Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you have any opinions on how long is 'too long' to breastfeed your child?

414 replies

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:04

Feeling awfully judged and wondering if anyone has an opinion on this?

OP posts:
FloorWipes · 24/11/2022 18:50

Everyone has an opinion, some are similar, some aren’t. They’re opinions, by definition neither right nor wrong. Some may be based on mistruths (such as yours), but they’re still opinions personal to the poster. If there were a definitive, unarguable answer to the question the OP has asked (which was a request for opinions, not answers, as it happens) we wouldn’t be here.

Everyone can have an opinion about when it’s ok to breastfeed and why. There is no definitive answer because of the nature of the question. We agree on that.

I suppose everyone can also have an opinion about whether the world is round or whether adults emotional regulate in relation to other people. It’s just that some of those opinions will be objectively false.

ArabellaScott · 24/11/2022 18:44

Cornflakes44 · 24/11/2022 18:15

I do think anything over 2 is a bit grim imo. It feels age inappropriate like letting a 4 year old have a dummy or bottle. Fine for a baby not for a toddler. I think once it’s just for comfort rather than food you should transition to other things, cuddles, stories etc. The people I know who breastfed longest I believe did it because it was an easy comfort technique and they didn’t want to hassle of coming up with something more complicated.

Why does comfort need to be complicated, though? Hugs aren't terribly complicated, and I'm guessing you think hugging your children is okay even as they progress beyond toddlerhood. I can't see why it's 'grim' in any way. Can you expand?

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 24/11/2022 18:39

antelopevalley · 24/11/2022 18:34

God I would not want to work somewhere where colleagues hug each other. I think it is inappropriate.

And to me that is really, really sad. Inappropriate to show compassion? Why would it bother you so much to see a colleague who is having a bad day getting a hug?

MilkyYay · 24/11/2022 18:39

I’m scratching my head about how it benefits the mother.

Many mothers enjoy breastfeeding and are sad when it ends.

This. Also many people enjoy the very physical nurturing of a baby and wish to prolong it. Plenty of people also like to feel very specifically needed & wanted and enjoy the feeling that they can provide something literally no one else can.

antelopevalley · 24/11/2022 18:36

terriblemomm · 24/11/2022 18:25

I’m scratching my head about how it benefits the mother.

Many mothers enjoy breastfeeding and are sad when it ends.

antelopevalley · 24/11/2022 18:34

God I would not want to work somewhere where colleagues hug each other. I think it is inappropriate.

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 24/11/2022 18:32

TheOrigRights · 24/11/2022 16:55

Hugs from your colleagues?

I've hugged and been hugged by colleagues, but only once they have become friends as well as colleagues and mostly outside of the work environment (exceptions being maybe conferences where I haven't seen a colleague for a long time).

I don't think I would ever approach a colleague and ask for a hug if I'm having a bad day. In fact I usually retreat into myself.

Yes hugs from colleagues, and I've hugged colleagues when they are having a bad day. We all care about each other and understand that sometimes a person needs a hug.

terriblemomm · 24/11/2022 18:30

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 24/11/2022 18:27

I agrée with “as long as it suits you and the child”

What I do think is that as babies become toddlers, it’s perfectly ok to make it a routine thing and not “on demand”. I don’t think it’s doing your 4 yr any favours for them to be able to walk up to you and open your blouse, as I’ve seen happen.

I definitely don’t let mine just lift up my shirt especially in public. Some mother described their kids screaming for milk in public. I think if mine started doing that I might have to wean her. I could not handle that. Lol. There definitely needs to be healthy boundaries with this as well as everything else. lol. We are very much in a routine. First thing in the morning, after breakfast, before nap time and then before and after dinner and then bedtime.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 24/11/2022 18:27

I agrée with “as long as it suits you and the child”

What I do think is that as babies become toddlers, it’s perfectly ok to make it a routine thing and not “on demand”. I don’t think it’s doing your 4 yr any favours for them to be able to walk up to you and open your blouse, as I’ve seen happen.

terriblemomm · 24/11/2022 18:25

PinkSyCo · 24/11/2022 17:21

Two years tops. Beyond that is for the mother’s benefit rather than the child’s imo.

I’m scratching my head about how it benefits the mother.

AegonT · 24/11/2022 18:20

Over the age of 7 years. They would loose the ability to as their adult teeth come in and their mouth shape changes. I fed my oldest till 3.5 years. I'm currently feeding my youngest at 18 months and aiming for 2.5 years; not sure if I want to feed any longer than that this time.

