Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask here for formula advice

36 replies

Orangepolentacake · 24/11/2022 09:25

Posting here for traffic as I see similar threads in other parts have not had many responses

Need to switch baby from Hipp as it’s not going down well.
DC was on cow and gate (and was fine on it + infacol) but I found the ready made bottles had these white lumps in them, which they say it’s safe but I’m not comfortable giving him lumpy milk.
then switched to Hipp a week ago, following a transition of mixing formulas until he only had Hipp in the bottle. He drinks it fine but, since on Hipp only, seems hungrier, to have more wind, squirms a lot, is upset more after a feed, brings back up a lot more and it’s just the cheesiest smell when he does bring it back up. So I’m thinking we need to change formulas again.
I need to be able to have the option of the ready made bottles.
thinking of switching to SMA or kendamil, any advice?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IamnotwhouthinkIam · 25/11/2022 21:59

I only managed 2 weeks with the Hipp too OP - that cheesy smell made me feel like I was going to vomit. Good to know the premixed Kendamil exists - I know powder is so much cheaper but new parent exhaustion + screaming baby makes pre-mixed formula so tempting if you can manage to afford it imo (especially since you aren't supposed to mix formula in advance now).

Btw don't tempted to change from the size 1 Mam teats imo. Several of our local HV's said DS should be on size 2 when he wasn't even 3 months yet and that persisting with them would help his wind (their idea being that quicker feeds = less air taken in, in fact according to them even newborns are given size 2 teats in hospital). All size 2 Mam teats did was turn my DS mild (mostly silent) reflux, into true reflux eg. masses of vomit after every feed, sometimes even up to an hour or so later😢It made little difference to his wind and his esophageal sphincter must have gotten irritated/damaged because of it as his reflux didn't then ease for months even after going back to the slower teats.

We always used room temp or slightly warmed formula too - didn't make a difference to mine, but maybe it will your DC. Paced feeding DID help a little bit though - although trying to get DS to stop drinking even for short pauses, let alone stopping to try to get a burp! was never the easiest😂Also try very, very slightly untwisting the bottom of the Mam bottles once they are filled - we didn't realise you needed to at first to help let any air in the bottle out (you can hear the difference in the vents then as they drink vs being screwed tightly shut - but you need to be careful obviously not to untwist too much and have the milk leak out instead😱).

chibsortig · 25/11/2022 19:32

Mine preferred formula warm rather than straight from the fridge. Also have you tried powder version rather than ready made?
It's just trial error I'm afraid.

ThePumpking · 25/11/2022 19:20

Orangepolentacake · 25/11/2022 13:13

Thanks all for the advice on paced feeding - I was already doing aspects of it but not all (need to change bottle angle) so will adapt. I also try to burp him every 30oz (as much as possible), have stayed with size 1 teats (we use MAM bottles) although he’s 3 months old, and keep him upright for some time after a feed. Haven’t paid attention to whether temperature makes a difference but will - he is happy to drink straight from the fridge but maybe that’s not a good thing

The size one teats may actually cause more of a problem, I found with my youngest when we switched to the next size up the colic decreased almost instantly and we always pace feed too. May be worth a try while you give the new milk time to settle. Also if you have a savers near you they usually have pre made kendamil for £1

Janedoe82 · 25/11/2022 18:23

senior30 Not a medic but I manage AHPs including HV and Midwives and I am trained to advise on infant feeding. And I know that you can change milk whenever you want.
For decades formula manufacturers have told nonsense to Health Professionals, especially HV and Midwives to get them to subconsciously promote their formulas and keep mothers using their product. There is a reason they are no allowed in hospitals, doctor surgery’s and family centres anymore!

Orangepolentacake · 25/11/2022 13:18

I didn’t check with a midwife/HV if I could change formula as I wasn’t changing type of formula (eg cow’s milk to soya), only brand and, honestly, I would’ve changed it anyways - I’m not comfortable with those lumps in cow & gate and how they responded to it so have lost confidence.

agree that 2 changes in a week aren’t ideal and maybe I should’ve given Hipp more time but it just stinks so bad of cheese

OP posts:
Orangepolentacake · 25/11/2022 13:13

Thanks all for the advice on paced feeding - I was already doing aspects of it but not all (need to change bottle angle) so will adapt. I also try to burp him every 30oz (as much as possible), have stayed with size 1 teats (we use MAM bottles) although he’s 3 months old, and keep him upright for some time after a feed. Haven’t paid attention to whether temperature makes a difference but will - he is happy to drink straight from the fridge but maybe that’s not a good thing

OP posts:
Orangepolentacake · 25/11/2022 13:05

IamnotwhouthinkIam · 24/11/2022 23:10

My DS had the same painful wind on formula too. Funnily enough we tried Cow and Gate, Aptimil and Hipp Organic - all the available ready mixed ones and none of them suited him - wind was worst on Aptimil but the very cheesy smelling vomit worst on Hipp.

Never tried SMA or Kendamil, but I wonder if the Kendamil might have been better since I don't think it contains fish oil unlike the other brands and apparently some young babies are more sensitive to fish oil? I think Kendamil doesn't do a pre mixed version but if you are happy to mix, that's the one I'd personally give a go.

I was planning to try it next as I'd heard good things about Kendamil if a DC has mild unknown allergies (but not serious enough to be truly lactose or CMP intolerant etc) - but luckily my DS suddenly got the hang of breast feeding better and his wind eased a lot. I realise that part doesn't help you though, sorry! - although I think wind does tend to improve naturally too as the weeks go by (as their digestive system matures), so fingers crossed for you, hang in there!

