Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’d want to do the same - mother kills children’s abuser

616 replies

HermioneKipper · 24/11/2022 08:18

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/sarah-sands-kill-sex-abuse-paedophile-b2231508.html

i think any parent would do the same if given the chance

OP posts:
Dutch1e · 25/11/2022 11:52

Lockheart · 24/11/2022 18:15

Out of interest what does it say about someone who jumps straight to murder without even the courtesy of a trial?

There were enough trials for 24 prior convictions. Any one of those trials could have protected these 3 boys and their mother from this absolute monster. They chose not to.

Namechangedforthisonetoday · 25/11/2022 08:38

FOJN Thank you for providing that info regarding sentencing. Hopefully that will make very interesting reading to some x

Namechangedforthisonetoday · 25/11/2022 08:36

lagioconda I’m not sure if we’ve had crossed wires on the prison/microchip point, but I’m advocating for sex offenders to be locked up for life so there would be no parole, probation etc. Those costs wouldn’t come into it. Of course we have an appeals process but I suppose that would need to be reviewed too (I am not advocating for the removal of appeals to be clear). Essentially I would support whole of life tariffs for paedophiles. There is absolutely no way when factoring in every last detail of the ‘microchip’ idea, that prison would be more expensive.

Wallstick · 25/11/2022 07:56

Yeah 24 convictions is a lot. I don't agree with America's three strikes usually but in these cases where the harm is so huge, three strikes would have been more than enough to see where the man was heading.

ThatsAboutEnoughOfThat · 25/11/2022 02:23

Justice is bullshit. It is a lie told to keep people quiet and in line.

We have legal systems, not justice systems. Legal systems created by powerful men, for men.

There is no justice.

FOJN · 25/11/2022 01:36

BadNomad · 25/11/2022 01:15

She didn't act in self-defence. She wasn't trying to protect her boys. She wasn't trying to protect anyone else's children. This wasn't an act of community service. She acted in anger. In vengeance. She wanted to hurt the person who hurt her children. That action hurt her sons. She knows this. That's why she says she regrets it.

I agree she didn't act in self defence but I don't think it was vengeance either. She went armed to protect herself whilst she asked him to plead guilty to spare her son's the trauma of having to testify at trial. He told her her son's were lying but she'd already been dealing with her children having nightmares because of the abuse. I suspect at that point she saw red and stabbed him.

FOJN · 25/11/2022 01:32

Suffrajitsu · 24/11/2022 23:41

He would have got an extra long sentence due to the extra factor of his deceitful conduct in changing his name. It's really unlikely that he would be out of prison in anything under 15 years, if he even survived that long. After all, he was 77 and there is no indication that he lived a healthy life.

15 years? You're having a laugh. 14 years is the maximum sentence for this type of offence and the majority of offenders aren't sentenced to anything like that. Prisoners have to behave pretty badly to serve their full sentence, most will serve half at best.

Here's the sentencing guidelines:

www.sentencingcouncil.org.uk/offences/magistrates-court/item/sexual-assault-of-a-child-under-13/

With the limited information we have about the details of the offences I would estimate that he commited category 2 offences with starting point A for culpability which means a sentence of 4 years with a range of 3 - 7 years. Even if we assume that the judge considers the prior offences to be a significant aggravating factor warranting the maximum sentence then he would only have got 7 years, out in three and a half or less. Even if he was convicted separately for all three boys the courts seem to have a habit of stipulating sentences run concurrently rather than consecutively which means his sentence wouldn't be any longer.

BadNomad · 25/11/2022 01:15

She didn't act in self-defence. She wasn't trying to protect her boys. She wasn't trying to protect anyone else's children. This wasn't an act of community service. She acted in anger. In vengeance. She wanted to hurt the person who hurt her children. That action hurt her sons. She knows this. That's why she says she regrets it.

Kanaloa · 25/11/2022 01:13

Novum · 24/11/2022 22:26

Do we know that these children did actually accuse this man of rape? I can only see references to assault in the reports. I fully accept that sexual assault of children is a very serious offence but it's not the same thing.

