Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Surely heating can't cost this much?

164 replies

Dreamwhisper · 24/11/2022 17:59

My DM lives in a 3 bed detached bungalow. She's getting down because she's says her gas usage is coming to £600 per month, just gas?

I don't understand how this can be right. That's over £7,000 a month just for gas, and she is being very conservative with it. She has an old fashioned boiler (is it old fashioned? I don't know much but what I mean is, it's not a combi boiler it's the one that heats a tank of water for hot water). But it is a new boiler.

She won't get someone out to look at her meter in case it's wrong as she says they charge £50 if they come out and nothing's wrong. I want to pay this for her or go halves with my brother as I simply don't see how it can be right?

My bill has gone up a lot too but £600 a month for conservative heating seems an absolute unsustainable nightmare.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NewBootsAndRanty · 02/12/2022 19:24

When I worked for an energy company 20 years ago it was standard for it to change, so it's nothing new. It's usually between 37.5 and 43.

www.nationalgrid.com/gas-transmission/data-and-operations/calorific-value-cv

mip-prd-web.azurewebsites.net/DataItemExplorer

^ have links to current and historic figures if this sort of data's your cup of tea.

LoveMyPiano · 02/12/2022 19:13

NewBootsAndRanty · 02/12/2022 19:08

The calorific value has always/will always fluctuate, and is sometimes different between regions too.

There's a link to regulations/how it's calculated on this page.

www.gov.uk/guidance/gas-meter-readings-and-bill-calculation

Mine has never changed, until recently.
(My spreadsheet says so - ha ha)

NewBootsAndRanty · 02/12/2022 19:08

The calorific value has always/will always fluctuate, and is sometimes different between regions too.

There's a link to regulations/how it's calculated on this page.

www.gov.uk/guidance/gas-meter-readings-and-bill-calculation

LoveMyPiano · 02/12/2022 19:01

Curlygirl06 · 02/12/2022 16:25

@LoveMyPiano do you mean the x by 39 changed to 39.2 in the calculation? I'm with EDF and they changed it on my last 6 months bill.

Having looked into it again, I think yes, that is the part of the calculation that has caused the difference. Ihave generally used the overall multiplication of 11.14 or thereabouts to work out how many units equal a kWh for charging purposes.

I noticed it on a bill of mine when there were a couple of occasions when part of the bill was for just ONE unit, which they then showed as 11.24 kWh, whoch was more than I thought.....

So..... (brings out magnifying glass)

British Gas seem to no longer show the steps of the calculation to convert, apart from the Calorific value, but I am not sure about others.
So, maybe something else HAS changed, but it is not a clear as it should be if it has (no surprise).

The steps to convert are -
No of units from meter readings (Newest minus previous, as you know)
x Calorific value (the 39.2, or 39.7 - this is what seems to be varying now)
x Volume Correction - which 1.02264
and
divide by kWh Conversion, which is 3.6

In the case of the ones of mine (with BG) that I have looked into, and there has been a change on each of the last three bills (March, June, Sept)

When the Calorific value is 39.2, one unit = 11.13 kWh
When the C/Vl is 39.6, one unit = 11.24 kWh
and
When the C/Val is 39.7, one unit = 11.27 kWh
So the difference between now, and before, is .14kWh

And again, as I said, multiply that by 8,000,000 (BG customers, let alone other suppliers and their customers). Quite a big number of extra kWh to be charged for, even with no extra use.

(Puts away magnifying glass.)

Curlygirl06 · 02/12/2022 16:25

@LoveMyPiano do you mean the x by 39 changed to 39.2 in the calculation? I'm with EDF and they changed it on my last 6 months bill.

DashboardConfessional · 02/12/2022 14:52

She needs to move supplier. I have a friend in a similar position with EDF. Meter mysteriously not pulling gas, refusal to review more than twice a year, DD £200 over what you'd expect for 2 adults in a semi-detached 3 bed.

stopringingme · 02/12/2022 14:00

@Dreamwhisper

I am with EDF (but only for electricity), if you have overpaid they give the money back to the account the DD comes from every time they do a review which is every 6 months, so the account goes back to zero.

They do not send bills in between.

Keep on giving the meter readings and I take a photo of the meter when I read it so there is date/time proof of when it is done.

You should be able to sign into her account by saying you have forgotten the password and they will send an email through (to your mum) and you can set up a new password you both know.

