Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think it's ridiculous for football player in Qatar to want to protest about LGBT rights?

165 replies

Sausagenbacon · 23/11/2022 23:07

when they are playing in stadiums built by migrant workers in appalling conditions? Plus, to me it seems the height of cultural imperialism to go to other countries and expect them to adopt out moral stances.

OP posts:
tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 24/11/2022 10:48

Homosexuality can be punishable by death in Quatar. It's great your friends are safe but that's one hell of a deterrent.

My point was to highlight how offensive it is to claim posters discussing this was just a silly western view

Tigofigo · 24/11/2022 10:46

I think you're missing the point that players in those 7 countries (not just UK) usually wear the one love armband in other matches as part of a long-standing agreement in an attempt to make men's football inclusive to gay / queer players and fans. They don't usually wear a migrant workers' rights or women's rights armband.

That's why in the past few days there's been a focus on LGBTQ+ armband discussion and the players' potential punishment. Then Alex Davies wore her armband which got more coverage. (Whether or not you think they are hypocrites, virtue signalling etc or not, the armband is a outwardly public sign of support)

I've read and heard plenty of discourse on the other human rights issues in Qatar personally. And the Iran team did a brilliant job of standing up for women's rights.

What I'm shocked at is the lack of discourse over the environmental impact. Those outside air con units make me so angry.

Should the world cup be in Qatar? 100% no, for ALL the reasons. I hope FIFA will learn a hard lesson from this.

purpleboy · 24/11/2022 10:45

I don't think football should be political. If individuals want to share their beliefs off the pitch fine, but it shouldn't be on the pitch. It's a sport/entertainment and has nothing to do with politics.

I don't agree the World Cup should be held there, however you could look at every country in the world and find plenty of reasons why it shouldn't be held there.

I don't agree with their values and agree we should have conversations about basic human rights out there, but I also agree that the predominant narrative is around the LGB community, and actually we should be talking about the workers who died out there and also the women's rights. Where are the armbands for migrant workers or women?

Varasnapars · 24/11/2022 10:43

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 24/11/2022 10:40

Bloody westerners, getting in a tizzy because Quatar wants to murder one man for loving another Confused

Genuine question, but who has been murdered? Not being goady: genuinely asking. As I said uptrend, I lived in Qatar alongside several gay people and they are all still alive and weren't arrested at any point.

MintJulia · 24/11/2022 10:42

Yabu.
Qatar has never had so many foreign tourists. This is the world's opportunity to show them that their laws are abhorrent.

Their money may have bought them a World Cup but that doesn't mean anyone should let them think they are a decent regime.

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 10:42

Qatar isn't a democracy. Do 'they' all live the way they want to live? The imposition of values is from within. so how does that entitle us to impose our values from without?

OP posts:
Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 10:41

But you didn't feel the need to apply your moral relativism to the South African boycotts - the argument you're trying to make doesn't depend on the nature or location of the protest.
I think you missed the post where I said I supported boycotts of SA. Which I did.

OP posts:
tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 24/11/2022 10:40

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 09:54

It's not about a moral stance, or a cultural difference though, is it, it's about basic human rights.
No, it's your view of basic human rights. Which obviously trumps everyone else's. Because, as I said before, you're a Westerner and we're always right.

Bloody westerners, getting in a tizzy because Quatar wants to murder one man for loving another Confused

lieselotte · 24/11/2022 10:39

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 09:54

It's not about a moral stance, or a cultural difference though, is it, it's about basic human rights.
No, it's your view of basic human rights. Which obviously trumps everyone else's. Because, as I said before, you're a Westerner and we're always right.

Wanting women to be treated properly isn't being a Westerner and wanting to always be right (lets face it, women aren't treated that well in the West, either). It's simply not wanting women to be treated like chattels. I notice we're now completely ignoring what's going on in Afghanistan.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 24/11/2022 10:39

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 09:48

Like other posters, I believe that it should not have been held in Qatar.
But I am uncomfortable with the assumption that we are Right. It's as though the British Empire never went away.

I don't understand this ... we're talking about a country which is openly and firmly oppressive to many groups , rich native men are ok though.

I think we absolutely can and should judge that as backward. How can a country that had such a system be anything but?

OakAshElm · 24/11/2022 10:36

Qatar have shot themselves in the foot with this one.
If Harry Kane et al had been allowed to wear the armband it would have been much more of a non-story. As it is, threats of yellow cards, very public backing down is hilighting the human rights issues there much more.
The powerful men running Qatar would not have changed their policies or morals just because some footballer wore an armband so it wouldn't have achieved anything anyway. In not allowing the armbands and the outrage that has caused I suspectvmany more people will avoid Qatar for and governments will think twice about trying to justify dealings with Qatar to their now more aware electorate.

Same with the alcohol thing. Loads of people (myself included) wouldn't have noticed Budweiser were sponsors until alcohol was banned in the stadiums. The ban brought them loads of publicity.

lieselotte · 24/11/2022 10:34

many of us don't holiday in Dubai either. I've never set foot in the ME and have no intention of ever doing so

Same here. Desert, heat and no regard for human rights whatsoever. What a great place for a holiday (not).

