Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tiger parenting

209 replies

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:14

I see a kid each week for tutoring. Chinese family, kid is Y8.

He's told me his parents love him and only hit him if he has been very bad. I've asked him to talk to his school counsellor but he said no, he's ok. I told him it's not allowed in this country for parents to hit kids. And that he can call Childline or NSPCC. But he doesn't want his parents to get in trouble.

If I report then I will never see him again and the situation doesn't change. Any advice?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cw112 · 25/11/2022 20:28

I can't believe this thread is still being debated. I work in safeguarding and this is actually terrifying that people are even suggesting that op doesn't pass this on.

Op has firstly ballsed up the disclosure. She should have informed the child in the first instance of the limits to confidentiality so he knows she has to pass this on.

Secondly any disclosure MUST be written down factually and sent on to the relevant child protection officer who will then make a call as to whether gateway need to be contacted or not. This is crucial because that child protection officer may have information relating to the family that op doesn't have. This should be done within 24hrs so op I hope you've followed through. If not you need to do so ASAP.

It will then be up to the child protection officer and gateway social worker as to whether this warrants investigation or not. It is under no circumstances ops decision to make.

Op I suggest you get yourself in for child protection refresher training ASAP because in your line of work you shouldn't even be questioning this. If you fail to disclose this and the child tells someone else that he told you then you could face disciplinary and rightly so. You clearly know the processes so just do your job and follow them.

fannyfartlet · 25/11/2022 16:59

MyTing · 25/11/2022 16:43

@fannyfartlet

Maybe re read your post!? You are complete missing the point so my only query is are you for real or this childs mother desperately trying to cover up the abuse of the dad in the home.??

Legal or not it's NOT ok! No court, cafcass or chlild services will agree.
I've given evidence against people who think it's ok because it's legal. It never goes their way in court !!

Chances are the smacking is tip of the iceberg of what's going on in that house

You have no understanding of safeguarding. And what a ridiculous thing to say that courts won't agree with legislation. What do you think legal decisions are based on??

There is no evidence of further abuse and your assumption that smacking is the tip of the iceberg are also without foundation.

I'd be interested in the cases you've given evidence about as I have been involved in many cases and straight forward smacking cases do not make it to court as they don't even make threshold for statutory assessment.

MyTing · 25/11/2022 16:43

@fannyfartlet

Maybe re read your post!? You are complete missing the point so my only query is are you for real or this childs mother desperately trying to cover up the abuse of the dad in the home.??

Legal or not it's NOT ok! No court, cafcass or chlild services will agree.
I've given evidence against people who think it's ok because it's legal. It never goes their way in court !!

Chances are the smacking is tip of the iceberg of what's going on in that house

PepsiMaxandPringleStacks · 25/11/2022 16:22

If a child makes a disclosure of abuse you speak to the designated teachers...

fannyfartlet · 25/11/2022 16:20

MyTing · 25/11/2022 14:19

I could not disagree more.

Smacking is abusive. It's power and control over children. And no different to assault of adults.

The child mentioned it which I believe means that on a level he won't understand he wants someone to help him.

He isn't going to consent to his parents "getting in trouble" no way.
He might well deny it but the SS won't give up at that point. They will also hopefully be skilled at taking to kids in the right way.

I'd be wanting to know if it's both parents doing it. Perhaps it's one and they are abusing the spouse and child. They might want help and not know how to do it.

I've had to do this very thing recently and while highly unpleasant it was by far the best thing I could have done. Ever.

OP - happy to DM if helpful on my recent experience of making a report.

It's irrelevant if you couldn't agree more. What is relevant is the legislation. My personal view is that smacking a child is abusive but that isn't the view set out in The Children Act 2004.

McCoysCheese · 25/11/2022 14:21

@LolaSmiles thank you, that's very clear and helpful

OP posts:
MyTing · 25/11/2022 14:19

Lilgamesh2 · 25/11/2022 13:14

Not being goady but it's not illegal to smack in this country so why on earth report it? He clearly stated it was done as a punishment when bad not just random abuse.

