Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you have any opinions on how long is 'too long' to breastfeed your child?

414 replies

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:04

Feeling awfully judged and wondering if anyone has an opinion on this?

OP posts:
Pythonese · 24/11/2022 16:41

First, until she grew teeth, 12 weeks. The other two were formula fed. They all grew up strong and healthy. No worries, no regrets but each to their own.

antelopevalley · 24/11/2022 16:40

As long as you want.

Whatnextarghhhhhh · 24/11/2022 16:40

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:22

Can anyone explain to me the actual reason WHY it's weird, other than because 'people think it's weird'?

It’s a where do you draw the line question. If 4 is ok, why not 5? If 5 is ok, why not 6? Is 7 ok?

There are apparently some studies that show early humans breastfed for up to one year.

terriblemomm · 24/11/2022 16:38

Mine is 16 months and still breastfeeds. It’s really just up to you.

EasterIssland · 24/11/2022 16:37

Suemademedoit · 24/11/2022 16:34

She definitely is breastfeeding for emotional regulation purposes. But then everybody uses tools for emotional regulation, and everybody uses other people for emotional regulation, at every age.

Everybody doesn’t use other people for emotional regulation. Almost all children have to. I don’t think I know many adults who do.

This is exactly the point I was making in my first post a short way up this thread. I don’t think there’s necessarily a direct line between 3-5yo children breastfeeding, and them becoming adults who need others to regulate their emotions. A lot can happen in 20, 30 years. But school years can leave an indelible mark for life, and we live in a society where school starts at 4-5yo. They need to be able to regulate their own emotions.

I take when you’re sad around others that love you they don’t give you hugs ? Cuz at least for myself feeling loved when I’m feeling vulnerable really helps me calming down. It won’t always happen. My son is not bf neither every time he’s unhappy but other times he’ll be as it’s his comfort zone

Notanotherwindow · 24/11/2022 16:36

2 would be the max for me. I find it weird after that; they're children, not babies and too old to be suckling at the breast. If you think they're a bit old to be walking round with a dummy, they're too old to breast feed. But that's just my own personal viewpoint, you should stop when it feels right to.

BreatheAndFocus · 24/11/2022 16:35

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:04

Feeling awfully judged and wondering if anyone has an opinion on this?

I’ve breastfed all mine, and for the last one actually looked up how long - it said up to 7 years. There was also something about it being when their big teeth came in, as they altered their palette/suck so they couldn’t really feed any more and self-weaned, if they hadn’t already done so earlier.

Different children have different needs. For my first, I thought I had to set a limit so stopped at 12 months, but for the other two I let myself be guided by them. One stopped much earlier than the other, and I was totally relaxed about it. Fortunately, as I’ve got older, I’ve become pretty immune to those judgey people who have issues with breastfeeding.

Carry on as long as you and your DC are happy. When mine self-weaned, it was quite sudden, like a switch had been flicked. They obviously knew what they needed and when they didn’t need it any longer.

Candlesoftime · 24/11/2022 16:35

I read somewhere that archaeologists/ anthropologists thought that pre- history, humans breastfed until 7. They were talking about nomadic people so maybe it was useful for that lifestyle - if there wasn't that much food that day the child could breastfeed instead, perhaps.

Fuuuuuckit · 24/11/2022 16:34

I Bf'd both of mine for about a year which horrified some especially ex mil who ff'd all 6 of hers a lifetime ago

We were ready to move on about that time tbh, they were more or less settled at night and happy to pat back to sleep etc - plus the nutrition value is negligible when they're weaned.

That said, I do wonder if extended bf is more for the mum's benefit than the dc past this age (and certainly to 7?!?) - I've taught kids that age who certainly don't have any comprehension of that sort of emotional connection, and certainly don't need bf nutritionally after they've stuffed their face with monster munch.

I believe that there is little argument to extended bf babies having better anything over ff - if not there would be such a push to bf, and the majority of toddlers struggling, which clearly they don't.

Suemademedoit · 24/11/2022 16:34

She definitely is breastfeeding for emotional regulation purposes. But then everybody uses tools for emotional regulation, and everybody uses other people for emotional regulation, at every age.

Everybody doesn’t use other people for emotional regulation. Almost all children have to. I don’t think I know many adults who do.

