Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send DS to school with a stab pack?

163 replies

PolkaDotMankini · 24/11/2022 11:44

DS is in year 8 (ages 12-13) at senior school. It's a great school but DS has been caught up in a couple of fights this half term and I'm doing the classic mum worrying. After the first one I bought a couple of Israeli bandages. They're the type used for serious bleeding.

WIBU to send him on a first aid course and pack one of these bandages in his bag, just in case? DS thinks I'm being way OTT.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Redebs · 24/11/2022 20:12

MarmaladeFatkins · 24/11/2022 16:34

@carefulcalculator I live inner city with relatively high knife crime. unless your kids are involved in gangs the likelihood of being stabbed, particularly at school is tiny..even the kids IN gangs rarely get stabbed. it would be interesting to hear how/why this is something that OP is fretting about

Yes, this.
I've lived and taught in some very difficult areas and am certain that the risk of being a random victim of knife crime for most young men is very low.
Traffic accidents and alcohol/substance abuse issues are absolutely much more common.

Stravaig · 24/11/2022 17:24

I'd prefer to spend my money on bringing first aid and self-defence providers into their school so that they can all benefit than on moving DS out.

This is a wonderful approach, @PolkaDotMankini

If you can find the right trainers, please emphasise conflict facilitation and violence de-escalation training. Kids can learn these skills remarkably effectively and will practice among their peers.

Better to defuse a situation, than have to physically defend yourself once it is underway, or have to patch people up afterwards.

All of them - defuse, defend, doctor - are valuable throughout life, especially if/as our world grows more precarious. (In case you need arguments to help sway others :)

dreamingbohemian · 24/11/2022 17:09

carefulcalculator · 24/11/2022 16:07

The risk of knife crime in some areas are real and people are 'freaking' because it is not very jolly for your child to be seriously assaulted or murdered Hmm

Yes I know, I live in such an area.

My question is why people are telling the OP to go live in a caravan because of the extremely remote chance of her kid being stabbed, while they all go about driving their children everywhere despite the statistically higher chance that a child will be killed or injured in a car accident.

I mean, several thousand children a year are killed or injured on the roads, I think it is. But I don't see people being told to uproot their entire lives so they never have to put their kids in a car.

Pumpkin20222 · 24/11/2022 16:49

Can the school run a first aid course for all pupils? At least so they know how to apply pressure to a limb injury and how catastrophic stab injuries are. If they all learn some skills they are all going to be safer.

Also, look into whether there is an NGO in the area that can ram home the dangers of gang violence and how to avoid getting caught up in it.

MarmaladeFatkins · 24/11/2022 16:34

@carefulcalculator I live inner city with relatively high knife crime. unless your kids are involved in gangs the likelihood of being stabbed, particularly at school is tiny..even the kids IN gangs rarely get stabbed. it would be interesting to hear how/why this is something that OP is fretting about

MarmaladeFatkins · 24/11/2022 16:30

you said that no one has ever turned up in school with a knife, as far as you know. so there have been no stabbing associated with the school and the kids that go there? in your area?

you are going on first aid course and buying bandages because your lad has been in a few fights?

how have you jumped from a few fights, to victim of knife crime?

KittieDaley · 24/11/2022 16:09

Notmysolution · 24/11/2022 15:44

You did get that not everyone has the financial resources to buy their way out of the shit things that happen in their life?

Lots of us just have to adapt as best we can.

The OP has already said that moving is a possibility.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 24/11/2022 16:09

KittieDaley · 24/11/2022 12:26

I would be moving to an area with better schools.

It's probably nice to have the financial ability to do so. Pity that the children more likely to be exposed to such things most are those generally in the least economically and geographically mobile families.

