Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think it's ridiculous for football player in Qatar to want to protest about LGBT rights?

165 replies

Sausagenbacon · 23/11/2022 23:07

when they are playing in stadiums built by migrant workers in appalling conditions? Plus, to me it seems the height of cultural imperialism to go to other countries and expect them to adopt out moral stances.

OP posts:
PeekAtYou · 24/11/2022 09:20

I think it's ridiculous because men's football (in England at least) has an environment where players can't/won't come out.

TooBigForMyBoots · 24/11/2022 09:19

YABU. I am loving the protests. Anything that shines the light on persecution and discrimination is fine by me.

toffeecrisps · 24/11/2022 09:16

headstone · 24/11/2022 02:21

It’s a World Cup, can’t just have it in western countries. This is the first time in an Arab country. I think there is a lot of racism going on and deep exaggeration. All those footballers are happy to get their massive salaries paid with Arab money. Respect the countries laws and enjoy the football, how hard is that.

Why should anyone respect laws that are abhorrent?

Henuinequest · 24/11/2022 09:11

‘I was surprised at some of the anti gay comments on here. Not what I thought I'd read on MN.’

unfortunately I’m not, but i do think it’s a reflection of the U.K. as a whole. Homophobia is still rampant and something that may gay people experience on a daily basis.
ANY thread on MN with gay people mentioned often tends to descend into wahtaboutery, homophobic comments or down an anti trans rabbit hole.

barneshome · 24/11/2022 08:55

WhereYouLeftIt · 23/11/2022 23:32

Agree. Empty virtue signalling from all involved.

Being told they'd be yellow-carded was enough to make the players/FA back down at high speed. If they'd actually cared, they'd have swallowed the yellow card and played 'clean' to ensure they weren't red-carded. But no, the possibility of consequences left them aghast and backing down.

Agree 100%
Personally I would not watch it as I have less than zero interest in a game where people dive cheat and cry all the time anyway
What does p me off is the idiot Rashford who constantly goes on about poverty and how the govt let him down ( not his own father who left his family with no money of course - it is the taxpayers who should have paid for him, )about discrimination, but he is happy to take money to play in a state where there is enormous slave labour and discrimination.
So to him only poor black people seem to matter - not LGBT rights - not gay rights - not workers right
Total hypocrite

EndlessRain · 24/11/2022 08:55

I thought you were going to say it was hypocritical as they are taking part.

But your argument is a little like all lives matter. They shouldn't be talking about LGTB+ rights because the workers? Would it be better to you if they said nothing about anyone?

It shoudl all be taked about - LGTB+, the workers, women, the entire lack of human rights. The world cup should never have been there.

Simonjt · 24/11/2022 08:52

Hobbesmanc · 24/11/2022 08:37

I was surprised at some of the anti gay comments on here. Not what I thought I'd read on MN.

As a gay person, sadly some of the comments I have seen on MN recently are very similar to ones I would usually see on MN, just not quite as often.

ASMRTingles · 24/11/2022 08:45

lemmein · 24/11/2022 01:42

What I don't understand is, if football is so cool with LGBT rights, if footballers truly believe in 'one love' then why is there only one premier league footballer who is openly gay? Are we really so enlightened and civilised in this country when young men have to hide their sexuality in 2022? Hmm

Exactly.

MissTrip82 · 24/11/2022 08:40

If you were waiting to hold it someone with a perfect human rights record it wouldn't happen. I can't see a problem with people speaking about the issues.

In any event, every last person using a phrase as stupid, narrow and mean-spirited as 'virtue signalling' would have used it if they'd said they wouldn't play, or indeed had taken any other action whatsoever other than silent acquiescence. These types always think anyone challenging the status quo in any way is doing it wrong, and never engage with the actual issue itself.

ImprobablePuffin · 24/11/2022 08:38

"Quatar has a culture that should be respected."

Why should we respect a culture that despises women, has no problem with slavery and imprisons and kills people because of their sexuality? A culture that only benefits straight men?

Anyone who respects that needs to take a good hard look at themselves.

Hobbesmanc · 24/11/2022 08:37

HotchPotched · 24/11/2022 08:30

Bots and trolls pushing homophobic and misogynistic agendas are out in full force all over the internet in relation to the World Cup in Qatar. They have swamped the comments sections of British newspaper’s websites and Facebook. I am pretty certain mumsnet also has it’s fair share. Some of these comments are absolutely not in the spirit of mumsnet….

I was surprised at some of the anti gay comments on here. Not what I thought I'd read on MN.

Hobbesmanc · 24/11/2022 08:35

The one love armband is intended to be a unification symbol and condemnation of all,discrimination. Although I appreciate the LGBT rainbow symbolism has been the focus of most commentary.

Sport. Religion. Politics. Culture. It's inevitably going to be messy. Kudos to individuals trying to have a voice above the FIFA/Qatar leadership lines. I thought the Iranians were so brave.

MMoon23 · 24/11/2022 08:30

BrightOrangeRectangles · 24/11/2022 07:24

YANBU, though I agree that it's ridiculous purely from the standpoint that they're not at all protesting for women's rights. Footballers taking the moral highground on LGBT but nothing else, not even mistreatment of migrants. It seems LGBT matters much much more 🤷‍♀️

this thread is so beyond depressing
it’s not a competition of minorities/oppressed groups

there are also many many people who belong to multiple groups (e.g Female, lgbtq people, living in countries where these traits are penalised). You don’t have to pick one to support! Or one to think is worthy and one not. Lots of people are affected by multiple layers of discrimination. It’s called intersectionality.

discrimination of ‘the other’, ‘less ideal’ group is the basically the same across the board. we are not against each other.

And ffs being pro the lgbt community and it’s progression Is basic human rights. It’s not a political or cultural stance or agenda. It’s peoples right to live as who they are.

HotchPotched · 24/11/2022 08:30

Bots and trolls pushing homophobic and misogynistic agendas are out in full force all over the internet in relation to the World Cup in Qatar. They have swamped the comments sections of British newspaper’s websites and Facebook. I am pretty certain mumsnet also has it’s fair share. Some of these comments are absolutely not in the spirit of mumsnet….

WickedSerious · 24/11/2022 08:29

It's been a proper shit show,hopefully this will be the last time they award a tournament to a medieval hellhole.

I won't hold my breath though.

gogohmm · 24/11/2022 08:25

@BrightOrangeRectangles

Mostly due to the homophobia at the youth level, they drop out long before they reach elite football. Women's football is more equal!

BrightOrangeRectangles · 24/11/2022 08:22

I don't know of one out and proud homosexual Premier league or national team footballer, yet there surely has to be at least one gay man amongst the ranks?? Why's that then?

Hypocrits

KnickerlessParsons · 24/11/2022 08:11

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 23/11/2022 23:15

Half-hearted protests which evaporate as soon as there's the merest suggestion of any kind of consequences for those protesting.

The time for real protest would have been for everyone who is a decent human being to have signed a pledge not to go to Qatar back when the decision was made to hold the event there.

Instead the regime is getting the message loud and clear that the west is totally happy to turn a blind eye to every kind of human rights abuse if there's any kind of money or influence up for grabs for those who cooperate.

I agree. If several high profile teams were to get disqualified for their protesting, wearing the armband, whatever - now that would make a point.

IcedPurple · 24/11/2022 08:09

KangarooKenny · 24/11/2022 07:21

I thought the Germany team photo was a good one, they all posed with their hand over their mouths, as in they are not allowed a voice.

So Germany made a gesture which they knew would cost them nothing. They could have insisted on wearing the armbands but when told they would risk a yellow card, they immediately backed down.

It's all very performative, and has more to do with making the football associations feel good rather than with gay rights in Qatar.

HiphopReplacement · 24/11/2022 08:01

Skelligsfeathers · 23/11/2022 23:09

What pisses me off is all the attention is on lgbtqi rights and noone is mentioning womens rights. Or rather the complete lack of them in Qatar

This.
By all means, raise the issue with LGB issues but what about women's rights?
They aren't even getting anywhere near the coverage.

Catastrophejane · 24/11/2022 08:00

Henuinequest · 24/11/2022 00:19

‘Plenty of people have mentioned their record on women's rights. It's not a competition.’

exactly. Being a woman isn’t punishable by lengthy prison sentences or death. Being gay is.

the main issue is that it shouldn’t be held in Qatar at all - it’s a joke that it is.
all those people who died building the stadiums…

I would challenge that assumption. Being a woman is subject to lengthy prison sentences. If you’ve been raped and you know the rapist ( as in most rape cases) then it’s basically considered sex out of marriage. You’ll get 7 years in jail. And extra lashes if you’re Muslim.

No-one is arrested for ‘being gay’ in the same way as no woman is arrested for ‘being a woman’. If a gay guy doesn’t engage in any sexual activity, he’s just a bloke and will be left alone.

and I don’t think that women being treated as ‘less than’ men is somehow not that bad!!

I am fully supportive of the LGBTQ protests, but it’s more than fair to point out the comparative silence on women’s rights. look through the articles on BBC website and Guardian. There’s rarely more than a line on women’s rights. ( I’ve checked!). That’s an issue that affects half of the world’s population ffs!!

HowDoYouOwnDisorder · 24/11/2022 07:59

I think it is interesting how there are some sporadic attempts to raise LGBQ issues, but NOTHING about women’s rights. Nothing

women are not free in Qatar, they are under male guardianship.

bit FIFA and all the presenters just saying we should respect their culture and rules

it just shows to the world that “Western Values” can be negotiated away for enough money. We are capitalist first, and care about equality or women’s or LGBTQ rights only if it does not cost us.

Gary Lineker, David Be kham, FIFA, Brutush media essentially saying : women are equal to men but we don’t really care if they are not free in other cultures, then we must respect the men of that culture and their rights and traditions to treat women badly, and exploit migrant workers

money talks

all those pundits out there supporting and defending Qatar are just out there for themselves and the money and fuck women’s rights, migrants rights and LGBTQ rights. As long as the men are alright, right?

gogohmm · 24/11/2022 07:59

@sofasofa42

I wouldn't holiday in Dubai either. I do admit to flying with Middle Eastern airlines for financial reasons (half the price of the national carrier, only alternative which I know is hypocritical

Cluelessdiyer · 24/11/2022 07:52

No one’s wearing suffragette armbands are they

Simonjt · 24/11/2022 07:52

headstone · 24/11/2022 02:21

It’s a World Cup, can’t just have it in western countries. This is the first time in an Arab country. I think there is a lot of racism going on and deep exaggeration. All those footballers are happy to get their massive salaries paid with Arab money. Respect the countries laws and enjoy the football, how hard is that.

Fairly hard for people who don’t hate women, who aren’t homophobic and for those who believe migrant workers are human beings.

Swipe left for the next trending thread