Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think it's ridiculous for football player in Qatar to want to protest about LGBT rights?

165 replies

Sausagenbacon · 23/11/2022 23:07

when they are playing in stadiums built by migrant workers in appalling conditions? Plus, to me it seems the height of cultural imperialism to go to other countries and expect them to adopt out moral stances.

OP posts:
WhatWouldKimDealDo · 24/11/2022 10:12

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 09:54

It's not about a moral stance, or a cultural difference though, is it, it's about basic human rights.
No, it's your view of basic human rights. Which obviously trumps everyone else's. Because, as I said before, you're a Westerner and we're always right.

Yeah....I'm ok with the view that all humans should be treated with respect irrespective of their gender, nationality or sexuality - and that people shouldn't be lashed, beaten or imprisoned for years on the basis of hatred and fear of difference/women getting to loud a voice.

Verv · 24/11/2022 10:11

antipodeancanary · 24/11/2022 01:49

This.There are way more women being harmed in Qatar than LGB people. Half the population to be exact.

Half of LGB people are women.

ErrolTheDragon · 24/11/2022 10:11

I believe in 'basic human rights' where I live. Because my culture subscribes to them.

So you don't really believe in basic human rights. You don't really believe women are equal to men, just that we're allowed to be (more or less) in our society. You don't really believe homophobic oppression is a bad thing. Would you have campaigned for homosexuality to be legalised in the U.K. at a time when 'our culture' didn't subscribe to that? Would you have asserted women's rights when 'our culture' was firmly against them?

EndlessRain · 24/11/2022 10:06

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 09:48

Like other posters, I believe that it should not have been held in Qatar.
But I am uncomfortable with the assumption that we are Right. It's as though the British Empire never went away.

You are uncomfortable saying we are "right" and they are "wrong" when we are talking about beating up people as punishment for being gay, slave labour, no rights for women and too many human rights abuses to mention? I am completely ok about saying we are right and they are wrong about that.

ErrolTheDragon · 24/11/2022 10:05

They live the way they want to live

Qatar isn't a democracy. Do 'they' all live the way they want to live? The imposition of values is from within.

SeenAndNot · 24/11/2022 10:03

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 23/11/2022 23:15

Half-hearted protests which evaporate as soon as there's the merest suggestion of any kind of consequences for those protesting.

The time for real protest would have been for everyone who is a decent human being to have signed a pledge not to go to Qatar back when the decision was made to hold the event there.

Instead the regime is getting the message loud and clear that the west is totally happy to turn a blind eye to every kind of human rights abuse if there's any kind of money or influence up for grabs for those who cooperate.

Exactly this.

our players shouldn’t be over there.

ErrolTheDragon · 24/11/2022 10:02

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 09:56

To make it clear, I support Gay and Women's Rights. But I'm not arrogant enough to think that everyone in the world should agree with me.

But you didn't feel the need to apply your moral relativism to the South African boycotts - the argument you're trying to make doesn't depend on the nature or location of the protest.
You appear to think it's fine to be 'right' on racism (which it is) but not right re homophobic oppression.

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 10:01

I believe in 'basic human rights' where I live. Because my culture subscribes to them.
Obviously, the view of what those rights are vary across other cultures. We don't have the right to impose our views on others, especially in their country.
If you don't like it, don't play there, and don't watch it.

OP posts:
mariiinaa · 24/11/2022 09:59

it's the fact that most people can't talk about this issue because we're labelled as LGBTQ-phobic??? when we're really not, but when has this become relevant to football in any way? there's no association whatsoever. it's bizarre to me to want to implement this when it's in no way relevant.

FluffyFlower · 24/11/2022 09:57

Armbands, silent protests.. this all seems to be self-fulfilling PR for western teams. The Arab world has felt disrespected. They live the way they want to live and I agree we can't impose western values to other counties. We go there - we respect their traditions, customs, laws and religion. They come here - they respect ours. Nothing wrong with holding the World Cup in Qatar, all kinds of nations have the right to enjoy football, does it only have to be in the West? Would not that be discrimination? As always, double standards..

HotchPotched · 24/11/2022 09:57

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 09:48

Like other posters, I believe that it should not have been held in Qatar.
But I am uncomfortable with the assumption that we are Right. It's as though the British Empire never went away.

So you are questioning whether basic human rights are ‘right’?

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 09:56

To make it clear, I support Gay and Women's Rights. But I'm not arrogant enough to think that everyone in the world should agree with me.

OP posts:
maranella · 24/11/2022 09:55

If anyone genuinely gave a flying fuck at LGBT, women's and migrant workers' rights they wouldn't have given Qatar the WC, the players would refuse to play and fans would refuse to attend. FIFA is a fucking disgrace - so corrupt.

