Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think it's ridiculous for football player in Qatar to want to protest about LGBT rights?

165 replies

Sausagenbacon · 23/11/2022 23:07

when they are playing in stadiums built by migrant workers in appalling conditions? Plus, to me it seems the height of cultural imperialism to go to other countries and expect them to adopt out moral stances.

OP posts:
Bideshi · 24/11/2022 11:53

I agree Pottydimly. It's been a few years but this was certainly my take on the gulf states when I had experience of three of them. Shocking me is the very muted outrage about the slave labour that has been a constant but reached shocking levels with the World Cup. Thousands of Nepalis (others too, but I have direct experience of these) lived and worked as slave labour. The number who died or sustained life-changing injuries ran into the thousands. There was no insurance or compensation. It was common for the ones who did survive to go home (when they finally got their passports back)with $1200 for three or four years hard work of long hours in blistering heat. Not such a right-on cause perhaps.
As for LGBTQ rights countries like Qatar are near the top of the intolerance curve without a doubt, but we're all on it somewhere. The World Cup should never have been awarded to Qatar but if you want it to be inclusive, as sport should be, there's always going to be a moral mismatch at some level.
It's unfair to blame the likes of Kane. He's a footballer, not some sort of moral lighthouse to guide us with its beams. FIFA should at the very least have cared for the wellbeing of its players, and not put them in an impossible position.

Brefugee · 24/11/2022 11:38

FIFA don't care. Membership of FIFA is mandatory for countries and their related players, to play in the WC, Euros etc etc. It's not as easy as "we're not coming" because that just means you're out. Forever.

Unles every country in Europe had said that, but they have to speak through UEFA who are closely tied, and probably as corrupt, as FIFA.

OnlyTheBravest · 24/11/2022 11:26

If they were that bothered, FIFA should not have allowed Qatar to host the world cup in the first place. Individual countries could have refused to participate.

Of course I believe in basic rights for all but I do not think it is the business of another country to tell another country what to do. It is for the citizens of that country to stand up for change and hold their government accountable.

KnittedCardi · 24/11/2022 11:24

The women’s national team were launched to great fanfare as part of Qatar’s World Cup bid in 2010 but they have not played a single competitive fixture since 2014

Progress eh?

KnittedCardi · 24/11/2022 11:21

You only have to look at the spectators for the Qatari and Saudi games. Spot the women - clue, there aren't any. They may be some gay men though, you just wouldn't know.

Totellyouthetruth · 24/11/2022 11:19

I agree with you OP.

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 11:14

Yes, I didn't miss it. That's the point - you apply moral relativism to homophobia but not to racism.
no, because I support a boycott of goods from a country, like SA. I wouldn't support those who went to SA to protest. It's nothing to do with racism vs homophobia. It's to do with the West still behaving as though it rules the world. With the inconvenient truth that we have to buy Qatari oil, so we are reduced to armbands

OP posts:
FuckabethFuckor · 24/11/2022 11:13

MavisChunch29 · 24/11/2022 11:09

Gay people are a minority. Women aren't

Doesn't that make women's rights the hotter issue in Qatar? When half the population are second class citizens?

Well, that depends on the perspective. I don't personally think a ranking system of rights is particularly helpful, because it's never going to be universally agreed. It's a dangerous path to go down, minimising or dismissing the rights of minority groups because there's a bigger group who have their own problems.

I think within the context of men's football, in a country where acts of male homosexuality are illegal and potentially punishable by death, it's more directly relevant to protest about inclusivity and gay rights first and foremost.

Again, as I said in my full post, this doesn't mean that women's rights and workers' rights aren't also important, relevant and protestable. Just the context is different.

HelensToenail · 24/11/2022 11:12

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 10:54

What I'm shocked at is the lack of discourse over the environmental impact. Those outside air con units make me so angry.
this in spades.
And, yes, I do watch football.
and I've never said that support from Gay Rights is a 'silly western view'. Just RTFT. I just think that to try and export my views is imperialistic.

Qatar has been a signatory to the UN Charter of Human Rights since 2018 having been a member of the UN for many years

Not sure why you're wanging on about imperialism, western values/culture etc
Human Rights correctly stand above all these

Arguably awarding the WC to Qatar has seen some small movement to aligning with global human rights and labour laws - sadly too late for the workers who died.

