Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shamima Begum's mother

583 replies

AddingUp · 24/11/2022 14:48

I read an article about Shamima Begum's mother in the Daily Mail. I am very much in the camp that Shamima Begum should come back to the UK and be trialed here as her crimes.

Anyway, the mother says how close she was with Shamima and how she misses her etc.

If I were Shamima Begum's mum and my daughter was not allowed into the UK, I would travel to the refugee camp to be with her. Or, I would take my daughter to Bangladesh just to be with her and not leave her on her own.

I don't understand why Shamima Begum's mum takes no action to support her daughter!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Daisybuttercup12345 · 01/03/2023 08:20

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 24/11/2022 14:54

If I was her mum I’d go NC actually.

This.

bellabasset · 28/02/2023 20:53

@sunglassesonthetable Try reading the Wikipedia entry on Shamina Begum

2bazookas · 27/02/2023 18:38

AddingUp · 24/11/2022 14:48

I read an article about Shamima Begum's mother in the Daily Mail. I am very much in the camp that Shamima Begum should come back to the UK and be trialed here as her crimes.

Anyway, the mother says how close she was with Shamima and how she misses her etc.

If I were Shamima Begum's mum and my daughter was not allowed into the UK, I would travel to the refugee camp to be with her. Or, I would take my daughter to Bangladesh just to be with her and not leave her on her own.

I don't understand why Shamima Begum's mum takes no action to support her daughter!

You sound really clueless. Shamima is held in a SECURE camp by Syrian Defence Forces. Secured to prevent infiltration by extremist groups like ISIL and Daesh

Her mother can no more "go to live there with her", than she could decide to move in and live in a high-security prison here

She can't take Shamima anywhere at all because Shamima has no passport.

splatfrog · 27/02/2023 16:09

I believe if she came back here she'd have a target on her back. She'd have to take on a new identity.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/02/2023 14:57

She was refused Bangladeshi citizenship, so the UK Government’s decision did leave her stateless

Not quite; looking at the timescale, the government served notice of the removal of Shamima's citizenship in February 2019 and Bangladesh didn't say they wouldn't have her until June 2020

I'm not a lawyer, far less an immigration expert, but because the UK effectively "got in first" with refusing her, I expect it may have been argued that we hadn't made her staeless because at that point she could - at least in theory - have applied to Bangladesh

And yes, I realise she doesn't want to go to Bangladesh because they'd probably execute her, but what she wants and what she's legally entitled to are two different things

MichelleScarn · 27/02/2023 11:53

BankOfDave · 27/02/2023 10:48

Some people are under the impression that anyone questioning is a sympathiser - not true for me. Most people commenting have probably read media headlines/version and that’s it. Because this is the ONE story where everything portrayed by the media is entirely true. 🤔

I don't think anyone questioning is a sympathiser, I think sympathisers are those who are saying 'oh the poor girl, she's only young, it's not her fault she watched all these torture and beheading videos and decided to travel to a war zone and do these for herself, she can't have known what it would be like, bring her back'.

AnnieSnap · 27/02/2023 11:45

FishBowlSwimmer · 27/02/2023 09:39

Shamima is currently detained in a "refugee" camp, awaiting trial for crimes she committed in Syria. The trial has been delayed while she fights for the right to be tried in the UK.

It is perfectly legal to strip her of her UK citizenship, she is not left stateless, Bangladesh cannot refuse her citizenship because that WOULD leave her stateless. She doesn't want to go to Bangladesh because they have the death sentence for the crime's she is accused of.

So her only options are, Syrian trial, Bangladesh trial or UK trial.

Her life literally depends on the UK claiming her and trying her under UK law.

According to our (UK) government there is overwhelming evidence against her.

I'm not sure she really was radicalised, she certainly wasn't trafficked, she herself admits she was inspired to join ISIS by watching videos of beheadings online. What sort of person watches a beheading and thinks, "that's what I want to do with my life"?

She was refused Bangladeshi citizenship, so the UK Government’s decision did leave her stateless!

