Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you have any opinions on how long is 'too long' to breastfeed your child?

414 replies

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:04

Feeling awfully judged and wondering if anyone has an opinion on this?

OP posts:
Suemademedoit · 24/11/2022 17:14

FloorWipes · 24/11/2022 17:02

Everybody doesn’t use other people for emotional regulation. Almost all children have to. I don’t think I know many adults who do.

Yes everybody does. You probably aren’t aware you are doing it, or you may not think about it in that way. You are literally doing it right now by posting on this thread.

Are you purporting to know me better than I know myself? If so, there’s nothing credible in any of your contributions to this thread.

BellePeppa · 24/11/2022 17:13

LolaSmiles · 24/11/2022 15:36

Crazy that bf toddlers needs to be justified when people routinely give their toddlers sweets and ice cream and chicken nuggets. What an upside down world
It really is
What I find funny is how many people outraged at the idea of human offspring having human milk in early childhood think nothing of feeding cow milk, from cow boobies to human children. 🤷‍♀️

Cup of cow milk from cow breasts, fine
Human milk from human breasts, not fine.

And they'll still tie themselves in knots that they don't have problematic attitudes towards women's breasts

Then why not put the milk in a glass, unless you mean they’re literally being bf from a cow? Otherwise your comparison doesn’t make sense.

BellePeppa · 24/11/2022 17:09

Freudpenis · 24/11/2022 15:42

Well cows don't have breasts but I agree. It's madness. Too old for the milk of their own species but it's fine for cow's milk to replace it? Confused

I think it’s more about the receptacle that the thread is about rather than its contents.

Saltywalruss · 24/11/2022 17:05

don't feel that remembering how it felt to suck milk out of human boobs is a very "normal" (purely statistically speaking) to have during your entire adult life

But if you have that memory it might feel normal?

89redballoons · 24/11/2022 17:05

I breastfed DS1 until 16 months. I wanted my body back and for me personally, I didn't like the idea of my son being able to actively ask me for milk with words/toddle over to me and pull my top down in public etc. It felt invasive. Stopping was relatively gentle and painless, and DS1 started reliably sleeping through the night around that time as well.

I'm currently breastfeeding DS2 who is 7 months. I was/am aiming to carry on until between 12 and 18 months. However, DS2 now has four teeth and is biting everything including my breasts during feeding. It really hurts. I'm still persevering with breastfeeding but when he bites I'm taking him off, and it doesn't seem like he's getting all the milk he needs from BFing because of that - he wasn't having as many wet nappies as before and he didn't seem satisfied after feeds. So he's also on three bottles of formula a day plus 3 little meals of solids. If he doesn't stop biting soon I think the breastfeeding will have to stop, as it's not really relaxing for either of us and nor is he getting much nutrition from it.

I don't really have an opinion on when other people should stop breastfeeding. I think it is individual and up to each mother and baby to kind of negotiate how and when they stop. Personally I have loved breastfeeding both of my DC, but I also don't think formula is the devil either.

ExhaustedFlamingo · 24/11/2022 17:04

Notanotherwindow · 24/11/2022 16:48

Can anyone explain to me the actual reason WHY it's weird, other than because 'people think it's weird'?

Not really, no. I can't put my finger on it. It just is. In much the same way as keeping them in nappies after they've been successfully potty trained would be weird. Maybe something to do with dignity? I'm really trying to put it into words why it gives me the ick but just can't.

I think it's because we teach children from a young age about boundaries. We teach them that adults can't touch the child's body in private areas etc. And we teach them that women's breasts are private spaces and they can't go around grabbing women's breasts, even if they like the feeling for comfort!! I have an autistic child who LOVED grabbing soft bouncy breast "pillows" so needed a lot of watching over to stop him grabbing strangers' breasts that looked inviting! 😅

I think that by the age of 2 or 3 encouraging a child to handle breasts - even with consent - blurs boundaries. I think there are more appropriate ways to provide maternal comfort.

But as I also said above, it is no one's business but your own what you choose to do.

FloorWipes · 24/11/2022 17:02

Everybody doesn’t use other people for emotional regulation. Almost all children have to. I don’t think I know many adults who do.

Yes everybody does. You probably aren’t aware you are doing it, or you may not think about it in that way. You are literally doing it right now by posting on this thread.

User12453315 · 24/11/2022 17:01

This is my honest opinions as someone who did extended BF until 2.5 and weaned for the reason below.

