Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send DS to school with a stab pack?

163 replies

PolkaDotMankini · 24/11/2022 11:44

DS is in year 8 (ages 12-13) at senior school. It's a great school but DS has been caught up in a couple of fights this half term and I'm doing the classic mum worrying. After the first one I bought a couple of Israeli bandages. They're the type used for serious bleeding.

WIBU to send him on a first aid course and pack one of these bandages in his bag, just in case? DS thinks I'm being way OTT.

OP posts:
PuckyMup · 24/11/2022 14:26

CoastalWave · 24/11/2022 14:18

It's bullshit. You can always move schools and move house/jobs

People just don't want to do it because they like their nice lifestyles and would rather turn a blind eye to it all.

I would ask why people aren't thinking ahead about this?! I was immediately thinking about schools as soon as we were pregnant and moved house accordingly. We will probably move again in 2 years time in order to secure a shorter school run. My kids always come first. A house is just bricks. No job is worth your kid getting stabbed.

Tell me you don’t live hand to mouth without telling me you live hand to mouth.

Moving means money. Even renting means deposit, rent, money (or time, resources, friends) to move your things, paying for new utilities etc. factoring in travel to work and school costs etc etc

HikingforScenery · 24/11/2022 14:26

Op, your post has made me terribly sad!

It’s reminded me of a campaign I saw a while ago where a mum was campaigning for packs to be made readily available in the event that someone is stabbed in the street. Is this the same as a bleeding

i cannot imagine you having to worry about the actual threat of this. My heart goes out to you.

If you put it in his bag, who would use it? Heaven forbid but in the moment, how would do none know he’s got it?

perhaps he could use it to save someone.

If it’ll give you peace of mind and he’s not opposed to carry it, I’d say why not.

On the other hand, you don’t want to be ‘jinxing’ him!

Freddosforall · 24/11/2022 14:25

Dunno why people are giving the OP a hard time. We're in a similar position of choosing the least shit, still quite scary school. Schools round here are either shit or massively over subscribed so only rich people living in the tiny catchment area can get in. What is she supposed to do?

PuckyMup · 24/11/2022 14:23

GreyTS · 24/11/2022 14:02

How do so many posters have no idea of the reality of raising teenage boys in big cities? Even living in supposedly good areas, every family member I had living in London emigrated when their sons reached secondary. These are people living in houses worth millions and they didn't feel their sons were safe either at school or walking home after. It's especially scary if your sons aren't white, I suppose it's a version of white privileged not knowing 🤷‍♀️

100% White privilege.

I am white and have recently had my eyes opened to a lot of the struggles of black men.
eg Stormzys recent interview with Louis Theroux, his knife scars were alien to his (white) work makes but he didn’t consider them unusual .. that’s insane no matter how you look at it :(

Discoh · 24/11/2022 14:21

There is no way on earth I would send my child to a school where I thought there was a real risk of them being stabbed.

I know it's not easy to move area but I would be doing absolutely everything in my power to make that happen.

CoastalWave · 24/11/2022 14:18

DuchessDandelion · 24/11/2022 12:52

Do some people really think that others have options as far as schooling is concerned?

Lots of reasons why simply moving schools won't be possible for some people.

It's bullshit. You can always move schools and move house/jobs

People just don't want to do it because they like their nice lifestyles and would rather turn a blind eye to it all.

I would ask why people aren't thinking ahead about this?! I was immediately thinking about schools as soon as we were pregnant and moved house accordingly. We will probably move again in 2 years time in order to secure a shorter school run. My kids always come first. A house is just bricks. No job is worth your kid getting stabbed.

CoastalWave · 24/11/2022 14:13

PolkaDotMankini · 24/11/2022 12:20

And put him where? The other schools are worse. Our catchment school has gang issues and a child was killed a few years ago. I obviously didn't send him there!

I would move house.

I certainly wouldn't be sending my child that school (or the others if they're worse)

azimuth299 · 24/11/2022 14:12

If I was so concerned that my child would be stabbed that I was considering this, I would take him out of school. Homeschool, move somewhere else, whatever. Either the risk is lower than you imagine and you're overreacting massively, or the risk is the level that you believe it is and you're underreacting massively.