Good luck I find it all very confusing too.

NewBootsAndRanty · 02/12/2022 13:15

If the gas meter is a smart meter, try the loop app. My gas usage doesn't show on my suppliers app, but shows fine on loop - it will also upload readings from previous months

loop.homes/

Notanotherusername4321 · 02/12/2022 13:10

Very concerned that they have no figures available to view re the gas usage at all. They have a nice graph for electricity but the option for gas doesn't work for me and it says the meter may not be communicating

so she has an electric smart meter. So the electric should be correct.

you need to send in gas meter readings if that meter doesn’t have smart functionality.

it’s that simple. Read the meter, send in the readings, get a correct number.

LoveMyPiano · 02/12/2022 12:48

Just one quick question, do you have any meter readings at all? And dates?
The above lengthy post was just to set it out for you to see how it's done, in a clear way.
But if you have just those two things, I can easily do the calculations for you - and that gives you facs and figures to give to EDF if you ever can speak to them, and to maybe reassure your Mum.

uhhuhyeahok · 02/12/2022 12:48

OP this seems obvious but is your Mum reading the meter correctly? I know it sounds obvious but it might be worth double checking she hasn't got confused with the decimal point etc.

LoveMyPiano · 02/12/2022 12:44

Just again - if possible - here is the (hopefully) straightforward calculation you need to do, for (A) Usage - and (B) cost:
(I have a spreadsheet that will do it for you but that won't upload successfully)

Most recent reading
Minus
Last known reading
This gives (A)
If the reading dates are known,
the standing chang can be calculated as well.

For example
48625 - most recent
MINUS
48000 - last known prior
would equal usage of 625 UNITS
over the period of time*

The 625 UNITS converts to kWh by multiplying by roughly 11.2
so kWh used would be

625 x 11.2 = 7000 kWh (nice round figure) This is (A) - usage.

Multiply this by the price perkWh, say 10.9p

so 7000 x .109 = £763
which is (B) the cost of that usage.

Dividing both usage and cost by number of days would give average daily use, in kWh or £s.

Standing charge to be added* for number of days, and sometimes they don't include the VAT (5%) until bottom line fo their calculations (which I hate).
Electricity is simpler as there is no conversion, a Unit = a kWh.

Dreamwhisper · 02/12/2022 12:42

Thanks all for your latest replies.

I think this is a bit beyond me and I think I will contact CAB. I'll give it a few more goes getting through to them!

Very concerned that they have no figures available to view re the gas usage at all. They have a nice graph for electricity but the option for gas doesn't work for me and it says the meter may not be communicating.

OP posts:
Ginmonkeyagain · 02/12/2022 12:23

OP you ned to stop trying to resolve this yourself. Something is very wrong, there is no way your mum will be using that much gas.

There is a number in her energy bill for Citizens Advice helpline. Call that and emphasis this is acomplex problem and your mum is elderly.

They can refer you to a specialist unit of experts who will work with EDF on your mum's behalf to try and resolve this.

Ginmonkeyagain · 02/12/2022 12:22

OP you ned to stop trying to resolve this yourself. Something is very wrong, there is no way your mum will be using that much gas.

There is a number in her energy bill for Citizens Advice helpline. Call that and emphasis this is acomplex problem and your mum is elderly.

They can refer you to a specialist unit of experts who will work with EDF on your mum's behalf to try and resolve this.

dolorsit · 02/12/2022 11:42

I would be wary about getting a smart meter. It's been in the news recently about them switching people to prepayment as they no longer need a court order as they don't need to enter the house to replace the meter.

I don't have a smart meter as when the installer came out he said we would need to resite our meters. I refuse to pay for that. Also check if the smart meter reads both gas and electricity. For me it defeats the point of getting a smart meter if I still have the hassle of reading the one next to it.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 02/12/2022 11:01

EDF is bloody useless though

Completely. I have had a bad experience with them, as did my parents. I don't blame you at all for not trusting them. If your mum isn't in arrears, I'd switch suppliers.

LoveMyPiano · 02/12/2022 11:00

geraniumsandsunshine · 02/12/2022 10:39

Get a smart meter installed

I don;t think they are done immediately these days (hmm.....? I wonder why though) - and in the meantime, we can all be our own smart meters.