Henuinequest · 24/11/2022 09:54

‘I think you’re being harsh on the players. ‘

not wearing the armbands because of the threat of a yellow card was a SUPREME act of cowardice. If those captains had all worn the armband regardless of the threat imagine the impact. Would FIFA really continue to ‘punish’ teams??
All this fuss about teams going but taking a stand or taking part because they’d get a chance to represent or some such BS crumbled immediately at the first obstacle. Beyond pathetic.

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 09:54

It's not about a moral stance, or a cultural difference though, is it, it's about basic human rights.
No, it's your view of basic human rights. Which obviously trumps everyone else's. Because, as I said before, you're a Westerner and we're always right.

OP posts:
Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 09:51

Do you think the teams and individuals who boycotted South Africa during apartheid were wrong?
No, because they didn't go. To go and still object is pathetic, especially as they tacitly pass over the construction issues .

OP posts:
WhatWouldKimDealDo · 24/11/2022 09:49

It's not about a moral stance, or a cultural difference though, is it, it's about basic human rights.

"but the gays are ok as long as they don't act gay" isn't really a great argument is it - would you be happy as a heterosexual person to live in a country where you weren't able to have a relationship, talk about your relationships, have any kind of family/friend/colleague discussion about your relationship? Where you had to keep it hidden or have a sham relationship with someone you weren't remotely interested in just so you didn't go to prison or get thrown off a building? Where how you felt every single day was universally thought of as perverse and something that the rest of the community needed to be protected from? Just because of who you love, who is another consenting adult?

Like the previous poster said, have you ever tried to go on holiday with your partner and not appear as a couple, or experienced people scrutinising you because they want to know what the nature of your relationship is?

Everyone on this thread is fully able to go out and protest women's rights and slave labour - those that are saying these should be the issue at the forefront, what have you physically actively done to protest these things? If you don't like the fact that LGBT lobby has a loud voice then get out there and add yours to the cause you want to champion - it's not a pie, if one protest has a big slice, the other issues don't get smaller slices.

And for the poster saying it's all about white men wanting anal sex or whatever you said - seriously, grow up.

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 09:48

Like other posters, I believe that it should not have been held in Qatar.
But I am uncomfortable with the assumption that we are Right. It's as though the British Empire never went away.

OP posts:
Wanderingowl · 24/11/2022 09:43

Runningslow · 24/11/2022 07:07

I think you’re being harsh on the players. The fault is with FIFA for awarding it to Qatar. The players will have been dreaming of playing in the World Cup all their lives- for some, this will be their only chance. Should we really be disappointed in them not giving up their life’s dream through no fault of their own? Do you really think it would change anything?

No sorry. These players aren't like most Olympians, for example, most of whom, at best, eke out a living based on their sporting talent while many others work a different job and have hundreds of people snapping at their heels who they could be replaced by without most people noticing. These are professional footballers. Some of the most highly paid, influential and known about people in Europe, if not the planet. If they had collectively said no, and refused to go to Qatar, it wouldn't have happened. But of course they wouldn't, because European football is flooded with middle Eastern money and their enormous salaries, depend on playing nice with regimes that have appalling human rights records.

So they will virtue signal a bit now, so they can look good to our general public. But they won't do anything real to protest it, because they would be compromising a portion of their potential for vast wealth if they do.

ErrolTheDragon · 24/11/2022 09:40

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 09:31

Fwiw I absolutely support Gay Rights. But I would never go to another country and demand that they changed their laws to suit my moral compass. Because I'M RIGHT and you're backward and wrong. And no, that doesn't make me homophobic.

It would have been much better if the teams hadn't gone. Do you think the teams and individuals who boycotted South Africa during apartheid were wrong?

HotchPotched · 24/11/2022 09:38

No one is demanding they change their laws, sadly that is not going to happen any time soon. People are supporting the LBGTQ community. You shouldn’t need a ‘moral compass’ to support such basic human rights.

MagpiePi · 24/11/2022 09:38

I agree with PP that it is all hypocritical of UK players and officials considering the number of out gay professional players here.

I'm sure the Qatar government are crying into their piles of cash at the thought of some rainbow armbands.

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 09:31

Fwiw I absolutely support Gay Rights. But I would never go to another country and demand that they changed their laws to suit my moral compass. Because I'M RIGHT and you're backward and wrong. And no, that doesn't make me homophobic.

OP posts:
ErrolTheDragon · 24/11/2022 09:24

PeekAtYou · 24/11/2022 09:20

I think it's ridiculous because men's football (in England at least) has an environment where players can't/won't come out.

Yes, it is pretty hypocritical.

I've a very faint hope that at least some of the mass of fans will be affronted by their teams being threatened with punishment for supporting gay rights (that's what's primarily at issue directly relevant to the men's game) and this may paradoxically make homophobia in their ranks a bit less acceptable at home.

HotchPotched · 24/11/2022 09:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What’s your point? The only gay people in the world are white men? That being gay reduces human beings to a sex act?

Swipe left for the next trending thread