Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL keeps pressuring us but it's a no!!

237 replies

SweetRascal · 24/11/2022 07:04

My parents in law moved away recently and they already miss their gc a lot. They moved away to a rural area several hours away for an early retirement. They just wanted to live in a more peaceful location, fair enough.

I think they're happy with where they've move to but MIL keeps telling us how much she misses our eldest child in particular. She asked us the other night AGAIN if we'd let him stay with then and got all funny about it when we said no.

He's only 4, he has adhd and asd being assessed. His behaviour is very challenging and unpredictable. His sleep can be very disturbed. If we're 3 hours away and he's having a night terror, it's not like we can just pop over. MIL can can't see any of this because in her mind, he'll be fine and that's that.

I think she's getting desperate for us to go to theirs but I've already said that won't be until next year. They can come and see us but MIL said she can't find suitable care for their dog yet in their new location.

Mil said to dh, you'll have to let him atay away sone time! Have to?!!!! What!!

I think dh wouldn't be as worried as me but I feel like I'm ds's mum and I won't be dictated to when he stays away when he's only 4 snd has special needs too.

OP posts:
Theskyisfallingdown · 24/11/2022 10:41

Say nah. It’s only a big deal if you make it one and keep on conversing about it.

ShimmeringShirts · 24/11/2022 10:34

I don’t actually understand why you’d say no tbh.

Hadtocomment · 24/11/2022 10:26

I realise that answer is way too influenced by the other thread so just to make it clear I really apologise if that's not you at all! But on the elements that are similar, I hope some of that answer might be helpful.

I don't think you should have to go carting around the country by the way just to do what they want and if you can't go til spring that's fair enough. But there's a lot to be said for daytrips in mutually accessible places if that's possible. Could be refreshing even and a bit of break, even if you're there too, to have someone else play and spend time with DS knowing they get on well whilst you sit back a little.

Hadtocomment · 24/11/2022 10:17

I read the other thread someone posted. If you are that person, I do sympathise. But what I notice (and forgive me if you're not the same person) is that you keep saying you said encouraging or supportive or nice things to them, whilst obviously feeling very resentful privately. You also talk (in the other thread if you are the same person) of being a worrier and unable to sleep and I wonder if this makes you run things over in your head.

It is sad that they've moved but it seems like you've taken it as a rejection rather than something they wanted to do independently for postivie reasons. They were probably imaging that they would move to this lovely new area with great things in it that they could show and share with you and their grandkids. They probably never dreamed you'd see it as some kind of personal rejection of you and your children. I would really try and think things through a bit more in terms of why you believe it is a rejection. You seem to have very specific expectations of people at particular times of life. But there are other ways of looking at it. There are even potential positives. That you have a place to stay in a nice area that isn't expensive if you need. That your children can be introduced to the different things of that area and that can be exciting to them. That the grandparents themselves are modeling doing something different and being adventurous for your children, and showing that older people can still makes changes and get out there. As you seem to be an anxious person (and I am sympathetic being one myself), having people that model not being so worried about trying things could actually be a really good thing to have in all your lives.

You sound like a nice person who tries to say the right things but then maybe broods and resentment builds. It's hard not to do this. But perhaps trying to see their moving through a different lense might help. It could be a positive thing for you and your children. But it could also be something they regret and change their minds about, and in that case it's still admirable that they've tried something and had the guts to make a change later in life. It could even be they are just restless or itchy feet people and never settle and that could be annoying, but again not personal and not a rejection of anybody.

On the MIL asking to see the grandchildren, this demonstrates even more that it's not a rejection and you and perhaps your DH are taking this too personally. If she is close to your DS, I'd try and find a way of meeting them halfway as he's only young and may be missing them. In the future you may be pleased that he has a nice safe place to go and visit and so it's not worth burning bridges over. If you don't want him to go stay that's fine. It sounds like they want you all to come and so you can enjoy their new place. Holding onto a grudge might be a shame for you as it might be that a break in a new place could be refreshing for you. If not and you don't want to go, maybe organise a day meet up or something somewhere in between both of you. Good luck OP. Sounds like you actually are fond of your inlaws, so perhaps trying to see it a bit differently would be nicer for all of you in the longrun.

pictish · 24/11/2022 10:09

I agree that there is still very low awareness about ASD.
It’s not the case for me. I work in child development with children with complex additional needs. Two of my own children are on the autistic spectrum (HF) while the eldest has adhd and dyspraxia.

I recognise OP’s authority on this subject. I also think her dh’s input is invaluable. I genuinely believe that sharing the load is the way forward.

GrinAndVomit · 24/11/2022 10:04

Also, what are the practicalities? Have I missed the travel arrangements she’s expecting?
Is she expecting you to drive three hours there to drop him off and then three hours home again, to repeated the next day for pick up?

