Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you have any opinions on how long is 'too long' to breastfeed your child?

414 replies

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:04

Feeling awfully judged and wondering if anyone has an opinion on this?

OP posts:
FancyFanny · 24/11/2022 16:16

When the child is old enough to talk about it they are probably too old

PurpleWisteria1 · 24/11/2022 16:16

pompei8309 · 24/11/2022 15:31

elephantonacid is a very low value liquid , the nutritional content is close to zero

Interesting.
What makes it change from life giving nutrient dense milk that formula companies strive to match into ‘low value liquid’?
And when does this happen? At how many months PP does the nutrient value of this milk drop down?

Kattouswhiskers · 24/11/2022 16:10

I've not read all 10 pages, but someone must have posted the Mongolia article:

www.naturalchild.org/articles/guest/ruth_kamnitzer.html

Any thoughts you have about 'limits' are 100% culturally bound.

Krakinou · 24/11/2022 16:09

@elephantonacid interesting thread but I don’t see where you have answered your own question. What age do you think is too old for breast feeding and why?

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 16:03

luxxlisbon · 24/11/2022 15:50

A couple of friends who I told (one my son asked for boob in front of her and he was only 2.5 at the time) and my two aunts and one of their husbands.

So you got less than a handful of comments and are so outraged by them 1.5years later that you started this post?

I just don’t see what you’re hoping to get onto of this. Most children are not breastfed until 4 or later so there are probably going to be more people who find it ‘weird’ than not weird because it’s actually just very uncommon. It doesn’t mean anyone is demanding you to justify your decision.

Where did I say people are demanding me to justify my decision? I was just thinking about it this morning and how if they thought it was weird when he was three, what the general consensus is for a 4yo. I've actually learnt a lot from this thread.

OP posts:
Choconut · 24/11/2022 16:02

Adeleskirts · 24/11/2022 15:51

the toys have changed, the stories changed, they will be teaching them to read, they will carry things that are too heavy for the child but others the child will carry themselves. So no, unless disabilities or additional needs a 4 year old will not be read to , played with etc “just like” when they were babies, because that too would be infantalising. Feeding a child, comforting a child, playing with a child, evolved as they grow. We should not treat four year olds the same as we treat babies.

The thing is though why is BFing babyish or infantilising? Who decided BF is only for babies? Only modern society, not biology. Don't you see that it is society that has made you feel the way you feel? If everyone BF their baby until they were 7 then you wouldn't feel like this because it would be seen as normal by everyone because that's what everyone does. But nowsociety has decided tits are for sex and so now there is something inherently wrong about anything other than a tiny baby BFing - and many people think even that's disgusting and shouldn't be done anywhere near other people.

It's all very depressing.

ivykaty44 · 24/11/2022 16:02

I always remember watching a true to life film and seeing a boy of around 10 being breast feed, that to me was pushing it to the extreme in my mind.

imnotwhoyouthinkiam · 24/11/2022 16:01

I BF DS2 until he was 3. He named my boobs and would ask for them by name. Apparently one of them had chocolate milk. HmmGrin
By 3 he had full (advanced ) speech and was starting to spell simple words and recognise letters/ numbers. He was potty trained. He had teeth. (My point here is that bf-ing hadn't held him back in anyway. )

Hes 16 now. He remembers being fed. He remembers feeling safe and loved and comforted. He loves that I "played along" with his names and chocolate milk thing.

And if people think that's weird/wrong/creepy... who cares. He was happy. I was happy. It hasn't held him back in anyway.

And I'm not saying a non bf child can't also feel loved and safe and comforted. But just that my ds has positive memories of it.

MollyRover · 24/11/2022 16:01

westthroughthewhitleywood · 24/11/2022 14:09

Personally, until they can eat and drink for themselves. I know it's a lovely bonding experience but I think when they no longer need to for survival, there's no purpose to it anymore and one would like to think the bond is already there and strong enough to manage without it.

This, in my opinion. I'm definitely a breastfeeding advocate but watched my own mother breastfeed my siblings for longer than it benefited them. Weaning was a nightmare that she only undertook when there was no other choice. I have trauma from it, can only imagine what it was like for them.

I think the best approach is to look at the signs that they're ready to stop, don't offer it, let it gradually happen. For my DC1 that was 8 months but was mixing with bottle feeding from 6 months (expressed milk from 3 months) so it was easier. They were done with bottles from about 12 months. With dc2 I'd like to ebf up to whenever they're on solids.

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 24/11/2022 16:00

You are not "breastFEEDING" though, you are "breastCOMFORTING". So all the people talking about the nutritional value of it, that has nothing to do with it in OPs case. She said it's for a few minutes every few days or weeks.

You asked everyone what THEY thought the age limit would be, what do YOU think it should be OP? If your child still asks at 5? 10? 15? will you be okay with it?

ArabellaScott · 24/11/2022 16:00

sucking it directly from the breasts

This is what breastfeeding involves.

