Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surely heating can't cost this much?

164 replies

Dreamwhisper · 24/11/2022 17:59

My DM lives in a 3 bed detached bungalow. She's getting down because she's says her gas usage is coming to £600 per month, just gas?

I don't understand how this can be right. That's over £7,000 a month just for gas, and she is being very conservative with it. She has an old fashioned boiler (is it old fashioned? I don't know much but what I mean is, it's not a combi boiler it's the one that heats a tank of water for hot water). But it is a new boiler.

She won't get someone out to look at her meter in case it's wrong as she says they charge £50 if they come out and nothing's wrong. I want to pay this for her or go halves with my brother as I simply don't see how it can be right?

My bill has gone up a lot too but £600 a month for conservative heating seems an absolute unsustainable nightmare.

OP posts:
Purplechicken207 · 26/11/2022 18:44

Haven't seen it mentioned but there was a big thing about you must submit a meter reading right before the rates went sky high a couple months ago, otherwise they have to guess how much usage is charged at the newer higher rate (or just charge it all at higher rate). Doesn't help now, but point is regular meter readings submitted will avoid things like that

Purplechicken207 · 26/11/2022 18:41

caringcarer · 24/11/2022 18:06

Those emersion heaters where you have to heat a whole tank to draw hot water just eat up the gas. Why didn't she get a combi boiler?

An immersion is electric. Basically an enormous kettle element. And yep they cost a fortune to run. Gas boiler heating the hot water is cheaper

LicoricePizza · 26/11/2022 18:36

My mum had this - was on a fixed cheap tarif back when they existed.

The energy company went under & she was sent emails but no letters to say EDF were taking them over & crucially to give a meter reading.

As my DB had done the original fixed deal online he’d unknowingly agreed to her being contacted by email - (she however doesn’t use it) so she missed any correspondence for further requests for readings etc.

Unbeknown to her they’d put her on what they call a default tarif -this is the most expensive kind & what they do when they can’t make contact with the account holder.

Then as energy prices increased & she never got onto a cheaper tarif she was hit with similar amounts to what your mum has to pay back.

The monthly amount she owed didn’t reflect her usage but basically debt.

If your mum can agree you to be a named contact on her account & then find out if she’s been put on a default tarif & if so get her onto the cheapest one (I wouldn’t fix atm).

Submit meter readings & work out why the amounts are so high.

Unfortunately my mum has had to pay her debt back as we looked back & they had sent her emails clearly saying she’d been put on default tarif etc.

But that tarif is like double or triple what she should have been paying.

endlesslystandingonlego · 26/11/2022 18:11

This might sound crazy, but she is definitely reading the gas meter rather than the electricity meter isn't she? I came across someone at work who didn't know there was 2 meters, as the electricity meter had 2 numbers on, they thought one was the gas. Credit due to customer of several thousand pounds.

PortalooSunset · 26/11/2022 17:57

Any resolution yet @Dreamwhisper ?

Decades ago we had a gas bill that was ludicrously high. Turned out the bush in front of the meter cupboard outside had basically obscured the meter reader's view so he'd misread a 1 as a 4. Instead of going up maybe a few hundred or whatever units for the quarter it had gone up by over 30,000!! Obviously we didn't pay, they were happy for us to send a photo of the actual reading. And we removed the bush!

Any chance your mum's meter could have been misread?

LoveMyPiano · 25/11/2022 23:21

GasPanic · 25/11/2022 15:45

There is probably just a mix up in the units that she reads from the meter and the units she is billed in.

Someone else had this on another thread.

If her meter is in m3 and she is billed in ft3 (x100) then she will pay 3x the amount she actually should do in gas (about).

127 units in m3 will cost about £150.
127 units in ft3 (x100) will cost about £450.

Get her to take a photo of her meter and a photo of her bill and send them to you.

The meter will have the units written on it as will the bill so you can check.

127 units in m3 is not an outrageous amount to use in 1 month (1400 kWh per month or 45 kWh per day), although it is a bit on the high side. Still, a big old boiler would probably run through that in a few hours per day.

I don't think the difference in imperial and metric meters works like that, with a 3x charge. There is another step in the equation of units to kWh when the meter is in imperial units.

I maintain that the supplier is basing the calcuation for the future direct debit on over-estimated use, for some reason, be it a meter misreading or a catchup bill from before, or something else.

