Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shamima Begum's mother

583 replies

AddingUp · 24/11/2022 14:48

I read an article about Shamima Begum's mother in the Daily Mail. I am very much in the camp that Shamima Begum should come back to the UK and be trialed here as her crimes.

Anyway, the mother says how close she was with Shamima and how she misses her etc.

If I were Shamima Begum's mum and my daughter was not allowed into the UK, I would travel to the refugee camp to be with her. Or, I would take my daughter to Bangladesh just to be with her and not leave her on her own.

I don't understand why Shamima Begum's mum takes no action to support her daughter!

OP posts:
Treeeeeeee · 24/11/2022 18:32

She is an adult now but even so she was 15 when she left. 15 year olds know right from wrong (especially to this extreme). She wasn't 5, she knew what she was doing

Blossomtoes · 24/11/2022 18:32

She wasn’t smuggled out of the country by anyone. She left Heathrow with two friends on her sister’s passport. Zero smuggling.

MrsThimbles · 24/11/2022 18:32

Croque · 24/11/2022 18:25

Culturally, I think that a mother would not stage such an intervention for a married daughter.
However, I can see why the mother may wish to support her given that she is technically a young widow who has buried several of her infant children. I wonder what became of the other girls with whom she travelled?

They’re dead.

lotuspie · 24/11/2022 18:31

Yazidi women and children were raped murdered and starved. This was all driven by the bigoted racist xenophobic agenda of Isis and their hatred.do I want what she stands for in my country. My sympathy lies with the yazidis , and other minorities butcherd by isis. why does anyone think it was just the internet. It was more than likely supported by family members as well.

MrsThimbles · 24/11/2022 18:30

Blossomtoes · 24/11/2022 18:26

I don’t think there was any grooming. It’s an excuse I’m not prepared to afford her.

I understand. I actually felt quite hesitant when typing it. But if you go in to her background it does give food for thought on why she may have been ‘persuadable’. Not that it would have taken much though. I’ve very conflicted about Shamima Begum.

Cw112 · 24/11/2022 18:30

Blossomtoes · 24/11/2022 18:26

I don’t think there was any grooming. It’s an excuse I’m not prepared to afford her.

You don't think there was any grooming? What do you call it when a 15 year old girl is smuggled out of the country by a much older man she met online?

Because that is the definition of grooming.

It was well documented at the time that this was a growing concern for young people in the UK. Social workers, youth workers, community workers were all made aware that this was happening.

Wankytramphands · 24/11/2022 18:29

She is a terrorist simple as that not trafficked groomed or whatever she went of her own free will anyone who sympathises and thinks she is anything more than that has been fooled.

PassMeTheValve · 24/11/2022 18:28

Puzzledandpissedoff · 24/11/2022 18:17

There is zero doubt that what she saw going on over there will have traumatised her. I have zero doubt she will be suffering from PTSD

And there is it, right on cue and exactly as predicted ... the advance excuses as to why Shamima couln't possibly stand trial, even if we were foolish enough to allow her to return

What about her victims PTSD?

Rowthe · 24/11/2022 18:28

RosieRooster83 · 24/11/2022 16:01

@MichelleScarn Exactly. I have a daughter the same age and there's no way she would think going to a Middle Eastern country to meet a man she didn't know to marry would be a good idea. There must have been something within her that wanted to get involved in that way of life. You don't accidentally get on a plane and travel halfway across the world on a whim.

Ive read plenty of news reports of young white girls being groomed by men and being taken abroad.

Usually the cops get involved and bring them back to be with their families.

Cw112 · 24/11/2022 18:27

"Firstly she never expressed remorse or regret never mentioned being trafficked etc UNTIL she got some lawyers who advised her the best option was to go back to being as English as possible and say you were a victim of human trafficking. "

You do realise the majority of trafficking victims don't realise they've been trafficked and the extent of what's happened to them until its broken down with them? It's like being in an abusive relationship- you don't know you're in one until someone holds a mirror up to the things in your relationship that are unsafe and the fog lifts. So as someone who's worked extensively with trafficking victims that's not a reason to not believe someone.

Rowthe · 24/11/2022 18:26

ScrappyCats · 24/11/2022 16:01

If she was a blue eyed blonde from a middle class family, with educated parents who knew how to deal with the press - the whole situation would have been viewed differently from day one. She would have been seen as a victim who needed to be rescued.

True.

Also not sure why people think she has Bangladeshi citizenship. She doesn't. Apparently shes never even been there.

Again just because of her colour.