(I refused one many times, as I can think of nothing worse than the bloody thing sitting there haunting me, but I actually in my early years lived in a house where my g/ps had to put 10p coins in the meter, surprised we didn'tr get gassed, o blow up! From one extreme to the other.)

geraniumsandsunshine · 02/12/2022 10:39

Get a smart meter installed

LoveMyPiano · 02/12/2022 10:37

dolorsit · 02/12/2022 10:23

EDF tried to increase my direct debit to £400. They insisted that this was correct. They were giving me a projected usage in £ value.

However, they had previously sent me an email with projected usage in Kw. I sat down and calculated the cost of those units and the standard charge and it was about £1800 lower than the cash value they were projecting.

when I copied and pasted the usage from the email and asked how they had calculated the projected bill from these projected usage figures they immediately agreed to reduce the direct debit. (It was actually reduced to lower than I was currently paying)

I was really shocked. It was only because I had an email of the projected usage and the ability/time to do the sums myself that they admitted the direct debit was too high.

I seriously considered reporting them to the ombudsman.

I think they rely on people not being able to so the sums, and call them out on it - and I believe it has been going on fo a long time. I have helped people in the past who did not understand their bills and saved them from going to CAB , or having to call their supplier and go through the blasted menus of confusion.

It s , as you say, better to have the info to hand, and the chance to talk to a human being who should also understand, as it is their job.

One thing that I have noticed that is in the VERY small print is that te conversion of gas unis to kWh has changed slightly (I am with BG - don;t know if this is across the board). This in effect means that the units become MORE kWh, without there being any additional usage. It makes avery small difference to the individual customer - but when multiplied by 8,000,000 (BG customers) it is quite a big sum of extra money that goes to them! (I am looking into the reasons why the conversion figure might change,.....)

I have always said (even when prices were lower)- and pardon the pun -
KNOWLEDGE IS POWER!

Munchyseeds2 · 02/12/2022 10:36

EDF are a nightmare to understand!!
The website is useless
Last month they were saying we were £200 in credit
This month it's £1000 in credit
We just keep paying £180 a month and send in actual readings monthly
Hope you get things sorted so DM feels happy to put the heating on

LoveMyPiano · 02/12/2022 10:26

Oh no..... what's happening?

@Dreamwhisper You have probably reached the high water mark of general assistance and input, and how much you want to read it all, I guess.
But, as someone has said - and the maths of it has made me doubt my own ability to do basic sums - it would be scary easy to use that amount (again, depending on the heating set up and it's efficiency) and need to pay £600 a month.

But also, I do not think this is the case for your Mum, so do hope that, to stop the confusion and worry all round, meters can be genuinely read, the readings given to the supplier and it all resolved without her giving them money over the winter that she should not have to (if that's the case), and also that her fears about using he heating can be allayed.
I know that that is what I have been trying to do (but venting is always OK in my book), and probably most others who have posted xx

dolorsit · 02/12/2022 10:23

EDF tried to increase my direct debit to £400. They insisted that this was correct. They were giving me a projected usage in £ value.

However, they had previously sent me an email with projected usage in Kw. I sat down and calculated the cost of those units and the standard charge and it was about £1800 lower than the cash value they were projecting.

when I copied and pasted the usage from the email and asked how they had calculated the projected bill from these projected usage figures they immediately agreed to reduce the direct debit. (It was actually reduced to lower than I was currently paying)

I was really shocked. It was only because I had an email of the projected usage and the ability/time to do the sums myself that they admitted the direct debit was too high.

I seriously considered reporting them to the ombudsman.

Dreamwhisper · 02/12/2022 10:02

Seriously FUCK OFF

OP posts:
HotChoxs · 02/12/2022 10:00

Dreamwhisper · 02/12/2022 09:49

I know, I've taken this on board and understand that. I have already clarified that my mum has been submitting meter readings but it's only recent.

All I've tried to explain in my update is that I'm concerned about the estimate as I don't get bills like this so the 73k figure was shocking. I've also just said that I'm worried that even if she's not overcharged, mum is paying loads a month and was thinking of increasing. Even if it turns out in Feb that it's loads in credit, she would still have spent the whole winter overpaying and being worried about putting the heating on. I'm just chatting/venting I don't know why people are starting to get aggy with me. If it annoys you just stop posting.

Ah right, so giving really clear helplful advice is getting aggro is it?

And you just wanted a chat about it dressed up as please give me advice.

Go over there and sort it out and stop wasting peoples time here.

Swipe left for the next trending thread