Smacking isn't inherently abusive.

I could not disagree more.

Smacking is abusive. It's power and control over children. And no different to assault of adults.

The child mentioned it which I believe means that on a level he won't understand he wants someone to help him.

He isn't going to consent to his parents "getting in trouble" no way.
He might well deny it but the SS won't give up at that point. They will also hopefully be skilled at taking to kids in the right way.

I'd be wanting to know if it's both parents doing it. Perhaps it's one and they are abusing the spouse and child. They might want help and not know how to do it.

I've had to do this very thing recently and while highly unpleasant it was by far the best thing I could have done. Ever.

OP - happy to DM if helpful on my recent experience of making a report.

Yogipineapple123 · 25/11/2022 13:25

MGMidget · 25/11/2022 08:35

That is a very tricky dilemma because if you have a duty to report and dont there could be repercussions for you later. However, I think it could be worse for him if you report it given there doesnt seem to be a sufficient reason to remove him from the family from what has been revealed. The repercussions for him could be worse (eg being sent abroad to other family members where there are no laws against hitting for discipline and or being beaten or punished in other ways for telling so he gets the message to say nothing in future). Given there have been some high profile examples of failings in social services in far more severe cases than this and where there were multiple warnings I think he wont be protected but more likely exposed to repercussions from reporting this. He probably wants a confidante and he may open up to you over time about worse abuses or tell you if things escalate but there is a risk he may clam up if its reported. I dont see a good solution to be honest.

This is terrible advice!

How would you feel if an adult took it upon themselves to be your child’s confidante and didn’t make appropriate disclosures?

If a concern is reported it will be logged - and action may or may not be taken based on other reports. If one person reports that a child is being smacked I seriously doubt social services would do anything? However, he could have made disclosures to multiple people that add up to a troubling picture.

This thread is eye opening - no wonder so many children are left to be abused.

Of course understanding cultural differences is important. However, it is racism to accept one standard for white children and a lower standard for children from other ethnic backgrounds.

toomuchlaundry · 25/11/2022 13:22

@HotPotato787 i don’t think that is true in respect of criminal proceedings against OP. It is currently being looked at whether a law should be brought in for anyone working with children so that failure to report could result in criminal proceedings. Statutory guidance for schools talks about ‘should’ and not ‘must’ report at the moment

LolaSmiles · 25/11/2022 13:21

Not being goady but it's not illegal to smack in this country so why on earth report it? He clearly stated it was done as a punishment when bad not just random abuse.
Because unless someone is going to do an investigation on the injuries (which they shouldn't), they don't know the level of violence that's been directed to the child.

If there's no other concerns around the child and the information is shared, it sits on the system and nothing will come of it.

But if the child has reported being physically disciplined to their tutor and that's reported, and the relevant safeguarding people also have reports from other adults around the child about concerns then that child is more likely to get the support they need.

(FWIW, I think smacking is abusive. In no other relation would be tolerate one person using violence and fear to control another person to behave a certain way, but have set that personal view to one side to answer your question).

Stompythedinosaur · 25/11/2022 13:20

Lilgamesh2 · 25/11/2022 13:14

Not being goady but it's not illegal to smack in this country so why on earth report it? He clearly stated it was done as a punishment when bad not just random abuse.

Smacking isn't inherently abusive.

As stated many times above, this decision is not for the op to make.

Also, something can be both legal and abusive. It is not illegal for a parent to abandon a child as long as someone else is caring for them, but it is still damaging. There is no criminal law to prevent a parent telling their child that they hate them and they are useless, but it is still abuse.

Stompythedinosaur · 25/11/2022 13:16

I don't know how people who fail to act to protect children can live with themselves afterwards.

Is that really the sort of person you want to be, op?

Lilgamesh2 · 25/11/2022 13:14

Not being goady but it's not illegal to smack in this country so why on earth report it? He clearly stated it was done as a punishment when bad not just random abuse.