UniversalAunt · 24/11/2022 10:01

‘I also notice a number of posters spouting about how GP visits have been important/beneficial - but don't seem to take into account the ASD. It's simply not the same, ND adds a whole new level of complexity that many don't understand.’

This.
Awareness about ASD & ND in general is still quite low.
My awareness is built upon working with ND adults, & there is more that I don’t know than do, so I would welcome being told by parents about their child’s needs.

Understandably @SweetRascal is protective & in very practical ways cautious about bringing disruption & upheaval that may cause distress for her child & family.

MiL & PiL seem to have low awareness… for now.
This can change, the pivotal point is when MiL & PiL gets the message about ASD & ND, seek to know more & become allies.

talkingmorenonsense · 24/11/2022 09:56

I have five grandchildren and not one of them has stayed overnight. For us and our family it’s just not an issue. My family visits here, we visit them and we do some childcare, on an ad hoc basis. We love taking the children out for the day, we do the beach, farm parks, museums, the zoo, etc. We love doing stuff you do with children but wouldn’t do normally. Three of mine live two hours away, but we still see them regularly. We make the effort.

For me this is what being a grandparent is about. I don’t need or want them at night. In your casev@SweetRascal I absolutely understand your reluctance. Stick to your guns.

MuddlingMackem · 24/11/2022 09:56

Onthecuspofabreakthrough · 24/11/2022 09:13

Would you like a second chance to read my post, where I said I wouldn't do overnights but think it's unreasonable to say, in November, that you can't visit till Spring? The woman won't stop loving her grandchild even if she never sees him again. But the child will not have the benefit of feeling that love in his life.

Why is it unreasonable to say in November they can't visit until spring? Christmas is coming up which costs most families money, and maybe they have other commitments which mean they won't be able to afford to visit until Spring.

Moving away from family does not mean that you can now dictate how your famly members prioritise their spending!

Blossomtoes · 24/11/2022 09:53

lifeinthehills · 24/11/2022 09:27

Some kids don't travel so well. A six hour round trip in a day wouldn't have worked for my young kids at all. PIL are adults without young children to travel with. They can sort out a new dog sitter and come too.

According to the previous thread Mil’s 85 year old mother lives with them too. It sounds as if difficulty in travelling is greater for them.

My boy stayed with his grandparents for the first time when he was five months. He spent a week with them in every school holiday. Good for him, good for them, good for me. There were no losers.

NWQM · 24/11/2022 09:53

I agree with the posters saying that you should stick to your guns. Its impractical for a 1 night stay and more - if the child wasnt used to staying with gp's would be too much.
I would decide with DH how many visits you are prepared to do per year and book them. Set the precedant of whether you stay with them or a hotel. Then simply say we will see you x.
It hard and frustrating but she is unlikely to give up so I think you will need stock phrases and trot them out. You cant solve her problems e.g re the dog as that will never be the right answer for her.
For me it doesnt really matter who moved away etc.... Get that its frustrating that its her choice but lots of variables in that in terms of the GP relationship.... Its the here and now that matters. 3 hours away for a potentially difficult sleepover just doesnt work.

UniversalAunt · 24/11/2022 09:47

‘People don’t think through the downsides of relocating away from family and friends. they chose to move away, not you.’

This very much.
Few people put as much thought into how far away they are relocating & the realities of friends/family travelling down as they do working out a daily commute to work.

Understandably for OP & her family, it’s not an everyday short haul journey.

billy1966 · 24/11/2022 09:47

Absolutely not.

I wouldn't entertain this without the complications of SEN.

This is not in your child's best interests.

They have chosen to move away, which is their right, but the consequences are clear.

Do not be pressurised to visit.

Her concern for her dogs comfort ahead of your son's is hilarious.

She visits you or she doesn't see him.

The other alternative is your husband occasionally does a visit and stays.

otherfavorites · 24/11/2022 09:46

are you the poster who overheard her mil bitching about her and the oldest not being as settled in childcare as you wanted them to think? sounds like nothing has improved if so

Itsybitsyminion · 24/11/2022 09:46

Would he even want to stay away from you and his so familiar environment? Your son would probably hate to be away from you! And do you feel like your MIL is capable to deal with him considering the special attention he needs? Ultimately is about how this setting would make you both feel. I can't envision my 3 yo sleeping away from us. I came to terms that my MIL, well PIL all together are absolute useless although they would love to have my DS for the night. But they absolutely ignore everything I say and all the routine he is used to and I hate that. And even DS sometimes refuses to go anywhere with them... So that makes me wonder.
My point is. Don't allow anything that makes you feel uncomfortable. The quicker you pass the message that you don't want him to go the quicker MIL will drop the subject.

pictish · 24/11/2022 09:44

I also think it’s unreasonable not to take dh’s point of view into account.

Mumsnet does have a slightly bonkers contingent of controlling/in-law hating/combative/my baby, my rules/me me me mothers in attendance.
I was never like that…not even with my PFB. He went to stay in France with the in-laws for 10 days when he was 3 and it was BLISS. Came back with a tan having learned to swim. Brilliant.

Can’t see any negatives in allowing the 4 yr old, to go and stay with granny. It can only be good for him. This is about mum not wanting to relinquish control. Some will argue that’s her right. Fair enough, I just happen to be cut from a different cloth.

Somuchgoo · 24/11/2022 09:43

It's only on MN I've come across this reluctance to allow children to stay over with grandparents etc. In real life, my children, and my friends children all do it - inc those with ASD.

I accurate can't think of a single friend in real life, who hasn't been at least semi regularly studying over with grandparents by the age of 4.

My first slept over fairly regularly (every couple of months maybe) from the age of 1, and my second from 2.

Thank goodness we did, because when my youngest was taken seriously ill, my eldest went to live with grandparents for 2 months whilst we were in hospital etc, with spending some weekends with friends. It would have been far more distressing for her if she'd never even started away from home before. You never know where life will lead, and when an emergency might come up.

That said, it's yours and your husbands (equal!) choice. It does feel like you are trying to punish them for their choices though.

PritiPatelsMaker · 24/11/2022 09:43

Why can't you visit till 2023 abs why can't they bring the DDog?

diddl · 24/11/2022 09:43

Bogofftosomewherehot · 24/11/2022 09:35

@diddl

Three hours away?
That's surely doable in a day?

Yeah - because 6 hours in a car with a 4yr old with ASD is a GREAT idea.

I was thinking of PILs travelling.

Flossflower · 24/11/2022 09:39

Could MIL come and visit and leave the dog with FIL

LetsGoDoDoDo · 24/11/2022 09:38

Could you or your DH meet mil with your son for a day trip half way?

I do sympathise with your point of view but on the other hand, Spring is a long way away! This could be a good compromise if she wants to see her GC more regularly.

UniversalAunt · 24/11/2022 09:37

‘When ours (also with asd) was 7 we first did a trial-run with him staying with GP and us in a hotel 5 minutes away in case anything went wrong. It all went well and now spending 3-4 nights with GP a couple of times a year is perfectly normal and fun for everyone.’

This is a sound gentle approach for developing a child’s sense of independence. By 8yo, staying away for a night is an adventure.
A nearby hotel, with a family room, is the right level of distance for an emergency quick dash to or from home. Not too far, not too ££.

A scoff-up breakfast buffet is a kid’s exotic banquet - endless sausages & pancakes, toast hot off a conveyer belt, little pots of jam & ketchup etc. Wanton plate piling with no exhortations to hold back or finish up, what’s not to like for a hungry kid?

Obviously 4yo is young, especially if the child needs support through the night.

As your DC settles more, Would you consider a brief weekend city break away with your In laws? Have your iLs babysit the kids in situ while you & DC have a date night? Build up the connection & camaraderie between all of you, it’ll bring joy, ease & future dividends.

Your iLs love your children, more than anyone other than you & their father.
It is an unconditional love for the children particularly when they are young, it’s all the ‘just’ adult stuff of life that gets in the way: time, distance, money & family dynamics etc.

They are squaring up to the challenges of early retirement in a lovely place but possibly that bit too far away from family, friends & community, maybe even missing work. Possibly they are having some buyer’s remorse - that’s their deal - & their grandchildren represent a loving closer connection, a future contentment they are yearning for? Bet they’d love to park the dog so they can get about a bit now they have all this time on their hands - city break maybe?

So, although MiL is not yet up to speed, loving energetic grandparents are a blessing. Nurture the connection, be direct & informative with kindness.

Do not look a ‘gift’ grandparent in the mouth.

Summerfun54321 · 24/11/2022 09:36

I would be asking her why she didn’t discuss this with you before she decided to move? And I’d also let your DH do the talking for you.

Bogofftosomewherehot · 24/11/2022 09:35

@diddl

Three hours away?
That's surely doable in a day?

Yeah - because 6 hours in a car with a 4yr old with ASD is a GREAT idea.

soupmaker · 24/11/2022 09:34

Sloth66 · 24/11/2022 09:17

People don’t think through the downsides of relocating away from family and friends.
they chose to move away, not you.

Exactly this.

When MIL moved abroad she gave absolutely no thought to this at all. DH has done weekly video calls since she went. She comes over annually and stays with us for at least a week of her 3 week trip, which is all organised to suit another relative and we just have to fall in line. We've been over to visit once and it cost us a fortune we don't have as we can't stay with her. She's a lovely granny to the kids but she won't have the same relationship with them as she would if she still lived 30 minutes away. Her choice.