Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you have any opinions on how long is 'too long' to breastfeed your child?

414 replies

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:04

Feeling awfully judged and wondering if anyone has an opinion on this?

OP posts:
VestaTilley · 24/11/2022 14:46

I think when either of you has had enough.

Nutritionally though I’m not sure it’s necessary past 2 in developed countries, and any later than that I (personally) think it starts to be more about what the Mum wants than what the baby needs.

carefulcalculator · 24/11/2022 14:45

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:22

Can anyone explain to me the actual reason WHY it's weird, other than because 'people think it's weird'?

There is no reason, it is just that over 3 years you are definitely a statistical outlier.

There are plenty of people who think Bf-ing is 'weird' or 'gross' fullstop!

RobertaFirmino · 24/11/2022 14:45

It's your business, nobody else's. However, when he starts school, do bear in mind that the playground can be a cruel place and if he is still on the breast and tells his classmates this, he may get teased.

MyBuggyIsOutToGetMe · 24/11/2022 14:45

I followed a “don’t offer, don’t refuse” policy from around 18 months or so. Except in practice sometimes I would refuse but perhaps looking to distract rather than a straight out “no”. My younger one appears in the bedroom at 0630 and his morning greeting is “Boob!”. It is very much child-led in my house.

I cannot emphasise how delighted I would have been if they self-weaned so I hadn’t had to be the meanie refusing. In practice, I tried to wean my first as gently as possible including books to prepare, and it made no difference whatsoever. The idea I get a kick out of it is an interesting one, as is the idea you could force feed a toddler….

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:44

I wonder if my African heritage has anything to do with this. I have a photo of my mum breastfeeding me whilst on a carrier, on her back 😂 I literally had grabbed her boob, and was 'feeding round the corner' as she used to call it.

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 24/11/2022 14:44

Because I suppose i see oral stimulation as the most basic/primitive form of comfort, and expect that as a baby grows and develops emotionally and with more language, they'll move on to more developed forms of seeking comfort.

I agree with this, and with the dummy analogy others have made. Rightly or wrongly we feel that a child above a certain age should have moved on from sucking things for comfort. It feels like it infantilises them.

For me they probably hit that point at about 3-4.

AnuSTart · 24/11/2022 14:44

Some of the comments...

4 is only school age in UK. It's terribly young and exhausting. Where I live it's 7.

InBlue · 24/11/2022 14:43

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 24/11/2022 14:35

@InBlue

I do sometimes privately wonder with women feeding older toddlers, does the toddler actually intentionally seek out the boob? Or is the mum just sort of going “okay it’s morning/night time routine so it’s breastfeeding time” and the toddler complies.

😂😂😂

Oh my god. The idea of a toddler meekly 'complying' with the mother's insistence that they breastfeed. I am genuinely laughing out loud. After being pursued by my 19month old around the grounds of a National Trust house at the weekend to the plaintive and slightly embarassing cry of "BoooooooOOOOOooooobooooOOOOoooo!" this has made me smile.

Don’t see why it’s so funny. I realised I was doing just this. Just automatically going to breastfeed my toddler at bedtime because it’s the bedtime routine. They didn’t ask, but happy to take it. I’ve recently realised I can just stick them in the cot, and they go to sleep without it. So yes, I probably could have kept it going for ages just from routine.

I’ve also had a 16m old toddler shouting “more milk!” at me up until a few weeks ago. But by “older toddlers” I actually meant “older toddlers”… like 2/3/4 year olds.

AnuSTart · 24/11/2022 14:42

LolaSmiles · 24/11/2022 14:09

Too long is when it's no longer the right thing for either the mother or the child.
As long as mother and child are happy then it's nobody else's business

This.

I breastfed all of mine (5) the longest was 4yrs 7months. I had to literally drag him off me then though.

It's no ones business in the end but you and your child.
I am sorry you feel judged. I did and then I got to the point where I didn't give a damn. I also moved to a country where it is common to see women feeding toddlers on benches so that helps.

MilkyYay · 24/11/2022 14:41

But equally they don't need sugary sweets, they don't need TV, they don't need loads of things that we still give them because they enjoy it, it's soothing/fun/calming/kills some time etc. We don't NEED everything we have.

Ok, so why don't we all continue breastfeeding to adulthood?

defi · 24/11/2022 14:41

Once they start moving onto mostly solids

MilkyYay · 24/11/2022 14:41

Even if they're still also using language to communicate? Are doing well and very independent? I just don't see the two as mutually exclusive

I don't either at an earlier age, but of course breastfeeding for comfort gets superseded and replaced by more advanced, complex stages.

Breastfeeding is an early developmental stage, so i would find it odd it continuing past a certain point. Like at some stage it feels like a child holding onto to developmentally immature traits.

Kinsters · 24/11/2022 14:40

I really don't know. I breastfed my daughter until about 18 months and stopped as I was pregnant. My 11mo son only really feeds when he wants to sleep so I think we'll stop in a couple of months. My neighbour breastfed her little girl until she was almost 3 and it didn't seem weird or anything.