My logic is that I would not be too comfortable with my child having clear memories (later in life as an adult) of how it felt to drink milk out of my boobs or graphically sucking a nipple. This has absolutely nothing to do with sexuality but respecting the boundaries between two bodies. I feel a 4 year old is a separate person and I don't want to force my body parts into her mouth, or have her drink my bodily fluids, as much as it is a habit out of love.

I was BF (for 1 year) and I love my mum but idea of being able to remember how it felt like to drink milk from her boobs gives me a massive ick. I have plenty of clear memories from age 4, and even more age 5. Thankfully those are relatively normal memories of attending nursery, sharing snacks, travelling with my parents etc. I don't feel that remembering how it felt to suck milk out of human boobs is a very "normal" (purely statistically speaking) to have during your entire adult life.

Nobody can predict the relationship they will have with their adult children. There are thousands of things that can crop up down the line (obviously not all preventable through breast milk). Should there ever be problems, then the fact that they can remember nursing could easily be twisted as co-dependency or separation issues that stemmed from early childhood. As an adult you will not think it was so wonderful because of the "closeness and comfort", which is an immediate effect that happens now and will eventually forgotten. You are just left with the graphic memory of nursing which you need to somehow deal with.

MilkyYay · 24/11/2022 16:59

To me, if your periods have come back, absent (socially engineered!!) contraception, you'd have likely fallen pregnant again, which nearly always leads to weaning for many reasons (milk dries up, mother often finds it painful or unpleasant).

Tandem feeding (excluding multiple births) is not a thing in the natural world and is extremely rare among tribal people.

Our bodies are designed to lactate, experience a period of lactational amenorrhoea, then resume fertility at which point the first offspring generally weans. Milk output often falls dramatically when periods return too - so much so it can trigger self weaning (it did for my DC).

You do not get children in tribes feeding until they are 7, then their parents having 8 year gaps between children (following 9 month pregnancy). Gaps are much smaller - more like 3-4 years. Allowing for 9 month pregnancy, this implies children are breastfeeding until 2-3 at most.

Its not comparable to say that people dislike breastmilk but embrace a cup of cows milk. Its not the substance people are questioning, its the act of suckling orally at the breast primarily for comfort. Most people are saying they expect children to become much less reliant on that comfort (absent unusual) trauma by about age 3.

Saltywalruss · 24/11/2022 16:59

User135792468 · 24/11/2022 16:46

My cut off is 2. A friends logic was, if he’s old enough to eat a happy meal / burger and chips then he’s told old for breastmilk.

Im not saying you should feed a 2 year old McDonald’s btw but I agree with the rationale.

Really? You think that you should only feed children nutritionally perfect food until they are old enough for junk food?

EasterIssland · 24/11/2022 16:58

antelopevalley · 24/11/2022 16:42

@eas My DP gives me hugs. But I can manage feeling sad and upset by myself. After all no one is giving me a hug if I have a bad day at work.

I hope my son when he’s in the school he’s comforted rather than being left on his own crying because he fall down and injured himself or because he was frustrated about something.
if I’m crying at work to the point others see me I hope they ask whether I’m ok.

terriblemomm · 24/11/2022 16:56

Whatnextarghhhhhh · 24/11/2022 16:40

It’s a where do you draw the line question. If 4 is ok, why not 5? If 5 is ok, why not 6? Is 7 ok?

There are apparently some studies that show early humans breastfed for up to one year.

I’m my opinion kids naturally want to grow up unless they have a cognitive difference that would make them A typical. There are studies in asia that prove this. Many children naturally stop breastfeeding around 5-6 if left to their own devices. Whether it’s from peer pressure, inconvenience because they started school out because they merely lost interest. I personally plan to stop at 2. But I think I understand why some mothers are interested in continuing on. I think you are describing this worry that it will become a slippery slope. There are always exceptions to the rule and those rare people who will take things to the extreme. But I don’t believe that society overall will be nursing their children into their 20’s. lol It’s pretty impossible to force a child to nurse. If they don’t want to they will make you wish you hadn’t even asked. 😂

TheOrigRights · 24/11/2022 16:55

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 24/11/2022 16:47

That's sad. I get hugs when I'm having a bad day at work

Hugs from your colleagues?

I've hugged and been hugged by colleagues, but only once they have become friends as well as colleagues and mostly outside of the work environment (exceptions being maybe conferences where I haven't seen a colleague for a long time).

I don't think I would ever approach a colleague and ask for a hug if I'm having a bad day. In fact I usually retreat into myself.

AntsGoMarchingOneByOne · 24/11/2022 16:55

For me personally, over 3yo is too long.

Whatnextarghhhhhh · 24/11/2022 16:51

EasterIssland · 24/11/2022 16:42

Not sure whether I care much about what they did thousand of years ago. Their life is completely different to mine

I just thought it was interesting.

