Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you have any opinions on how long is 'too long' to breastfeed your child?

414 replies

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:04

Feeling awfully judged and wondering if anyone has an opinion on this?

OP posts:
Lilgamesh2 · 24/11/2022 15:21

Haven't RTFT but I suspect it's good to continue as long as the child wants to, probably a bit like taking a probiotic. I don't believe the nutrition benefits have really been fully studied so I disagree with the assumption that extended breastfeeding is just for comfort. For example, I have read that babies breastfed to age 1 are less likely to develop Crohn's disease but the study stopped following the kids past age 1 - so maybe we should feed to 2! Or 3! Or 5! Who knows.

DD has allergies and a higher than average likelihood of developing Crohns so I will breastfeed her at least to age 2 and a half. I only want to stop when I conceive the next child.

Feeding at age 4 is a fantastic effort, you should be proud not having to worry about people judging you.

Freudpenis · 24/11/2022 15:20

CoastalWave · 24/11/2022 15:00

I feel breastfeeding is for babies.

There's your answer!

When I see toddlers/children being breastfed it makes me feel very uneasy - clearly for the adults benefit not the child.

Oh dear lord. I expected the replies to be more educated than this.
I'm trying to cut down on my nearly three year old's feeds. Sometimes I say no or later when we're sitting together on the sofa. Now that is for MY benefit. Toddlers love breastfeeding

ThatPirateLady · 24/11/2022 15:20

pompei8309 · 24/11/2022 15:13

What you produce is not milk , don’t fool yourself only because it’s white . I understand it provides some comfort for your child but it definitively doesn’t provide nutrition. Sorry but Little Britain comes to mind here 😂he goes to nursery, he’s out of nappies , he feeds himself, I would stop before it became a problem.

What the fuck do you think breast milk is if not milk?

what about me? I’ve got a 3 year old and a baby. Am I producing milk for them or your mythical nutrition free white liquid?

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 24/11/2022 15:19

SleepingStandingUp · 24/11/2022 15:05

As someone who's milk dried up at 6 months both times in just impressed yours is still going with such infrequent feeds. Do you have to express if he doesn't take any for a few days?

Once milk supply is well established it's much more flexible I've found. In both directions actually. So I'm going away for a few days this weekend, I'm taking my pump but don't expect to need to use it more than once a day (DD feeds much more often than that!). And when I get back, she'll soon enough have me back to usual production.

RunLolaRun102 · 24/11/2022 15:19

pompei8309 · 24/11/2022 15:13

What you produce is not milk , don’t fool yourself only because it’s white . I understand it provides some comfort for your child but it definitively doesn’t provide nutrition. Sorry but Little Britain comes to mind here 😂he goes to nursery, he’s out of nappies , he feeds himself, I would stop before it became a problem.

WHO thinks it’s still breastmilk and that it provides nutrition. New emerging research even says kids bf until 4 seem to live longer and healthier due to the dna transmission that occurs. I think I’ll believe them over some random troll thank you very much.

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 15:17

SleepingStandingUp · 24/11/2022 15:16

Yes sorry I know that, I was asking CoatalWave what they thought you were getting from it as they thought you bf for you not your child

Ah sorry. My bad.

OP posts:
YellowTreeHouse · 24/11/2022 15:17

Zibbydib · 24/11/2022 15:10

My opinion is that mothers who breastfeed older toddlers/kids is that it’s more for their needs rather than the child’s. If you stopped tomorrow I wonder if your child would be bothered?

What do you gain from breastfeeding him? (Im genuinely interested, not being arsey!)

I never ask my toddler if she wants to breastfeed. She asks me when she wants some.

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 15:17

pompei8309 · 24/11/2022 15:13

What you produce is not milk , don’t fool yourself only because it’s white . I understand it provides some comfort for your child but it definitively doesn’t provide nutrition. Sorry but Little Britain comes to mind here 😂he goes to nursery, he’s out of nappies , he feeds himself, I would stop before it became a problem.

