Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel really irritated by my friend asking me to review her book…

158 replies

RunicWords · 24/11/2022 19:08

So a friend of mine has self-published a book for kids. It seems nicely written with cute illustrations. But I don’t think it’s exceptional. She’s asked me to help her by reviewing it on Amazon.
Of course I’ve said I will… once I’ve purchased it of course, otherwise it won’t be a ‘verified purchase’.
I looked on Amazon and she already has multiple 5-star reviews (nothing less) … they must all be from friends as it’s only just come out and how would anyone know about it otherwise? Now it’s really bugging me as I often rely on reviews when I buy books and other stuff, and the thought of being hoodwinked by reviews like that enrages me.
On the other hand, fair play to her, she’s gone for it, she needs the support and encouragement, and it would be really mean not to help, right?
I can’t decide what to think, please help!!

OP posts:
WednesdaysChild11 · 25/11/2022 18:21

overwhelming desire to protect the buying public

Careful we don't know what abject terrors this book is about to unleash upon the world
🤣🤣🤣👀

**

RunicWords · 25/11/2022 17:57

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/11/2022 17:37

Is the book defective? Can it cause an injury? No.

That's quite a low bar, though! "5 stars - it didn't give me a paper cut" Grin

That's hilarious. Best comment I've read on here so far!

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/11/2022 17:37

Is the book defective? Can it cause an injury? No.

That's quite a low bar, though! "5 stars - it didn't give me a paper cut" Grin

Maggiethecat · 25/11/2022 16:04

And do you spend this much time agonising over yourAmazon purchase reviews generally, weighing the potential harm that a 1 star difference might make?

Maggiethecat · 25/11/2022 15:56

RunicWords · 25/11/2022 15:40

Wow, I wasn't aware you knew what I did for a living...
But I don't think you need to be part of the publishing world to understand the integrity that was mentioned... do you think book publishers have a monopoly on that?
I'm really passionate about books and reading and I love kids' books. I expect the books I buy for my kids (or for anyone) to be beautifully written, beautifully illustrated, well edited and well produced. Otherwise I'd rather not spend money on them.
Sorry but there it is.
So yup, being taken in by a fake review would really piss me off.

It’s fair to think that you would have said at the outset if you were in that area of work as that would have probably influenced your reaction.

Put things in the scales - your overwhelming desire to protect the buying public (from what, I’m not sure since everyone knows that book preferences are subjective) and saying something honest and nice about the book even if it’s not 5 star, probably 4 star since you’re so very conflicted? At least it drives traffic.

What’s the worst that can happen? she’s mad at you and you’re no longer friends? Might be best for both of you.

Autumnalleavestime · 25/11/2022 15:50

God how jealous are you; and what silly excuses for your own behaviour. How many mates does dhe have v the size of rhe intended audience,

Christ I did this for my daughters friends mum. I bought the book and yes gave a 5 star review. I didn’t even read it. Why, Becsyde I like the friend, they asked me to and I’m happy to support anyone getting a food hold.

get over yourself going on about the ethics of Amazon reviews. Seriously

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 25/11/2022 15:49

saraclara · 25/11/2022 15:36

My mind is boggled by the vast majority of posts here.

I think I'm a good friend. I also know that none of my friends would ask me to post a fake review for them.

OP, I'd simply go with the old saying "if you can't say anything nice, say nothing at all". It's not like she's short of fake 5* reviewers already.

Agree. There is no way I would leave a fake review just to pander to a friend. Integrity is important.

RunicWords · 25/11/2022 15:40

Maggiethecat · 25/11/2022 12:39

@Remaker - I don’t think your situation is comparable to the OP’s since you are into publishing professionally.

The OP’s professional integrity is not at stake here.

Wow, I wasn't aware you knew what I did for a living...
But I don't think you need to be part of the publishing world to understand the integrity that was mentioned... do you think book publishers have a monopoly on that?
I'm really passionate about books and reading and I love kids' books. I expect the books I buy for my kids (or for anyone) to be beautifully written, beautifully illustrated, well edited and well produced. Otherwise I'd rather not spend money on them.
Sorry but there it is.
So yup, being taken in by a fake review would really piss me off.

OP posts:
saraclara · 25/11/2022 15:36

My mind is boggled by the vast majority of posts here.

I think I'm a good friend. I also know that none of my friends would ask me to post a fake review for them.

OP, I'd simply go with the old saying "if you can't say anything nice, say nothing at all". It's not like she's short of fake 5* reviewers already.

RunicWords · 25/11/2022 15:31

jelly79 · 25/11/2022 15:20

Irritated that your friend has asked you to support her business and it will take very little effort!

Do it! More so you should of offered

If you'd read the thread, you'd know your answer has no bearing on the debate here...
Haven't suggested anywhere that writing a review is an effort or a chore.

OP posts:
jelly79 · 25/11/2022 15:20

Irritated that your friend has asked you to support her business and it will take very little effort!

Do it! More so you should of offered

WednesdaysChild11 · 25/11/2022 13:49

The point is your priorities are wrong. As long as it isn't a crap book you should be ok with stretching your desired 4 star review to a 5 star one. Your friend is going to run out of friends to review the book eventually, this is just to give her a head start. Then the "real" reviews will come in. You're being ridiculous.

rookiemere · 25/11/2022 13:07

I'm with @Remaker .

It's her friends hobby. I've done some writing myself and now know that creating a version is only about half the work. Editing and producing a final version that someone else is willing to print is a totally different matter.

