Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Scotland, (Wales and NI) has the right to self determination?

204 replies

Fragmentsof2022 · 24/11/2022 05:37

*MNHQ has deleted an image at the request of the OP"

So the Supreme Court voted yesterday to not allow Scotland Indy ref 2 without the permission of Westminster, ending the idea that Scotland (and wales, NI) are participants in a voluntary union.

International law states that:

“Self-determination denotes the legal right of people to decide their own destiny in the international order.
Self-determination is a core principle of international law, arising from customary international law, but also recognized as a general principle of law, and enshrined in a number of international treaties.
For instance, self-determination is protected in the United Nations Charter and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights as a right of “all peoples.”Self-determination denotes the legal right of people to decide their own destiny in the international order.
Self-determination is a core principle of international law, arising from customary international law, but also recognized as a general principle of law, and enshrined in a number of international treaties.
For instance, self-determination is protected in the United Nations Charter and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights as a right of “all peoples.”

So, Aibu to think that Scotland (and Wales, Ni) has the right to decide it’s own future if it wants? And that includes the right to another referendum if it wants?

Interesting image doing the rounds on Twitter! I speak as an “Indy curious” Welsh person who had never considers Welsh independence until recently because we have always been told we were too poor, too small etc and I don’t nescessarily believe that anymore!

OP posts:
Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 24/11/2022 08:18

They have had their vote. They voted to remain. Thats it. You don't get to continually hold referendums because you didn't like the result.

kingvizzytarg · 24/11/2022 08:16

That's because people are blinded by independence. They do not care about their poor track record or the rest of their policies. Plus you have the other pro-independence parties telling their supporters to vote SNP first.

The pro-unionist parties have a larger vote share. If we could magically make everyone just vote for one party at the next election instead of Labour/Tory/Lib Dem/Independent......but most voters care about more than a single issue

FortSalem86 · 24/11/2022 08:15

Cosycover · 24/11/2022 08:13

Catalonia don't have an issue with Scotland at all.

You missed my point entirely. Spain would though.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 24/11/2022 08:15

beavonsfield isn’t a country- Scotland, wales and Ireland are countries!

How far do we go back? Cornwall was historically a country in its own right. What about the Kingdoms of Wessex, Mercia and all the rest?

The people of Scotland had the special privilege in 2014 that nobody else in the UK has been given in recent times to vote on whether they wanted to leave the UK and they voted that they did not want to leave. Yes, it wasn't by the widest of margins, but nobody will ever convince me that NS wouldn't have seized it as a decisive victory had it tipped the other way by the same margin.

As has already been said, this new ruling also removes any right for the other three home nations to a binding vote for independence. Just imagine that England said "We've had enough of all the squabbling" and voted to leave the UK - how would that play out? Doubtless, we'd be called nasty bigoted racists for even hinting at merely wanting the exact same opportunity as Scotland has already had.

Wereongunoil · 24/11/2022 08:15

Fragmentsof2022 · 24/11/2022 08:12

@MichelleScarn i already said I think there needs to be a better process than a referendum- I don’t know what that is.

The point ultimately is that Scotland has cited the SNP into nearly every parliamentary seat in Scotland knowing that they are a nationalist party who wants independence. That’s what the SNP are basing all of this on.

If, in the next election, they stand on a single issue and get voted out in every seat then there’s your answer. If they get voted in again unanimously then there is your answer too.

We have a first past the post voting system.

That doesn't mean the majority party got more than 50% of the votes, it just means they got more than anyone else.

If there were only two parties yes but where there are three or more it's highly likely they got less than 50%

Cosycover · 24/11/2022 08:15

Fragmentsof2022 · 24/11/2022 08:12

@MichelleScarn i already said I think there needs to be a better process than a referendum- I don’t know what that is.

The point ultimately is that Scotland has cited the SNP into nearly every parliamentary seat in Scotland knowing that they are a nationalist party who wants independence. That’s what the SNP are basing all of this on.

If, in the next election, they stand on a single issue and get voted out in every seat then there’s your answer. If they get voted in again unanimously then there is your answer too.

Which they will.
I think Scotland have made it clear where they stand.
Brexit pissed them off big time.
Scotlands votes count for nothing down South.

luxxlisbon · 24/11/2022 08:14

So the Supreme Court voted yesterday to not allow Scotland Indy ref 2 without the permission of Westminster, ending the idea that Scotland (and wales, NI) are participants in a voluntary union.

How does that change anything? NI would need Westminster to call a border poll too.

IamThegreaterMole · 24/11/2022 08:13

Fragmentsof2022 · 24/11/2022 08:06

@IamThegreaterMole i will get the picture removed as I didn’t mean it to cause so much offence

@mumsnet - can you remove the picture from my post?

Thank you

Fragmentsof2022 · 24/11/2022 08:13

@Freysimo yea and loads of research done since points to that vote in Wales being swayed by English retirees

OP posts:
Rainbowshit · 24/11/2022 08:13

We had a referendum just a short while ago. Scotland voted to remain part of the UK. We did have self determination. Just because it didn't go the way you would like doesn't mean Scotland didn't decide.