Not sure that I'm expecting much further progress in future

MavisChunch29 · 24/11/2022 11:09

Gay people are a minority. Women aren't

Doesn't that make women's rights the hotter issue in Qatar? When half the population are second class citizens?

ErrolTheDragon · 24/11/2022 11:07

Penalising players for making the mildest of protest is 'imposing values'

steaval · 24/11/2022 11:07

Getoff · 24/11/2022 10:52

What is the sentence in Qatar for "being gay", if that's a crime, and what is the sentence for "anal sex"?

Never mind, I've consulted wikipedia. It looks like it is anal sex, not "being gay" that is a problem for them.

Lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) people in Qatar face legal challenges not experienced by non-LGBT residents. Sexual acts of male homosexuality are illegal in Qatar, with a punishment of up to three years in prison and a fine and the possibility of a death penalty for Muslims under sharia law; however, there are no known cases where the death penalty was enforced for homosexuality.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_Qatar

Why is being gay in quotes?

Why are you defending these homophobic laws?

ErrolTheDragon · 24/11/2022 11:05

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 10:42

Qatar isn't a democracy. Do 'they' all live the way they want to live? The imposition of values is from within. so how does that entitle us to impose our values from without?

A protest isn't imposing anything. It's a protest.

FuckabethFuckor · 24/11/2022 11:04

I can think of a couple of reasons, or at least contextualisations, as to why gay rights is the bigger hot-button issue here.

1 Gay people are a minority. Women aren't.
2 Male sexuality could be seen to have a direct relevance to men's football because a certain %age of male players will be gay, even if they are not out. (And much has been written about the toxic nature of men's football, and how gay players are abused, victimised, pressurised to stay in the closet or hounded out of the game.) Women aren't directly involved in playing men's football. There are no women playing for men's teams. So the context for gay men and their representational struggles/issues is more immediately relevant to this situation than women's rights.

This doesn't mean that women's rights or workers' rights don't matter. But the context is relevant. I can totally see why gay rights has become more of a story here than women's rights, and is the better protest in this circumstance. This doesn't mean I don't support better women's rights in Qatar, and indeed many other countries.

ErrolTheDragon · 24/11/2022 11:03

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 10:41

But you didn't feel the need to apply your moral relativism to the South African boycotts - the argument you're trying to make doesn't depend on the nature or location of the protest.
I think you missed the post where I said I supported boycotts of SA. Which I did.

Yes, I didn't miss it. That's the point - you apply moral relativism to homophobia but not to racism.

Brefugee · 24/11/2022 11:02

My feeling is that maybe one or two players might come out after the competition. We'll see.

also "lack of discussion about the environmental impact". Where do you hang out? I've seen plenty.

NetballHoop · 24/11/2022 11:01

Usernamesarboring · 24/11/2022 10:55

It may not be perfect in England or other western countries but you cannot compare this to situation in Qatar where being gay is a punishable crime

When the world cup was held in England, being gay was a punishable crime. Thankfully we have come a long way in the last 56 years, but we are far from perfect.

MavisChunch29 · 24/11/2022 11:00

I think footballers making political points should be their own personal choice. Primarily they are there to play a sport and need to focus on that.

However, they should be aware that as role models and celebrities their words and actions can influence, but it's entirely up to them (other than what they might be required to do or not do contractually) whether they choose to exercise that influence and how they do so. Marcus Rashford, for example, had great effect with his campaign to feed children in the school holidays and while schools were closed.

There is something of a hypocrisy in wearing armbands in support of LGBT+ when not one single male player in league football is openly gay, to my knowledge. Not that everyone should be required to declare their sexuality in the press or whatever these days, but you might think, statistically that there would be several guys in each squad who goes out with guys, not girls, or indeed both.

Obviously the situation in Qatar is much worse, but the FA and Premier League - and indeed UEFA and FIFA - as I can't imagine the situation is much better across Europe or in other football-playing nations - need to get their own houses in order and it takes a lot more than paying lip service to wearing an arm band to encourage diversity and openness in sexuality.

