Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think it's ridiculous for football player in Qatar to want to protest about LGBT rights?

165 replies

Sausagenbacon · 23/11/2022 23:07

when they are playing in stadiums built by migrant workers in appalling conditions? Plus, to me it seems the height of cultural imperialism to go to other countries and expect them to adopt out moral stances.

OP posts:
RedAppleGirl · 24/11/2022 07:50

headstone · 24/11/2022 02:21

It’s a World Cup, can’t just have it in western countries. This is the first time in an Arab country. I think there is a lot of racism going on and deep exaggeration. All those footballers are happy to get their massive salaries paid with Arab money. Respect the countries laws and enjoy the football, how hard is that.

I agree entirely this is racism pure and simple.
As it stands the tournament has actually been quite good so far.

pd339 · 24/11/2022 07:47

Indeed. Virtue signalling at its finest.

Mumsgirls · 24/11/2022 07:42

I think the Iranian team were brave by not singing in protest at their government. With that regime it took real guts and made the rest look feeble.
Reminds me of the black power salutes 1968 that rocked the world. They paid a big price. Footballers have missed chance to do the right thing and look pathetic Roy Keane right on this
All too late anyway UEFA should have stood up to FIFA a when it was corruptly awarded many years ago. They should have threatened a boycott and fifa would have backed down or imploded. World Cup not feasible without Europe and they should have used their clout for good.

FiveMins · 24/11/2022 07:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Urghh what a vile homophobic load of bile.
You realise gay men in much of the world are at risk of imprisonment or worse. It's about love not just sex.
It is possible to fight for more than one group of people's basic rights at the same time. The focus should be on treating all people well.

Lawandsawdus · 24/11/2022 07:30

Runningslow · 24/11/2022 07:07

I think you’re being harsh on the players. The fault is with FIFA for awarding it to Qatar. The players will have been dreaming of playing in the World Cup all their lives- for some, this will be their only chance. Should we really be disappointed in them not giving up their life’s dream through no fault of their own? Do you really think it would change anything?

Agree with this. As to protest at the time a lot of the players will have been under 18 or just over 12 years ago when it was awarded.

of course the consequences are not brutal or violent but here is what happens- it will likely affect the Captain, team and therefore fans of the team.

If the players did continue the protest and were given yellow cards they would not be able to play the final group game. As Captain is usually one of the best players affect the team badly. The final tie break at the group stage is numbers of yellow and red cards. If they get through to the final stage it starts again - miss the World Cup final itself.

sashagabadon · 24/11/2022 07:30

It was rather pathetic. Personally I don’t agree with politics in football in the first place ( others might disagree) but if you are going to make football political which they have then you need to follow through on your political statement or else you look like an idiot. The same applies to Gary linekar et al. A yellow card for your principals is pretty tame imo. Harry Kane either supports lgbt rights or he doesn’t really but is going along with it as long as no personal cost to himself.

ArcticSkewer · 24/11/2022 07:27

lemmein · 24/11/2022 01:42

What I don't understand is, if football is so cool with LGBT rights, if footballers truly believe in 'one love' then why is there only one premier league footballer who is openly gay? Are we really so enlightened and civilised in this country when young men have to hide their sexuality in 2022? Hmm

Yup.

Football world is so homophobic noone dares come out. Yet here they are being all Rainbow.

ememem84 · 24/11/2022 07:25

I said to DH that I thought it was crazy the threat of a yellow card made the teams put their protesting away. (Although still think a better protest would have been for them to not go but hey ho)

he said that because of the yellow card rules he suspects there will be more protesting the further the teams go into the contest. St this stage if too many cards were given to the England players (for example) I think the players would be banned from playing. So imagine the media circus. “We could have brought it home if it wasn’t for x protesting….”

either way. I think fifa are doscraceful.

BrightOrangeRectangles · 24/11/2022 07:24

YANBU, though I agree that it's ridiculous purely from the standpoint that they're not at all protesting for women's rights. Footballers taking the moral highground on LGBT but nothing else, not even mistreatment of migrants. It seems LGBT matters much much more 🤷‍♀️

KangarooKenny · 24/11/2022 07:21

I thought the Germany team photo was a good one, they all posed with their hand over their mouths, as in they are not allowed a voice.

amylou8 · 24/11/2022 07:18

The mistake here is with FIFA, what were they thinking. But as a football supporter if you don't like it don't go. The woman complaining she couldn't wear her rainbow hat, come home and wear your rainbow hat. If the Quataries came here and stated anti gay demonstrations we'd all have something to say about it, yet we think we have the right to go there and impose our values on them.