HolidaysAreComin · 24/11/2022 14:12

What have I just read? I thought by stab pack you meant stab vest (bad enough), but you mean packing your son off to school with bandages? I think if you are stabbed having a bandage is going to do very little as you'd be stabbed and very unlikely to do anything to help yourself.

If you think he might be the victim of a violent assault, it would probably be a better idea to remove him from the situation?

TheABC · 24/11/2022 14:09

OP, I think the first aid class is a good call, as is a self-defence course. It won't make him into a kick-arse ninja, but it will teach him to look for the signs and how to disengage. The best way to 'win' a fight is not to get dragged into one.

Finally, if targeting is a problem, get him a rape alarm and tell him to keep it in his pocket. They are easy to activate, easy to carry and the attacker's pain from the unexpected noise should give him a few seconds to get away if he is threatened with a knife.

Plexie · 24/11/2022 14:02

I'm in the minority who think it's an OK idea and don't understand the mockery the OP is receiving.

I interpreted it to mean that DS might need to use first aid on someone else, not that he would necessarily use it on himself.

As for some of the comments:

There don't need to be lots of stabbings in your local area to make you concerned about knife crime. It might only happen once but you could be the bystander who could make a difference between life and death.

Collect him from school so that he's not at risk: so he has to be accompanied by an adult whenever he's outside the house, until he's at adult? Don't be so bloody ridiculous.

Move to a different school: it's not the school that's the problem, there's the possibility of knife crime in the area. And no, that doesn't mean the OP is necessarily living in a gang-infested high-crime corner of London. I live in a safe part of London and there have been very occasional street stabbings in the wider area over the past 10+ years. And one lad who was stabbed while visiting a different part of London.

It's unlikely to happen, so what's the point: the likelihood may be low, but the possible outcome is extreme (ie death). Weighing that up, it's worth making an effort because the value of your action in the, admittedly unlikely, situation might make the difference between someone dying on the pavement or surviving to live many more decades. Or maybe only surviving a few hours, but that's enough time to get to them hospital and having their loved ones joining them.

Stabbing scenarios or not, learning first aid is a good idea - for everyone, including the OP her/himself. I'd also recommend the CitizenAid app which gives advice for a range of emergency scenarios (eg multiple casualties in a major incident, terrorist attacks etc). Obviously read it occasionally first, don't wait until you're faced with an emergency. And, yes, you'll probably be too panicked to scroll through your mobile phone for advice, but it might just give you confidence to deal with the situation or a memory of what information to give to the emergency services.

www.citizenaid.org/

Lavenderflower · 24/11/2022 14:02

The responses are interesting.

It seem as some people lived very charmed lives. Gang culture, shooting and stabbing exist all over the UK particularly in large cities.

School fight are nothing new! This has alway happened. It not unusual for neighbouring schools to fight each other, even in affluent.

Boy and young men fight - it's a fact of life. This quite normal but sometimes people take things too far.

I think it is sensible for your son to learn how to defend himself and learn how to navigate these situation. Perhaps get in contact with an organisation that supports teenagers and young men - they can provide advice and information on what to do.

GreyTS · 24/11/2022 14:02

How do so many posters have no idea of the reality of raising teenage boys in big cities? Even living in supposedly good areas, every family member I had living in London emigrated when their sons reached secondary. These are people living in houses worth millions and they didn't feel their sons were safe either at school or walking home after. It's especially scary if your sons aren't white, I suppose it's a version of white privileged not knowing 🤷‍♀️

FunnyTalks · 24/11/2022 13:57

www.google.com/amp/s/www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/doctors-to-teach-london-pupils-how-to-give-stabbing-victims-first-aid-a4232321.html%3famp

I've seen this mentioned much more recently in the news too but couldn't find a link. Kids are dying from wounds which are survivable, if somebody gets there fast enough.

You're not at all unreasonable OP. I feel safe - in daylight - in my London borough, but most of the day-time stabbings are against teens /young people. I'm very careful where my kid goes alone.