OP, first aid is important - with the 'never attempt to remove a weapon and always call an ambulance for a stab wound, no matter how tiny it appears to be' drilled into him now.

carefulcalculator · 24/11/2022 16:07

dreamingbohemian · 24/11/2022 15:45

I live in a place where I am very confident my children are safe (apart from cars, of course

Personally I'm glad to live in a city where my son never has to be driven anywhere. Why is everyone freaking about the extremely remote chance of being stabbed when it's much more dangerous (statistically) to be spending so much time in cars? I'm pretty sure more kids are killed and injured in car accidents every year than stabbed.

Bad things can happen everywhere, you can live in your wholesome rural safe place and your child can still be killed by a car or get addicted to drugs or be sexually assaulted. All of those things are far more likely than being stabbed.

The risk of knife crime in some areas are real and people are 'freaking' because it is not very jolly for your child to be seriously assaulted or murdered Hmm

carefulcalculator · 24/11/2022 16:05

toomuchlaundry · 24/11/2022 15:24

For those saying they would move, or glad they live in a 'nice' area, you do realise these ares maybe rife with county lines. We live in a town that probably fits the nice bill. If I wasn't involved with schools I probably wouldn't know that there is a huge issue with county lines. With drugs there is a likelihood of knives. There have been no knife incidents here yet but I would never think it wasn't a possibility

It is always a possibility, I went to a school where there were knives. But if you review crime stats they are very varied, the risk is not the same in every place.

Feef83 · 24/11/2022 16:04

but what’s your point that should say

Feef83 · 24/11/2022 16:03

I live in a SE commuter town.
I have very little cause to be worried about gangs and gun crime
i worry a heck of a lot about when my DC get their driving licences

if I lived where the OP does in a city and hardly anyone drives - then my worry would be flipped

if I lived in an area where there was high gun crime AND many teens drove - I would be worried about both!!

The worry as a parent is broad!

Feef83 · 24/11/2022 16:01

dreamingbohemian · 24/11/2022 15:45

I live in a place where I am very confident my children are safe (apart from cars, of course

Personally I'm glad to live in a city where my son never has to be driven anywhere. Why is everyone freaking about the extremely remote chance of being stabbed when it's much more dangerous (statistically) to be spending so much time in cars? I'm pretty sure more kids are killed and injured in car accidents every year than stabbed.

Bad things can happen everywhere, you can live in your wholesome rural safe place and your child can still be killed by a car or get addicted to drugs or be sexually assaulted. All of those things are far more likely than being stabbed.

Parents your what’s your point in respect of the OP…. The Op shouldn’t move? OR Shouldn’t buy the Stab vest? Or shouldn’t do both?

dreamingbohemian · 24/11/2022 15:45

I live in a place where I am very confident my children are safe (apart from cars, of course

Personally I'm glad to live in a city where my son never has to be driven anywhere. Why is everyone freaking about the extremely remote chance of being stabbed when it's much more dangerous (statistically) to be spending so much time in cars? I'm pretty sure more kids are killed and injured in car accidents every year than stabbed.

Bad things can happen everywhere, you can live in your wholesome rural safe place and your child can still be killed by a car or get addicted to drugs or be sexually assaulted. All of those things are far more likely than being stabbed.

Notmysolution · 24/11/2022 15:44

KittieDaley · 24/11/2022 12:26

I would be moving to an area with better schools.

You did get that not everyone has the financial resources to buy their way out of the shit things that happen in their life?

Lots of us just have to adapt as best we can.

theleafandnotthetree · 24/11/2022 15:40

PolkaDotMankini · 24/11/2022 15:02

If I was concerned that DS was getting into a bad crowd then we'd move. We're in the fortunate position of that being a possibility open to us. I'm not particularly worried about that though. I've known his close friends since they were all at nursery together, am friends with their parents, they all play in the same football team etc. They're good kids and more interested in football and doing well at school than gangs (at least for now). It's some of the older kids who worry me. Yesterday's incident involved two older boys calling his dark-skinned friend a racist name and strangling the friend when he objected. DS pulled them off and got thrown to the floor (he's the shortest in his year and had no idea what he's doing in a fight!).