Cornflakes44 · 24/11/2022 18:15

I do think anything over 2 is a bit grim imo. It feels age inappropriate like letting a 4 year old have a dummy or bottle. Fine for a baby not for a toddler. I think once it’s just for comfort rather than food you should transition to other things, cuddles, stories etc. The people I know who breastfed longest I believe did it because it was an easy comfort technique and they didn’t want to hassle of coming up with something more complicated.

LarryandLeon · 24/11/2022 18:10

Saltywalruss · 24/11/2022 18:06

How does it benefit the mother after the child turns two?

I was going to ask this as I have no idea either! I definitely didn’t continue for my benefit!

Saltywalruss · 24/11/2022 18:06

PinkSyCo · 24/11/2022 17:21

Two years tops. Beyond that is for the mother’s benefit rather than the child’s imo.

How does it benefit the mother after the child turns two?

terriblemomm · 24/11/2022 17:57

Autumnalleavestime · 24/11/2022 17:55

In japan for example it’s quite common to breastfeed for a long time

this is very misleading, 90 % of women stop breastfeeding by the age of 2 in Japan, and public Breast feeding is not allowed, women have to go sit in the loo.

globally the average is about 4, but this takes into account 3rd world counties where poor sanitisation, nutrition and poverty is rife

so for example is nearly 100 percent of mothers breastfeeding in Senegal at a year, but less than 20 percent in Europe, with differing rates per country.

the uk is the lowest globally with 0.5 percent of women still breastfeeding ar the age of 1. So the British women on here are in a very small exclusive group. With the advances in nutrition, formula, working women, and the lack of any scientific evidence that after 6 months any health benefit is prevalent, then women are doing what’s right for their families,

women in Japan don’t feed for a long time, unless you class 2 years as a long time and in comparison the the west averages it could be argued it is.

Well where I am from I confess it is a long time because it is even debated whether one should breastfeed till 6 months sadly… 😅

Autumnalleavestime · 24/11/2022 17:55

In japan for example it’s quite common to breastfeed for a long time

this is very misleading, 90 % of women stop breastfeeding by the age of 2 in Japan, and public Breast feeding is not allowed, women have to go sit in the loo.

globally the average is about 4, but this takes into account 3rd world counties where poor sanitisation, nutrition and poverty is rife

so for example is nearly 100 percent of mothers breastfeeding in Senegal at a year, but less than 20 percent in Europe, with differing rates per country.

the uk is the lowest globally with 0.5 percent of women still breastfeeding ar the age of 1. So the British women on here are in a very small exclusive group. With the advances in nutrition, formula, working women, and the lack of any scientific evidence that after 6 months any health benefit is prevalent, then women are doing what’s right for their families,

women in Japan don’t feed for a long time, unless you class 2 years as a long time and in comparison the the west averages it could be argued it is.

Suemademedoit · 24/11/2022 17:31

FloorWipes · 24/11/2022 17:16

Are you purporting to know me better than I know myself? If so, there’s nothing credible in any of your contributions to this thread.

I don’t need to know you personally - I know about human psychology and we’re all quite similar.

The Oracle, eh? Let every other poster be on notice that you have arrived, you know about human psychology and you have The Answer.

Good grief, woman. A little self-awareness wouldn’t go amiss. Everyone has an opinion, some are similar, some aren’t. They’re opinions, by definition neither right nor wrong. Some may be based on mistruths (such as yours), but they’re still opinions personal to the poster. If there were a definitive, unarguable answer to the question the OP has asked (which was a request for opinions, not answers, as it happens) we wouldn’t be here.

terriblemomm · 24/11/2022 17:29

User12453315 · 24/11/2022 17:01

This is my honest opinions as someone who did extended BF until 2.5 and weaned for the reason below.

My logic is that I would not be too comfortable with my child having clear memories (later in life as an adult) of how it felt to drink milk out of my boobs or graphically sucking a nipple. This has absolutely nothing to do with sexuality but respecting the boundaries between two bodies. I feel a 4 year old is a separate person and I don't want to force my body parts into her mouth, or have her drink my bodily fluids, as much as it is a habit out of love.

I was BF (for 1 year) and I love my mum but idea of being able to remember how it felt like to drink milk from her boobs gives me a massive ick. I have plenty of clear memories from age 4, and even more age 5. Thankfully those are relatively normal memories of attending nursery, sharing snacks, travelling with my parents etc. I don't feel that remembering how it felt to suck milk out of human boobs is a very "normal" (purely statistically speaking) to have during your entire adult life.

