Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel really irritated by my friend asking me to review her book…

158 replies

RunicWords · 24/11/2022 19:08

So a friend of mine has self-published a book for kids. It seems nicely written with cute illustrations. But I don’t think it’s exceptional. She’s asked me to help her by reviewing it on Amazon.
Of course I’ve said I will… once I’ve purchased it of course, otherwise it won’t be a ‘verified purchase’.
I looked on Amazon and she already has multiple 5-star reviews (nothing less) … they must all be from friends as it’s only just come out and how would anyone know about it otherwise? Now it’s really bugging me as I often rely on reviews when I buy books and other stuff, and the thought of being hoodwinked by reviews like that enrages me.
On the other hand, fair play to her, she’s gone for it, she needs the support and encouragement, and it would be really mean not to help, right?
I can’t decide what to think, please help!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hoplesscynic · 28/11/2022 11:17

I would be more annoyed that the friend is asking me to buy their book. If you can't review it without buying, then she needs to give you a free copy - because she is the one who wants your review.
Not the same situation, but I had a friend advertising their book, I made the right noises (sounds interesting etc) but did not purchase as it wasn't my cup of tea. Had another friend advertise book on a WhatsApp chat, cue everyone falling over immediately wanting (paid) copies. I just kept quiet as again, didn't really care for it.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 28/11/2022 11:05

mynameiscalypso · 24/11/2022 19:16

Amazon reviews and ratings are a complete pile of horse shit. I would have no problem helping a friend out with a review given that 99% of review on there are bollocks.

Look at the number of 5* reviews the fifty shades series had....

Probably the worst written book (erotica or otherwise) I've ever read!

Softplayhooray · 28/11/2022 11:03

Angelofthenortheast · 24/11/2022 19:27

@SoftwareDev yes I used to work in publishing! Waterstones do NOT decide which books go in the window, or even in the big circular tables, and which ones just go on the shelves with only the spines visible. Publishers pay for those slots for the authors they're most invested in.

@Angelofthenortheast that's so interesting! can you do an AMA sometime?

OP if she's a great friend give her a five star review to help, as @Angelofthenortheast says the odds seem against people like your friend so isn't it good to help her if you can?

RunicWords · 28/11/2022 10:58

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/11/2022 00:59

As for reviews on a kids book... Unless it's destined to be the next Harry Potter it's just a book. Just say it's nice

I'm guessing that, 5-stars or not, the friend is looking for something significantly more effusive than "this is a nice book". It could be taken as quite passive-aggressive when coming from a friend, even if that's really not the intention.

That reminds me a bit of the reviews of the musical in The IT Crowd that said very non-committal things like "not as long as some musicals" and "everybody clapped at the end" Grin

I'm really not getting the jealousy that people are imputing to OP, mind.

In my experience little kids like the books that are total rubbish ! Not literary masterpieces!

Like when you spend thousands taking them on an amazing holiday to Disneyworld and ask them what their absolute favourite bit was, and without skipping a beat, they say "When Daddy farted on the plane!" Grin

Thank you @WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll
I'm glad that you get what I'm trying to say.
I've noticed a few people on here saying stuff like it's 'ONLY' a book, and 'don't even read it, just give it 5 stars and get over your jealousy!'

Or just write 'Cute illustrations.'
I think she, as the writer, might hate me forever if I put that.

Also, if I wrote a book and my friend couldn't even be bothered to look at a few pages, that would probably piss me off more than an honest review!

Anyway, obviously I'm never going to give the book three stars or share my real thoughts with her. (That's what anonymous forums or for, right? I was just interested in what others thought.) In real life, I've been nothing but supportive actually - though I've found the thought of a fake 5-star review very uncomfortable and wondered how to approach it. I mean, the book has good points but also grammatical errors and inconsistencies.

(Yup, get over yourself and your pathetic 'save the world from fake reviews' mission, OP).

OP posts:
notnowB · 28/11/2022 01:22

Just support your friend!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 28/11/2022 00:59

As for reviews on a kids book... Unless it's destined to be the next Harry Potter it's just a book. Just say it's nice

I'm guessing that, 5-stars or not, the friend is looking for something significantly more effusive than "this is a nice book". It could be taken as quite passive-aggressive when coming from a friend, even if that's really not the intention.

That reminds me a bit of the reviews of the musical in The IT Crowd that said very non-committal things like "not as long as some musicals" and "everybody clapped at the end" Grin

I'm really not getting the jealousy that people are imputing to OP, mind.