However, that also means that I care about these boys. I'd prefer to spend my money on bringing first aid and self-defence providers into their school so that they can all benefit than on moving DS out. If it makes any child at that school think twice about violence or know what to do in the worst scenario then it makes my son safer.

Can I just say you sound like such a good person, I can't believe how many on here are advocating purely individualist 'solutions' with no thought for the other children in these situations, the other good things about the children's lives (including life long friendships and connections, etc.), other links to community. Society never improves if the automatic solution is to just yank ourselves away from situations which aren't completely of our liking, we have to try and fight to make things better where we are.

CheeseAndNutellaSandwich · 24/11/2022 15:39

Definitely move schools if it’s that bad. I mean, being careful is fine but that’s ridiculous. What’s next, are you going to get him a firearm?

PolkaDotMankini · 24/11/2022 15:37

I think some of the more drastic suggestions on here have actually really helped me to reflect on the real level of risk. As I'm not willing to uproot the family or plunge us all into poverty, I'm clearly not as worried as I thought I was.

There are also some sensible things I can do that have come out of this thread that will actually help.

OP posts:
Polyethyl · 24/11/2022 15:34

Someone upthread has already mentioned the citizen aid app. Please do load it on your phones. It is a wonderful guide to how to keep people alive in all sorts of different first aid crisis.

www.citizenaid.org

toomuchlaundry · 24/11/2022 15:24

For those saying they would move, or glad they live in a 'nice' area, you do realise these ares maybe rife with county lines. We live in a town that probably fits the nice bill. If I wasn't involved with schools I probably wouldn't know that there is a huge issue with county lines. With drugs there is a likelihood of knives. There have been no knife incidents here yet but I would never think it wasn't a possibility

Bythehairywartsonmywitchychin · 24/11/2022 15:22

Reading some of the posts a lot of people seem to live in bubbles. Knife crime is a real issue at the moment, and isn’t just an issue in poor/bad areas.

carefulcalculator · 24/11/2022 15:20

PolkaDotMankini · 24/11/2022 15:16

We could move, but it's a bit drastic: pull two DC out of the friendship groups they've known all their lives and take on debt to the tune of hundreds of thousands of pounds to move somewhere we don't know is going to be any better. Our town is relatively cheap, housing-wise, so we'd be moving from an ok area with the best school to an area we don't know at all, that might be even worse. The only way I see that helping is if either DC was getting into a bad crowd.

I think you might have become inured to your situation. You are considering providing bandages in case your child is stabbed.

I live in a place where I am very confident my children are safe (apart from cars, of course, the eternal menace in every area) - this is the biggest privilege IMO.

I don't think it is easy for eveyone to move, many people can not, but I do think it is strange to be able to and not do it, given what you posted.

Bythehairywartsonmywitchychin · 24/11/2022 15:19

Just to add. The nice areas where I live have issues with guns and stabbing, especially the town centre. One lad was also stabbed outside of a school (which admittedly is not in a nice area), however I know someone who has a teen boy and does live in a ‘nice’ area who is being targeted by teens that carry knives, as it’s seems to be a thing that teens carry knives.

PolkaDotMankini · 24/11/2022 15:16

carefulcalculator · 24/11/2022 15:07

@PolkaDotMankini I think if you have the option to move then you are doing the wrong thing by your child in staying.

I reject entirely the idea that anyone can upa and move - but if you can, I do not understand why you continue to put your child in this situation.

We could move, but it's a bit drastic: pull two DC out of the friendship groups they've known all their lives and take on debt to the tune of hundreds of thousands of pounds to move somewhere we don't know is going to be any better. Our town is relatively cheap, housing-wise, so we'd be moving from an ok area with the best school to an area we don't know at all, that might be even worse. The only way I see that helping is if either DC was getting into a bad crowd.

OP posts:
Bythehairywartsonmywitchychin · 24/11/2022 15:16

Knife crime also happens in nice areas, so moving wouldn’t necessarily help. Also if you live in a ‘nice’ area you’re probably more at risk of being mugged/burgled etc so those saying just move, that won’t solve the issue with crime…..