Also, your finally paragraph is the very definition of grooming. She certainly was trafficked. Yes, she was keen to go, having been groomed, but it was adult men (including one who was working for the Canadian Government at the time) who all of the expenses, gave her the instructions for the journey and met her to transport her at various points.

red78hot · 27/02/2023 11:13

I'd wipe my hands of her tbh

YellowDaffodillie · 27/02/2023 11:11

Rowthe · 24/11/2022 15:29

Regardless of what shes done, she needs to be brought back to face justice here.

She hasn’t committed any crimes in the U.K. so what trumped up charges would you like to see brought against her? 🤔

BankOfDave · 27/02/2023 10:48

Some people are under the impression that anyone questioning is a sympathiser - not true for me. Most people commenting have probably read media headlines/version and that’s it. Because this is the ONE story where everything portrayed by the media is entirely true. 🤔

MichelleScarn · 27/02/2023 10:34

I'm not sure she really was radicalised, she certainly wasn't trafficked, she herself admits she was inspired to join ISIS by watching videos of beheadings online. What sort of person watches a beheading and thinks, "that's what I want to do with my life"
Agree with this, and then goes on to take part and encourage the rape and torture of other people, watch beheadings and people being burned to death, and only when her fellow Isis terrorists are losing, apparently 'see the light' but still say things like Manchester bombing was OK.
Do her sympathisers believe that if Isis still had that stronghold she wouldn't still be there enjoying the power and torture of others?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 27/02/2023 09:47

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 23/02/2023 02:07

If you are eligible to apply it’s likely that you actually have the citizenship already (we’re born with it) and the application you refer to is just an application for a passport/ to register it. Look at the Australian politicians dual citizenship issue.

Could someone please tell the Italian consulate that re citizenship by descent?

FishBowlSwimmer · 27/02/2023 09:39

Shamima is currently detained in a "refugee" camp, awaiting trial for crimes she committed in Syria. The trial has been delayed while she fights for the right to be tried in the UK.

It is perfectly legal to strip her of her UK citizenship, she is not left stateless, Bangladesh cannot refuse her citizenship because that WOULD leave her stateless. She doesn't want to go to Bangladesh because they have the death sentence for the crime's she is accused of.

So her only options are, Syrian trial, Bangladesh trial or UK trial.

Her life literally depends on the UK claiming her and trying her under UK law.

According to our (UK) government there is overwhelming evidence against her.

I'm not sure she really was radicalised, she certainly wasn't trafficked, she herself admits she was inspired to join ISIS by watching videos of beheadings online. What sort of person watches a beheading and thinks, "that's what I want to do with my life"?

sunglassesonthetable · 27/02/2023 08:29

@bellabasset

Wilkiepedia says SB's mother died of cancer in 2014. Her father then remarried. She left soon after.

bellabasset · 27/02/2023 08:19

@BankOfDave ? Shamima Begum's mother isn't dead. The thread is about her mother not going to Syria

BankOfDave · 26/02/2023 22:45

I don’t know what the answer is but I firmly believe it’s not as clear cut as some people on the thread make out and think the media have hugely influenced public opinion.

I understood her biological mother died in the Jan. By the Sept her father had remarried (a man she didn’t live with until she was 8) and by the Dec she had followed her friend to Syria age 15. At no point did her school or police seemingly try to engage on the dangers of radicalisation knowing what a school friend had done. Many people describe life in Bethnal Green within a conservative family as feeling not fully part of society. She repeatedly talks about not feeling loved in her childhood. I’m no psychologist but that all seems rather meaningful to unpick as a set of of motives/triggers/potential to be exploited.

I believe the judgement in the most recent case is not as clear cut, basically saying having seen the evidence they were somewhat sympathetic to the case for grooming but that their ruling is the Home Secretary ultimately has final say.

Those camps are not fully secure, the original friend has already escaped. They are the worst possible solution in my view.

ancientgran · 26/02/2023 22:19

Xenia · 25/02/2023 21:35

But they don't - they don't get you out, they don't pay for lawyers, they don't help you - they might contact you but not much, and they certainly don't spend £5m on your legal costs as we have done for this ISIS terrorist.

You said, Also if I broke the law and was jailed in say Brazil for drug smuggling the British Gov would do nothing to help me but they would, they would visit you, help you get a lawyer, contact your family for you and maybe get you transferred to a British prison. So no they aren't going to hand you £5m but they wouldn't take your nationality and leave you stranded and stateless.

