Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surely heating can't cost this much?

164 replies

Dreamwhisper · 24/11/2022 17:59

My DM lives in a 3 bed detached bungalow. She's getting down because she's says her gas usage is coming to £600 per month, just gas?

I don't understand how this can be right. That's over £7,000 a month just for gas, and she is being very conservative with it. She has an old fashioned boiler (is it old fashioned? I don't know much but what I mean is, it's not a combi boiler it's the one that heats a tank of water for hot water). But it is a new boiler.

She won't get someone out to look at her meter in case it's wrong as she says they charge £50 if they come out and nothing's wrong. I want to pay this for her or go halves with my brother as I simply don't see how it can be right?

My bill has gone up a lot too but £600 a month for conservative heating seems an absolute unsustainable nightmare.

OP posts:
Dreamwhisper · 02/12/2022 09:52

EDF is bloody useless though, the account page won't let me view the graph for gas only electricity, and it just says no one is available to chat come back later.

OP posts:
Dreamwhisper · 02/12/2022 09:49

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 09:44

Again several people have suggested submit meter readings, also try and get meter readings from her for an hour when the heating is on

Bear in mind you would only have to have the heating on 10 hours a day to get to 600 quid a month.

She may have left the hot water on for 10 hours a day.

You wont get any more insight unless you go over there and examine the energy usage and submit readings to the Energy company.

I know, I've taken this on board and understand that. I have already clarified that my mum has been submitting meter readings but it's only recent.

All I've tried to explain in my update is that I'm concerned about the estimate as I don't get bills like this so the 73k figure was shocking. I've also just said that I'm worried that even if she's not overcharged, mum is paying loads a month and was thinking of increasing. Even if it turns out in Feb that it's loads in credit, she would still have spent the whole winter overpaying and being worried about putting the heating on. I'm just chatting/venting I don't know why people are starting to get aggy with me. If it annoys you just stop posting.

OP posts:
HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 09:44

Again several people have suggested submit meter readings, also try and get meter readings from her for an hour when the heating is on

Bear in mind you would only have to have the heating on 10 hours a day to get to 600 quid a month.

She may have left the hot water on for 10 hours a day.

You wont get any more insight unless you go over there and examine the energy usage and submit readings to the Energy company.

Dreamwhisper · 02/12/2022 09:40

The reason I've needed the password is because with EDF it's far easier and quicker to log in and use the live chat through there.

OP posts:
Dreamwhisper · 02/12/2022 09:38

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 01/12/2022 15:03

She's not going to be scammed out of anything. If the previous readings were estimates it will resolve itself when the actual ones are submitted

In the nicest possible way it's rather annoying reading all your reasons why this can't be resolved when many posters have told you have to resolve it really easily online or via the app

Why would you need a password for online chat? If you ring them up with the copy of the bill just say you are your mum, they won't know you aren't, download the app, reset forgotten passwords etc

If there's a rogue appliance you need to know asap

Oh can't you piss off! If I'm annoying then don't post? Literally how helpful do you think it is to tell me it's annoying when I've clearly said I have no idea what I'm doing with all this and just venting a bit too.

Energy companies are scamming some people with wild estimates, it's in the news, and I've never once said it can't be fixed, it's why I posted in the first place because I'm sure it's not right and can be fixed?

It's just hard when the person who's account it actually is keeps telling you it's right and not to do anything. I have no idea how these bills work and I've clearly said or agreed, it's either the bill that's wrong or there's something wrong with the house which is playing on my mind.

OP posts:
Notanotherusername4321 · 02/12/2022 09:24

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 01/12/2022 15:03

She's not going to be scammed out of anything. If the previous readings were estimates it will resolve itself when the actual ones are submitted

In the nicest possible way it's rather annoying reading all your reasons why this can't be resolved when many posters have told you have to resolve it really easily online or via the app

Why would you need a password for online chat? If you ring them up with the copy of the bill just say you are your mum, they won't know you aren't, download the app, reset forgotten passwords etc

If there's a rogue appliance you need to know asap

This.

she won’t be scammed. If the estimates are incorrect she will get a refund.

there have been 6 pages of advice to submit regular meter readings and that will show whether the estimates are accurate pretty quickly.

the only other thing I haven’t seen is if your mum doesn’t have smart meters get them fitted asap. Then you can see how much she’s using hour by hour, and what it causing the biggest load.

HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 05:22

If it's possible get her to read the meter. Put the heating/hot water on for an hour, then read the meter again. You'll be able to work out how much her heating should cost.

Topee · 02/12/2022 04:41

Read the meters and submit the readings.

LoveMyPiano · 01/12/2022 18:32

I am just watching an old Escape to the Chateau DIY - and it was calculated that to heat Chateua de la Londe (?) was costing about 900 Euros a month.

Just as a comparison.....

I think it is a bit bigger than a three-bedroomed bungalow.

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 01/12/2022 15:03

She's not going to be scammed out of anything. If the previous readings were estimates it will resolve itself when the actual ones are submitted

In the nicest possible way it's rather annoying reading all your reasons why this can't be resolved when many posters have told you have to resolve it really easily online or via the app

Why would you need a password for online chat? If you ring them up with the copy of the bill just say you are your mum, they won't know you aren't, download the app, reset forgotten passwords etc

If there's a rogue appliance you need to know asap

LoveMyPiano · 01/12/2022 13:43

I don't think they will/should ask for an online password to chat.... Maybe date of birth?
Even so, I would do a "forgot my password", if she uses email for that account, and (she) set a new one that you both know/remember. I find a useful way is to set the name of the company, so maybe EDF for example, and some memorable numbers.

Can you clarify for me ----
The 73K estimate is JUST for gas, or gas AND electricity (some do this, just to make matters more confusing)?
What is the kWh estimate for Electricity, if it is a separate figure?
Tariffs for both - I know you said about .10 for gas, what is it for elec?
What was she paying on her direct debit previously and did it cover the bils she got and finally, is there anywhere on her account any other annual usage estimate? They cannot call it usage if it is a catch-up.....

Dreamwhisper · 01/12/2022 11:38

LoveMyPiano · 30/11/2022 23:40

Hell's bells. Is the 73000 kWh for the gas prediction, not electricity?
Even I am getting muddled now.

Yes the electricity charge and the gas charge were billed separately, and yes the annual predicted usage was just over 73k! Mum has forwarded me the email wih the bill so I can speak to them on the online chat but she can't remember the password 🙄 so it will be next Sunday now when I get that and speak to them.

She just keeps saying she's not bother about the estimates now that she is giving meter readings, but she's not realising that the direct debit they wanted her to pay (£718 for gas and electric) and "negotiated" down to £460 was based on that ridiculous estimate. She can afford to pay the £460 but she thinks that's her actual usage so isn't putting the heating on enough.

My brother has told her to put the heating on and if in Feb it comes to it he will pay any lump sums.

But unless she or I actually look into these dodgy estimates and usage I fear she could be scammed out of money rather than it turning out she's in plenty of credit come February.

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 30/11/2022 23:48

AND I am wrong with how much more it would be from what it was (??) before..... it will be about 30% ish more, if usage was the same.
Duh. It's late.

For it to be "acceptable" and the maths to work, she would have to have been paying £400 per month before price changes.

LoveMyPiano · 30/11/2022 23:40

Hell's bells. Is the 73000 kWh for the gas prediction, not electricity?
Even I am getting muddled now.

LoveMyPiano · 30/11/2022 23:39

Dreamwhisper · 30/11/2022 08:08

Thanks again for the replies, I'm still looking into this. Mum showed me her meter readings that she'd taken herself and explained why she thinks it's right from last bill in summer, because her rate was 6.9p and has now gone up to the 10.3p.

However, her estimated annual usage was 73,000kw!! (Not exactly I can't remember the figure off the top of my head)

My mum keeps saying she's not bothered about that now she's giving readings. But the point is, she thinks it's right (the £460 per month) and thinks it's right based on her minimal usage. Which means she's paying through the nose for minimal usage. And since the next bill doesn't come in til February, she'll be in that state over the whole winter.

