Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel really irritated by my friend asking me to review her book…

158 replies

RunicWords · 24/11/2022 19:08

So a friend of mine has self-published a book for kids. It seems nicely written with cute illustrations. But I don’t think it’s exceptional. She’s asked me to help her by reviewing it on Amazon.
Of course I’ve said I will… once I’ve purchased it of course, otherwise it won’t be a ‘verified purchase’.
I looked on Amazon and she already has multiple 5-star reviews (nothing less) … they must all be from friends as it’s only just come out and how would anyone know about it otherwise? Now it’s really bugging me as I often rely on reviews when I buy books and other stuff, and the thought of being hoodwinked by reviews like that enrages me.
On the other hand, fair play to her, she’s gone for it, she needs the support and encouragement, and it would be really mean not to help, right?
I can’t decide what to think, please help!!

OP posts:
RunicWords · 24/11/2022 19:57

Maggiethecat · 24/11/2022 19:42

what is so hard about writing a review for a friend? by your own admission it seems nicely written/ illustrated, did she ask you to say it was exceptional?

no, she didn’t so write the review and help a friend fgs.

It's not hard to write a review. I like doing nice things for my friends and of course I want to help. I was caught out by my reaction. Who knows, maybe I want to write a book and I'm a bit jealous Shock
It's just that anything less than 5 stars will look really mean-spirited now. Probably worse than no review. It just irks me because, like I say, I really rely on reviews, especially when weighing up books to read. Guess it's the principle.
But as people have suggested, I'll focus on the positives and think of the effort that's gone into it.

OP posts:
socialserviceshelpplease · 24/11/2022 19:55

Angelofthenortheast · 24/11/2022 19:23

Bloody hell! It's your friend! If you gave a speech at her wedding would you say "it's only fair that I'm honest - I'd give her 2.5 stars as a wife"... ?

This is funny
Well done

Maggiethecat · 24/11/2022 19:52

Artygirlghost · 24/11/2022 19:44

Some friend...

You don't need to write that this is a masterpiece.

Simply write something brief and positive and focus on the aspects of the book you like.

Frankly you sound a bit jealous...

yep, green eyed did come to mind.

for those talking about the issue of buying a book - if you genuinely can’t afford to that’s one thing but otherwise it’s weird that you’d be offended by the principle of buying the book. If your friend was selling stuff at a stall would you consider supporting her with a purchase?

CorvusPurpureus · 24/11/2022 19:48

I think you are being over-scrupulous.

Yes, if you're buying a tin opener, you want to choose one with 5 star reviews that actually works.

If you're buying/reading a 'self published children's book' then you're pretty much guaranteed family/friend. Should it be a work of genius, it'll be picked up by a publisher (& this will probably already not have happened, & not for want of the author trying).

I'd just write something like 'Peter the penguin's journey to become a polar bear tamer is heart warming, & the illustrations of the seals were delightful!' & go about your day.

No one's going to buy the thing, & if they did, off the back of your review, well, you didn't exactly claim it would change their life.

You just said it was readable & the illustrations were cute, as per your OP.

Pepsipepsi · 24/11/2022 19:45

burnoutbabe · 24/11/2022 19:40

But you have to buy the book? Different to just skimming though and then doing a quick review.

I'd be happy to review but not be forced to but a full priced copy

The OP has only stated that a friend has requested a review. OP could leave a review without spending anything. Verified sale doesn't mean anything in this case. You could read it in a library for free for all review readers know.

Artygirlghost · 24/11/2022 19:44

Some friend...

You don't need to write that this is a masterpiece.

Simply write something brief and positive and focus on the aspects of the book you like.

Frankly you sound a bit jealous...

Maggiethecat · 24/11/2022 19:42

what is so hard about writing a review for a friend? by your own admission it seems nicely written/ illustrated, did she ask you to say it was exceptional?

no, she didn’t so write the review and help a friend fgs.

burnoutbabe · 24/11/2022 19:40

Pepsipepsi · 24/11/2022 19:27

I hate nepotism with a passion. BUT helping out a self published friend is just a nice thing to do, it's likely the book won't lead to anything. But if it does I doubt it would be because of friend's reviews on Amazon. I would hate to think my friends couldn't be bothered to take 2 mins to leave a review, after I take an interest in their lives.

It's literally the same as taking the time to listen to a boring anecdote and replying "oh that sounds nice" not "I don't give a duck" thought that goes through your head.

But you have to buy the book? Different to just skimming though and then doing a quick review.

I'd be happy to review but not be forced to but a full priced copy

NoSquirrels · 24/11/2022 19:39

one of the terms of her contract was that she’d write a certain number of positive Amazon reviews for the publisher’s other authors

That is… non-standard. Shock

I’ll assume your friend’s ‘publisher’ was not exactly top tier legit.

Supe · 24/11/2022 19:38

LoobyDop · 24/11/2022 19:34

A friend of mine used to be contracted to a publisher, and one of the terms of her contract was that she’d write a certain number of positive Amazon reviews for the publisher’s other authors. She said she had to spend far more time on that and marketing/PR (mostly by engaging with fans on social media) than on the actual writing.

I’m a writer and I have never ever heard of this! Was she employed by some unknown publisher startup?!