Nobody can predict the relationship they will have with their adult children. There are thousands of things that can crop up down the line (obviously not all preventable through breast milk). Should there ever be problems, then the fact that they can remember nursing could easily be twisted as co-dependency or separation issues that stemmed from early childhood. As an adult you will not think it was so wonderful because of the "closeness and comfort", which is an immediate effect that happens now and will eventually forgotten. You are just left with the graphic memory of nursing which you need to somehow deal with.

Not coming down on you or anything. I think you have every right to feel the way you do and to draw boundaries based on that. But I guess from my perspective I remember taking baths with my mother and even though I would obviously never want to do that as an adult they are fond memories and not traumatizing at all. I think People can discern the difference that it was age appropriate. In japan for example it’s quite common to breastfeed for a long time. Those children remember breastfeeding when they become adults. They aren’t traumatized by it. But I respect your feelings and I’m glad that you weened if you weren’t comfortable with that idea.

LarryandLeon · 24/11/2022 17:26

Hi OP, my DD is now 4 & was obsessed with having breast milk. I was actually forced to stop before she turned 3 as unfortunately I developed cancer. Otherwise there is no doubt in my mind that she would still be going! I never expected to breastfeed for so long but it worked for us. In fact even though I no longer produce milk my DD still likes a cuddle with the ‘boobs.’ I have to say that I don’t tell people in real life as I have definitely felt judgement. But keep going as long as it works for you!

LarryandLeon · 24/11/2022 17:26

Hi OP, my DD is now 4 & was obsessed with having breast milk. I was actually forced to stop before she turned 3 as unfortunately I developed cancer. Otherwise there is no doubt in my mind that she would still be going! I never expected to breastfeed for so long but it worked for us. In fact even though I no longer produce milk my DD still likes a cuddle with the ‘boobs.’ I have to say that I don’t tell people in real life as I have definitely felt judgement. But keep going as long as it works for you!

LemonDrop22 · 24/11/2022 17:23

I guess I thought about 2 ish.

Having read the comprehensive post about primitive societies' habits, that lines up.

I suppose doing it past that at home/in bed etc is the mum's business and is understandable; they're still very young and need comfort. If they've breast fed all.along, that's a natural go to.

I think we as a society are just not used to seeing breast feeding (to some extent at all) but esp past baby age, so it's our norms and subsequent discomfort that is the issue.

Brainfogmcfogface · 24/11/2022 17:21

My daughter is almost 4 and just this week has self weaned. My oldest self weaned at around 18 months.
Before I had kids I thought breastfeeding past the baby stage was just weird, but now, knowing the power it has to sooth, calm and heal i think it’s absolutely fine to keep going. I love seeing older children bf, but I think had mine kept going till 5 I would have weaned for selfish reasons as mine mainly used it to aid sleep or when poorly/upset, so meant they would hang off me so I’d want to help them find other ways to sooth, but I wouldn’t judge anyone who carried on if they’re happy to do so.

PinkSyCo · 24/11/2022 17:21

Two years tops. Beyond that is for the mother’s benefit rather than the child’s imo.

DearHorse · 24/11/2022 17:19

User12453315 · 24/11/2022 17:01

This is my honest opinions as someone who did extended BF until 2.5 and weaned for the reason below.

My logic is that I would not be too comfortable with my child having clear memories (later in life as an adult) of how it felt to drink milk out of my boobs or graphically sucking a nipple. This has absolutely nothing to do with sexuality but respecting the boundaries between two bodies. I feel a 4 year old is a separate person and I don't want to force my body parts into her mouth, or have her drink my bodily fluids, as much as it is a habit out of love.

I was BF (for 1 year) and I love my mum but idea of being able to remember how it felt like to drink milk from her boobs gives me a massive ick. I have plenty of clear memories from age 4, and even more age 5. Thankfully those are relatively normal memories of attending nursery, sharing snacks, travelling with my parents etc. I don't feel that remembering how it felt to suck milk out of human boobs is a very "normal" (purely statistically speaking) to have during your entire adult life.

Nobody can predict the relationship they will have with their adult children. There are thousands of things that can crop up down the line (obviously not all preventable through breast milk). Should there ever be problems, then the fact that they can remember nursing could easily be twisted as co-dependency or separation issues that stemmed from early childhood. As an adult you will not think it was so wonderful because of the "closeness and comfort", which is an immediate effect that happens now and will eventually forgotten. You are just left with the graphic memory of nursing which you need to somehow deal with.

I remember being breastfed (I was breastfed until I was 3 or so). It is not a graphic memory, just a neutral one. To me, the milk tasted like warm milk with honey.

FloorWipes · 24/11/2022 17:16

Are you purporting to know me better than I know myself? If so, there’s nothing credible in any of your contributions to this thread.

I don’t need to know you personally - I know about human psychology and we’re all quite similar.