In my experience little kids like the books that are total rubbish ! Not literary masterpieces!

Like when you spend thousands taking them on an amazing holiday to Disneyworld and ask them what their absolute favourite bit was, and without skipping a beat, they say "When Daddy farted on the plane!" Grin

BeepyBoo · 27/11/2022 20:48

Oh and now you are talking about her in a post, and although confidentially, trying to get others to agree with the fact that she is irritating in some way for asking for your support. Nice.

BeepyBoo · 27/11/2022 20:46

You sound a bit jealous. It's really hard to create something and actually follow through to the end, get it published and expose yourself to potential public criticism (or comments like, 'it's not exceptional'. So what if it's simply 'good', that's still an amazing achievement). It takes a lot of courage. Getting any genuine sales at all is really hard, particularly if it's your first attempt. This applies to not just books, but artwork, music, a new business venture, etc....

You are her friend, so give her a nice review and help her along FFS.

Plumnora · 27/11/2022 19:30

Seriously?!! Does it really matter if you big up your mate’s book? Will anyone die if you say you loved it but you didn’t?? Everyone knows Amazon book reviews are mostly fake anyway so stop stressing and just give her 5 stars. She’s going to be pretty upset if you don’t.

Radiatorvalves · 27/11/2022 11:54

If it is rubbish I’d probably leave a fairly anodyne review. She’s your friend and these reviews are important (even though I take them with a large pinch of salt). A friend of my brother’s wrote a political memoir a couple of years ago. I really enjoyed it and messaged him saying so. He asked if I’d review it on Amazon as it makes a difference. I was delighted to do so.

Tillow4ever · 27/11/2022 10:13

Just a thought, OP - why not just leave the review WITHOUT buying it from Amazon? If you have a verified purchase review, people put my weight behind them when deciding whether or not to buy it.

If you don't buy it, people will be able to tell you're a friend/family member reviewing, and decide accordingly. Another thing to fluff it out, you could say "I received an advance copy of this book". That also tells people you're a friend!

burnoutbabe · 27/11/2022 09:42

Faith77 · 27/11/2022 07:28

How would you feel if you asked a friend for a personal reference & they told the absolute truth, warts & all? As someone whose work relies on good reviews, I am enormously grateful to my friends for supporting me through leaving positive remarks. There have been the odd few who have taken your approach, though (despite being happy enough to take freebies from me in most cases, though, or receive massive discounts), & it has been deeply hurtful. It opened my eyes as to who my friends were.
Support your friend & give the 5 stars.

But reviews and references should be honest? I'd not do a reference for anyone unless they had a worked for me (unless it's a personal one where it's being done more on basis of confirming work gaps)
So I also won't review a service I hadn't used.
The ones who used your service and gave you bad reviews are rude. Better to leave no review if you didn't think it any good.

SilentHedges · 27/11/2022 08:25

rookiemere · 27/11/2022 08:17

Good reply @SilentHedges .

Your DH is a professional author, and as such he's not reliant on his friends and family to subsidise him, as he has a contract through an actual publisher.

My friend is an author and the only time she asked me to leave a review she actually gave me the book - not self published- to allow me to do that. She does quite a lot of self promotion through her FB feed, but as that's free to read, I'm fine with that.

@rookiemere Thank you, likewise your author friend has integrity, which comes from belief and confidence in their work.

rookiemere · 27/11/2022 08:17

Good reply @SilentHedges .

Your DH is a professional author, and as such he's not reliant on his friends and family to subsidise him, as he has a contract through an actual publisher.

My friend is an author and the only time she asked me to leave a review she actually gave me the book - not self published- to allow me to do that. She does quite a lot of self promotion through her FB feed, but as that's free to read, I'm fine with that.

AliceDownTheRabbitHole · 27/11/2022 08:04

I never trust amazon reviews anymore. There's been quite a few times I've ordered something and been promised a £5 amazon voucher for a 5 star review. If. I've done an honest review and then mentioned the offer of a voucher in my review, amazon have declined my review saying it breaches community standards. The also never seem to want to publish my negative reviews for things either

SilentHedges · 27/11/2022 07:53

@RunicWords My OH is an author. He is signed up with one of the largest publishing houses in the world. It is incredibly difficult to achieve that. At no point when starting out, had he asked for 5 star reviews, and he has never asked anyone to buy his books. Many people we know haven't bought them, or left reviews, and that's fine, it's not their genre or taste and he's successful through sheer hard work without them. Its deeply presumptuous to expect people to buy XYZ from you.