Runningslow · 24/11/2022 07:07

I think you’re being harsh on the players. The fault is with FIFA for awarding it to Qatar. The players will have been dreaming of playing in the World Cup all their lives- for some, this will be their only chance. Should we really be disappointed in them not giving up their life’s dream through no fault of their own? Do you really think it would change anything?

NuNameNuMe · 24/11/2022 06:58

YABU. The fault is with FIFA awarding the world cup to countries with poor to none human rights. Russia and now Quatar. If Gianni Infantino is really "gay", "disabled" or a "migrant worker" I'd expect him to be arrested and have his passport confiscated. An offensive clown. Quatar has a culture that should be respected. Football has a culture of its own, which is incompatible. This is a disaster of FIFA's choosing that everyone else puts up with.

Letsjumpthebroomstick · 24/11/2022 02:54

They shouldn't have agreed to have played in the first place if they were serious about making a stand . Different the Iran team who may be shot for not taking part. And I agree with the Pp who said that no one seems to care much about the dead workers or the women's rights in the country.

TheOriginalEmu · 24/11/2022 02:42

Just because one issue is a problem doesn’t mean you can’t take a stand against another does it? If everyone took that view no one would protest anything.
Also disagreeing with killing people for their sexuality isn’t cultural imperialism but a basic human right.

jesus Christ.

user1471453601 · 24/11/2022 02:39

@Skelligsfeathers no one is talking about women's rights?

I'm not watching this corrupt travesty, but even I couldn't miss the fact that Iranian players refused to sing their national anthem in support of the many being killed by their countries regime because they are demonstrating for women's rights. A small act of defiance to be sure, but still more than all European teams managed. Iranian footballers risked their lives for that action, Harry Kane couldn't even risk a yellow card.

as others have said, it's not an either or situation. I don't have to choose whether to support the human rights of migrant workers (or slaves, to name them appropriately) lgbt+ people or women. I'm capable of supporting all three. Mainly because they are all basic human rights issues.. If you hate what happened to those migrant workers, surely you must hate the abuse that happens in that country to women and lgbt+ people also?

BaileySharp · 24/11/2022 02:32

They should have refused to participate if they really wanted to make a stand

IdisagreeMrHochhauser · 24/11/2022 02:25

I think they're all hypocrites unless they come back to their own leagues and make the environment safe enough for gay footballers to come out. Then I'll be impressed.

headstone · 24/11/2022 02:21

It’s a World Cup, can’t just have it in western countries. This is the first time in an Arab country. I think there is a lot of racism going on and deep exaggeration. All those footballers are happy to get their massive salaries paid with Arab money. Respect the countries laws and enjoy the football, how hard is that.

Cheekymaw · 24/11/2022 02:11

@Henuinequest no- greedy people and chavs like Dubai.

How delightfully classist of you. I don't know anyone in my council estate that could afford or want to go to Dubai.

antipodeancanary · 24/11/2022 01:59

Being raped is punishable, being pregnant and unmarried is punishable, being divorced as a woman is punishable, lashes of a whip being a preferred punishment. Working, having custody of children, travelling or studying are punishable unless authorised by a father or husband. Wasn't it Qatar that took all the Australian women off a flight in Doha as a foetus has been found in an airport toilet and they carried out intimate examinations in order to find out which woman had delivered, as miscarriages are also punishable. Unhappy days.

antipodeancanary · 24/11/2022 01:49

Skelligsfeathers · 23/11/2022 23:09

What pisses me off is all the attention is on lgbtqi rights and noone is mentioning womens rights. Or rather the complete lack of them in Qatar

This.There are way more women being harmed in Qatar than LGB people. Half the population to be exact.

lemmein · 24/11/2022 01:42

What I don't understand is, if football is so cool with LGBT rights, if footballers truly believe in 'one love' then why is there only one premier league footballer who is openly gay? Are we really so enlightened and civilised in this country when young men have to hide their sexuality in 2022? Hmm

ErrolTheDragon · 24/11/2022 01:37

Two (or in the case of Qatar, many) wrongs don't make a right.
No, it's not ridiculous the footballers wanted to protest about gay rights.
It's ridiculous they caved in. I'd have thought there should have been at least a few pairs of teams where everyone would have agreed to wear the armband so they'd all have got a yellow card and it would have been fair.

Softplayhooray · 24/11/2022 01:28

It's never wrong to protest injustice, ever.

Lots of word salads on social media and whataboutism and intellectual statements about this and that. All that matters is that it's wrong.

The treatment of migrant workers is a separate issue and also very wrong. You're welcome to join a lot of people already out there to make a noise about that or any other issue, and how it is wrong. We can all stand up and use our voices.

Swipe left for the next trending thread