Blossomtoes · 24/11/2022 18:26

I don’t think there was any grooming. It’s an excuse I’m not prepared to afford her.

Croque · 24/11/2022 18:25

Culturally, I think that a mother would not stage such an intervention for a married daughter.
However, I can see why the mother may wish to support her given that she is technically a young widow who has buried several of her infant children. I wonder what became of the other girls with whom she travelled?

MrsThimbles · 24/11/2022 18:24

think in this instance the radicalisation was absolutely a part of the grooming though? I think they're two halves of the same coin

I think the radicalization was well underway due to her environment and the grooming followed on from that.

Cw112 · 24/11/2022 18:21

Blossomtoes · 24/11/2022 18:05

The grooming took place in the UK

Via the Internet apparently from Syria. She wasn’t groomed, she was radicalised. The romanticism on this thread is shocking.

I think in this instance the radicalisation was absolutely a part of the grooming though? I think they're two halves of the same coin. We know that grown adult women who have been groomed and subjected to extreme situations and extensive trauma can end up becoming complicit in abuse themselves in order to survive. They are still recognised as victims though. They still need extensive support and therapy and rehabilitation as a result. And this was a 15 year old child. I don't honestly believe that any of those 15 year old girls could fully have known what they were walking into when they were trafficked out of the country and doubtless the grooming they experienced was giving them a very false romanticised version of that reality. There should have been more done to protect those girls from online exploitation and grooming in the first instance before it got so far that they were trafficked. So I think UK should allow her to come home and take responsibility for that failing because they did not safeguard her effectively in the first place when it was known at the time that such grooming and exploitation was happening to young people online. I don't see why her mum should leave, if it were me I'd be doing everything I could to get her home where i felt she'd be safer. To me it's really similar to child soldiers who are groomed and recruited and then brutalised and brainwashed into killing people. We see them as victims, we recognise their need for support and rehabilitation. This girl hasn't killed anyone we are aware of so I think it's an unfair double standard that she's seen as a "murderous terrorist" instead of a victim of a terrorist regime. I also think it really calls up the question of "what is a victim supposed to look like". She is extensively traumatised and traumatised people don't always present as we expect victims to. Eg no crying or shaking or remorse, but instead a complete shut down and coldness. It's the same problematic approach that affects rape trials and dv trials where the victim just doesn't look victimy enough for the jury to believe them.

Bluekerfuffle · 24/11/2022 18:20

MzHz · 24/11/2022 17:51

Yabu for reading the mail. It’s utter shite and responsible for a lot of division and misinformation

There is nothing divisive and no misinformation in the article. It’s just quoting her mother and sister and is about how much they miss her. People on this site are quite ridiculous about the daily mail, it’s not that bad.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 24/11/2022 18:17

There is zero doubt that what she saw going on over there will have traumatised her. I have zero doubt she will be suffering from PTSD

And there is it, right on cue and exactly as predicted ... the advance excuses as to why Shamima couln't possibly stand trial, even if we were foolish enough to allow her to return

PassMeTheValve · 24/11/2022 18:16

Shamima Begum is an abuser of women and children.

Remind me why she needs support and sympathy? She is a brainwashed terrorist and mercilessly abused children and women. She can repent where she is.

MrsThimbles · 24/11/2022 18:16

Let's not forget her father was captured on film at one of the delightful Anjhem Choudrys hate rallies, along side one of Lee rigbys murderers
Wasn't that Hussen Abase, Amira Abase's dad

Shamima’s father didn’t live full time in the UK for very long. He left the family and went back to Bangladesh to live where he married a second wife and only returned to the UK occasionally for a few months at a time thereafter.

The family really were on their own in many respects.

Wankytramphands · 24/11/2022 18:15

Firstly she never expressed remorse or regret never mentioned being trafficked etc UNTIL she got some lawyers who advised her the best option was to go back to being as English as possible and say you were a victim of human trafficking. Unfortunately she can cry all she wants about how she was a poor innocent but fact remains she was part of it all wanted to be and the onmly reason she isn't is because it was too dangerous and her husband died she has not many options left. I don't believe her but the more she goes on about her being a 15 year old child tricked into it all the more she wears western clothes and sploshes her image all over the place the more people will believe her. As for her mum I k n ow nothing about her but if she helps her she would probably be supporting terrorism and get arrested don't think you are allowed to send money etc but on the other hand it might be because she cannot get over what she has done or she wants to appear thst way. I think just leave her there she made her bed noone else did no matter how much she cried that they did.