While it's lovely that your friend has fulfilled her desire to write a book, absolutely anyone, regardless of their grasp of writing, can be self published on Amazon. Consequently there is a lot of complete rubbish out there. The book buying public know that, and a solid wave of 5 stars on a self published book, tells you they are all fake. It's difficult as your friend would like you to support her, but you're lying to the public, which I don't condone. It p1sses me off when ive bought stuff and wasted money due to fake reviews. I've been in exactly this situation OP, and I successfully avoided the topic, and didn't review. No falling out, no lying.

Squeezedsquash · 27/11/2022 07:28

I have an acquaintance who self published and promoted with a book launch, publicity, social media campaign etc. I read a lot and willingly parted with the £2.99 for the kindle version.

My goodness it was challenging to read. I gave up on the third chapter. it reminded me of my 10 year old’s prose. All of the reviews were 5* but I could work out who some of them are by their nicknames on Amazon.

when I asked I said it wasn’t my genre and changed the subject…

Faith77 · 27/11/2022 07:28

How would you feel if you asked a friend for a personal reference & they told the absolute truth, warts & all? As someone whose work relies on good reviews, I am enormously grateful to my friends for supporting me through leaving positive remarks. There have been the odd few who have taken your approach, though (despite being happy enough to take freebies from me in most cases, though, or receive massive discounts), & it has been deeply hurtful. It opened my eyes as to who my friends were.
Support your friend & give the 5 stars.

Purple52 · 27/11/2022 06:24

In my experience little kids like the books that are total rubbish ! Not literary masterpieces!

a five star review on amazon would put me off as it’s clearly all adults doing the reviewing.

children are more likely to enjoy a book where the adults say it’s irritatingly repetitive with a limited story line! 😂

unless I knew of the book/author (Road Dahl/Shirley Hughes/Allan ahlberg etc) I’d not buy off Amazon anyway. I’d take children to a shop/library & let them choose.

Statusunknown · 27/11/2022 06:22

I don't understand reviewing books and only buying on the thoughts of others. What one person would think is brilliant, others find awful. Read the blurb and if it interests you read the book.

As for reviews on a kids book... Unless it's destined to be the next Harry Potter it's just a book. Just say it's nice l, support your friend on her adventure and stop getting jealous of what she has achieved and you haven't.

Mamma2017 · 27/11/2022 06:16

Jealous much

CorvusPurpureus · 25/11/2022 20:49

Paq · 24/11/2022 20:11

I'd just write something like 'Peter the penguin's journey to become a polar bear tamer is heart warming, & the illustrations of the seals were delightful!' & go about your day.

In fairness I would give this book one star as polar bears live at the North Pole and penguins in the far southern hemisphere, so they never meet....

That's why it's a hero's journey. Obvs. Wouldn't be much point if the polar bears were just irritably having a lie in & a takeaway next door.

I'm not saying I'd write it, btw. It's a terrible premise & I was taking the piss. But it's got legs (tiny flippy penguin legs).

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 25/11/2022 20:07

I think, to say how many parents there are on MN, there's quite a surprisingly dismissive attitude here of 'whatever - that'll do' when it comes to books for children. Just because their appropriate level of content and vocabulary will be basic, that's no reason not to seek to select quality for them.

We all know very well that children frequently get fixated on their favourite books and want the same one again and again and again. They absorb them until they learn them by heart. Why would you not want to actively choose titles that will help them learn and develop in the best way possible - as well as grabbing their interest and attention?

I'll bet nobody on here would say "oh whatever - it's only a children's book" if they accidentally bought a book that promoted a sexist attitude or even one with questionable language in it, of any kind.

I'm not saying that OP's friend has used any inappropriate content or language - I'm sure she hasn't; but why would you not want to give your children the very best books that you can for them, rather than just 'that'll do' fillers - and, by extension, help other parents to make a similarly informed decision?

RunicWords · 25/11/2022 18:31

Yes @Maggiethecat seems to have decided my desire to protect the buying public from dodgy purchases is simply too blooming overwhelming to be ignored. It's true people... I simply cannot fight the feeling anymore. And yes, underneath it all I'm just ragin' with green-eyed jealousy.

But anyway ... no... just a simple query about 5star Amazon reviews and friends who ask for them that seems to have taken on a weird life of its own. 

OP posts:
WednesdaysChild11 · 25/11/2022 18:22

@Maggiethecat forgot to quote you in above.