BorgQueen · 25/11/2022 21:11

The chances of a new boiler not being installed properly are close to zero. Modern boilers are on manufacturers default settings for one thing and with modern tech like digital flue gas analysers, which cost £1k+ and have to be recalibrated every year, mistakes are highly unlikely.

Gas engineers also have re-register with Gas safe every year, can be inspected on spec. AND they have to requalify for their licence every 5 years - it’s pretty much the most heavily regulated of ‘trades’.

Settings for heat and hot water could well be too high but for that amount of use, the only thing that makes sense is for the HW to be on constant.

Yet again for the hard of thinking - 127 metric units is not outrageous. I am currently using 3 units a day = £3.50, so 90 units/ £105 a month, in summer it’s below 1 unit/day.

GasPanic · 25/11/2022 15:45

There is probably just a mix up in the units that she reads from the meter and the units she is billed in.

Someone else had this on another thread.

If her meter is in m3 and she is billed in ft3 (x100) then she will pay 3x the amount she actually should do in gas (about).

127 units in m3 will cost about £150.
127 units in ft3 (x100) will cost about £450.

Get her to take a photo of her meter and a photo of her bill and send them to you.

The meter will have the units written on it as will the bill so you can check.

127 units in m3 is not an outrageous amount to use in 1 month (1400 kWh per month or 45 kWh per day), although it is a bit on the high side. Still, a big old boiler would probably run through that in a few hours per day.

mathanxiety · 25/11/2022 14:56

The new boiler might have been installed incorrectly. I think the DM needs a gas engineer to take a long look at the gas supply and settings.

Onnabugeisha · 24/11/2022 21:50

NameInUseAlreadyAgain · 24/11/2022 19:38

That’s just not right unless she’s left immersion switch on and hot water running all the time and topping tank up

we use 10 units a month in the summer for hot water …..

Yeah 127 units in less than a month is extremely high. I’d check the meter readings and I’d have a gas engineer go through and check everything.

user1484264563 · 24/11/2022 21:36

Agree with others this couldn't possibly be correct, readings and forward estimations etc are out of kilter. Way forward is a smart meter so you can monitor down to the current/hourly cost and she or you to sign up for the providers online access to the account so you see accurately the monthly DD, current spend etc. No need for her/you to be in the dark. Also might be worth getting a plumber out to check all ok, don't understand the logic of £600 pcm ok but £50 not ok?! Best wishes getting it sorted.

dementedpixie · 24/11/2022 20:56

OP says its a new boiler so shouldn't need anything doing to it. Need to look at the way it's being used e.g. how many hours is it on and at what temperature?, how long is the hot water on for and can the time be reduced?

BorgQueen · 24/11/2022 20:48

Definitely get the boiler serviced, if it has a magnetic filter, get it cleaned out, the amount of muck in there is incredible, it’s like sticky, sooty sludge. If no filter, you can have a chemical flush, basically stick cleaning additive in, leave for a few days, drain the system then refill and add inhibitor.
DH is, as of this week, a fully qualified Gas safe engineer.
A boiler service is normally £60-90, depending on area.
He’s just gone self employed and is fully booked next week already just from facebook for services and fitting Hive controllers etc. People are desperate to save money.

BorgQueen · 24/11/2022 20:38

Ignore my wrong calculations!
The gas price cap is 10.7p not 33p.

127 units = 1418kwh x 10.33p = £146.50 /23 days = £6.37 a day.

bellabasset · 24/11/2022 20:36

If you haven't done so set up an online account for your mother. That will allow you to access the information on there. Have a look at the bills to see if there have been regular meter readings or if there have been estimated bills. What you're looking for is the annual average usage

When the government quote the average bill its based on 12000kw gas and 2900kw electricity annually. That's £2,500 and it's 97% higher than the cap of £1,271 last winter. I'd guess that 65% of that cost would be November to April so £2,500 ×.65 =£1,625 ÷ 6 = £270. Your mum should get £66/67 a month plus the £500 pensioner household winter fuel allowance. That's £900 towards her energy costs.

It might pay you to get the boiler engineer out to set the water temperature on the boiler - it's 80° for water and 60° for the ch - also to reset the radiators so they're lower in the unused rooms.