This is exactly the point I was making in my first post a short way up this thread. I don’t think there’s necessarily a direct line between 3-5yo children breastfeeding, and them becoming adults who need others to regulate their emotions. A lot can happen in 20, 30 years. But school years can leave an indelible mark for life, and we live in a society where school starts at 4-5yo. They need to be able to regulate their own emotions.

Itsabitnotcold · 24/11/2022 16:32

Puberty 🤷‍♀️ when they or you feel uncomfortable.

EasterIssland · 24/11/2022 16:31

As someone has said as long as you and your child are happy.

im bf at an age other posters in some threads in mumsnet have told me :
im sexually abusing my son
my son will hate me in the future
my son will resent me in the future and be ashamed of me
my sons friends are laughing at him
I’m only doing it for myself and I’m selfish

and I don’t give a shit what others think. So if you’re happy and so is your child then carry on as much as you both need. Life is too short to stop (or do) things just because other people want you to

WeightoftheWorld · 24/11/2022 16:30

No, no opinion, different for every family, couldn't really care less. Eldest I only BF for 12 weeks and would have loved to have felt able to BF for longer so was very upset about stopping. DC2 BF for 10 months and was only slightly upset at stopping, it didn't wholeheartedly feel like my choice again because basically he was refusing to BF much and drinking milk better out of bottle by then (both mine were combi fed anyway by choice), but on the other hand he was about to start nursery and I couldn't express so it was probably a decent a time as any to stop.

I cant personally imagine breastfeeding a child over the age of one ish HOWEVER I know people who have BF up until 4 (and possibly beyond, I wouldnt necessarily know). And thays obviously absolutely fine, it worked for their family.

FloorWipes · 24/11/2022 16:27

My 4 yo is unwilling to stop so far. I sometimes feel like I want her to stop, but when I think deeply about why, the judgment from other people, including from my husband and family, is one of the most significant factors in all that. Other people’s opinions can be so tiresome. She’s a super sociable girl who goes to nursery and doesn’t need me around all the time. She definitely is breastfeeding for emotional regulation purposes. But then everybody uses tools for emotional regulation, and everybody uses other people for emotional regulation, at every age.

LolaSmiles · 24/11/2022 16:27

To be fair, I'm not sure it's the milk itself that people have such an issue with, but the sucking it directly from the breasts
Oh you're right. That's the big objection. Most people who object to natural term weaning and insist it's weird/they're too old/shouldn't once they start speaking/it's just for the mum's benefit rarely admit that's their objection because they'd have to be honest and open about the fact they have a weird attitude to women's breasts.

Not really a fair comparison, unless you mean feeding directing from the cows nipples? 🤣
It is a fair comparison unless someone holds a weird view that women's breasts are primarily sexual.
Plenty do mind, and it's why they seem to have such a big issue with human boobs being used to feed human offspring the human milk that human boobs have evolved to do.

KitchenFleur · 24/11/2022 16:26

Kattouswhiskers · 24/11/2022 16:10

I've not read all 10 pages, but someone must have posted the Mongolia article:

www.naturalchild.org/articles/guest/ruth_kamnitzer.html

Any thoughts you have about 'limits' are 100% culturally bound.

Thank you for sharing this!
I read this years ago when I was breastfeeding ds and loved it!
I lost it when I upgraded my phone and had forgotten what it was called.

Saltywalruss · 24/11/2022 16:26

I think breastfeeding beyond the age it’s nutritionally necessary is about this (after all, a 3yo or 4yo who breastfeeds once every few days or weeks isn’t doing it for food, if there’s even any milk there)

But people feed their children all sorts of things that aren't "nutritionally neccesary" .

Lilgamesh2 · 24/11/2022 16:24

The nutritional make up of milk changes when kids reach toddlerhood to specifically meet their needs. It's designed for toddlers. Any argument that says it's not natural or healthy for toddlers to breastfeed hasn't got a leg to stand on.

Saltywalruss · 24/11/2022 16:23

FancyFanny · 24/11/2022 16:16

When the child is old enough to talk about it they are probably too old

Does that apply to any other things too?;Or just breastfeeding?

Somethingsnappy · 24/11/2022 16:23

FancyFanny · 24/11/2022 16:16

When the child is old enough to talk about it they are probably too old

Why?