Stressfordays · 24/11/2022 16:00

I know logically it doesn't matter as long as mum and child are happy and I would never outwardly voice my opinion to someone. But I do feel it's a bit weird. Mainly because people make such a song and dance about taking young children's comfort items away from the such as dummies and bottles (yes I know they damage teeth) that it feels quite hypocritical.

I was made to feel awful about my 3yo having a dummy despite the fact she had been traumatised by her own father from a young age. Yet if I was breastfeeding her, no one would dare say anything to me and it would be ok to comfort my child like that. That is my own issues though.

roarfeckingroarr · 24/11/2022 15:59

I stopped when DS turned 2, partly because I'm pregnant again and wanted time between weaning and the baby arriving so he doesn't feel pushed out.

I think that within reason it's about what's right for you and your child. I would find it strange to see a school aged child breastfeeding, but maybe that's my issue.

upfucked · 24/11/2022 15:58

pompei8309 · 24/11/2022 15:13

What you produce is not milk , don’t fool yourself only because it’s white . I understand it provides some comfort for your child but it definitively doesn’t provide nutrition. Sorry but Little Britain comes to mind here 😂he goes to nursery, he’s out of nappies , he feeds himself, I would stop before it became a problem.

Hmmm. It is a milk and is nutritious. Unless you have some research which I haven’t seen?

Hankunamatata · 24/11/2022 15:58

Extended bf is your business. I don't need to know about it - doesn't matter how I feel about it.

CantStartaFireWithoutaSpark · 24/11/2022 15:57

In my opinion they shouldn’t remember it!!!
But from 1, babies are too easily distracted! A bottle is just easier.

Dogtooth · 24/11/2022 15:57

PixieLaLa · 24/11/2022 15:53

Cup of cow milk from cow breasts, fine

Human milk from human breasts, not fine

Not really a fair comparison, unless you mean feeding directing from the cows nipples? 🤣

Why do you think they're called nanny goats? They used to get kids to feed directly from them. Safer than a filthy bottle.

Wam90 · 24/11/2022 15:57

I feel as though you have to do what’s best for you and the child/ baby.
I breastfed my first until he was one and still feeding my 18 month old but would really like to stop for my sanity, I just don’t know how to! But I wouldn’t judge anyone who decided to feed for longer, it’s definitely personal choice

Floomobal · 24/11/2022 15:55

To be fair, I'm not sure it's the milk itself that people have such an issue with, but the sucking it directly from the breasts.

Yes, because breasts are for other’s sexual gratification, not for feeding young. Silly me

Floomobal · 24/11/2022 15:53

Adeleskirts · 24/11/2022 14:14

I don’t understand this comment, hugs are not the equivalent of breastfeeding, so no of course I’d not say the same. 🤨

op. Ok you’ve taught him other mechanisms. How often is he tired, poorly, anxious enough to need breastfeeding?

This is the problem. People feel they have a right to judge, when it’s got FUCK ALL to do with them. Unless it’s your child, or your boob, its nothing to do with you.

Why does OP need to justify herself to you, about coping mechanisms and how often she feeds etc? Bizarre

PixieLaLa · 24/11/2022 15:53

Cup of cow milk from cow breasts, fine

Human milk from human breasts, not fine

Not really a fair comparison, unless you mean feeding directing from the cows nipples? 🤣

Adeleskirts · 24/11/2022 15:51

Saltywalruss · 24/11/2022 15:47

Why does it "baby",them? Don't you still read them stories, play with them, carry their things around just like when they were babies?

the toys have changed, the stories changed, they will be teaching them to read, they will carry things that are too heavy for the child but others the child will carry themselves. So no, unless disabilities or additional needs a 4 year old will not be read to , played with etc “just like” when they were babies, because that too would be infantalising. Feeding a child, comforting a child, playing with a child, evolved as they grow. We should not treat four year olds the same as we treat babies.

luxxlisbon · 24/11/2022 15:50

A couple of friends who I told (one my son asked for boob in front of her and he was only 2.5 at the time) and my two aunts and one of their husbands.

So you got less than a handful of comments and are so outraged by them 1.5years later that you started this post?

I just don’t see what you’re hoping to get onto of this. Most children are not breastfed until 4 or later so there are probably going to be more people who find it ‘weird’ than not weird because it’s actually just very uncommon. It doesn’t mean anyone is demanding you to justify your decision.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 24/11/2022 15:50

K37529 · 24/11/2022 15:48

In my opinion If they’re old enough that they will remember it when they grow up then they are too old to breastfeed

Why?

wp65 · 24/11/2022 15:49

LolaSmiles · 24/11/2022 15:36

Crazy that bf toddlers needs to be justified when people routinely give their toddlers sweets and ice cream and chicken nuggets. What an upside down world
It really is
What I find funny is how many people outraged at the idea of human offspring having human milk in early childhood think nothing of feeding cow milk, from cow boobies to human children. 🤷‍♀️

Cup of cow milk from cow breasts, fine
Human milk from human breasts, not fine.

And they'll still tie themselves in knots that they don't have problematic attitudes towards women's breasts

To be fair, I'm not sure it's the milk itself that people have such an issue with, but the sucking it directly from the breasts.