Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tiger parenting

209 replies

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:14

I see a kid each week for tutoring. Chinese family, kid is Y8.

He's told me his parents love him and only hit him if he has been very bad. I've asked him to talk to his school counsellor but he said no, he's ok. I told him it's not allowed in this country for parents to hit kids. And that he can call Childline or NSPCC. But he doesn't want his parents to get in trouble.

If I report then I will never see him again and the situation doesn't change. Any advice?

OP posts:
viques · 25/11/2022 12:02

Dontaskdontget · 25/11/2022 10:55

I think a lot of posters are really oversimplifying this.

The truth is that UK social services are incompetent, quick to take kids away from parents (I think we have the highest forced adoption in the world?) and stick them in care where sexual abuse and grooming into drugs are common. Children taken into care have been placed on several occasions with more socially acceptable (white middle class) parents who then murder them, just look at the news reports in the last few years. It would have to be a very very extreme situation for me to involve social services in a child’s life and I’m not convinced that a disciplinary smack from an otherwise loving parent (who btw cares about the child enough to hire a tutor) meets that test. Being taken away from parents even just for a few days is one of the most traumatic things that can happen to a young child.

OP you are in an incredibly difficult position and I think you should explore and unpack further with the child exactly what is happening. Are these quick smacks or full on beating with belt? Is the child attacked when genuinely being naughty/rude to parents, or is this random abuse when the child didn’t think he was misbehaving?

Then follow your conscience and instincts and ignore the lot of us.

I think it is a shame that you have got your information from unreliable sources and are now presenting them as facts.

Please cite the sources for your assertions that:

a)Social services are quick to take children away from parents
b) the UK has the highest forced adoption rate in the world

Yes, I accept that a tiny number of children have been abused by foster/ adoptive carers, these are tragedies that can’t be minimised or denied but it is worth remembering that far more children annually are abused both physically and emotionally by their parents. A horrifying number are killed by their parents. For many of those children a call to social services, or a referral to a safeguarding lead at a school could have prevented what happened within the walls of those childrens homes .

We have safeguarding procedures because they are needed, not because they tick boxes.

I was involved in child protection and believe me, some of the abuses I heard about were as far removed from “quick smacks to naughty children” as you can imagine, or to be more accurate, as you clearly can’t imagine.

Mahanii · 25/11/2022 12:01

Unfortunately even if you refer on to school or children's services it is highly unlikely that anything will change. Someone will investigate and may deem it below threshold for intervention, meanwhile the family will have been alerted to the fact that their son is talking.

You do however have a legal duty to report. I would speak to school safeguarding team, explain that he is comfortable talking to you and therefore you wish to remain anonymous. The most likely scenario is that school will then keep a closer eye on him and possibly make a decision to refer on IF they have prior information which adds weight to this.

Legally you cannot keep it secret and the child cannot make his own decision on whether it is ok to be hit or not (and he wouldn't have mentioned it if he was genuinely ok with it).

KittieDaley · 25/11/2022 11:57

TheOrigRights · 25/11/2022 11:36

Yes. A child has disclosed abuse. She has a duty of care to do something with that information.

The child has disclosed being smacked when he does something really bad (in his words). He has not disclosed abuse. As I said, the OP should get more information before deciding what to do.
There are many posters on this thread who think that a smack automatically translates into abuse. It doesn't.
Yes there are cases of abuse, but this is a child whose parents care enough to pay for a tutor. I haven't heard of any other child abuse cases where the child has the advantage of lessons outside school.

HairyToity · 25/11/2022 11:50

Dontaskdontget · 25/11/2022 10:55

I think a lot of posters are really oversimplifying this.

The truth is that UK social services are incompetent, quick to take kids away from parents (I think we have the highest forced adoption in the world?) and stick them in care where sexual abuse and grooming into drugs are common. Children taken into care have been placed on several occasions with more socially acceptable (white middle class) parents who then murder them, just look at the news reports in the last few years. It would have to be a very very extreme situation for me to involve social services in a child’s life and I’m not convinced that a disciplinary smack from an otherwise loving parent (who btw cares about the child enough to hire a tutor) meets that test. Being taken away from parents even just for a few days is one of the most traumatic things that can happen to a young child.

OP you are in an incredibly difficult position and I think you should explore and unpack further with the child exactly what is happening. Are these quick smacks or full on beating with belt? Is the child attacked when genuinely being naughty/rude to parents, or is this random abuse when the child didn’t think he was misbehaving?

Then follow your conscience and instincts and ignore the lot of us.

Agree wholeheartedly with this.