Did you just say, it's not milk? Your opinion on it is your opinion but it most certainly is milk 😂

OP posts:
KitchenFleur · 24/11/2022 15:16

pompei8309 · 24/11/2022 15:13

What you produce is not milk , don’t fool yourself only because it’s white . I understand it provides some comfort for your child but it definitively doesn’t provide nutrition. Sorry but Little Britain comes to mind here 😂he goes to nursery, he’s out of nappies , he feeds himself, I would stop before it became a problem.

Not sure where you’ve got this from?

Breastmilk adapts to the child’s needs. Obviously a 4 year old won’t need as much nutrition from breastfeeding as a baby, but breasts still provide valuable antibodies tailored to the child’s needs.

Of course with that level of ignorance Little Britain will come to mind 🙄

SleepingStandingUp · 24/11/2022 15:16

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 15:10

None at all other than a happy child.

Yes sorry I know that, I was asking CoatalWave what they thought you were getting from it as they thought you bf for you not your child

RunLolaRun102 · 24/11/2022 15:15

Zibbydib · 24/11/2022 15:10

My opinion is that mothers who breastfeed older toddlers/kids is that it’s more for their needs rather than the child’s. If you stopped tomorrow I wonder if your child would be bothered?

What do you gain from breastfeeding him? (Im genuinely interested, not being arsey!)

My nearly 3 yo chases me for bf, still feeds 2-3 times a day, and cries himself into hysterics if he doesn’t get it. It’s not about me at all. But his needs. He sees bf as comfort, the milk seems to help when he’s cold or under the weather, and he often processes his day at the breast. Lol he tells me about everything that’s happened to him at nursery during the day

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 24/11/2022 15:14

CoastalWave · 24/11/2022 15:00

I feel breastfeeding is for babies.

There's your answer!

When I see toddlers/children being breastfed it makes me feel very uneasy - clearly for the adults benefit not the child.

What benefit exactly?

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 15:14

ladycarlotta · 24/11/2022 15:11

I understand why you keep asking why! It's because you're not getting solid answers. All the answers you're chasing up are like "well it's weird isn't it" and "but if a child can talk they shouldn't breastfeed" and "developmentally they're past that stage" - but there is no elaboration on or explanation of any of those statements. It's fair to ask why again when the answer isn't satisfactory!

Yes maybe I didn't articulate that very well.

OP posts:
pompei8309 · 24/11/2022 15:13

What you produce is not milk , don’t fool yourself only because it’s white . I understand it provides some comfort for your child but it definitively doesn’t provide nutrition. Sorry but Little Britain comes to mind here 😂he goes to nursery, he’s out of nappies , he feeds himself, I would stop before it became a problem.

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 15:13

Dogtooth · 24/11/2022 15:11

Do you still have milk if you don't feed for weeks? Genuinely interested - he's not just having a suck?

In all honestly I'd raise an eyebrow at someone breastfeeding a four year old. I think it's because at birth you have total intimacy with your baby, then you step back and reclaim privacy bit by bit. I have a 3.5 yo who sees me naked etc but I'd find breastfeeding him too intimate. It's just a line that's drawn at some point. Maybe it's sad that it is!

Everyone is different. Some people's milk dried up very quickly. Some not at all. All to do with prolactin levels.

OP posts:
KitchenFleur · 24/11/2022 15:12

“Breastfeeding is an early developmental stage, so i would find it odd it continuing past a certain point. Like at some stage it feels like a child holding onto to developmentally immature traits.”

This is a very western centric view.
Many cultures feed as standard until the child stops, many of those places also use breastfeeding as their main contraception.
I don’t agree that natural term breastfeeding can be holding onto developmentally immature traits because all children come to an age where they can no longer breastfeed - when that age is 5-7 years old that’s surely within that developmental age, even if western society disagrees.

