Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you have any opinions on how long is 'too long' to breastfeed your child?

414 replies

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:04

Feeling awfully judged and wondering if anyone has an opinion on this?

OP posts:
WeWereInParis · 24/11/2022 14:36

I do sometimes privately wonder with women feeding older toddlers, does the toddler actually intentionally seek out the boob? Or is the mum just sort of going “okay it’s morning/night time routine so it’s breastfeeding time” and the toddler complies. But that’s just because of my experience where DC get to a certain age and stop asking (far too distracted by toddling round/play etc, and preferring to eat snacks).

With my DD she weaned herself down to just two feeds - first thing in the morning and last thing at night - shortly after she turned 1. This gradually reduced in that feeds got shorter, and some would be missed where she didn't ask. She was also able to spend nights away from me without being fussed about not feeding. I only ever fed her when she asked, and when she stopped asking (when I was pregnant with DD2), we just stopped.

MilkyYay · 24/11/2022 14:36

To me it’s not exclusive to breastfeeding, I would also think 4 is too old to sleep in a cot, have a dummy or drink from a bottle.

This, I associate those things with babies and they are somehow incompatible with the much mature development of an older child, a child who can explain their worries, who is happy to be independent at school enjoying time with peers.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 24/11/2022 14:35

@InBlue

I do sometimes privately wonder with women feeding older toddlers, does the toddler actually intentionally seek out the boob? Or is the mum just sort of going “okay it’s morning/night time routine so it’s breastfeeding time” and the toddler complies.

😂😂😂

Oh my god. The idea of a toddler meekly 'complying' with the mother's insistence that they breastfeed. I am genuinely laughing out loud. After being pursued by my 19month old around the grounds of a National Trust house at the weekend to the plaintive and slightly embarassing cry of "BoooooooOOOOOooooobooooOOOOoooo!" this has made me smile.

frozengoose · 24/11/2022 14:34

I think breastfeeding is associated with babies and infants. Like Dummies, cots and mobiles.
Therefore it can seem jaring in the same way a school child using a dummy would be.

But it is a parental choice issue so I wouldn't waste time worrying about what others think. Just focus on what is right for your child.

EarringsandLipstick · 24/11/2022 14:34

Because people associate breasts with sex rather than their biological function

I don't believe this at all & doubt most people do.

But as a PP said, a school going toddler having a soother, sleeping in a cot or eating puréed food would seem less than ideal, and I'd view b/f at that age in a similar light. (While recognising it's none of my business, rightly so!)

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:34

EarringsandLipstick · 24/11/2022 14:32

Like everyone else has said, it's a personal preference and should be guided by the mum & baby / child.

However from my own personal perspective, I feel that like other aspects of early childhood, breast feeding has a natural time limit. My 3 DC self-weaned at about 14 - 18 months, felt right to me as they transitioned to more solids, greater independence, and the acquisition of other skills (language, ability to express their needs & seek comfort in other ways).

I wouldn't in any way judge mothers making other decisions but I do feel there can be a sense of excessive virtue & achievement shown by mothers who do extended b/f (not meaning you OP!)

Agree partially, but I actually disagree with your last comment to an extent. The only other two women I know who breastfed for a long time (age 4 and age 5) kept it very secret due to social judgement.

OP posts:
KitchenFleur · 24/11/2022 14:33

My youngest was 5 when I stopped.
At that point no one outside of my dh and dc knew.
Past 18 months I started to get “bitty” comments (because feeding a toddler is exactly like feeding a massive creepy middle aged man), so it was only done at home.
Family life was stressful, and I think for little ds it was a vital part of every night before bed to wind down.

People have weird attitudes to breastfeeding in this country. If you do it there’s a limited time before people think you’re doing it for your own selfish needs, or you’re doing it for some perversion.

Boobs are very much for men to look at, anything threatening that is to be questioned, dismissed and somehow made dirty. It’s very sad.

BendingSpoons · 24/11/2022 14:33

I am still feeding my almost 4yo. No-one really knows apart from my parents and PIL as it doesn't really come up. Before I had children I thought that feeding past about 18m was a bit odd but now it's just normal.

I'm not sure why people think you need a 'reason' to carry on feeding and try to focus on the purpose e.g. nutrition. My reason is that my DS still wants to and I'm happy to. It's 5 minutes lying down on the bed after bathtime. I'm perfectly happy with that! Although when DS had a 5 day sickness bug and struggled to drink anything it was handy to be able to feed him.

I do get frustrated by this idea of mums forcing it. I had a humongous battle the other day to get DS to take Calpol. I don't see how I could force him to feed when he doesn't want to!

Like you OP my DS goes to nursery, stays the night at grandparents etc. He feeds himself, dresses himself, manages fine without me but when I'm there, still often asks for a feed. It's dropping off and more frequently he will choose a cup of milk instead.

MilkyYay · 24/11/2022 14:33

For me personally if they can hold a conversation with you then it's too old....like age 4....

But why though? Not being goady, just wondering what the actual reason is?

Because we perceive infants differently to older children in terms of having very physical needs, and when a child is talking to you using developed language, you stop perceiving them as an infant.

MyBuggyIsOutToGetMe · 24/11/2022 14:33

Totally agree this is very personal. I fed my older one until he was almost 3 and then stopped because I’d had enough. I’d really wanted him to self-wean but he wasn’t having any of it.

My younger one is nearly 3 and I plan to wean this week. Again, he shows no sign of stopping, though is perfectly happy with alternatives when I’m not there, but it’s stopped being a pleasant experience for me as he’s such a fidget and also keeps grabbing at my other nipple despite me being very firm with him. So I’ve decided I’m ready to stop.