TheOrigRights · 25/11/2022 11:36

KittieDaley · 25/11/2022 11:21

It's not for her to consider cultural implications, or what the outcome might be or all the other uncertain factors.

So, she should just interfere without giving the situation any thought? OK then.

Yes. A child has disclosed abuse. She has a duty of care to do something with that information.

KittieDaley · 25/11/2022 11:21

It's not for her to consider cultural implications, or what the outcome might be or all the other uncertain factors.

So, she should just interfere without giving the situation any thought? OK then.

TheOrigRights · 25/11/2022 11:05

Then follow your conscience and instincts and ignore the lot of us.

This is absolutely not something a tutor with a duty of care should be doing.
It's not for her to consider cultural implications, or what the outcome might be or all the other uncertain factors.

KittieDaley · 25/11/2022 11:04

Dontaskdontget · 25/11/2022 10:55

I think a lot of posters are really oversimplifying this.

The truth is that UK social services are incompetent, quick to take kids away from parents (I think we have the highest forced adoption in the world?) and stick them in care where sexual abuse and grooming into drugs are common. Children taken into care have been placed on several occasions with more socially acceptable (white middle class) parents who then murder them, just look at the news reports in the last few years. It would have to be a very very extreme situation for me to involve social services in a child’s life and I’m not convinced that a disciplinary smack from an otherwise loving parent (who btw cares about the child enough to hire a tutor) meets that test. Being taken away from parents even just for a few days is one of the most traumatic things that can happen to a young child.

OP you are in an incredibly difficult position and I think you should explore and unpack further with the child exactly what is happening. Are these quick smacks or full on beating with belt? Is the child attacked when genuinely being naughty/rude to parents, or is this random abuse when the child didn’t think he was misbehaving?

Then follow your conscience and instincts and ignore the lot of us.

Yes, this. The OP needs to find out more about the situation before wading in and potentially making things worse.

Dontaskdontget · 25/11/2022 10:55

I think a lot of posters are really oversimplifying this.

The truth is that UK social services are incompetent, quick to take kids away from parents (I think we have the highest forced adoption in the world?) and stick them in care where sexual abuse and grooming into drugs are common. Children taken into care have been placed on several occasions with more socially acceptable (white middle class) parents who then murder them, just look at the news reports in the last few years. It would have to be a very very extreme situation for me to involve social services in a child’s life and I’m not convinced that a disciplinary smack from an otherwise loving parent (who btw cares about the child enough to hire a tutor) meets that test. Being taken away from parents even just for a few days is one of the most traumatic things that can happen to a young child.

OP you are in an incredibly difficult position and I think you should explore and unpack further with the child exactly what is happening. Are these quick smacks or full on beating with belt? Is the child attacked when genuinely being naughty/rude to parents, or is this random abuse when the child didn’t think he was misbehaving?

Then follow your conscience and instincts and ignore the lot of us.

bimpeymop · 25/11/2022 10:51

I would say something maybe to social services i think his ethnicity is relevant. It is normal amongst Chinese parents. My dd is in a school with lots of Chinese dc. They have the same treatment. One also came from a school in China that caned her when she got answers wrong. My dd is 9!!

Lovetotravel123 · 25/11/2022 10:50

When a child makes a disclosure, one of the main things to tell them is that you will have to tell the appropriate person in school. That helps to make sure they don’t think you have betrayed their trust.

Stompythedinosaur · 25/11/2022 10:49

Flutterbybudget · 25/11/2022 10:47

Exactly
without more information it could easily escalate into something far more serious
Eg. It’s a one off, legally allowed smack (however reprehensible and frowned up by mumsnetters) but parents see “social services” and send child back to China to avoid the “shame”, resulting in him losing a loving home, and being more vulnerable.

I doubt this is right, but if it is then it is perfectly safe to report the conversation to social services, and they can choose to take no further action.

The op isn't the person to decide that, though. They don't know what other information might have been reported previously.

MGMidget · 25/11/2022 10:48

As you are in England and smacking is legal as a ‘reasonable’ punishment I am not sure that what he has disclosed to you is illegal. It would seem wrong to most people In England nowadays but may still be legal. If it is legal does the OP still have to disclose or can OP use their judgement on how to deal with the situation?

Capturetotalelotion · 25/11/2022 10:48

I lived in Hong Kong for years and some of the things I saw and heard were very shocking. My domestic helper told me that in a previous employment, the grandmother would put hot needles under the grandson’s nails if he wasn’t performing well enough at school. Just putting that here for context.