Brefugee · 24/11/2022 11:00

Everyone makes their own decisions about the actions they take on a personal level. I try not to buy products containing palm oil, for eg, and it's bloody hard and often i just buy a product because i'm in a hurry and realise later. It doesn't mean I should just pack in and buy All The Palm Oil because i slipped up once or twice.

I remember reading an interview with Peter Gabriel (in Q) in the early 90s and of course it covered South Africa and then the interviewer said "the grapes in this meeting room are Cape Grapes and you've been eating them" like some kind of GOTCHA! at PG. And Gabriel said, rightly, that we can't control everything but if most people avoid the thing most of the time it is enough. Not everything is in your control.

The playing life of a footballer is relatively short, but it has been the majority of their waking moments from the time they're picked up by a club at age 7 or so. They work hard to be as good as they can and the best are selected for their national teams. If they refuse to play, their licence could be revoked as a sanction. Career over. Individual players don't choose where the competition is held. They are young men, and they may not care. They may care deeply but care about their career and their earnings for the rest of their lives. and everything in between. They might be homophobic twats who don't care about dead workers.

So there is no single line of thought (the Germans, typically, have a player committee who discussed and decided on the gesture they made, a yellow card could cock up their chances in the tournament, it's a risk that has consequences. - may not matter for them now anyway)

Nobody is perfect. Nobody can take a stand about everything. And even if you do take a stand, it doesn't have to be your hill to die on.

Usernamesarboring · 24/11/2022 10:55

PeekAtYou · 24/11/2022 09:20

I think it's ridiculous because men's football (in England at least) has an environment where players can't/won't come out.

It may not be perfect in England or other western countries but you cannot compare this to situation in Qatar where being gay is a punishable crime

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 10:54

What I'm shocked at is the lack of discourse over the environmental impact. Those outside air con units make me so angry.
this in spades.
And, yes, I do watch football.
and I've never said that support from Gay Rights is a 'silly western view'. Just RTFT. I just think that to try and export my views is imperialistic.

OP posts:
Getoff · 24/11/2022 10:52

toffeecrisps · 24/11/2022 00:09

You realise that that are non-white gay people too right? And that being gay isn't about anal sex?

What is the sentence in Qatar for "being gay", if that's a crime, and what is the sentence for "anal sex"?

Never mind, I've consulted wikipedia. It looks like it is anal sex, not "being gay" that is a problem for them.

Lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) people in Qatar face legal challenges not experienced by non-LGBT residents. Sexual acts of male homosexuality are illegal in Qatar, with a punishment of up to three years in prison and a fine and the possibility of a death penalty for Muslims under sharia law; however, there are no known cases where the death penalty was enforced for homosexuality.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_Qatar

Sausagenbacon · 24/11/2022 10:51

So you don't really believe in basic human rights. You don't really believe women are equal to men, just that we're allowed to be (more or less) in our society. You don't really believe homophobic oppression is a bad thing. Would you have campaigned for homosexuality to be legalised in the U.K. at a time when 'our culture' didn't subscribe to that? Would you have asserted women's rights when 'our culture' was firmly against them?
Of course I would, but then, I'm intelligent enough to know that culture is constantly evolving. and also that, just because I am from Britain doesn't make me entitled to demand others take on aspects of my culture that they might find abhorrent. Just because I hold something to be self-evident (Gay and Women's Rights) doesn't mean that I have the right to impose that opinion on others.
Would posters have whole-heartedly supported missionary workers in the 19th Century, who were prepared to sacrifice their health and sometimes life (no stupid armbands then) because they sincerely believed in the Christian message? Probably not. But they are espousing the same values.

OP posts:
Tigofigo · 24/11/2022 10:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This post stinks of homophobia

Brefugee · 24/11/2022 10:49

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
Do you regularly watch football, OP? We've been talking about All The Things since Qatar were awarded the event.

Footballers are people and can have various views on what is going on. The German team were photographed with their hands covering their mouths to indicate how they are being silenced.

Xhaka (god i love him playing football but he can say some daft things) says Football shouldn't be political (unless he's doing his Kosovo-Albanian symbols)