Smacking isn't inherently abusive.

LolaSmiles · 25/11/2022 13:11

You sound like you haven’t got a clue about safeguarding procedures, and on that basis, should not be working with children in a professional capacity.
Agree with this 100%

Nobody who is this clueless about safeguarding should be working with children and it frankly very worrying that there's a lot of equally clueless posters encouraging the OP to act in a way that could put a child at risk.

HotPotato787 · 25/11/2022 13:08

sorry, can’t read the whole thread but I have read all of OP’s replies.

@McCoysCheese you have a legal and professional duty to report the disclosure to Children’s Services. It is not your place to decide that they may make things worse. If you do not report this then you are negligent in your duty to protect this child. Your silence leaves him at risk of harm.

You sound like you haven’t got a clue about safeguarding procedures, and on that basis, should not be working with children in a professional capacity.

Report what was said directly to children’s services - their contact details will be on your local council’s website.

Then book yourself on to a safeguarding course.

Aside from your duty to report the disclosure in order to protect the child, you’re also leaving yourself open to criminal proceedings for negligence if you do not report it.

magma32 · 25/11/2022 13:05

“It would have to be a very very extreme situation for me to involve social services in a child’s life”

what, like death?

I hope you don’t work with children.

LolaSmiles · 25/11/2022 13:04

OP you are in an incredibly difficult position and I think you should explore and unpack further with the child exactly what is happening. Are these quick smacks or full on beating with belt? Is the child attacked when genuinely being naughty/rude to parents, or is this random abuse when the child didn’t think he was misbehaving?

Then follow your conscience and instincts and ignore the lot of us.
Safeguarding training makes it very clear that on having a safeguarding concern, or in the event a child discloses, it is NOT the role of the adult to investigate.
It is the role of the adult to pass the information on to the relevant person/authority, and they will decide next steps.

Unfortunately the OP thinks she's above following safeguarding procedures and is being cheered on by equally uninformed people like yourself.

It would be a fairly awful situation for a serious case review to happen and someone seriously has to live telling themselves they did a great thing by doing their own investigation and /or ignoring safeguarding concerns due to a child's race, but it's ok because some random people on Mumsnet gave her a pat on the back and said she was fine.

Stompythedinosaur · 25/11/2022 12:57

Dontaskdontget · 25/11/2022 10:55

I think a lot of posters are really oversimplifying this.

The truth is that UK social services are incompetent, quick to take kids away from parents (I think we have the highest forced adoption in the world?) and stick them in care where sexual abuse and grooming into drugs are common. Children taken into care have been placed on several occasions with more socially acceptable (white middle class) parents who then murder them, just look at the news reports in the last few years. It would have to be a very very extreme situation for me to involve social services in a child’s life and I’m not convinced that a disciplinary smack from an otherwise loving parent (who btw cares about the child enough to hire a tutor) meets that test. Being taken away from parents even just for a few days is one of the most traumatic things that can happen to a young child.

OP you are in an incredibly difficult position and I think you should explore and unpack further with the child exactly what is happening. Are these quick smacks or full on beating with belt? Is the child attacked when genuinely being naughty/rude to parents, or is this random abuse when the child didn’t think he was misbehaving?

Then follow your conscience and instincts and ignore the lot of us.

A lot to unpack here.

Social services teams have made mistakes, but it is ridiculous to write an entire profession off as incompetent.

Social services do not remove children from their families - only a judge can do that.

"Follow your instincts" is bad advice, because people who have had abusive experiences themselves will often feel like something is ok when it isn't. It also provides a get out clause when someone doesn't want to inconvenience themselves by acting in the way they should. That is why there is generally a policy or guidance to follow.

Something can both be legal and be abusive.

The lack of detail in the disclosure means it is impossible to know if the physical abuse described crosses the bar into illegality.

It is completely irrelevant when a child is abused in response to bad behaviour or not. No child can behave in a way that "deserves" abuse.

morecookes · 25/11/2022 12:57

Dontaskdontget · 25/11/2022 10:55

I think a lot of posters are really oversimplifying this.