The SNP immediately called for another referendum. What do you think would happen if they had a right to call a referendum whenever they choose? They would call one again and again and again and it would be extremely destabilising to Scotland and the UK. Not to mention the cost and the focus being away from more important things like education, the NHS etc.

The Supreme Court decision was absolutely correct.

Cosycover · 24/11/2022 08:13

FortSalem86 · 24/11/2022 08:06

I can't see the EU welcoming Scotland or the rest into the EU as independent countries otherwise that would cause problems with places like Catalonia.

Catalonia don't have an issue with Scotland at all.

Fragmentsof2022 · 24/11/2022 08:12

@MichelleScarn i already said I think there needs to be a better process than a referendum- I don’t know what that is.

The point ultimately is that Scotland has cited the SNP into nearly every parliamentary seat in Scotland knowing that they are a nationalist party who wants independence. That’s what the SNP are basing all of this on.

If, in the next election, they stand on a single issue and get voted out in every seat then there’s your answer. If they get voted in again unanimously then there is your answer too.

OP posts:
Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 24/11/2022 08:11

I just wish that the English were allowed to vote on whether they want to stay in a Union with Scotland. Union is supposed to be a joining of two partners, but one side is not allowed a divorce , or even asked whether they would favour one.

One person, one vote doesn’t apply in questions of Union, I guess.

Cosycover · 24/11/2022 08:10

midgetastic · 24/11/2022 07:41

What about the north east ?

What about Newcastle ?

What about femham ( small part of Newcastle )

What are the criteria for "self determination"

As others have said they voted and lost once very recently

Although brexit majorly changed what they voted to stay part of

A solution would be better representation in the UK parliament not rule by the tories based on the results in a few constituencies

Those places you mentioned aren't countries. They are in England.

MarshaBradyo · 24/11/2022 08:10

HeraldicBlazoning · 24/11/2022 08:05

Yup, you clearly know the law better than the Supreme Court judges. Go you. 🙄

The ruling was very considered and unanimous amongst the judges. I heard some of it and it was good to know the legal case.

Freysimo · 24/11/2022 08:09

Fragmentsof2022 · 24/11/2022 08:04

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll although if we look at the Welsh government, it’s never ever voted tory as a majority.

Wales voted for Brexit though?

MichelleScarn · 24/11/2022 08:07

I've found that when people pose the ops question, they only mean 'self determination as long as its the answer we want' which is clear as they're not accepting the original vote.
If it was a yes @Fragmentsof2022 would you allow for another vote the year after, or would that be final?

Changingplace · 24/11/2022 08:06

Fragmentsof2022 · 24/11/2022 07:45

@DownNative I am not deliberately distorting international law at all. I am asking a question and saying I’m Indy curious.

Many leading commentators in Scotland (and wales) are all talking about self determination today and lack of democracy at Westminster making decisions about another country having a right to decide their own future and I agree.

Scotland already had a vote to decide its own future, why are you trying to overturn that democratic process that already happened?

What would make a new vote more democratic than the previous one?

Fragmentsof2022 · 24/11/2022 08:06

@IamThegreaterMole i will get the picture removed as I didn’t mean it to cause so much offence

@mumsnet - can you remove the picture from my post?

OP posts:
FortSalem86 · 24/11/2022 08:06

I can't see the EU welcoming Scotland or the rest into the EU as independent countries otherwise that would cause problems with places like Catalonia.

Wereongunoil · 24/11/2022 08:05

They had a referendum, they voted to stay as part of the UK.

There was a referendum to determine whether we wanted to be part of the EU. We voted against.

Both were touted as once only.

Why can Scotland have another vote because they didn't like the result of the first but not the UK on staying in the EU? 🤔

Double standards I think

HeraldicBlazoning · 24/11/2022 08:05

Yup, you clearly know the law better than the Supreme Court judges. Go you. 🙄

Coconut212 · 24/11/2022 08:05

I’d vote yes, as I did at the last referendum and I’d keep voting yes.

Fragmentsof2022 · 24/11/2022 08:04

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll although if we look at the Welsh government, it’s never ever voted tory as a majority.

OP posts:
Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 24/11/2022 08:04

TeenDivided · 24/11/2022 08:00

I don't think referenda should be allowed to make massive changes with out a massive majority, at least 60-40 if not 65-35. Or a 50%+1should have a repeat referendum say 10 years later before action.

I therefore think that a) Brexit shouldn't have gone through and b) The Scots had their chance, they can't keep repeating this every few years until by luck once it just gets through by a slim vote.

Agree absolutely with this. To change the status quo should require more than 50% of the vote. Maybe 50% of the eligible vote or 66% of actual vote. So then, it can definitely be said that change is wanted by the majority.

Swipe left for the next trending thread