Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shamima Begum's mother

583 replies

AddingUp · 24/11/2022 14:48

I read an article about Shamima Begum's mother in the Daily Mail. I am very much in the camp that Shamima Begum should come back to the UK and be trialed here as her crimes.

Anyway, the mother says how close she was with Shamima and how she misses her etc.

If I were Shamima Begum's mum and my daughter was not allowed into the UK, I would travel to the refugee camp to be with her. Or, I would take my daughter to Bangladesh just to be with her and not leave her on her own.

I don't understand why Shamima Begum's mum takes no action to support her daughter!

OP posts:
phishy · 24/11/2022 21:44

@JuvenileEmu what are you on about? How does any of that have anything to do with my post saying ‘She was an illegal immigrant to Syria, they are entitled to have her returned to the place of her birth. The UK is taking advantage of the lack of infrastructure in Syria for illegal immigrants.’?

JuvenileEmu · 24/11/2022 21:42

phishy · 24/11/2022 21:36

🙄

Your post was about Syria, how has it now become about me not wanting justice?

So you think this British woman's welfare is more important than some justice for the innocent yazidi women she chose to travel thousands of miles to join in their persecution? This is nothing like the victims in Rotherham, she's the equivalent of a British person reading about the concentration camps in WW2 and travelling to Nazi Germany to join the SS.

phishy · 24/11/2022 21:42

The UK does repatriate illegal immigrants back to their home countries. Especially if they have committed a crime.

Syria is in a civil war, they don’t have the means to do this right now.

Purplebunnie · 24/11/2022 21:37

phishy · 24/11/2022 21:29

She was an illegal immigrant to Syria, they are entitled to have her returned to the place of her birth. The UK is taking advantage of the lack of infrastructure in Syria for illegal immigrants.

I'm being a bit thick here.

If we have illegal immigrants in this country who have committed crimes, have been tried and found guilty and we imprison them here why can't Syria do the same

phishy · 24/11/2022 21:36

JuvenileEmu · 24/11/2022 21:35

I would like her victims to get some justice. I'm sorry you disagree and prioritize the feelings of SB.

🙄

Your post was about Syria, how has it now become about me not wanting justice?

PhillySub · 24/11/2022 21:36

Bringing her back here and putting her through the courts would cost the British tax payer hundreds of thousands. If found guilty she would be deprived of her freedom and sent to prison. It would also go some way for her to legitimize her claim to British citizenship all payed for again by the tax payer. She is deprived of her freedom where she is. Leave well alone.

JuvenileEmu · 24/11/2022 21:35

phishy · 24/11/2022 21:29

She was an illegal immigrant to Syria, they are entitled to have her returned to the place of her birth. The UK is taking advantage of the lack of infrastructure in Syria for illegal immigrants.

I would like her victims to get some justice. I'm sorry you disagree and prioritize the feelings of SB.

Zone2NorthLondon · 24/11/2022 21:34

Professionally, I know that children live in loving secure homes and they self harm,have suicidal ideation,suicidal intent, get radicalised and don’t tell anyone. Esp not their loving families. Unfortunately it becomes known when there is a near miss or catastrophic event.

Precipice · 24/11/2022 21:31

Whoopy · 24/11/2022 20:57

This would be the best outcome, punished under the Laws of the Country she decided to go to.

But Syria (well, the semi-autonomous Kurdish authorities which govern where she is) doesn't want to. They do repatriate those ISIS-related internees whom they can move elsewhere. A lot of articles on repatriations of ISIS members stress that the Kurds have been calling on governments to take their citizens back and deal with them at home.

AnnieSnap · 24/11/2022 21:31

oakleaffy · 24/11/2022 16:03

If Begum’s mother was initially supportive, she would have protected her daughter from the get go.
This “Radicalisation “ is unlikely to have happened in a secure and loving family.

That is naive at best. 15-year-olds usually have very easy access to online websites that their parents know nothing about. Recently, there was the outcome of an inquest on the death by suicide of young girl from a very good, loving family, who was being encouraged to commit suicide in groups on Instagram. Plenty of kids engage in various forms of self harm, including anorexia and cutting, in groups on social media, kids are sexually groomed and bullied to the point of suicide on social media. You carry on deluding yourself that you would always know if your kid was at risk, but it won’t make it true.

phishy · 24/11/2022 21:29

JuvenileEmu · 24/11/2022 21:27

Because she committed her crimes in Syria. I would be happy for the UK to pay for her trial and imprisonment in Syria.

She was an illegal immigrant to Syria, they are entitled to have her returned to the place of her birth. The UK is taking advantage of the lack of infrastructure in Syria for illegal immigrants.

JuvenileEmu · 24/11/2022 21:27

MarmaladeFatkins · 24/11/2022 20:06

because she is a British citizen

why do you think Syria should have to deal with her/pay for her?

Because she committed her crimes in Syria. I would be happy for the UK to pay for her trial and imprisonment in Syria.

Againstmachine · 24/11/2022 21:26

It’s a difficult one, on one hand she knew about the beheadings and the slavery before she went, I don’t think you can compare this to the Rotherhams girls, they never signed up to anything, they just thought they had a nice new boyfriend 🙁. I think it’s pretty vile to make the comparison tbh.

I haven't read a the thread has been 159 posts since my last.

But what vile animal is comparing with exploited Rotherham girls.

This a vile person who went to join Isis a completely different matter.

I'm from Rotherham so misuse them at your peril.