The truth is that UK social services are incompetent, quick to take kids away from parents (I think we have the highest forced adoption in the world?) and stick them in care where sexual abuse and grooming into drugs are common. Children taken into care have been placed on several occasions with more socially acceptable (white middle class) parents who then murder them, just look at the news reports in the last few years. It would have to be a very very extreme situation for me to involve social services in a child’s life and I’m not convinced that a disciplinary smack from an otherwise loving parent (who btw cares about the child enough to hire a tutor) meets that test. Being taken away from parents even just for a few days is one of the most traumatic things that can happen to a young child.

OP you are in an incredibly difficult position and I think you should explore and unpack further with the child exactly what is happening. Are these quick smacks or full on beating with belt? Is the child attacked when genuinely being naughty/rude to parents, or is this random abuse when the child didn’t think he was misbehaving?

Then follow your conscience and instincts and ignore the lot of us.

But if you're saying they are incompetent, it follows that thousands fall through the net and end up with years of abuse, or worse.

Like the tragic case of Logan Mwangi, how many little boys are slipping through the net, suffering, only to hear about them when it ends with murder?

magma32 · 25/11/2022 12:38

Safeguarding is everyone’s responsibility not just professionals including Joe Public. The tutor doesn’t need to legally undergo safeguarding training but anyone interested in child protection would want to learn about the procedures involved to be better informed so if something were to come out of it, you’ve got your back covered and can justify why you didn’t report it when someone made a disclosure to you. The fact that the op thinks hitting is just a part of ‘tiger parenting’ shows their ignorance really.

TheOrigRights · 25/11/2022 12:15

KittieDaley · 25/11/2022 11:57

The child has disclosed being smacked when he does something really bad (in his words). He has not disclosed abuse. As I said, the OP should get more information before deciding what to do.
There are many posters on this thread who think that a smack automatically translates into abuse. It doesn't.
Yes there are cases of abuse, but this is a child whose parents care enough to pay for a tutor. I haven't heard of any other child abuse cases where the child has the advantage of lessons outside school.

OP says "only hit him if he has been very bad". He is upset enough to have told an adult and to be worried about repercussions. I think that he is being subjected to abuse.

"Care enough to pay for a tutor". I don't even know where to start with that level of ignorance.

Getoff · 25/11/2022 12:10

If you are working as a tutor you must have a safeguarding policy in-line with the law.

She has a duty of care to do something with that information.

I've just googled, and apparently tutoring is completely unregulated in England, which must mean there are no specific legal obligations that tutors have.

If I'm wrong to believe that tutors have no more legal obligations than any other person a child comes in contact with, somebody please post a link to show this. (Don't assume tutors will be teachers.)

tunthebloodyalarmoff · 25/11/2022 12:10

McCoysCheese · 24/11/2022 22:26

If I speak to his school and they speak with him he will deny it and know I've betrayed his trust.
If I speak to the parents they will stop bringing him to me.
In both cases he loses out.

Just mind your own business

Feetupteashot · 25/11/2022 12:07

Speak to local safeguarding team foe advice. You can do this anonymously initially.

They should have records of whether other people have reported concerns about the child as well

magma32 · 25/11/2022 12:05

KittieDaley · 25/11/2022 11:57

The child has disclosed being smacked when he does something really bad (in his words). He has not disclosed abuse. As I said, the OP should get more information before deciding what to do.
There are many posters on this thread who think that a smack automatically translates into abuse. It doesn't.
Yes there are cases of abuse, but this is a child whose parents care enough to pay for a tutor. I haven't heard of any other child abuse cases where the child has the advantage of lessons outside school.

Nobody is saying it’s abuse -the legal duty of deciding whether it’s abuse or not is down to the professionals who work in child protection not for the tutor to investigate. Clearly many do not have any knowledge of how safeguarding works in this country and it’s shameful op has clearly not undergone any training on this despite working with children.