Personally I think I'd make them stop before going to school/pre-school as I'd be worried they'd be teased or called a baby.

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:39

EarringsandLipstick · 24/11/2022 14:37

But why though? Not being goady, just wondering what the actual reason is?

It's inherent in the answer OP! Everything has a stage, in terms of childhood, in my view. Nappy-wearing, weaning, sleeping in a cot - and breast feeding. They don't need it beyond a certain age, and developmentally they are ready to move on

(With same caveat as my other posts - none of my business etc)

But equally they don't need sugary sweets, they don't need TV, they don't need loads of things that we still give them because they enjoy it, it's soothing/fun/calming/kills some time etc. We don't NEED everything we have.

OP posts:
MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 24/11/2022 14:39

Firen · 24/11/2022 14:30

I agree with this. A dummy is a good example. I would find it weird if a 10yr old had a dummy, same with breastfeeding at that age. In fact I’d say the age that I’d find breastfeeding odd would be the same age I’d find a dummy odd.

The difference is dummies are an artificial substitute for the comfort of breastfeeding. So in a sense they're always weird (not judging, my eldest had a dummy as well as bf because she had undiagnosed allergies and needed to comfort suckle even when I wasn't around/available to feed to deal with pain). And they can be bad for dental health once teeth are grown in. Not so breastfeeding.

EarringsandLipstick · 24/11/2022 14:39

The only other two women I know who breastfed for a long time (age 4 and age 5) kept it very secret due to social judgement.

And I'm sorry to hear that - while I'm expressing a view here it's only as you've asked. In real life, this decision along with any other parenting choice, is none of my business to judge in any way.

Fuwari · 24/11/2022 14:39

I have a skewed perspective due to being a victim of abuse. But for me it’s uncomfortable to see anyone other than small babies being breast fed. I know logically there’s nothing sexual in it, and I know it’s 100% my issue. But you did ask for opinions. For that reason yes I would feel uncomfortable seeing someone breast feed a 4yr old. But sounds like you only do it at home anyway?

Anyone who does breastfeed older DC in public though, if someone nearby looks uncomfortable, understand it is probably their issue. I just can’t help how it makes me feel.

DuchessofSandwich · 24/11/2022 14:38

I'd stop at school age do they won't say anything about it and get bullied.

Well, that is if they want to feed until then. DD stopped wanting the breast at 20 months. I'd also judge if a toddler is forced to feed. It should ve a natural thing.

Vallmo47 · 24/11/2022 14:38

I breastfed my daughter until she was 2 and felt judged throughout, to be completely honest. I don’t tend to get involved in this conversation anymore because people get so heated. For me I think whatever goes on in your private home is your business, as long as you are both happy with it. If I was pushed for an opinion, I’d say school age because I wouldn’t want my child to want me for this reason at the wrong time when I wasn’t available. I definitely felt 2 was the right time for us.

Duttercup · 24/11/2022 14:38

I fed until 2.5 and then I woke up one day and decided to stop. No real reason, I just felt like I'd done my bit.

I never fed her in the day time, apart from on planes, after 12 monthsish so never dealt with any pushback.

People love to have opinions on child-raising. If it isn't breastfeeding, it's something else.

saltofcelery · 24/11/2022 14:37

No view on anyone else's breastfeeding journey and I certainly don't judge. For my first, exactly three years, for my second and a little bit longer than that. I'm expecting my third (and final!) baby and looking forward to doing it all over again all being well.

Cotswoldmama · 24/11/2022 14:37

I breastfed until my son was 3 the last year was very occasionally. I got a really bad cough and fractured my ribs from coughing so we stopped quite suddenly as I was too ill and in too much pain. We were trying to ease off but probably would have done it much more gently. I think personally if they're too old for a dummy then that's the age to stop around 3.5-4 but obviously some children self wean much earlier.

EarringsandLipstick · 24/11/2022 14:37

But why though? Not being goady, just wondering what the actual reason is?

It's inherent in the answer OP! Everything has a stage, in terms of childhood, in my view. Nappy-wearing, weaning, sleeping in a cot - and breast feeding. They don't need it beyond a certain age, and developmentally they are ready to move on

(With same caveat as my other posts - none of my business etc)

InBlue · 24/11/2022 14:37

@elephantonacid Okay fair enough. I think that’s fine then. It doesn’t matter what anyone else thinks.

All children are soooo different. You only need to look at the school gates for Reception class to see that some seem a lot younger or more sensitive than others.

Regardless of whether they’re breastfeed til 6 months or 6 years or not at all, it all evens out in the end.

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:36

MilkyYay · 24/11/2022 14:33

For me personally if they can hold a conversation with you then it's too old....like age 4....

But why though? Not being goady, just wondering what the actual reason is?

Because we perceive infants differently to older children in terms of having very physical needs, and when a child is talking to you using developed language, you stop perceiving them as an infant.

Even if they're still also using language to communicate? Are doing well and very independent? I just don't see the two as mutually exclusive (sorry not trying to be argumentative I just find it all really interesting).

OP posts: