either
try to avoid the issue by pretending ethnicity does not
matter when working with people from diverse
backgrounds, or draw upon their own limited
knowledge and experiences of ethnic minority families,
which may include many stereotypes and prejudices; or
perhaps they acknowledge their own limitations and
do the best they can in the circumstances, aware that
some ethnic minority families may not be in receipt of
the services or practices they deserve; or even try to pass
the responsibility to another worker or professional
from the same ethnic background as the family. These
strategies are not mutually exclusive, but they all have
their problems and/or limitations. "
From here
sci-hub.yncjkj.com/

Chand, Ashok (2003). ‘Race’ and the Laming Report on Victoria Climbie: Lessons for Inter‐Professional Policy and Practice. Journal of Integrated Care, 11(4), 28–37. doi:10.1108/14769018200300040

I would say report it to social services directly, rather than through the school, as you are a professional who isn't employed by the school. Childline would be fine if you feel more comfortable doing that.

You can call Childline to report if their online form isn't working.

Unless we challenge child abuse every time as a country it will remain endemic.

toomuchlaundry · 25/11/2022 09:40

Technically it is allowed @Blueberry111 if it is smacking

Japaneseifyouplease · 25/11/2022 09:39

Could you speak to his parents? That would be my first step. I would ask to talk to them in private and explain that something had been disclosed and you would like to hear their side of story. You can then go on to say that it's not permitted in the UK and you appreciate that their culture is different but if it is disclosed at school, social services will be informed and consequences could be quite harsh. Also a slap on the wrist is very different from regular beatings. Perhaps you could speak to the boy beforehand to gauge the level of physical punishment they are using. If it's regular beatings then it has to be reported to SS. If it's an occasional slap on the wrist etc then I would speak to them and tell them it needs to stop or they will be reported.

Stompythedinosaur · 25/11/2022 09:39

McCoysCheese · 25/11/2022 08:12

The NSPCC anonymous form isn't working unfortunately. I suppose I can call his school.

It's not important to me that it's this particular kid, no, I'd have concerns about any kid being helped correctly in this situation. The cultural background is not meaningless. Some posters get this but most of you are rudely parroting the one size fits all solution.

Suggesting that an adult to whom a child has disclosed abuse has a duty to report this is a situation where there really is a "one size fits all" situation. There is not situation where a decent human should ignore (and thus become complicit in) abuse of a child.

Perhaps what this child has told you may be legal. Maybe it isn't. But that isn't for you to judge. You still need to report it.

I cannot say how disgraceful and cowardly it would be to not do the right thing here. The law is clear. Safeguarding advice is clear. What it is that is making you struggle to do the right thing?

fannyfartlet · 25/11/2022 09:38

It depends on where you are. Smacking/hitting is illegal in Scotland and Wales but not England. It also has to be a "reasonable punishment" and not leave a significant mark.

Blueberry111 · 25/11/2022 09:36

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:53

Maybe I talk to the parents?

Or to his uncle who is less traditional in his parenting?

Yesss, please talk to his parents / uncle , siblings anyone. Tell parents clearly it's not allowed in this country and he could be removed from your care if you continue. They might not recognise the consequences of hitting their child. Maybe even find them a parenting class they can attend in Chinese if there is one.
And let them know if after this you do find out they're still hitting you'll have to report it to safeguarding.
They might not send him to you anymore but that's fine you've done your part by informing them. Often with the Asian cultures corporal punishment isn't considered bad and seen more like disciplining the child, so they need to be make aware this is not acceptable nor the correct way to discipline a child.

GelatoQueen · 25/11/2022 09:35

How old are you OP? You sound immature to me, going on about cultural issues. Just because something is normalised in a culture doesn't mean it is right.

It is very simple - you put in a report to social services. They will not go in all guns blazing - very likely it will be just noted on a file maybe with the child being identified as 'at risk' unless there have been reports from other agencies eg school flagging similiar concerns.

kateandme · 25/11/2022 09:35

No judgment on whether you agree with smacking.but has he disclosed what he meant.a smack,hit,beating

NerrSnerr · 25/11/2022 09:34

Flutterbybudget · 25/11/2022 09:20

Where has the OP mentioned “beating”?
“hit” is completely open to interpretation in the context we have.
My parents “smacked” me - which I don’t endorse, but neither was it in the “abuse - remove into the care system or even involve social workers” category either.
A lot of people seem to jump to a lot of conclusions and exaggerate on Mumsnet tbh.