PurpleWisteria1 · 24/11/2022 15:12

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 14:08

My child has just turned 4 and I don't breastfeed him out and about, but he will still breastfeed when he's poorly, very tired, anxious etc. Feels completely normal but have learnt that I'm highly judged by those around me for doing this.

Your business OP. As long as it’s right for you and your child don’t take a blind bit of notice about what anyone else thinks.
Plenty or people bf past 4 years- it’s just stigmatised so you don’t tend to hear about it so much

RunLolaRun102 · 24/11/2022 15:12

MilkyYay · 24/11/2022 15:04

The 'biological norm' as far as can be determined from tribal societies seems to be around 5-7 years old (as the milk teeth go).

The studies that "show" this are quite flawed. I've read them. They are by no means universal agreed with.

Academic Studies are led by white people and flawed as a result because white colonial attitudes to breasts destroyed bf across the globe. Ancient written texts from South Asia / East Asia / the Middle East show us a more accurate picture - that bf until milk teeth fell out was commonplace. In my ‘home village’ in India we even still have a ‘saasuji health manual’ (it’s a manual for married women whose mil was dead) from the 14th century that clearly stated bf until the first teeth come out will ensure children survive past their 5th birthdays.

MrsMarigold · 24/11/2022 15:12

My DD breastfed till she was six. Yep, years not months. She was very difficult to get off, and I literally had to wear roll necks tucked into my knickers. It has had no ill effects and she is a very smart, sweet child. After age three it was only at home when it was just the two of us. My DS was only breastfed for four months.

Dogtooth · 24/11/2022 15:11

Do you still have milk if you don't feed for weeks? Genuinely interested - he's not just having a suck?

In all honestly I'd raise an eyebrow at someone breastfeeding a four year old. I think it's because at birth you have total intimacy with your baby, then you step back and reclaim privacy bit by bit. I have a 3.5 yo who sees me naked etc but I'd find breastfeeding him too intimate. It's just a line that's drawn at some point. Maybe it's sad that it is!

ladycarlotta · 24/11/2022 15:11

elephantonacid · 24/11/2022 15:04

Totally disagree. There's absolutely nothing wrong with asking people who have a different opinion to me 'why?'. I'm not being angry or abusive. I'm debating with people, which I think is quite normal, no? I don't believe I have offended anyone.

I understand why you keep asking why! It's because you're not getting solid answers. All the answers you're chasing up are like "well it's weird isn't it" and "but if a child can talk they shouldn't breastfeed" and "developmentally they're past that stage" - but there is no elaboration on or explanation of any of those statements. It's fair to ask why again when the answer isn't satisfactory!

saltofcelery · 24/11/2022 15:11

@SleepingStandingUp you didn't ask me and I have no explanation, but my milk never dried up. Since my first birth, I've always had a supply - not as big as the first year but I could easily feed a baby right now.

I don't know why this is!

Tripsabroad · 24/11/2022 15:11

I'd like to say 7 in line with WHO guidance, but if I'm honest with myself I'd find it weird to see that.

I am currently assuming I'll stop when dc self-weans. I'm dreading it, I love breastfeeding. I suppose I'm expecting that to be before school age - not sure what I'll do if dc is still keen! Probably what some of my friends did (keep doing it in private and keep quiet about it).

Mahanii · 24/11/2022 15:10

My eldest self weaned when she was 14 months, I then found out I was pregnant, I think the milk must have changed. My youngest would have kept going forever but I was done by 22 months.
I respect those who keep going as long as they are clear with themselves on their motive. (I have met some mums who are determined to keep feeding even when it seems their child doesn't want to.)

Zibbydib · 24/11/2022 15:10

My opinion is that mothers who breastfeed older toddlers/kids is that it’s more for their needs rather than the child’s. If you stopped tomorrow I wonder if your child would be bothered?

What do you gain from breastfeeding him? (Im genuinely interested, not being arsey!)