ChesterDrawz · 24/11/2022 21:16

JudgeJ · 24/11/2022 20:51

Why should anyone care about her circumstances, she didn't care about the people who were murdered by her terrorist friends.

I agree with this.

And given she's not a British citizen, I hope the funding for these various legal appeals is coming from elsewhere.

Rinatinabina · 24/11/2022 21:10

It’s a difficult one, on one hand she knew about the beheadings and the slavery before she went, I don’t think you can compare this to the Rotherhams girls, they never signed up to anything, they just thought they had a nice new boyfriend 🙁. I think it’s pretty vile to make the comparison tbh.

But she was 15. Her mum can’t realistically meet her in Bangladesh as she is likely to be denied citizenship. Feel quite conflicted about this, I genuinely think she knew what she was signing up for, she is by all accounts very intelligent but I also think her 15 year old brain could fully comprehend the horror of that or what that would actually entail for her personally. 15 years olds are often black and white thinkers and idealists (I know this whole death cult is far from ideal).

But yes if it was my child I would want them with me, I look at her and see a terrorist facilitator her mum looks at her and sees a baby, a toddler, a pre schooler, a tween a teenager. I’m not saying the UK government should help her with that but I understand as a mum.

a1poshpaws · 24/11/2022 21:07

PestorPeston · 24/11/2022 20:11

Are you Mandy Smith's mother?

Do you think all sex with 15 y/o s is concentual?

Umm - where do you see me mention sex? Or do you simply have such an obsession with it that it colours everything you see and do?

consensual has an s not your c.

BorderlineBagpuss · 24/11/2022 21:01

a fallacious comparison surely - if you cared that much about your daughter it is unlikely in the extreme that your daughter would end up there. I’m afraid I rather suspect that life isn’t as valued amongst some people, inc this family.

MichelleScarn · 24/11/2022 20:59

*Why would they go to Bangladesh? The govt have said they would execute Shamima.

It’s best Shamima comes here, is tried as a 15yo would have been and to serve her time and be rehabilitated.*

Do you think she can be rehabilitated? I agree with other posters who say the risk of her being a sleeper cell is too high.

Whoopy · 24/11/2022 20:57

DollyDoofer · 24/11/2022 20:41

why do you think Syria should have to deal with her/pay for her

Surely Syria have a duty towards their citizens. The citizens that SB and her friends murdered. Syria have a duty to bring SB to justice, on behalf of the families they murdered!

Her crimes didn’t happen in the Uk so UK taxpayers shouldn’t have to stump up costs for her. Why should we?

Syrian citizens should be able to try her and then rejoice in her sentence - on behalf of the unfortunate, innocent people (and their families) she helped to murder!

This would be the best outcome, punished under the Laws of the Country she decided to go to.

phishy · 24/11/2022 20:52

JudgeJ · 24/11/2022 20:51

Why should anyone care about her circumstances, she didn't care about the people who were murdered by her terrorist friends.

Because that’s the whole point of the thread 🙄

phishy · 24/11/2022 20:51

AddingUp · 24/11/2022 14:48

I read an article about Shamima Begum's mother in the Daily Mail. I am very much in the camp that Shamima Begum should come back to the UK and be trialed here as her crimes.

Anyway, the mother says how close she was with Shamima and how she misses her etc.

If I were Shamima Begum's mum and my daughter was not allowed into the UK, I would travel to the refugee camp to be with her. Or, I would take my daughter to Bangladesh just to be with her and not leave her on her own.

I don't understand why Shamima Begum's mum takes no action to support her daughter!

Why would they go to Bangladesh? The govt have said they would execute Shamima.

It’s best Shamima comes here, is tried as a 15yo would have been and to serve her time and be rehabilitated.

JudgeJ · 24/11/2022 20:51

AnnieSnap · 24/11/2022 20:49

@AddingUp Apparently, Shamima could face execution in Bangladesh and we don’t know the mother’s circumstances. Would be be permitted to live in the refugee camp? Does she have younger children or elderly relatives to care for? What is her own health like. It’s easy to jump to judgment.

Why should anyone care about her circumstances, she didn't care about the people who were murdered by her terrorist friends.

fallfallfall · 24/11/2022 20:50

legally the uk will most likely have to backtrack as bangladesh laws suggest she will hang for her involvement (which means she can't be deported to her death). as she married a dutch fellow maybe she is entitled to dutch nationality?
politically however no one wants her.
like a virus i suspect she is still able to do much harm. for example brainwashing further children she may bare.
sexual crimes and crimes against humanity are two different kettles of fish.
as for her parents i assume they are complicit.
where should she go? down in the books as a lesson for all children as to what NOT to do in life and how cruel and difficult it can be on the wrong side of history.

JudgeJ · 24/11/2022 20:49

FiscalDragQueen · 24/11/2022 19:31

I see SB’s father had a lot to say on the subject. Interesting he lives in Bangladesh. Maybe if he had been present in her childhood, she wouldn’t have been such easy pickings for ISIS. He should blame himself rather than the British government.

I think she should be let back here, but put on trial when she gets here.

But we'll be stuck paying for her forever. She chose her path, let her stay there.

AnnieSnap · 24/11/2022 20:49

@AddingUp Apparently, Shamima could face execution in Bangladesh and we don’t know the mother’s circumstances. Would be be permitted to live in the refugee camp? Does she have younger children or elderly relatives to care for? What is her own health like. It’s easy to jump to judgment.