A friend in our book group has just written a children's book and asked for feedback. I said how wonderful it was that she had achieved this and good on her, I see that as being a supportive friend.

Paying for a copy of it is a different matter and I'd only do that if I thought it was good enough to be a present for our niece or someone else.

I don't expect other people to subsidise my hobbies, so I don't expect to subsidise theirs.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 25/11/2022 12:59

It's an obnoxious request; just fob her off with an excuse about being busy.

clpsmum · 25/11/2022 12:53

Some friend you are

Maggiethecat · 25/11/2022 12:39

@Remaker - I don’t think your situation is comparable to the OP’s since you are into publishing professionally.

The OP’s professional integrity is not at stake here.

Remaker · 25/11/2022 12:13

OP I understand where you are coming from. I work in publishing. What your friend should have done is just let her friends know that IF you like the book then reviews would be really appreciated. Anyone who specifically requested a review from me would not get one unless I absolutely loved the book.

I understand the POV that says encourage your friends. But isn’t this how MLMs are run? Guilt your friends into supporting your business? I have a couple of friends who have really burnt their friendship circles because of their constant pestering to crowdfund albums or buy/review poorly written books. It puts you in an uncomfortable position as a friend. And before anyone condemns me, two of the books I’ve been asked to review (happens a lot when people find out you’re an editor even though I work in non-fiction!!) were badly written crime fiction with an excessive amount of gratuitous sexual violence. So no, I didn’t feel obliged to reward that effort with a review, despite the friendship.

WiddlinDiddlin · 25/11/2022 12:02

And actually ‘cute illustrations’ is not what she’s after, since she’s the writer, not the illustrator.

If she's self published, she's picked the illustrator herself and the illustrations in a kids book are a huge and vital part of the book - and I am not just saying that as an illustrator... a kids book for a certain age group without illustrations is pointless, not going to be bought by anyone!

So mentioning illustrations in the review is well worth it (also, us illustrators are people too and we take pride in our work, we'd like a mention in reviews where relevant!) and not a 'shit review' at all.

Brokenunicorn · 25/11/2022 12:00

They should have given you a copy if you're going to review it.

Maggiethecat · 25/11/2022 11:28

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/11/2022 11:13

Would people calling OP a 'shitty friend' be saying the same thing if her friend had designed a device that was highly unreliable and of dubious quality - maybe like those rubbish 'indoor TV aerial boosters' they used to sell in the weekend papers decades ago, that didn't do a thing for you (apart from rob you of £19.99 plus p+p) - and was insistent on OP complicitly giving a 5-star review?

If anything, I don't see why across-the-board 5-star reviews even matter with something like a book, as long as you bother to say a few words as to why you feel that way. Somebody could write the finest-crafted sci-fi novel ever, with an outstanding storyline, but it still wouldn't be worth 5 stars to me, as I can't stand sci-fi - just personal preference.

That’s the point though, it’s not a piece of kit or something that objectively you can say is good or bad/ fit for purpose etc and are being asked to misrepresent.

It’s a book and its merits are subjective. You may hate it and I may love it and that’s the attitude to take when considering book reviews. Surely everyone knows that.

So I just can’t understand why the OP is so fearful of duping the public. Perhaps time to consider what’s really underlying all of this angst.

kirinm · 25/11/2022 11:22

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll why do you keep trying to compare the OP reviewing her "friends" kid's book with things that are not at all the same. Is the book defective? Can it cause an injury? No.

And I think the OP would have mentioned if she is a critic.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/11/2022 11:15

Is the OP a book critic? No she isn't. It is a poor comparison.

She didn't say one way or the other, so we don't know if she is or if she isn't. Even if she isn't actually a critic by profession, plenty of people become online 'power reviewers' and will build a reputation based on that.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/11/2022 11:13

Would people calling OP a 'shitty friend' be saying the same thing if her friend had designed a device that was highly unreliable and of dubious quality - maybe like those rubbish 'indoor TV aerial boosters' they used to sell in the weekend papers decades ago, that didn't do a thing for you (apart from rob you of £19.99 plus p+p) - and was insistent on OP complicitly giving a 5-star review?

If anything, I don't see why across-the-board 5-star reviews even matter with something like a book, as long as you bother to say a few words as to why you feel that way. Somebody could write the finest-crafted sci-fi novel ever, with an outstanding storyline, but it still wouldn't be worth 5 stars to me, as I can't stand sci-fi - just personal preference.

kirinm · 25/11/2022 11:07

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/11/2022 10:54

You need to ask yourself why you are so resentful of it

I'm not getting that OP is resentful - just conscious of the fact that many people will assume that being a good friend means never giving any fair criticism of the friend or their works, which I completely get.

OP suggests that the book is quite good, but nothing special; but what if it were an absolute stinker, littered with spelling mistakes and terrible illustrations?! Reviews go both ways and, although not always so easy to link, people will come to trust and respect the reviews of certain reviewers; if you give a glowing review to something meh, that can impact on you as well.

If Barry Norman had raved about Sex Lives Of The Potato Men being simply the best film ever made in the history of humanity, do you not think that might have compromised the value that people ascribed to all of his future reviews?!

Is the OP a book critic? No she isn't. It is a poor comparison.

KittieDaley · 25/11/2022 11:05

kirinm · 25/11/2022 10:29

You sound like a shitty friend. Why make such a big thing out of absolutely nothing?

This.