@IamnotwhouthinkIam glad to hear your LO got the hang of BF! I couldn’t BF for medical reasons so stuck in the formula minefield
that Hipp cheesy vomit stinks so bad!! I found Kendamil does 200ml bottles - in tesco and waitrose, 10p cheaper in tesco (£1.20) I think they don’t have the bottles on their website tho.

OP posts:
senior30 · 25/11/2022 13:02

Janedoe82 · 24/11/2022 21:31

You can change milk whenever you like. This is a myth from the formula industry.

Are you a medical professional?

Orangepolentacake · 25/11/2022 12:54

thanks for the info @Janedoe82 - I’m aware it’s tightly (and rightly!) regulated so all formulas are of equal nutritional value, and that if something is found to be of benefit to babies then all formulas must have that, and that labels such as “organic” don’t mean much when it comes to formula due to the amount of pesticides residue allowed, etc. ingredients can however be different and come from different source eg DHA can be from fish or plant source, so formulas aren’t all exactly the same. I’m also observing how it affects my baby/his reaction and there is a difference.

OP posts:
Herecomestreble1 · 25/11/2022 05:34

If your baby has reflux, Kendamil may not be the best choice. It was far too rich for mine and made him worse.

KeyWorker · 25/11/2022 04:32

I second the advice about paced bottle feeding, give it a try. it’s unlikely to one particular milk over another causing a problem, they are all so similar they are practically the same.

None of the formulas are like breast milk, they are based an a cows milk protein. That’s something I they say to sell it to you.

HeyyyMrNoodle · 25/11/2022 00:03

My daughter is on on cow and gate and has been fine but have friends who have used kendamil for their DC who haven't settled on other milks.

FWIW when my daughter was younger she struggled a bit more on the premade C&G whereas she was perfecltly fine with the powder, but as she got older she's been fine (as long as it's not cold from the fridge)

ChildcareIsBroken · 24/11/2022 23:56

Search pace bottle feeding and try that, it should help. It's likely your baby is drinking too much too fast. If that doesn't work and you're worried, contact your GP.

IamnotwhouthinkIam · 24/11/2022 23:10

My DS had the same painful wind on formula too. Funnily enough we tried Cow and Gate, Aptimil and Hipp Organic - all the available ready mixed ones and none of them suited him - wind was worst on Aptimil but the very cheesy smelling vomit worst on Hipp.

Never tried SMA or Kendamil, but I wonder if the Kendamil might have been better since I don't think it contains fish oil unlike the other brands and apparently some young babies are more sensitive to fish oil? I think Kendamil doesn't do a pre mixed version but if you are happy to mix, that's the one I'd personally give a go.

I was planning to try it next as I'd heard good things about Kendamil if a DC has mild unknown allergies (but not serious enough to be truly lactose or CMP intolerant etc) - but luckily my DS suddenly got the hang of breast feeding better and his wind eased a lot. I realise that part doesn't help you though, sorry! - although I think wind does tend to improve naturally too as the weeks go by (as their digestive system matures), so fingers crossed for you, hang in there!

Janedoe82 · 24/11/2022 22:11

A lot of the issues are more to do with the type of bottle, how the baby is fed and the amount they are fed and what happens after as opposed to the actual formula.

Speedweed · 24/11/2022 22:08

Also OP, don't do a sudden switch - do a slow transition as their digestive system can revolt from the change rather than the milk (75% old brand and 25% new brand for a few days, then 50/50 for a few more, the 25/75 etc).

Also consider the temperature too, mine had more issues with fridge cold rather than room temp/warmed.

Janedoe82 · 24/11/2022 22:07

There are a lot of badly informed GPs, midwives and Health Visitors in relation to infant feeding and a huge amount of time, money and effort is being spent trying to re educate them on the actual science of infant feeding.

CatSeany · 24/11/2022 22:06

We use Kendamil and my daughter loves it. We switched from breast feeding to mostly formula feeding when I went back to work at 9 months and have had no issues.

FamKeNekson · 24/11/2022 22:02

Kendamil
Kendamil
Kendamil

That is all!

ThePumpking · 24/11/2022 21:58

Janedoe82 · 24/11/2022 21:44

This is not the advice of the World Health Organistion. Honestly it is ALL clever marketing. There is no evidence that formula makes babies have collick

Well that's not what the medical professionals I spoke to regarding it said. And it also ignores the fact that the ingredients list is different therefore, they are different. And the difference in ingredients can mean one ingredient aggravates the immature digestive system while another does not. No one says its the formula causing colic but a specific ingredient might set it off for different babies.

Janedoe82 · 24/11/2022 21:51

I have phrased that badly- cows milk can make babies have collick due to their immature digestive system but that will happen regardless of which formula used.

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 24/11/2022 21:49

Aldi mamia for powder and aptamil for ready made as a combo

WooWooWinnie · 24/11/2022 21:46

Why don’t you go back to cow & gate but not the ready made one?

Janedoe82 · 24/11/2022 21:44

This is not the advice of the World Health Organistion. Honestly it is ALL clever marketing. There is no evidence that formula makes babies have collick

ThePumpking · 24/11/2022 21:39

Janedoe82 · 24/11/2022 20:49

They are all the same!! have to be made to the same formula to meet safety requirements. I have just spent days on training about this.
It is all an absolute con. None of them are a replica of breastmilk- including aptamil who have been called out many times on these claims.
You also can switch milk however often you like.

They all have the same nutrional values but you literally only have to look at the ingredients list to know they are not all the same the same.

My eldest was colicky, struggled to poo and refluxy on cow and gate, fine on hipp. Clearly the different ingredients play a part in how a baby reacts.

When we switched we were told to give it at least 2 weeks op to let their belly settle on the new milk.