Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL keeps pressuring us but it's a no!!

237 replies

SweetRascal · 24/11/2022 07:04

My parents in law moved away recently and they already miss their gc a lot. They moved away to a rural area several hours away for an early retirement. They just wanted to live in a more peaceful location, fair enough.

I think they're happy with where they've move to but MIL keeps telling us how much she misses our eldest child in particular. She asked us the other night AGAIN if we'd let him stay with then and got all funny about it when we said no.

He's only 4, he has adhd and asd being assessed. His behaviour is very challenging and unpredictable. His sleep can be very disturbed. If we're 3 hours away and he's having a night terror, it's not like we can just pop over. MIL can can't see any of this because in her mind, he'll be fine and that's that.

I think she's getting desperate for us to go to theirs but I've already said that won't be until next year. They can come and see us but MIL said she can't find suitable care for their dog yet in their new location.

Mil said to dh, you'll have to let him atay away sone time! Have to?!!!! What!!

I think dh wouldn't be as worried as me but I feel like I'm ds's mum and I won't be dictated to when he stays away when he's only 4 snd has special needs too.

OP posts:
IneedanewTV · 24/11/2022 08:15

My sons stayed at their grandparents a couple of times a year from just pre school so 4ish. They learnt to grow potatoes, visited the 100 year old neighbour for tea and cakes, played water fights, picked runner beans and soft fruits. All stuff I would not have the time to do. They both look back fondly on that period of time as both grandparents died when they were 14 and 16.

However it is your choice but don’t use your kids to punish your Hs parents for enjoying their retirement.

GoonerGirl5231 · 24/11/2022 08:15

GoonerGirl5231 · 24/11/2022 08:14

OP has started multiple threads expressing her anger that her PIL have dared to move away to have a nice life, but she tells it through a complaint like this one. To me, what her MIL sounds like a throwaway remark, not an order OP's DS needs to be delivered to her door for a week's stay. I think it helps OP when everyone on MN froths on her but it's becoming unhealthily obsessive.

I mean, 'what her MIL SAID sounds like'...

GoonerGirl5231 · 24/11/2022 08:14

ExtraOnions · 24/11/2022 08:07

You sound angry at them for moving, where you unhappy with their decision ?

I think it’s good that children experience the odd sleepover away from their parents, just in case of a future emergency, where there might be no choice other than them staying over elsewhere.

Do PIL now live somewhere really nice? Why not book a B&B nearby… have some downtime with OH, but, be on hand in case things something happens.

OP has started multiple threads expressing her anger that her PIL have dared to move away to have a nice life, but she tells it through a complaint like this one. To me, what her MIL sounds like a throwaway remark, not an order OP's DS needs to be delivered to her door for a week's stay. I think it helps OP when everyone on MN froths on her but it's becoming unhealthily obsessive.

JustBeKinder · 24/11/2022 08:12

Just to balance things out a bit, my little GS 3 yrs old (almost 4) has stayed overnight with me on a number of occasions and we ve been very close since he was born and he stayed happily with me for a week when mum was in hospital. He now has a little sibling and they ve both stayed at my house overnight while mum and dad had a much needed night out and I ll be doing that again soon. I guess it depends on the family circumstances and how well the children are connected with the GP. I m very lucky to be close to my GC and they only live a 5 min drive away, I have no doubt I ll be doing this for many years to come, health permitting or until they reach an age where they don’t want to go to grandmas anymore and that ll be a sad but probably inevitable day

LadyVic · 24/11/2022 08:11

I get this. My MIL moved from 4 mins up the road to 3+ hours away, and now complains she doesnt see the kids as Im lazy and wont drive the distance!
I work 40+ hours a week, plus do a lot of volunteer work (which I love) and I dont really fancy spending my weekends driving to a place where you are lucky to get a phone signal, let alone wifi! It also doesnt have a pub.

MadelineUsher · 24/11/2022 08:11

How is he supposed to get there?! I don't understand why you have to make allowances for them not finding a dog sitter, but send your little boy to them like a package (who knows if the dog is suitable for a little boy, anyway?).

It is a pity your DH does not have your back on this unreasonable demand.

Privatestate1 · 24/11/2022 08:10

We have a similar situation with IL moving away to a rural location and then constant comments that they don’t see the grandkids enough, pressurising us to go and stay (even though we do see them a lot, they come to us!). She tends to nag at me and sort of use me as a go between like ‘why doesn’t DH visit, can you get him to visit 🤷‍♀️). So I have delegated all conversations to him! Just refer to DH as he organises visits. I think four is too young to stay alone and we work and have weekend committed activities. It’s just difficult and I also hate being made to feel guilty for not visiting when it was their choice to live somewhere far away from us.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 24/11/2022 08:10

YANBU And I would actually say to her well you chose to move so far away. I would even say you won't consider an overnight stay until he's 9 or 10. That should shut her up.

VeganFromSveden · 24/11/2022 08:09

Hi, your mil states she can’t find suitable dog care as yet…
try telling her about “Borrow my Puppy”.
Reviews on Trustpilot are mostly very good.
That will enable her to come to see you all.