It's not up to the OP to look into it further and ascertain what is going on. She does have a responsibility to report any concerns.

suzyscat · 25/11/2022 09:31

There are plenty of accredited safeguarding courses available online. You should undertake one asap and keep your qualifications up to date. This will also cover how to talk to people when they have made a disclosure or you suspect abuse, including not asking leading questions. TED - Tell me, explain, describe and help you form your own (legally required) safeguarding policy as well as how you proceed, which has already been covered by numerous PPs.

Bakergram · 25/11/2022 09:26

I’d look at the worst/best case scenario in all cases…

you don’t pass this on or follow relevant safeguard principles - the child could end up physically and mentally harmed.

you do pass this on and nothing happens- the child can end up harmed but you did your duty.

you pass it on and authorities step in- abuse stops

1 of these I could live with, 1 I’d struggle but cope, the other is unbearable.

Im surprised that as a teacher you are unsure which to do.

Blueberrybuns · 25/11/2022 09:20

If you are working as a tutor you must have a safeguarding policy in-line with the law. In brief: If you are aware of abuse you have no choice other than to share the information. If you don't have a DSL in your tutoring business then use his school DSL. You cannot and must never promise confidentiality to a child. To do so would in itself be a safeguarding risk. This is not your professional call to make. You must pass the information immediately and state what he has told only without your opinion. You need to leave the consideration of cultural contexts etc to the professionals. It isn't youe call to keep this quiet because you think it's for the best. This isn't about you and tbh if you can't adhere to basic and legally binding safeguarding procedures you should not be working with young people. Sorry to be blunt but this is also to protect you.

McCoysCheese · 25/11/2022 09:20

I'm in England so yes it is legal

OP posts:
Flutterbybudget · 25/11/2022 09:20

Where has the OP mentioned “beating”?
“hit” is completely open to interpretation in the context we have.
My parents “smacked” me - which I don’t endorse, but neither was it in the “abuse - remove into the care system or even involve social workers” category either.
A lot of people seem to jump to a lot of conclusions and exaggerate on Mumsnet tbh.

EVHead · 25/11/2022 09:12

Im a tutor and we received child protection training.

You’re way overthinking it, OP. It’s not your place to decide what the outcome is for this child. That’s for child protection professionals.

Your duty, your OBLIGATION, is to report what he’s told you to the relevant person/body. What happens after that is not your business.

Onlyforcake · 25/11/2022 09:07

Using culture to excuse abuse is a terrifying path. It's not 'tiger' anything. It's beating a child.

Bretonstrip · 25/11/2022 09:06

It is legal to smack your child in England. Rightly or wrongly - but it is legal.

JohnStuartMill · 25/11/2022 09:05

Where are you based?

In both Scotland and Wales, there is now a legal ban on smacking children (it became illegal in Scotland in November 2020 and in Wales in March 2022).

In England, smacking a child is still legal for a parent to smack a child, in certain circumstances.

It is illegal for teachers, nursery workers and workers in other education settings to hit children in their care – ever.

It is illegal for a privately employed babysitter or nanny to smack a child in their care, unless the parent has given specific permission.

viques · 25/11/2022 08:55

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:46

I know I have a duty of care.

But informing his school may make things worse not better.

He told me because he is in a safe place with me I suppose.

He told you because he trusts you - trusts you to do the right thing. Kids don’t disclose to adults because they don’t think the adult will do anything about it, they disclose to an adult because they trust that adult to act and help them.

FiveMins · 25/11/2022 08:55

morecookes · 25/11/2022 08:47

I think the whole scared of being accused of racism is complete bullshit, its a cover for overworked and downright incompotent social workers who basically don't give a shit about kids from poor or troubled backgrounds. Its used as a defence for dealing with kids from ethnic minorities or working class children.

It happens time after time.

Like this case, a complete fucking failure from GP's, Social workers , top to bottom:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-63749813

I do agree with you to some extent. However virtually every single person we work with was poor and working class or majority at that time we're refugees from Somalia, Iraq and Rwanda. There was definitely a different response to children that will be in physically abused by British parents than non-british. And again a difference between those for the travelling community and other white nationals.