Suprima · 24/11/2022 16:50

I am honestly astounded by how many people have issues with children suckling for comfort. Breastfeeding isn’t all about nutrition.

even posts that start off meaning well descend into this lunacy.

If young children want to suckle their mums for comfort, that is completely natural and fine. Who fucking cares if they are ‘comfort feeding?’. We are supposed provide comfort for our young and some children may need to feed a bit longer.

SallyWD · 24/11/2022 16:49

It's so individual. For me breastfeeding for one year was enough. I'm sure it's healthy and normal to breastfeed for several years. I must admit I find it unusual when someone's breastfeeding a 4 or 5 year old but that's my problem, not theirs.

Notanotherwindow · 24/11/2022 16:48

Can anyone explain to me the actual reason WHY it's weird, other than because 'people think it's weird'?

Not really, no. I can't put my finger on it. It just is. In much the same way as keeping them in nappies after they've been successfully potty trained would be weird. Maybe something to do with dignity? I'm really trying to put it into words why it gives me the ick but just can't.

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 24/11/2022 16:47

antelopevalley · 24/11/2022 16:42

@eas My DP gives me hugs. But I can manage feeling sad and upset by myself. After all no one is giving me a hug if I have a bad day at work.

That's sad. I get hugs when I'm having a bad day at work

SquigglePigs · 24/11/2022 16:46

InBlue · 24/11/2022 14:29

For me, aged about 4 would be about the limit.

Both mine self-weaned at about 16 months - as in, around that age, they didn’t ask for it. Unless I actively offered it to them (got my boob out) they wouldn’t think of it. And just as happy with cows milk.

I do sometimes privately wonder with women feeding older toddlers, does the toddler actually intentionally seek out the boob? Or is the mum just sort of going “okay it’s morning/night time routine so it’s breastfeeding time” and the toddler complies. But that’s just because of my experience where DC get to a certain age and stop asking (far too distracted by toddling round/play etc, and preferring to eat snacks).

I think anyone judging a mum for breastfeeding their child is a fucker though.

To answer your musings about who leads it...

DD is almost 4. We night weaned at 13 months because I couldn't hack being back at work and being up several hours a night. From about 2 I adopted "don't offer, don't refuse" as a policy. Now she asks for some most evenings when she gets tired and a few mornings a week. Sometimes I think she uses it as a delaying tactic to get an extra 10 mins snuggles instead of getting out of the door to nursery to be honest. She will also occasionally ask if she has hurt herself or if we've had a particularly busy couple of days and she just wants to wind down and connect. If we're at her Grandparents and busy she will probably only ask once or twice in a whole weekend. If we're having a chilled weekend at home she might ask a couple of times a day.

To be honest I thought she'd have weaned herself by now. Before I had her I thought once they were old enough to ask they were probably too old, but this has felt right for us. I am probably going to encourage her to wean before she starts school next year. I just haven't worked out if I'm thinking that because I think I should or if it's because it's what I actually want!

I was grateful we were still breastfeeding a few months ago when she had a stomach bug though as it's the only thing she kept down!

User135792468 · 24/11/2022 16:46

My cut off is 2. A friends logic was, if he’s old enough to eat a happy meal / burger and chips then he’s told old for breastmilk.

Im not saying you should feed a 2 year old McDonald’s btw but I agree with the rationale.

Candlesoftime · 24/11/2022 16:43

Breastmilk is said to be such a super food, maybe it's better to feed for longer? Cancer- fighting, etc. Should we consider giving 4 year olds expressed milk to boost their immune systems even after they've self weaned? Just a thought

Candlesoftime · 24/11/2022 16:43

I do think that in our culture we see breasts as sexual, and only as functional as an afterthought. I did before I was a mother. I wonder whether some people think that if a 4/5/6/7 year old can remember breastfeeding, they'd feel embarrassed about it when they were older? You know, that they could remember sucking on their mum's boobs and that this would feel too intimate?

Surely that's just cultural though. I don't see why things have to be that way.

antelopevalley · 24/11/2022 16:42

@eas My DP gives me hugs. But I can manage feeling sad and upset by myself. After all no one is giving me a hug if I have a bad day at work.

EasterIssland · 24/11/2022 16:42

Whatnextarghhhhhh · 24/11/2022 16:40

It’s a where do you draw the line question. If 4 is ok, why not 5? If 5 is ok, why not 6? Is 7 ok?

There are apparently some studies that show early humans breastfed for up to one year.

Not sure whether I care much about what they did thousand of years ago. Their life is completely different to mine