Keep a weekly record of the readings and send them in monthly

LoveMyPiano · 24/11/2022 20:33

BorgQueen · 24/11/2022 20:26

It survived for 25 years without going bang 🤷

I meant that water coming out of the taps at that temperature. isn't that why there is a thermostat in the first place.

BorgQueen · 24/11/2022 20:26

It survived for 25 years without going bang 🤷

LoveMyPiano · 24/11/2022 20:18

BorgQueen · 24/11/2022 20:16

5.5 units a day is a bit high if she hardly has the heating on but it’s not ridiculous, especially if the HW tank has no thermostat, our old one didn’t so would get up to 80 odd degrees if on constant or even on for more than an hour at a time!

I'm sure that's dangerous as well as expensive.

LoveMyPiano · 24/11/2022 20:17

RosyDawn · 24/11/2022 20:10

True, that’s why I said “if you can wait” because if that’s possible it’s quite possible the company will adjust everything anyway - mine just did.

Bit obvs not everyone can wait so once readings have been taken it will be possible to get them to reverse charge (repay) and lower the DD before the next bill. Just prob a bit more hassle.

But no one should have to wait, whether they "can", or not.
It is inefficiency on the part of these companies - who have fully tarined employees and streamlined compuyer systems. Why should the work be done for them, or it be made so difficult? Needs an overhaul if you ask me (I know you didn't) and everything made clearer for the customer - and not with a nasty little counter sitting in the corner like a gremlin (aka a Smartmeter).
But hey, they only make billions in profit.....

BorgQueen · 24/11/2022 20:16

5.5 units a day is a bit high if she hardly has the heating on but it’s not ridiculous, especially if the HW tank has no thermostat, our old one didn’t so would get up to 80 odd degrees if on constant or even on for more than an hour at a time!

LoveMyPiano · 24/11/2022 20:12

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 24/11/2022 20:05

There isn't any point in all the speculating and worrying until you've got the account back on track with accurate readings

Set up an account on the EDF website or app and input the readings, you don't need to even understand anything more than how to read the numbers. They will automatically calculate the actual usage and once that's sorted make sure to give accurate readings

It sounds like because your mum doesn't understand it she isn't able to have a proper conversation on the phone, I wouldn't bother when you can do it all online.

Not "understanding anything other than how to read the numbers" is how these issues arise.

For example,

it takes someone with good eyesight to be able to actually read the flippin' bills for a start.

But this is a classic case of it not even being clear that a UNIT is very different from a kilowatt hour, when it comes to understanding the bills, vs what is seen on the meter display (for Gas that is, and complicated further by the fact that for Elec, a unit DOES = a kWh).

Understanding the nitty gritty was less important when we werre all paying about £40 a month and still ending the year in credit - but it is a very different matter nowadays, and understanding is important, and relatively simple in the end.

RosyDawn · 24/11/2022 20:10

LoveMyPiano · 24/11/2022 20:00

And meanwhile Mum is exepected to pay a ridiculous Direct Debit?

I don't think that would be for the best.

I think it will be quite easy to sort out when the correct figures are to hand.

True, that’s why I said “if you can wait” because if that’s possible it’s quite possible the company will adjust everything anyway - mine just did.

Bit obvs not everyone can wait so once readings have been taken it will be possible to get them to reverse charge (repay) and lower the DD before the next bill. Just prob a bit more hassle.

BorgQueen · 24/11/2022 20:09

127 units at £1.15 (price cap of 33p per kwh / 442 kwh) is £146. For 23 days that’s £6.34 per DAY.

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 24/11/2022 20:05

There isn't any point in all the speculating and worrying until you've got the account back on track with accurate readings

Set up an account on the EDF website or app and input the readings, you don't need to even understand anything more than how to read the numbers. They will automatically calculate the actual usage and once that's sorted make sure to give accurate readings

It sounds like because your mum doesn't understand it she isn't able to have a proper conversation on the phone, I wouldn't bother when you can do it all online.

Cliffordthebigreddog · 24/11/2022 20:04

Definitely can’t be right! We’re in a 5 bed detached barn conversion, we have the heating on for about 4 hours a day and the underfloor heating at a constant 20 degrees in the kitchen/diner and our gas bill this month is £353.78 with 2 days of the month to go. Get her to have it checked out.