I was responding to a poster sarcastically saying ‘oh so if your child says their teacher abused them you run down to school with a knife?’ I was just saying there’s a difference between a child saying a random personally abused them and saying a known sex abuser abused them. One you’d be more careful, supporting and believing while investigating took place, the other you’d immediately believe whole heartedly.

But that poster was just trying to case doubt on these children and make them out as liars.

Frezia · 25/11/2022 01:01

@Suffrajitsu The irony! There already are state condoned killings and innocent people get killed in our name too. How many fanatics get the medals? I don't know how many, I haven't analysed their profiles. But it is naive to think there aren't fanatics among those performing state condoned killings.
That's the thing about fanatics - they'll kill regardless of the sanction which is hardly a deterrent at all. But the criminal justice system should serve to keep such people away from the public and make the world safer. What Sarah did made the world safer and I doubt anyone else is in danger from her. She was clearly not a fanatic with an agenda but a desperate cornered mother trying to protect her children from further harm by a prolific paedophile, after the state had the chance to do so and failed, putting them and others at risk again.

I'm saying this particular woman should've been let go for self defence or a similar argument. Im not arguing that from a legal standpoint but a moral one. The fact that this individual case should've been judged differently doesn't mean we're giving carte blanche for people to kill each other. It's already in the law anyway that not every taking of life carries a prison sentence or even a guilty verdict.

BadNomad · 25/11/2022 00:35

I'd probably just say it was illegal to do so but only give the killer a slap on the wrist, suspended sentence.

But that's not enough to deter other people from doing it. If people think killing someone in the name of vengeance will only get them a suspended sentence, then more people will go around killing people they think need to be punished. Can't you see the chaos that would create? The law is not there just to punish. It's there to deter.

Florenz · 25/11/2022 00:19

Luredbyapomegranate · 25/11/2022 00:06

You cannot have a civilised society when people take justice into their own hands.

Apart from that, I have no particular sympathy for him, but she deprived her children of a mother for 4 years, which is not on.

It’s a terrible thing to suffer as a parent, but what she did was selfish, giving her to her (totally understandable) desire for vengeance, rather than putting her children’s welfare first - especially awful given the trauma they’d experienced.

I am sure her kids love her, hence the expressions of support, but they will have been damaged by her as well as him, and when they are older they will realise that.

People already do take justice into their own hands.

I'd probably just say it was illegal to do so but only give the killer a slap on the wrist, suspended sentence.

Luredbyapomegranate · 25/11/2022 00:06

You cannot have a civilised society when people take justice into their own hands.

Apart from that, I have no particular sympathy for him, but she deprived her children of a mother for 4 years, which is not on.

It’s a terrible thing to suffer as a parent, but what she did was selfish, giving her to her (totally understandable) desire for vengeance, rather than putting her children’s welfare first - especially awful given the trauma they’d experienced.

I am sure her kids love her, hence the expressions of support, but they will have been damaged by her as well as him, and when they are older they will realise that.

Suffrajitsu · 24/11/2022 23:55

Dubonet · 24/11/2022 23:27

The regulated controlled system that you seem to think exists failed, many many times. Leaving this predator free to abuse more children.

It didn't just fail by allowing this monster bail, it had failed many times befoe that by allowing him to be free when he was a huge danger to children.

It failed in this instance. That doesn't for one second justify abandoning the system and allowing state-sanctioned killing, especially given that that would inevitably lead to innocent people being cold-bloodedly killed in our name.

Suffrajitsu · 24/11/2022 23:52

PetraBP · 24/11/2022 23:13

The state should do it.

Child sexual abuse is worse than murder and should be punished worse than murder.

Life imprisonment for murder.

Death penalty for child sexual abuse.

What are you going to do about the inevitable wrongful convictions that would happen? You can't unkill someone.

Suffrajitsu · 24/11/2022 23:47

Frezia · 24/11/2022 22:10

If we give her a medal, we're sending out a signal that it's open season for any fanatic go go out and kill people s/he thinks shouldn't be allowed to live.

We already give medals to plenty of people who decide who shouldn't be allowed to live.

How many fanatics who kill people do we give medals to?

Sevensins · 24/11/2022 23:44

jonesy1999 · 24/11/2022 14:33

I'm so very sorry @Sevensins.

And I understand your thinking.