Varasnapars · 24/11/2022 10:34

@Henuinequest I know of several gay people living their lives with partners in Qatar. Two lesbian couples and one single guy who certainly wasn't living a celibate life out there. One of my ex colleagues was a gay guy from England and my gay friend came for a holiday when I was living there and his sexuality wasn't a secret. Im not arguing with you about what you have said, but am just providing some of my own experience having lived there for several years. Everyone has their own story, of course, but there were definitely lots of gay people going about their lives without being arrested and flogged. Also, PDAs aren't allowed anywhere, even between husbands and wives. Again, not arguing just recounting that there were several gay people on my radar at the time, just going about their lives. Two of them actually came out while living there!

lieselotte · 24/11/2022 10:34

Skelligsfeathers · 23/11/2022 23:09

What pisses me off is all the attention is on lgbtqi rights and noone is mentioning womens rights. Or rather the complete lack of them in Qatar

exactly this, I saw the title of this thread and thought "I wish everyone was as bothered about womens' rights".

It's not LGBT rights either, it's G rights. I doubt anyone much cares about lesbians, either.

maranella · 24/11/2022 10:32

sofasofa42 · 24/11/2022 00:42

I find it amazing that everyone has managed to separate Qatar from the rest of the Middle East. Everyone seems to follow all the morons who go on holiday to Dubai on sponsored Instagram holidays. The world loves a bit of Dubai. How on earth do you think Dubai was built??! It's the SAME.
If you holiday in Dubai you are part of the same issue.

Agreed, but many of us don't holiday in Dubai either. I've never set foot in the ME and have no intention of ever doing so.

TheShellBeach · 24/11/2022 10:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I love this answer.

ErrolTheDragon · 24/11/2022 10:30

I remember an awful lot of people including here saying that the womens win had inspired girls and boys to think they could reach that peak (in sport and other things). Do any of your children or those you know dream of scoring the winning goal for their country?

A proper boycott or protest might have inspired children in other ways, as the sportsmen (it was mostly men in those days) who took a stand against apartheid did when I was young. A proper protest might have inspired them to stand up against homophobia in footballing at home.

ErrolTheDragon · 24/11/2022 10:26

IDidntKnowItWasAParty · 24/11/2022 10:19

What pisses me off is all the attention is on lgbtqi rights and noone is mentioning womens rights. Or rather the complete lack of them in Qatar

This. The appalling treatment of women is almost never mentioned.

I'm extremely pissed off by the absence of interest in women's rights or lack thereof. But that doesn't mean I should be pissed off by some attempt at highlighting gay rights (Im not mentioning the other letters simply because I've no idea what pertains in Qatar). I'm pissed off that it's so half hearted and ineffectual.

Lawandsawdus · 24/11/2022 10:26

As regards the players would you forgo the pinnacle or close to that of your career - richly paid or not? I can’t say hand on heart I would.

I remember an awful lot of people including here saying that the womens win had inspired girls and boys to think they could reach that peak (in sport and other things). Do any of your children or those you know dream of scoring the winning goal for their country?

Not all the teams would take the stand so just another team would win. The player may be injured or just never play at that level again.

This was a corrupt decision made by a group of old men. They are the ones that should be accountable or maybe the football associations rather than individual players.

ScrollingLeaves · 24/11/2022 10:23

Skelligsfeathers· Yesterday 23:09
What pisses me off is all the attention is on lgbtqi rights and noone is mentioning womens rights. Or rather the complete lack of them in Qatar

I agree. Think of how visiting women must dress in many countries let alone behave.

FluffyFlower · 24/11/2022 10:21

ErrolTheDragon · 24/11/2022 10:18

Let them evolve at their own pace within their religions and traditions? Without having some Western football team loudly protesting?! Saudi Arabia has eased lots of rules, and more and more women take senior posts in various Arab countries.

Do you really think the reforms in Saudi (such as they are) happened in a vacuum?

Surely they did so without some Brit or American or German coming over with an armband? They wanted to integrate in the world community and open up the country

pottydimley · 24/11/2022 10:20

sofasofa42 · 24/11/2022 00:42

I find it amazing that everyone has managed to separate Qatar from the rest of the Middle East. Everyone seems to follow all the morons who go on holiday to Dubai on sponsored Instagram holidays. The world loves a bit of Dubai. How on earth do you think Dubai was built??! It's the SAME.
If you holiday in Dubai you are part of the same issue.

Exactly. Having worked across the Middle East, I can give numerous examples of equivalencies in the other Gulf states, including openly expressing outrageously racist views about Jewish people and black people. Qatar's mistake was to open themselves up to scrutiny as part of their wider agenda around diversification in anticipation of oil reserves running out. I think they're probably shocked by the reaction: my impression is that whilst conservative, they are less so than some other Gulf states.

IDidntKnowItWasAParty · 24/11/2022 10:19

What pisses me off is all the attention is on lgbtqi rights and noone is mentioning womens rights. Or rather the complete lack of them in Qatar

This. The appalling treatment of women is almost never mentioned.

ErrolTheDragon · 24/11/2022 10:18

Let them evolve at their own pace within their religions and traditions? Without having some Western football team loudly protesting?! Saudi Arabia has eased lots of rules, and more and more women take senior posts in various Arab countries.

Do you really think the reforms in Saudi (such as they are) happened in a vacuum?

FluffyFlower · 24/11/2022 10:12

ErrolTheDragon · 24/11/2022 10:05

They live the way they want to live

Qatar isn't a democracy. Do 'they' all live the way they want to live? The imposition of values is from within.

Let them evolve at their own pace within their religions and traditions? Without having some Western football team loudly protesting?! Saudi Arabia has eased lots of rules, and more and more women take senior posts in various Arab countries.

Swipe left for the next trending thread