Glittertwins · 24/11/2022 13:52

He needs to walk away and not get involved at all. A teenage boy was stabbed to death near us a few years ago - he was trying to break up a fight that he wasn't previously involved in. He got killed for trying to do the right thing.

EverydayImPuzzling · 24/11/2022 13:49

The ignorance from some of the replies here is astounding.

I went to secondary school fifteen years ago. I lived in an affluent, leafy London suburb. I went to the nearest catholic school which was a short bus ride away but in a different area. It was rated Outstanding, had better academic credentials than local private schools and was highly oversubscribed every year.

Sounds ideal, right?

Yet every year there were students who got caught up in gangs which escalated to incidents with other students from nearby schools. There was often talks of fights after school and some years a child would get stabbed.

I don’t know what I’d do in your position OP, but you’re not wrong to be aware of the risk and put measures in place accordingly. Working with the school is a good idea.

Blankscreen · 24/11/2022 13:47

It's not the school!! It's the area in which is situated but sadly I think it is wide spread.

Somuchgoo · 24/11/2022 13:45

Between the bandage and the roleplaying, I'm worried that you'll be creating a lot of anxiety in your child.

I personally think it's a ridiculous idea - and I say that as someone who was threatened with a knife at school (he put it up to my face and threatened to 'rearrange my face with it').

In an emergency, he's unlikely to be in a fit state to either use it himself or explain to someone else that he even had it. What's far more likely is it'll fall out of his bag and he'll be mocked for it.

If you are that worried, you need to work out if it's a justifiable worry or not. If it is justifiable, then move him to a better school. If its not justifiable, then please get help for your anxiety before you pass it along to him.

Blankscreen · 24/11/2022 13:44

OP I understand what you are saying and think you have been given a hard time.

No easy answers for you. I guess the main one is can you pick him after school to avoid running the gauntlet of the walk home.

Crinkle77 · 24/11/2022 13:37

What an over reaction.

Legallypinkish · 24/11/2022 13:37

It’s not just bad areas. We live in a “nice” area with a good school locally. 2 year 8’s got stabbed a couple of weeks ago by another 2 year 8’s. Thankfully both boys are ok. I’ve no idea who the kids are, they’ve all been permanently excluded. It’s so scary.

pallache · 24/11/2022 13:36

well there's a helpful suggestion!

2bazookas · 24/11/2022 13:35

No need. Just buy a giant roll of cotton wool, wrap him in it like a cocoon and pack DS away in his bedroom under the duvet.

He'll be perfectly safe there until you and DH die.

Cleothecat75 · 24/11/2022 13:27

Underanothersky · 24/11/2022 12:14

I'd pull my child out of school if I thought this was an issue.

Do you mean you would home educate? We live in a ‘nice middle class area’. The high school is ofsted good and has a generally good reputation. I’m told their are kids carrying knives there. I don’t think moving schools will help, gang culture and carrying knives is more widespread and I hate that. As OP says she is at the best school in the area already, it’s not a school problem, it’s a community/society problem. My dc know first aid, but I think the bandage is a bit OTT. Basic first aid is always a good idea though.
I remember the winter before covid, it transpired there was a drugs problem on the town park in the evenings. There was uproar on social media about how such a lovely town could possibly have drug dealers in it. Quite a revelation to the middle aged towns folk that the problems they associate with city centres and ‘rough’ areas are actually also problems in leafy green towns.

dad11122 · 24/11/2022 13:23

FixTheBone · 24/11/2022 11:57

First aid is fine, the bandage is probably OTT.

If someone gets stabbed in a limb, I've never encountered a situation where direct pressure hasn't been enough, and paramedics carry these bandages / tourniquets in any case.

If someone gets stabbed somewhere important, nothing is going to help that you can do at the roadside without some serious skills, equipment and training.

DOI Major trauma surgeon.

I have encountered situations where direct pressure isn't enough or where it's very difficult to get the pressure right. An Israeli bandage is a fantastic bit of equipment that's easy to use and I hope no one has to use one but where does it stop? Do you give him packing gauze, face mask for CPR, etc? If stabbing are a big problem then go for it, they're not going to take up much room in his bag.