Flowers

Thank-you xx

Suffrajitsu · 24/11/2022 23:41

downanduppy · 24/11/2022 22:09

With the English justice system, he would have been out and abusing other children within a decade. She did what the court system refuses to do, protect victims. Fair play to her.

He would have got an extra long sentence due to the extra factor of his deceitful conduct in changing his name. It's really unlikely that he would be out of prison in anything under 15 years, if he even survived that long. After all, he was 77 and there is no indication that he lived a healthy life.

Suffrajitsu · 24/11/2022 23:35

Frezia · 24/11/2022 22:06

I think we all know on a visceral level that she served him his comeuppance which by all accounts he would not have received otherwise. It's cruel that she and her boys were them robbed of family healing time, a great price she paid for dealing justice. But sometimes things need to be done no matter the cost.

The criminal justice system on the other hand is completely abhorrent.

Completely?

Was it completely abhorrent when, say, it locked up Ian Huntley and Rose West?

LaGioconda · 24/11/2022 23:29

Namechangedforthisonetoday · 24/11/2022 21:57

lagioconda you are being deliberately obtuse. You know full well I was referring to everything surrounding this fantasy microchip as I explained. The poster herself wasn’t proposing microchipping and leaving them. Apparently they were going to be monitored by apps. A ‘team’ would be dispatched at the first sign of trouble. Do you have any idea how much things like this would cost? Then when they reoffended (because they would), the costs to take the case to court again, the police time, the prep work, compensation to the victim as they’d have been failed by the ‘microchip’. It would all cost more than £40 odd thousand and if you don’t believe that to be the case, you are delusional. The fact that you believe the buck would stop with a microchip tells me all I need to know.

You are still being unrealistic. If you are going to assume reoffending in these circumstances, then you must also bring into your calculations all the costs of the parole system including rearresting people who don't keep to parole conditions, compensation for their victims, etc. Then there are all the costs of rehabilitating ex-prisoners back into the community and supervising them there. Costs of prison would still come out way ahead.

Dubonet · 24/11/2022 23:27

Suffrajitsu · 24/11/2022 23:03

I'm bothered by it because I want to live in a society where people are only punished in a regulated, controlled system after being convicted beyond reasonable doubt. Anything else leaves open not just the possibility, but the virtual certainty, that innocent people will be killed. Also because when we say "you must not kill, but it's OK for us to do so" we become hypocrites well below the level of the individuals in question.

The regulated controlled system that you seem to think exists failed, many many times. Leaving this predator free to abuse more children.

It didn't just fail by allowing this monster bail, it had failed many times befoe that by allowing him to be free when he was a huge danger to children.

Suffrajitsu · 24/11/2022 23:21

LemonDrop22 · 24/11/2022 21:45

Oh were they tossed out on the street Charles Dickens style.

🙄

They had to live with their grandmother in overcrowded accommodation. Unsurprisingly, they would have preferred to carry on living with their mother.

GettinHyggeWithIt · 24/11/2022 23:18

Suffrajitsu · 24/11/2022 22:47

I suspect you are confusing "apologists" with people who simply say that vigilantism is wrong. If you condone vigilante justice, can you explain to us how you guarantee that an innocent person will never be victimised by it?

Principally I agree that there can be no vigilantism else where do you draw the line.

I also principally agree with a criminal justice system that serves to keep the public safe and punishes criminals in an adequate way. In this country we police by consent.

However, it would seem the latter failed in this instance, on multiple occasions, and defending the right of a few (1 man here) has caused more harm to the majority (these 3 boys plus 24 prior convictions?).

Given failures of the criminal justice system in so many areas of life, it’s hard to argue it is fit for purpose. Police by consent means there is broad public support for it. Now whether it’s inadequacies to prosecute, or policing (mis)conduct generally this will only lead down one path if the belief is the ‘justice’ system doesn’t deliver justice.

Suffrajitsu · 24/11/2022 23:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

That's not actually what her sons said.

XanaduKira · 24/11/2022 23:14

PetraBP · 24/11/2022 23:13

The state should do it.

Child sexual abuse is worse than murder and should be punished worse than murder.

Life imprisonment for murder.

Death penalty for child sexual abuse.

Agreed.