Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I’d want to do the same - mother kills children’s abuser

616 replies

HermioneKipper · 24/11/2022 08:18

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/sarah-sands-kill-sex-abuse-paedophile-b2231508.html

i think any parent would do the same if given the chance

OP posts:
Namechangedforthisonetoday · 24/11/2022 12:55

Yes that’s right learnercook, this woman is no better than a man who has over 20 convictions for sexually assaulting children 🤔 In the nicest possible way, why don’t you go back to looking for those flat shoes you were posting about a couple of weeks ago.

Namechangedforthisonetoday · 24/11/2022 12:53

Onnabugeisha Tell that to the children let down everyday by the justice system.

Namechangedforthisonetoday · 24/11/2022 12:51

Why does a child have to have committed suicide for you to deem the actions of that paedophile bad enough that he must go to prison for life? That makes no sense. Google Shy Keenan and Stanley Claridge. Shy is an incredible woman. She suffered horrendous abuse. She didn’t kill herself. Does that mean that Stanley Claridge doesn’t deserve life inside on the basis that Shy was able to try and work through her trauma to help others?

Those microchips you’re referring to. You know that they’d find a way to remove those don’t you? You’re aware we’ve had electronic tagging for years? Plenty of those people disappear off the radar. The police and the government do not have the manpower to monitor these people day and night.

Its interesting that a main concern of yours appears to be how much tax you’d potentially pay keeping a paedophile in prison for life. I’m assuming you are a net contributor? Do you use the NHS? State schools? You’d rather a sex offender was out in the community potentially having contact with children if it meant your taxes were safe?

LearnerCook · 24/11/2022 12:51

In doing what this woman did, she has sunk to his level. Both convicted of incredibly serious crimes. She's no better than he is now.

Japaneseifyouplease · 24/11/2022 12:48

Lockheart · 24/11/2022 08:37

But she wasn't the one who should have been there. She should have let justice take it's course, then he'd have been in jail and she'd have been around for her boys.

I have to agree with you but I can see how she ended up doing what she did.
I think for her children, although they say they felt better knowing he was dead, They would have felt better having their mum and knowing he was in prison. They might have even felt guilt that she was in prison which makes it even worse.

ClemFandango1 · 24/11/2022 12:45

I think there's a chance I would have done the same to my brother's abuser if I had known who he was.
Not now though, because I have kids to worry about.

FourTeaFallOut · 24/11/2022 12:43

LaGioconda · 24/11/2022 12:33

Define "paedophiles". Is it the whole gamut from those who have abused children regularly all the way to someone who accessed a low level photograph twenty years ago but has never done anything else? If not, where do you draw the line?

And what if someone is convicted wrongly? How do we give their lives back to them?

Let's start with those who have a proven conviction for repeatedly sexually assaulting children. See if they can get that right to begin with?

Onnabugeisha · 24/11/2022 12:42

Namechangedforthisonetoday · 24/11/2022 12:35

Onnabugeisha The other option would have been a pathetic sentence (if one at all) and back out to reoffend. People are sick of sick child rapists protected and allowed back into our communities. This is what happens when the justice system isn’t fit for purpose.

The justice system is much improved compared to the past. It is a work in progress.

Onnabugeisha · 24/11/2022 12:41

Namechangedforthisonetoday · 24/11/2022 12:25

Onnabugeisha what are your thoughts on the fact that he was repeatedly allowed out of prison and able to go on to abuse further children? Whether the punishments were ‘harsher’ is neither here nor there, they were not a deterrent. Genuine question, what sort of sentence would you like child sex offenders to receive? Do you think they should be given life upon first offence?

Well it sort of depends on the severity what they did tbh how long the sentence should be. I would argue life sentence if say their abuse of a child led to that child committing suicide.

Once they’ve done their time, I think they should be chipped like a pet and live under strict restrictions. As in can’t go within 100m of a school or nursery. They should only be permitted to live in adult only communities. Be allowed only minor freedom to go between work and home. Be barred from all domestic and international travel so they don’t do child abuse tourism. The government is quite capable of setting up the software to real time track chipped people and use geo-location so an alarm goes off of they violate this. They should not be permitted to change their name by deed poll so DBS checks work. They should be added to the watch list so their online activity is constantly monitored.