Newlifestartingatlast · 24/11/2022 18:09

Usernamesarboring · 24/11/2022 18:08

15 is not 5, she has some personal responsibility in being open to be groomed for a role killing people.

And if you hear her latest interview, she doesn't give direct answer. Interviewer asked her if she was trafficked and she talked in 3rd person and said that would be definition of trafficking. She also justified Manchester bombing.

Yep, which is why she must be tried, and punished under uk law as she is a uk citizen.

Usernamesarboring · 24/11/2022 18:08

Newlifestartingatlast · 24/11/2022 18:00

She was 15. Groomed. Radicalised through that grooming with adult men and adult women
she was not an adult. She was not a 19, 20 , 30 year old man who went specifically to kill people

There are men who went to specifically fight, and did fight, that have come back here to serve their sentences. Including other women who became ISIS brides, having gone when they were adults (Shakil was imprisoned in uk for 6 years for instance and is now freed ).

Yes, Begum has held onto her (a lot) of beliefs once older during being interviewed. By then she been subject to ISIS propaganda, threats, fear, grooming etc. for some years. She went through the trauma of giving birth to and loosing 4 children in 5 years. She’s seen some traumatic things which she said didn’t impact her- all the signs of someone who has been taught to normalise extreme violence through exposure - like child soldiers. she would not have access to a balanced view of ISIS or any outsider perspective. Fgs, she couldn’t even show her face in that regime. I’m not saying her views are ok- but it’s not like she was sitting in uk, watching balanced news and coming to same conclusion.

she has been singled out and vilified because she is female and it makes good news stories. Bad women are always pilloried worse than an even worse man. They’re held to standards men are not. The British government has then used her as a pawn in showing how tough they are on terrorist. Name, off the top of your head, one other British citizen who’s been stripped of their citizenship and is stateless? Nope? There are 23 form that ISIS era, but it seems it is only her that gets the attention because papers like the daily mail make her to be the personification of that evil regime - rather than the vulnerable and susceptible school girl she was, who made mistakes. Yes, she needs to be held accountable and punished : but the uk government refuse to do that even though she is a British citizen.

If she had been groomed for marriage to an extremist, and stayed in this country and not gone abroad, and been “married off at 15” - we’d be prosecuting the groomer for crimes including rape (she was under 16) , even if she was stupid, naive and walked happily away with her abuser.

the government has acted potentially illegally in removing her citizenship. It was a landMark ruling - she was the first one. Legally you can only do that if a person has for citizenship in another country. Even then there are additional stipulations. The only country theoretically she may have citizenship for is Bangladesh- her parents were born there. She has never lived there. She does not hold citizenship there right now and would have to apply. This whole ruling has created much fear in immigrant populations, it opens up a 2 tier citizen right question- even if you were born in uk and have no other citizenship, if your parents once held citizenship in another country, the government can rip away your passport and rights and treat you like a foreign national. And she faces the death penalty if she does go to Bangladesh and is tried there. Hardly a choice. She remains stateless indefinitely, in a refuge camp with the uk government determined to use her to make a point. They have no intention of actually, putting her on trial and letting justice decide her punishment. She is trying to fight that decision- as is her right . The USA incidentally repatriated all its “ISIS “ citizen and put them on trial.

but I’m guessing you thought detaining people indefinitely in appalling conditions, without trial , in Guantanamo Bay was a excellent idea too,

15 is not 5, she has some personal responsibility in being open to be groomed for a role killing people.

And if you hear her latest interview, she doesn't give direct answer. Interviewer asked her if she was trafficked and she talked in 3rd person and said that would be definition of trafficking. She also justified Manchester bombing.

StressedToTheMaxxx · 24/11/2022 18:06

Mummyoflittledragon · 24/11/2022 15:25

My dd is almost the same age as Shamima when she and her friends left. I am sure her mum desperately wants to see her. I couldn’t imagine my dd leaving in this way and not seeing her for so long. It wouldn’t be safe for a her mum to travel there.

I don’t get it. Virginia Guiffre, who was 17, and many other teens as old or older than 15 are seen as exploited and trafficked, even the ones, who find other girls for their abusers. Yet a 15 yo school girl, who was groomed online has her citizenship removed. I do struggle to see the difference between her and the girls abused in the Rochdale scandal.

Isn't the difference that the groomed girls didn't willingly be a part of a regime that kills men, women and children? I'd count the former as victims, I'd count the latter as a murderous terrorist.

Blossomtoes · 24/11/2022 18:05

The grooming took place in the UK

Via the Internet apparently from Syria. She wasn’t groomed, she was radicalised. The romanticism on this thread is shocking.