Stompythedinosaur · 25/11/2022 10:47

antipodeancanary · 25/11/2022 10:07

It's so easy for affluent overseas parents to remove a child from the country. DS friend never returned to school after the first allegation. As I said before, she turned up years later as an adult on social media, having been shipped back to India to live with distant family. The disgrace she brought on the family was not something they were ever going to overlook.

I'm not sure the point of this post. Are you saying it is bad to attempt to prevent children from being abused in case something worse happens to them? Or in case it damages their relationship with their abuser?

Either way, I don't agree.

Think about all the scandals were adults knew a child was being abused and did nothing. Victoria Climbie etc. Don't be that sort of person.

Flutterbybudget · 25/11/2022 10:47

Rowthe · 25/11/2022 10:41

I dont get it.

Smacking is still legal in England?
So what can Social Services do?

Exactly
without more information it could easily escalate into something far more serious
Eg. It’s a one off, legally allowed smack (however reprehensible and frowned up by mumsnetters) but parents see “social services” and send child back to China to avoid the “shame”, resulting in him losing a loving home, and being more vulnerable.

magma32 · 25/11/2022 10:44

Rowthe · 25/11/2022 10:41

I dont get it.

Smacking is still legal in England?
So what can Social Services do?

What is there to get, if a child reports his parents hitting it’s a safeguarding concern, abuse is illegal but it depends on if it’s one off smack or systemic -only safeguarding and child protection professionals can make that judgement not Op or randoms on mumsnet

LolaSmiles · 25/11/2022 10:43

A large number of tutors are just graduates, or even A level students who have paid for DBS check and signed up with an agency or tutor company.

I know a few who drifted into it for a bit of cash on top of their jobs, while many are teachers, many are not and do not know anything about safegaurding.

So you can't assume OP is a teacher
You're right we can't assume that the OP is a teacher, but threads like this illustrate perfectly why private tutoring should be a regulated area like schools, childminders, childcare etc.

It's horrifying to think there are people like the OP working with children who don't give a damn about safeguarding, seem to have quite a high opinion of themselves, and have a low opinion of more experienced professionals with appropriate safeguarding training, despite their highly problematic lack of understanding of safeguarding.

magma32 · 25/11/2022 10:42

OP are you a qualified teacher or unqualified tutor. I ask because as a teacher you would have annual safeguarding training to know what to do in this situation but a random tutor you may not have access to such training. Get yourself onto a course if you’re working with kids is my advice.

Rowthe · 25/11/2022 10:41

I dont get it.

Smacking is still legal in England?
So what can Social Services do?

magma32 · 25/11/2022 10:39

You can uphold cultural values of discipline and importance of education without resorting to beating and emotional abuse. Doesn’t matter if it’s a cultural norm, it’s illegal in the U.K. end of and any ‘professional’ overlooking or trying to put this in some context is a cause for concern in themselves.

magma32 · 25/11/2022 10:34

TheOrigRights · 25/11/2022 10:31

This.
You seem to need the approval from anonymous members of the public to keep this information to yourself - like you know better than the NSPCC or the established safeguarding recommendations.

Exactly.

magma32 · 25/11/2022 10:33

Blueeyedgirl21 · 24/11/2022 22:20

@KindergartenKop I initially thought the same but if you read the book “battle hymn of the tiger mom” I think it’s called, it talks specifically about East Asian culture around achievement and how it’s intrinsic to some families of that background (obvs not all) , therefore this boys family experience might be contextualised in that way

Yes I’ve read that book but she didn’t mentioning hitting her children in that. I come from an immigrant background so can relate a lot to it but hitting and any other abuse is a safeguarding concern so no, ethnicity isn’t important.

TheOrigRights · 25/11/2022 10:31

Yogipineapple123 · 25/11/2022 00:07

OP, what advice were you hoping to get from this thread?

This.
You seem to need the approval from anonymous members of the public to keep this information to yourself - like you know better than the NSPCC or the established safeguarding recommendations.

Carbon12 · 25/11/2022 10:22

Just to clarify OP, you reporting it doesn't automatically mean that the child is going to end up in the system.

I taught a boy who's parents were VERY hard on him. It was well known among the staff in school that he used to get hit if he didn't meet his parents' expectations.

SS and the school were working with his parents to combat their ridiculously high expectations. He was never removed from home.

Also, as staff we weren't allowed to call the parents directly if we had any issues with student. If we wanted to inform home of any misbehaviour, we had to tell the DSL to make the call on our behalf. This was in case we made the situation worse without realising.

I think you'll make things worse by speaking to the parents directly. Ask to speak to the DSL at the school and they will take it from there. They will work in the child's best interests and do so tactfully (I hope).