I don’t think a child sex offender should get housing, board, medical care for life on my taxes unless their actions resulted in a child losing their life. I know prison isn’t nice, but I think they should still have to work a job to house and feed themselves. There’s plenty of decent people starving to death, dying of lack of heat, homeless on the streets so why should a child sex offender have it better?
I don’t think the cost to keep them warm and fed and healthy is something I should contribute to.

PinkButtercups · 24/11/2022 12:40

Lockheart · 24/11/2022 08:23

They might, that doesn't mean it's not illegal. You don't take the law into your own hands.

You bloody well do. I'd happily do time to protect my babies.

Lockheart · 24/11/2022 12:40

LaGioconda · 24/11/2022 12:33

Define "paedophiles". Is it the whole gamut from those who have abused children regularly all the way to someone who accessed a low level photograph twenty years ago but has never done anything else? If not, where do you draw the line?

And what if someone is convicted wrongly? How do we give their lives back to them?

Or the pubescent children and young teenagers who realise their developing sexual attraction is abnormal but have nowhere to turn to ask for help.

Namechangedforthisonetoday · 24/11/2022 12:39

lagioconda what do you define as a ‘low level photograph?’ That’s an interesting turn of phrase. Photographs of abuse are photographs of abuse. They are pictures of innocent little children being hurt, whatever ‘level’ or category they are placed in. It is also well known that as sex offenders become ‘immune’ to those ‘low level’ photographs, they will seek out more explicit content. Do you know what ‘hurtcore’ is? There can be no grey area for these people. It’s black and white. If you enjoy viewing images of children being sexually abused, you are a paedophile and you must be removed from society. Whether they are physically hurting the child themselves or not, someone is and they are getting off on it.

Namechangedforthisonetoday · 24/11/2022 12:35

*seeing

Namechangedforthisonetoday · 24/11/2022 12:35

Onnabugeisha The other option would have been a pathetic sentence (if one at all) and back out to reoffend. People are sick of sick child rapists protected and allowed back into our communities. This is what happens when the justice system isn’t fit for purpose.

Kanaloa · 24/11/2022 12:33

Onnabugeisha · 24/11/2022 12:28

There’s always another option.

She chose to pick up a knife, walk to his block of flats, take the lift, knock on his door, go into his flat and stab him to death.

She had an option to not do this. And I’m not saying this is a case of a deranged woman just looking for an excuse to murder, I’m saying no reason is good enough for murder.

And she knew what she did was wrong because she then chose to turn herself in to the police that same night wearing the bloody clothes and giving them the bloody knife.

Which option involves this man not raping children again?

And she did turn herself in - she did a strong thing that this man himself refused to do. She took ownership of her actions.

LaGioconda · 24/11/2022 12:33

FourTeaFallOut · 24/11/2022 08:54

I civilised society would keep paedophiles behind bars so they can't harm children again and again and again and again.

Define "paedophiles". Is it the whole gamut from those who have abused children regularly all the way to someone who accessed a low level photograph twenty years ago but has never done anything else? If not, where do you draw the line?

And what if someone is convicted wrongly? How do we give their lives back to them?

SomePosters · 24/11/2022 12:33

LaGioconda · 24/11/2022 12:22

Do you think that having your parent in prison for years would have been more helpful to you at that point?

Suppose your parent had got it wrong and killed the wrong person? It's inevitable that that will happen if you leave these issues to lynch-fever justice. How would you have felt then?

Your post is very insensitive.

I have quite enough trauma without playing through your imaginary scenarios for your entertainment

I don’t think she should have done time for it… if the justice system actually targeted predators and kept their victims safe then she wouldn’t have.

That should be the focus here not how you imagine my preschool age self would have coped with my mum going to prison.

The justice system should be held to account for the predators it releases back into society.
In this case he had double figure convictions

Why is anyone wasting time talking about their mum leaving it to the police when the police had their chance to keep people safe and let her children be abused.

doesn’t fill you with faith in the system if you have actually experienced it

LaGioconda · 24/11/2022 12:28

SouperNoodle · 24/11/2022 08:52

If it were up to me, I'd have spared her jail.
If someone abuses your children and you kill them, you should be celebrated for protecting yours and any other children that have/will be abused by that person 🤷‍♀️

So what happens when you get it wrong and kill the wrong person? Because that is what happens when you leave things like this to vigilante justice. Should we celebrate you then?

This is the mindset that led to that unfortunate paediatrician being demonised.