LoobyDop · 24/11/2022 19:34

ICanHideButICantRun · 24/11/2022 19:19

In what way are they bollocks? I'm a writer and know tons of writers. There's only been one person I know of where I've thought the reviews were bought in.

I've written reviews that Amazon has cancelled without warning, saying they thought they weren't genuine. One was for someone who'd reviewed one of my books and one was a review I wrote of a truly awful book.

A friend of mine used to be contracted to a publisher, and one of the terms of her contract was that she’d write a certain number of positive Amazon reviews for the publisher’s other authors. She said she had to spend far more time on that and marketing/PR (mostly by engaging with fans on social media) than on the actual writing.

FictionalCharacter · 24/11/2022 19:33

I wouldn’t leave a review at all. I wouldn’t want to lie for someone by saying it’s great if it isn’t.

KittieDaley · 24/11/2022 19:33

BUT, I do think it’s cheeky fuckerish of her to ask for a review when what she’s really asking for is a sale

Most paperback books cost less than £5, and a Kindle version can be as little as £0.99. Why wouldn't a friend make the gesture?

rookiemere · 24/11/2022 19:32

It's not the review I object to, as much as being forced to buy her book.
I'd just say you didn't realise you had to buy a copy to leave a review and you don't really need a book.

NoSquirrels · 24/11/2022 19:32

Angelofthenortheast · 24/11/2022 19:27

@SoftwareDev yes I used to work in publishing! Waterstones do NOT decide which books go in the window, or even in the big circular tables, and which ones just go on the shelves with only the spines visible. Publishers pay for those slots for the authors they're most invested in.

This is sort of true and sort of not true at her same time.

Publishers pay for the privilege of being included in the promotions that go on the tables and window and front of store. But Waterstones head office buyers actually choose those books - it’s just they’re choosing from a small selection each publisher shows them that they know they’re willing to spend marketing money on to promote. Again, it is what it is, pretty circular. But not bad faith or misleading.

carefulcalculator · 24/11/2022 19:31

Now it’s really bugging me as I often rely on reviews when I buy books and other stuff, and the thought of being hoodwinked by reviews like that enrages me

YABU to be this naive about the review process. I also think you are being a bit tight towards your friend. Read it and write some nice things.

LemonDrizzles · 24/11/2022 19:30

1st wave reviews for self published= friends/family giving 5 star reviews giving the book some exposure
2nd wave reviews= if the book really isn't exceptional, I'm sure those reviews will bring the rating down.

Tbh, we have a family friend who writes children books. There are like 17 characters with complicated names. The adults struggle to follow. It's aimed at 3-5 probably. But if he asked me to review, I would likely give 5 star and try to envision who would love the book and aim my review at that person.

I can see how much care, love and effort this person put in. From this perspective, it is the sweetest book.

But please do what you feel is the right thing to do.

All the best

1982mommaof4 · 24/11/2022 19:30

drpet49 · 24/11/2022 19:12

You sound like a lovely friend 🙄

This

NoSquirrels · 24/11/2022 19:29

Absolutely ALL publishing - ‘traditional’ and self-publishing - relies on early reviews.

They may not all be ‘bought’ in the sense that they’re honest reviews and no obligation to post a 5-star review, but most early reviewers do post positively, because they want their own record to reflect that they don’t do negative reviews. So that they keep getting offered advance copies of books to review…

It is what it is.

But if she’s your friend and the book us halfway decent, give her a good review as quick as you can. It really helps.

Angelofthenortheast · 24/11/2022 19:27

@SoftwareDev yes I used to work in publishing! Waterstones do NOT decide which books go in the window, or even in the big circular tables, and which ones just go on the shelves with only the spines visible. Publishers pay for those slots for the authors they're most invested in.

Pepsipepsi · 24/11/2022 19:27

I hate nepotism with a passion. BUT helping out a self published friend is just a nice thing to do, it's likely the book won't lead to anything. But if it does I doubt it would be because of friend's reviews on Amazon. I would hate to think my friends couldn't be bothered to take 2 mins to leave a review, after I take an interest in their lives.

It's literally the same as taking the time to listen to a boring anecdote and replying "oh that sounds nice" not "I don't give a duck" thought that goes through your head.

MelchiorsMistress · 24/11/2022 19:27

It doesn’t have to be exceptional for you to give your friend a nice review. Give her an honest review about the nice things like the cute illustrations and say something factual about the moral of the story or a problem it could help a child with or whatever.

BUT, I do think it’s cheeky fuckerish of her to ask for a review when what she’s really asking for is a sale.

Angelofthenortheast · 24/11/2022 19:23

Bloody hell! It's your friend! If you gave a speech at her wedding would you say "it's only fair that I'm honest - I'd give her 2.5 stars as a wife"... ?

KittieDaley · 24/11/2022 19:22

Just do it, to help your friend. Regardless of your opinion, she has spent months writing the book, and a little appreciation wouldn't go amiss.
Everyone knows the first few reviews are from friends and family.

Thereisnolight · 24/11/2022 19:21

Give her a nice review. You don’t have to say it’s a literary masterpiece. You can say something along the lines of, this is a really sweet book about xyz with cute pictures. I especially liked x character’s hat. Discerning readers can read between the lines, just like on Tripadvisor.