I do believe that you can only let your children stay away when YOU are ready.

it doesn’t matter when other mums feel ready.
depending on how your dc progresses as he gets older, you might then feel ok to let him stay away.
please don’t let anyone pressure you into thinking you should enable this… don’t pressure yourself either.

make sure your dh is on board with this too.
if mil detects that he could be the weak link, she may try to get her way via him.

stay strong.

you are dc parent

mil has had her child rearing experience

this is your time to take the rights and responsibilities of parenting… also the rewards!
she may well be fine with your dc, but you will be distraught if dc isn’t fine, and even if all goes well, you (knowing your dc best) will be unable to relax, and possibly will be an unpleasant experience for you.

take care

RampantIvy · 24/11/2022 08:08

SweetRascal · 24/11/2022 07:12

@Runningslow We can but it won't be until next spring

Why can't it be before next spring?

Charitybargainhunter · 24/11/2022 08:07

I’m not sure what the big deal is?🤷‍♀️

my son (ADHD) has stayed over with both sets of grandparents - both of whom live more than 3 hours away.

he loves it. Gives him a taste of independence, while still being with people who love and care for him.

I also stayed with Grandparents at this age- loved it!

ExtraOnions · 24/11/2022 08:07

You sound angry at them for moving, where you unhappy with their decision ?

I think it’s good that children experience the odd sleepover away from their parents, just in case of a future emergency, where there might be no choice other than them staying over elsewhere.

Do PIL now live somewhere really nice? Why not book a B&B nearby… have some downtime with OH, but, be on hand in case things something happens.

Cotonsugar · 24/11/2022 08:03

autumnboys · 24/11/2022 07:13

It’s interesting that she’s prioritising the dog’s comfort over your son’s. Could they not bring him with them and put him in which kennels they used locally to you? What she means is, she doesn’t want to be three hours away from the dog in case he’s unhappy……..oh.

One day you may want to consider him sleeping away overnight, but that’s likely to be at a Beaver sleepover at the local scout camp or a friend around the corner, not three hours away! It’s your prerogative as a parent to decide when where and who, not hers.

Stick to your guns!

You can’t leave a dog alone in the house while you’re away for the weekend - it’s not about it being happy or uncomfortable 🙄

GoonerGirl5231 · 24/11/2022 08:03

Aren't you the poster who has posted about this half a dozen times already? Two children, one with SN, PIL have moved hours away. You really need to let go of your anger at them choosing to live somewhere else to see out their retirement because it is becoming so toxic.

Genevieva · 24/11/2022 08:01

All in good time. He is still very little.

My MiL pressurised us to have ours overnight from 3 weeks old. She is baby-obsessed and really didn't want me to breastfeed so that she could take the baby. Once the next baby came along she dropped all interest in the older one (who had reflux), and so on. When we were at a point where a sleepover would have worked she had lost interest in our family altogether and was on to obsessing over my niece and nephew. The result is that she has a distant relationship with her now teenage grandchildren, but still resents us. It was all about her and consequently she has missed out.

AndysPandy · 24/11/2022 08:00

It's a shame there isn't a solution which suits everyone, grandparents can be such a positive in children's lives. That said, no-one - particularly someone who has moved away - should be insisting on overnights.

I'm interested as to why some posters don't want their children staying with grandparents. Our grandchildren stay regularly with all grandparents (3 sets due to a divorce) and have done from being small (about 1). It's a lovely positive experience for everyone and gives parents a much needed break.

NopeNotHere · 24/11/2022 07:57

My mum moved 6 hours away and abroad then bitterly complained we didn’t visit her enough and that she only saw gc once year, because I couldn’t afford the flights more than once a year. Moving away was your in law’s choice. Let them say whatever they like and only do what you want to do.

fruitsaladsweets · 24/11/2022 07:55

SweetRascal · 24/11/2022 07:14

@gigirlmom21 mil said they will but can't find anyone to have their dog yet

That's her problem.

Just be firm.

Cigarettesaftersex1 · 24/11/2022 07:55

RobinRobinMouse · 24/11/2022 07:45

Fait enough to say no to sleepover but pretty terrible you won't visit until next Spring. I think you could make it happen sooner than that if you wanted to, just go for a weekend. I'd be sad if my child grew up and couldn't make it to visit me for so many months just because I was a few hours away. Even if it was their choice to move, I would still prioritise a visit.

Maybe the parents could prioritise a visit?

Wibbly1008 · 24/11/2022 07:55

Tell her a firm no, then say you are not discussing this again. Tell her she moved, you didn’t, end of conversation. What a cf. there is always someone trying to dictate without thinking of the child. He is 4, he will be upset and scared being so far from his mum in a strange place overnight.

lifeinthehills · 24/11/2022 07:54

Did MIL really think they could move away and see everyone as much? Not have anything change?

AdInfinitum12 · 24/11/2022 07:53

Twiglets1 · 24/11/2022 07:48

Where did OP say they wouldn't visit until next Spring?
Next year could mean January which is only a few weeks away.

They clarified in a post it would be next spring.

Lozzybear · 24/11/2022 07:53

I think it very much depends on the relationship the DCs have with the GPs. My dad lived with us when my DCs were a toddler and a baby and then he moved round the corner. They have always had a close relationship with him and he has taken them away for short breaks and has had them to stay at his house since they were small - they are now 9 and 12. However, they have never stayed at my PIL. They don’t see them that often - once every couple of months.

Devoutspoken · 24/11/2022 07:52

I would jump at the chance, it's a lovely idea

ChubbyMorticia · 24/11/2022 07:50

Actions have consequences, positive or negative. They chose to move, it’s not your responsibility to negate the consequences of that decision. They can find an acceptable arrangement for their dog and travel to you. Or not. Why the responsibility rests on your shoulders baffles me. Absolutely no way I’d send a 4 yo to a strange place, 3 hours away. Let alone one with probable special needs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread