Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL keeps pressuring us but it's a no!!

237 replies

SweetRascal · 24/11/2022 07:04

My parents in law moved away recently and they already miss their gc a lot. They moved away to a rural area several hours away for an early retirement. They just wanted to live in a more peaceful location, fair enough.

I think they're happy with where they've move to but MIL keeps telling us how much she misses our eldest child in particular. She asked us the other night AGAIN if we'd let him stay with then and got all funny about it when we said no.

He's only 4, he has adhd and asd being assessed. His behaviour is very challenging and unpredictable. His sleep can be very disturbed. If we're 3 hours away and he's having a night terror, it's not like we can just pop over. MIL can can't see any of this because in her mind, he'll be fine and that's that.

I think she's getting desperate for us to go to theirs but I've already said that won't be until next year. They can come and see us but MIL said she can't find suitable care for their dog yet in their new location.

Mil said to dh, you'll have to let him atay away sone time! Have to?!!!! What!!

I think dh wouldn't be as worried as me but I feel like I'm ds's mum and I won't be dictated to when he stays away when he's only 4 snd has special needs too.

OP posts:
inthemarblejar · 24/11/2022 13:18

Oh definitely not.

My child is autistic (and actually I think has ADHD too but as yet is unconfirmed). She is super close to my mum, who lives five minutes away and sees her several times a week.

She (child) was begging for a sleepover at Grandma's (very familiar) house. She's seven. I knew it wasn't wise because a disruption to her routine throws her into a total spin so I said she could stay over but I would stay too, in the spare room.

Surprise surprise it was not a success!

Child is perfectly happy to have Grandma stay overnight at our house if ever we have an evening out for example though, because she's her own ' safe space' surroundings and Grandma follows her routine.

I think for a flexible NT child even 4 might be too young considering the distance and lack of very regular face to face contact but for an ND child? Not a chance. Tell her no, firmly. They can come to you and if they don't like it then tough. The needs of your child outweighs their want to do this and the welfare of their bloody dog!

Travis1 · 24/11/2022 13:17

I’m torn because I don’t think you’re necessarily being unreasonable for your child if she wouldn’t cope with the intricacies of his ASD but on the other hand I’m going on holiday for a week next year with my cousins two kids, it’s me, DH, my aunt and her other daughter taking the two kids abroad without their parents. And they are 5 and 3. We’ve taken them on weekends away and stuff too. They’ve definitely had attention and experiences they wouldn’t have otherwise had.

so I suppose for me it’s all about the child and what’s best for him rather than you or your MIL. Will he get anything out of trips to visit the grandparents?

ivykaty44 · 24/11/2022 13:07

I don't get why grandparents move away and then badger people to visit them.

my inlaws moved to Spain when the dc were small 8 & 6 ish, then moved back when they were both fully grown adults and expected to slot back into their lives. They were the ones that moved away and changed the dynamics of the relationship

Bunnycat101 · 24/11/2022 13:03

we have grandparents who live a distance away but more like 2 hours. For it to work at that distance, you need to visit and stay over for a weekend (to help get him used to the house) and maybe go out for a meal leaving him with grandparents. You can then build up. Realistically to make the journey worthwhile you may be looking at a week during the school holidays. This could actually save you lots of money/be helpful so I wouldn’t dismiss the idea entirely unless SEN would make it miserable for everyone. Mine has been going for a week in summer and Easter since she was about 5 and she loves it

Blossomtoes · 24/11/2022 13:02

MadelineUsher · 24/11/2022 10:43

This is what I am wondering also. There has been no mention of how this magical deliverance of the little boy to this distant location is to be arranged.

They could meet halfway, that’s how we did it.

DisforDarkChocolate · 24/11/2022 12:57

I'd be saying no too, probably for at least the next 4 years in your circumstances.

Can she bring the dog and put in in kennels near you? Hire a pet sitter?

I plan on retiring nearer my grandchildren not further away.

ItsaMetalBand · 24/11/2022 12:51

When ours (also with asd) was 7 we first did a trial-run with him staying with GP and us in a hotel 5 minutes away in case anything went wrong. It all went well and now spending 3-4 nights with GP a couple of times a year is perfectly normal and fun for everyone.

Gently is the way to do it with lots of kids. DS doesn't have SN, but was very wary of sleepovers. He'd only ever stayed with one aunt we live beside who is like a second mammy to him. So we made a deal that IF he chose to go on a sleepover to his friends house, I would 100% go get him if he wanted me to, for any reason at any time. Having the security of knowing he could come home if he wanted, gave him the confidence to want to go then.

In the OPs case I would: do a few sleepovers with him at PILs until he got used to their house and routine. Then I would leave him but be sober and 5mins away in a hotel. And after that, I'd be ok to leave him - as long as PILs knew him and his routines well enough to cope.

Wiluli · 24/11/2022 12:50

Can you not all visit so she can see the reality of him staying the night ? Sounds like a great place if she is rural and you can just make a weekend if it

SaveMeFromMyBoobs · 24/11/2022 12:15

It was their choice to move away so they're now 3 hours away from their family. They had every right to make that choice, but they also have to understand that came with consequences. She can't expect to move 3 hours away and maintain the same level of contact with her grandchildren.

Stick to your guns OP, it's not right for him and it's not fair for her to put it on you that she misses him when it was entirely her choice to leave.

TheBelmont · 24/11/2022 12:15

Is she generally a “performance granny?” ie the type that likes to post pictures on Facebook of them looking after their grandkids because they are such dutiful grandparents (when in reality they see them twice a year) Or does she want to show your son off to her new pals? Maybe that is the reason she is using the dog as a ridiculous excuse. She doesn’t want to visit you as it is a less interesting story to tell everyone.

buckingmad · 24/11/2022 11:51

Why can't the dog come with them to yours?

ShesThunderstorms · 24/11/2022 11:49

I don't think MIL has thought this through. Have you humoured her and said "ok, when's good for you? Will you be doing the 6 hour round trip to pick him up? As I've got plans bits to be getting on with here if we're having a night to ourselves!" I doubt they'll be rushing to drive for that long to get him!
I must admit though, I'm envious a little bit of posts like this- we have one set of grandparents 5 mins away who refuse to ever have the kids overnight and one set 5 hours away who would love to have them overnight but are just too far for one night. It sounds as if you could do with a good nights sleep Flowers

serenaisaknobhead · 24/11/2022 11:46

"I won't be dictated to"

Absolutely this. Stand firm.

YANBU.

starfishmummy · 24/11/2022 11:40

It's nit a "right" to have their grandkid(s) stay over. Ours never did.

As others have said they chose to move. Surely they can find kennels for the dog either where they live now, or some near your home? If they put the dog before visiting the grandkid they allegedly miss so much, well in my book they can't be missing him that much!!

Laiste · 24/11/2022 11:37

I think the idea PP had of the inlaws staying at a dog friendly pub somewhere nearby is a good one. A weekend every few weeks?

They are retired presumably with more time/free weekends on their hands than OP?

Re: the Spring visit.
DH and i would probably not be able to facilitate a visit to someone who lives 3 hours away till the new year/spring now either. These are the various reasons why it would be a big deal for us to do a 6 hour round trip or stay away all weekend and i'm sure we're not that unusual.
Work commitments.
Health (DH back problems at the mo. means more than an hour in the car cripples him). Weekend lessons for younger kids paid up.
Cost of petrol.
Car issues.
Commitments to older kids/other adults at weekends.
Younger DCs would/DO struggle with more than 2 hours in the car at once.

I have to say - i feel that the one's who did the moving away should be the ones doing the lions share of sacrifices to keep up regular contact.

stepmad · 24/11/2022 11:36

The answer is no stick to it but they find dog care in your area Drive down or train it drop dog off easy

rainbowstardrops · 24/11/2022 11:34

I wouldn't send him all that way but I'd also suggest to them that they rent a dog friendly cottage or B&B or something near to you.
Or look into kennels.

BHRK · 24/11/2022 11:26

I think it’s fine to say no he’s too young. But I think you’re really unreasonable for saying you won’t visit til spring. Seems pretty mean

VickyEadieofThigh · 24/11/2022 11:24

Here's what I might do if I were the OP: research the dog boarding kennels within reasonable distance of the PiL House, send the list and say to MiL, "Go and look at these, pick the best one, book Fido in for a stay and come to visit".

People who have to get their dog sat by friends or home-based sitters need to consider the alternatives- I they want something this much.

Phos · 24/11/2022 11:21

Stay firm. My inlaws live an hour away and there's no way I'd allow my 5 year old to stay there unless her dad also went. She does stay at my mum's once a week but she's 2 miles away and has been involved since she was a baby. My in laws only saw the child 4 times in the first 4 years of her life.

PollyPut · 24/11/2022 11:20

4! She's got to be joking. Especially if she's expecting you to make a 6 hour round trip, twice, to facilitate it.

fishonabicycle · 24/11/2022 11:17

My stepdaughter is always wanting us to have her son overnight, and has done since he was about 2. Her mum lives abroad and looks after him alone as well (either when they visit her or she visits them). It gives her a break and chance to go out/away with her partner. Can't really see why you are so reluctant (unless there is a massive back story).

whumpthereitis · 24/11/2022 11:12

Another thread about this?

Are they pressuring you, or are you coming at it from this angle to get people to finally rip into them for moving away?

Doveyouknow · 24/11/2022 10:50

For balance both my DC have stayed with my in laws at that age and we live about that distance away. One also has an asd diagnosis. They love it and have a great relationship with their grandparents despite the distance. So your MiL's suggestion doesn't sound completely unreasonable to me.

MadelineUsher · 24/11/2022 10:43

GrinAndVomit · 24/11/2022 10:04

Also, what are the practicalities? Have I missed the travel arrangements she’s expecting?
Is she expecting you to drive three hours there to drop him off and then three hours home again, to repeated the next day for pick up?

This is what I am wondering also. There has been no mention of how this magical deliverance of the little boy to this distant location is to be arranged.