The only customer using 73000kWh of electricity per year would be someone with a "farm" in their loft (if you know what I mean....).
I really do wish the companies (sytsem) would flag up this kind of abnormality, rather than hope (or not) that it gets spotted by the customer. While they keep the moneu and then grumble baut giving it back.
The key word is ESTIMATED - i.e. predicted.... Funny how they never predict it will be lower/cost less.
The unit price will mean that the increase in charge will be about 70%, not "even" double.
The standing charge will be about £270 per year, for both. That is not the increase, but the new price.

LIZS · 30/11/2022 08:20

Can you report actual readings each month?

POTC · 30/11/2022 08:19

Dreamwhisper · 30/11/2022 08:11

They were charging her £200 a month over the summer. She didn't have the heating on at all

I would get the hot water tank checked. I don't have a combi boiler and I'd managed to knock the sensor that tells the tank when it has reached temperature. Without that it was constantly heating the water and we used £80 in a few weeks in the summer when I'd expected that to last me a few months! Once fixed it went back to me paying more in standing charges than I was actually using. I'm EDF. Don't forget to add the standing charge too, you pay that even if you use nothing.

Toastandavocado · 30/11/2022 08:16

Op can you download the app for whatever company your mum is with and submit her meter readings for her? My initial bill was a ridiculous amount (off of the company’s own estimate) as soon as I downloaded the app and submitted actual meter readings I went from over £1000 owed to them to £250 in credit. This allowed me to adjust my own direct debit on the app to less than half what they’d originally asked for. This also allows you to bypass being on the phone for hours too, if they’re not being very helpful. Good luck.

Dreamwhisper · 30/11/2022 08:11

They were charging her £200 a month over the summer. She didn't have the heating on at all

OP posts:
Dreamwhisper · 30/11/2022 08:08

Thanks again for the replies, I'm still looking into this. Mum showed me her meter readings that she'd taken herself and explained why she thinks it's right from last bill in summer, because her rate was 6.9p and has now gone up to the 10.3p.

However, her estimated annual usage was 73,000kw!! (Not exactly I can't remember the figure off the top of my head)

My mum keeps saying she's not bothered about that now she's giving readings. But the point is, she thinks it's right (the £460 per month) and thinks it's right based on her minimal usage. Which means she's paying through the nose for minimal usage. And since the next bill doesn't come in til February, she'll be in that state over the whole winter.

OP posts:
LoveMyPiano · 27/11/2022 13:01

LoveMyPiano · 24/11/2022 20:33

I meant that water coming out of the taps at that temperature. isn't that why there is a thermostat in the first place.

Just to quote myself, and having looked at the Boiler Manual (for another reason), I believe that the built in upper temperatures allowed are:
Water - 64 deg C
Heating - 80 deg C.

Older immersion heaters and tank set ups seemed to bypass this, and I once had water coming out of the taps at near boiling I swear!

dementedpixie · 26/11/2022 20:46

But I don't need it on all the time as 1 hour per day is sufficient. I dont want to pay more for no reason

Circe7 · 26/11/2022 20:42

It doesn't cost that much more to have water on all the time. We used to do this (with a new efficient boiler and well insulated tent) and it was marginally more expensive than having it on a few hours per day.

Notanotherusername4321 · 26/11/2022 20:37

dementedpixie · 26/11/2022 19:22

Just because there is a hot water cylinder doesn't mean its an immersion heater. I have a similar system to the OPs mother and it uses gas to heat the water. I heat my water for 1 hour per day and that's sufficient for our needs as our shower is electric and appliances are cold fill.

Yep I have a tank but it’s heated by the gas boiler, it’s not an immersion heater.

I also have mine on for an hour a day and that does 3 of us showers and some left for hand washing etc.

dementedpixie · 26/11/2022 19:22

caringcarer · 24/11/2022 18:06

Those emersion heaters where you have to heat a whole tank to draw hot water just eat up the gas. Why didn't she get a combi boiler?

Just because there is a hot water cylinder doesn't mean its an immersion heater. I have a similar system to the OPs mother and it uses gas to heat the water. I heat my water for 1 hour per day and that's sufficient for our needs as our shower is electric and appliances are cold fill.