Xenia · 25/02/2023 21:35

But they don't - they don't get you out, they don't pay for lawyers, they don't help you - they might contact you but not much, and they certainly don't spend £5m on your legal costs as we have done for this ISIS terrorist.

Untitledsquatboulder · 25/02/2023 20:56

Ponoka7 · 23/02/2023 00:55

I'd like to know what we didn't know about the 400 male Isis fighters, who joined Isis as adults and took part in warfare. As opposed to the 15 year old girl who was married after knowing her husband for ten minutes and raped and beaten until (in his words) knew how to please him and be obedient. Then was pregnant/or watching her newborn die, three times. I don't believe the government. Men who we know have actually beheaded people have come back and been through deradicalised. Their wives and children were treated as victims.

👏 👏 👏

ancientgran · 25/02/2023 20:51

Xenia · 24/02/2023 17:33

Indeed. Also she is not the only one we have not allowed back. Also if I broke the law and was jailed in say Brazil for drug smuggling the British Gov would do nothing to help me and I certainly would not be given £5m of legal aid as Ms Begum has had.

Yes they will, the advice is if you are arrested abroad you contact the British Embassy or consulate. There are even agreements with some countries so you can get transferred to a British prison. The time they won't help is if you have dual nationality and you are arrested in your "other" country. They warn you about it if you take out dual nationality.

From the govt website about what to do when arrested abroad: Our staff are there to support you and to take an interest in your welfare. We aim to be sensitive and non-judgemental. We also aim to treat everyone in prison or detention the same, no matter what they are being held for, or whether they are on remand or have been sentenced. You should stay in touch with our staff and ask for their help, as they have experience in dealing with many of the problems you may face.

Xenia · 24/02/2023 17:33

Indeed. Also she is not the only one we have not allowed back. Also if I broke the law and was jailed in say Brazil for drug smuggling the British Gov would do nothing to help me and I certainly would not be given £5m of legal aid as Ms Begum has had.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 24/02/2023 16:45

Situaciones · 23/02/2023 22:37

Well the mum and family definitely knew what she was doing. You would need to be incredibly naive to think they didn't. I imagine the mum is deliberately keeping a low profile so no one asks too many questions.

I'm always reminded of Abase Hussen (father of Amira) and his stunt holding her Arsenal teddy, carrying on about what a sweet innocent she was - only for it to be discovered he'd been taking her to extremist rallies

Different case of course, but I wouldn't be in the least surprised if it turned out that the rest of the family are on the security services' radar too

Situaciones · 23/02/2023 22:37

Well the mum and family definitely knew what she was doing. You would need to be incredibly naive to think they didn't. I imagine the mum is deliberately keeping a low profile so no one asks too many questions.

Maybebabyno2 · 23/02/2023 22:14

Quveas · 24/11/2022 15:57

AH, so the teenage girls groomed by gangs in Rotherham and Rochdale knew right from wrong and deserved what they got? Many of them were 15 year olds. And were groomed. You cannot pick and choose which 15 year old groomed girls are victims and which ones are criminals.

And we currently have NO evidence that she has committed a crime. Rumour. Speculation. And the Daily Mail. But no court of law has found her guilty of anything. If the Syrians had evidence that she committed crimes, don't you think they'd have charged her?

One of the girls who was groomed who went out and got others involved was held accountable as far as I remember.

SirMingeALot · 23/02/2023 21:27

Xenia · 23/02/2023 20:51

I tihnk most of us know that it is a huge deal to choose to get another passport. Our family is only eligible for British but plenty of people with an Irish grandparents after brexit had to think lonlg and hard about the downsides of having two passpots. There are also tax issues if you have two as Boris J found to his cost as he has US and UK.

Anyway like many I am very glad the English courts apply the law without fear or favour and have reached the right decision here.

People with an Irish grandparent only would've had to go through a process to acquire Irish nationality, even with a long wait. The calculation is quite different when you already hold the citizenship and just haven't bothered with the passport before, like if your parent is Irish for example. Not a huge deal at all in that instance.