Itsabitnotcold · 24/11/2022 12:28

Agree. Although if they got a reasonable sentence I'd rather them see it out. More often than not it's a pitiful few years, so I'd make sure he got justice myself.

Onnabugeisha · 24/11/2022 12:28

Kanaloa · 24/11/2022 12:03

I haven’t suggested that. I’ve said that a justice system which allows men to rape and abuse children is what leads to these awful cases. It isn’t just people inherently wanting to murder others. It’s people being left with no other options because the justice system doesn’t protect them.

There’s always another option.

She chose to pick up a knife, walk to his block of flats, take the lift, knock on his door, go into his flat and stab him to death.

She had an option to not do this. And I’m not saying this is a case of a deranged woman just looking for an excuse to murder, I’m saying no reason is good enough for murder.

And she knew what she did was wrong because she then chose to turn herself in to the police that same night wearing the bloody clothes and giving them the bloody knife.

ShimmeringShirts · 24/11/2022 12:27

I had to force myself to put down the knife I was holding down while cooking dinner when my 3yo told me why was going on while her abuser sat in my living room before I went through to confront him. It is the biggest regret of my life as he got off with it. This woman did what many other parents wish they could when it comes to protecting their kids, I’ve got nothing but admiration for her.

Namechangedforthisonetoday · 24/11/2022 12:25

Onnabugeisha what are your thoughts on the fact that he was repeatedly allowed out of prison and able to go on to abuse further children? Whether the punishments were ‘harsher’ is neither here nor there, they were not a deterrent. Genuine question, what sort of sentence would you like child sex offenders to receive? Do you think they should be given life upon first offence?

Quveas · 24/11/2022 12:22

barneshome · 24/11/2022 08:49

As a Chinese colleague said
The Uk thinks they are better than us because we execute murderers and sex offenders
In China we do not think that keeping people like that alive and upsetting the victims and there families is in any way civilized

In China they also torture and execute people for their ethnicity and political beliefs, and imprison people for thinking. So I am not sure that your Chinese colleague has much to brag about. I also assume that he's "over here" and not in China!

As for the general point, if people break the law then there is a penalty to pay. We don't get to pick and choose which laws we obey, otherwise we have anarchy. You can campaign to change the law or to increase penalties for wrongdoing, but nobody gets to take the law into their own hands with impunity, and nobody should avoid the consequences of their choices because they had "a good reason". There are always alternatives. She intended to kill or seriously harm him. I might, individually, understand why someone felt like that. I might be tempted to do it myself. But that is vastly different from deciding that I have the right to mete out my own version of justice just because I want to.

LaGioconda · 24/11/2022 12:22

SomePosters · 24/11/2022 08:51

Love all these trust the systems types

Show of hands then… how many of you trust the system types can tell me
the conviction rates for this kind of thing?

I went through the conviction process once and it caused more angst and agony spread over years. Starting with the medical exam.

wouldn’t wish it on anyone tbh and I would certainly never put myself through it again

Do you think that having your parent in prison for years would have been more helpful to you at that point?

Suppose your parent had got it wrong and killed the wrong person? It's inevitable that that will happen if you leave these issues to lynch-fever justice. How would you have felt then?

piisnot3 · 24/11/2022 12:22

One of the kids I was at school with (we were neighbours and friends to some degree) turned out to be a paedophile. He reoffended while on parole after his first conviction and is (or was) serving a second term. Prior to his first conviction he also sought out positions of responsibility and was a school governor. Between convictions, he changed his name. Looking back, you'd never have said - in general they are impossible to spot. This has caused me to think about this issue for a long time.
Any sexual offence by an adult against a child should carry a mandatory life sentence. Life should mean life. Bail should never be given while legal proceedings are ongoing. These people cannot be rehabilitated. They have by their actions foregone a place in society. The issue should not be about "strict controls while they are in the community" but about their permanent removal from the community. Name changing would be an irrelevance if they were never released.
The problem with the death sentence, vigilante justice or chemical castration is not that they wouldn't deserve it, if guilty, but that by doing so we as a society lower ourselves and risk the possibility of irreversible miscarriages of justice. Prisoners convicted of those offences should still have access to due process, legal representation and an appeals process, as well as medical care, but that's about all they should be entitled to.
The justice system completely failed that poor woman and her children - in her shoes many people would do the same thing.