WinterLobelia · 24/11/2022 16:22

I could not breastfeed at all for either mine. (Well, I did not even bother trying for DS2 as the first time round nearly sent me loopy and just not even going there was a much better experience for me). So personally I have no experience but I would say as long as you wish to and feel comfortable doing. It's nobody's business but yours, and if anyone criticises you then they can boil their heads.

Suemademedoit · 24/11/2022 16:20

Having bf my DC to 6mo (their choice) and 2yo (their choice) I understand it as some children needing it in a way that others don’t.

I don’t think there’s anything wrong with bf up to age 3-4yo (4yo is pushing it imo) or so, because babies and children develop at different rates. Some humans communicate in physical ways: some adults need hugs and cuddles and affection as emotional nourishment, some abhor it.

I think breastfeeding beyond the age it’s nutritionally necessary is about this (after all, a 3yo or 4yo who breastfeeds once every few days or weeks isn’t doing it for food, if there’s even any milk there). Some children can get their emotional needs satisfied through words and actions and their own reason/logic/stores. Some still need hugs/cuddles/breastfeeding.

Beyond 4yo, I think in the Western world where children are often in childcare settings and in any event interacting frequently with the outside world, they need to learn self-sustenance for emotional needs. It’s in their best interests. I think it is best for them to address with language and thoughts how to deal with unwanted or unpleasant or unhappy feelings and emotions. Hugs and cuddles for fun and because they’re cute and funny and cuddly are always welcome no matter the age - the key is dependency. Breastfeeding instead if tackling head on is dodging the issue.

Of course, just my opinion in the spirit of a thread asking for opinions, which I’ve taken at face value.

TheOrigRights · 24/11/2022 16:19

My opinion is that natural weaning is the preferred way to BF.

[ponders whether I have time for all I want to say]
Both mine naturally weaned; DS1 at 3 and DS2 at 4. I went into motherhood very keen to BF, and with an open mind. I never for a moment thought I would do it for so long, I hadn't really thought about it tbh.
There were times when I wished I'd knocked it on the head at a year old.
There were times after that, that I just wished I was DONE.
But most of the time it was lovely, and I look back fondly (they are 23 and 13 now). Physically, naturally weaning meant I never knew when the last BF was - for a long time preceding they'd be nursing maybe only once every 3 or 4 days.
My body adjusted as it went along and I feel I gave my boys what they needed.

I was working full time for most of the time I was BF and it helped with my relationship with them I think. It's the one thing that only I could do and to reconnect in that way benefitted us.

After about 2 years old I didn't really tell people I was BF. They didn't need to know and I had a good network of supportive friends and family. I wasn't hiding it, but kind of got fed up of people trying to dump their own issues on me by saying e.g. "Oh you're so lucky you can BF, I had to give up after nnnn because of xyz", or "they don't really need it after n months". I could quickly tell if people were open minded and actually wanted to hear what my opinion was and was then happy to talk.

I do admit that I felt slightly uncomfortable thinking DS2 would start school before he weaned, not because I thought he was too old to BF, but because I didn't want him to possibly put himself at risk of teasing, if he told people he had Mummy Milk at bed time sometimes. In other cultures it would be fine, but I don't think many 4 year olds in the UK would understand, and the last thing I wanted was for my DS to think he was odd because of it. It was a non issue anyway, as he weaned about 6 months before school.

If I see a child of 3 or 4 BF I admit I look at them and think they look big, but honestly, when it was my child, snuggled up in bed at the end of the day it felt absolutely perfect.

I never had a negative comment about BF in public, only ever a few positive ones. I never had anything more than a blocked duct so I feel fortunate in that respect.

speakout · 24/11/2022 16:19

I don't think it is any of my business how a woman chooses to nurture her child.

Saltywalruss · 24/11/2022 16:17

Floomobal · 24/11/2022 15:55

To be fair, I'm not sure it's the milk itself that people have such an issue with, but the sucking it directly from the breasts.

Yes, because breasts are for other’s sexual gratification, not for feeding young. Silly me

I agree. But few people will admit that. They would rather try to find other reasons as to why it's not acceptable after a certain age .

Swipe left for the next trending thread