I found it interesting that for me personally, I have reached the point where I want to stop at exactly the same point! (A month shy of their third birthday)

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 24/11/2022 14:32

ThatPirateLady · 24/11/2022 14:26

My 3.5 is still nursing (bloody loads this week as he has cold). I can’t see him weaning before 4. DH wants him finished before school but I genuinely can’t see the point in forcing the issue at this point. He’ll stop when he stops.

in comparison I doubt the baby will still be nursing at 3. Completely different personalities.

i never understand the 'they shouldn't still be doing it when they're at school' thing. I mean, they're not going to be doing it AT school are they?

EarringsandLipstick · 24/11/2022 14:32

Like everyone else has said, it's a personal preference and should be guided by the mum & baby / child.

However from my own personal perspective, I feel that like other aspects of early childhood, breast feeding has a natural time limit. My 3 DC self-weaned at about 14 - 18 months, felt right to me as they transitioned to more solids, greater independence, and the acquisition of other skills (language, ability to express their needs & seek comfort in other ways).

I wouldn't in any way judge mothers making other decisions but I do feel there can be a sense of excessive virtue & achievement shown by mothers who do extended b/f (not meaning you OP!)

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:30

InBlue · 24/11/2022 14:29

For me, aged about 4 would be about the limit.

Both mine self-weaned at about 16 months - as in, around that age, they didn’t ask for it. Unless I actively offered it to them (got my boob out) they wouldn’t think of it. And just as happy with cows milk.

I do sometimes privately wonder with women feeding older toddlers, does the toddler actually intentionally seek out the boob? Or is the mum just sort of going “okay it’s morning/night time routine so it’s breastfeeding time” and the toddler complies. But that’s just because of my experience where DC get to a certain age and stop asking (far too distracted by toddling round/play etc, and preferring to eat snacks).

I think anyone judging a mum for breastfeeding their child is a fucker though.

I can't speak for anyone else, but I only ever breastfeed my son if he asks.

OP posts:
Firen · 24/11/2022 14:30

luxxlisbon · 24/11/2022 14:25

To me it’s not exclusive to breastfeeding, I would also think 4 is too old to sleep in a cot, have a dummy or drink from a bottle.
If someone posted about their school age child still having a dummy I don’t think the thread would be encouraging that.

It doesn’t matter though, people do different things with their children.

I agree with this. A dummy is a good example. I would find it weird if a 10yr old had a dummy, same with breastfeeding at that age. In fact I’d say the age that I’d find breastfeeding odd would be the same age I’d find a dummy odd.

InBlue · 24/11/2022 14:29

For me, aged about 4 would be about the limit.

Both mine self-weaned at about 16 months - as in, around that age, they didn’t ask for it. Unless I actively offered it to them (got my boob out) they wouldn’t think of it. And just as happy with cows milk.

I do sometimes privately wonder with women feeding older toddlers, does the toddler actually intentionally seek out the boob? Or is the mum just sort of going “okay it’s morning/night time routine so it’s breastfeeding time” and the toddler complies. But that’s just because of my experience where DC get to a certain age and stop asking (far too distracted by toddling round/play etc, and preferring to eat snacks).

I think anyone judging a mum for breastfeeding their child is a fucker though.

WeDontNeedToTalkAboutJamie · 24/11/2022 14:29

If either you or the dc wants to stop then stop.

Its nothing to do with anyone else.

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:29

sneezingpandamum · 24/11/2022 14:28

For me personally if they can hold a conversation with you then it's too old....like age 4....

But why though? Not being goady, just wondering what the actual reason is?

OP posts:
MilkyYay · 24/11/2022 14:29

Can anyone explain to me the actual reason WHY it's weird, other than because 'people think it's weird'?

Because I suppose i see oral stimulation as the most basic/primitive form of comfort, and expect that as a baby grows and develops emotionally and with more language, they'll move on to more developed forms of seeking comfort.

trailerandtractor · 24/11/2022 14:29

It’s all personal opinion though. My personal opinion is 18 months, possibly 2 years max. I fed dc until 18 months.

I have a 4 year old who is at school. I would find feeding her now, gross.

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:28

PuttingDownRoots · 24/11/2022 14:27

Because people associate breasts with sex rather than their biological function

Wouldn't it then apply to breastfeeding all kids though regardless of age?

OP posts:
sneezingpandamum · 24/11/2022 14:28

For me personally if they can hold a conversation with you then it's too old....like age 4....

UpdownUpdownAltogetherNow · 24/11/2022 14:28

I fed DS until he self weaned at 4. There’s nothing with it as long as you are both happy.

PuttingDownRoots · 24/11/2022 14:27

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:22

Can anyone explain to me the actual reason WHY it's weird, other than because 'people think it's weird'?

Because people associate breasts with sex rather than their biological function

ThatPirateLady · 24/11/2022 14:26

My 3.5 is still nursing (bloody loads this week as he has cold). I can’t see him weaning before 4. DH wants him finished before school but I genuinely can’t see the point in forcing the issue at this point. He’ll stop when he stops.

in comparison I doubt the baby will still be nursing at 3. Completely different personalities.

luxxlisbon · 24/11/2022 14:25

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:22

Can anyone explain to me the actual reason WHY it's weird, other than because 'people think it's weird'?

To me it’s not exclusive to breastfeeding, I would also think 4 is too old to sleep in a cot, have a dummy or drink from a bottle.
If someone posted about their school age child still having a dummy I don’t think the thread would be encouraging that.

It doesn’t matter though, people do different things with their children.