Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Argument with husband tonight

87 replies

colourPink · 23/11/2022 20:35

So my husband and I have a joint bank account where both of our wages go into the same account each month. We essentially earn the same (I do earn slightly more but my pension outtake is so high we take home about the same).

Today, my sister text me and asked me to borrow some money (£50) and I agreed. My husband is now fuming that I didn't check in with him about it and that I lent her money in the first place. He's super anti (and always has been) lending money and we've had a row about it as it's "our money". He's not wrong and we always check in before big purchases but this wasn't that to me.

I feel that I don't need his permission to spend my money. Of course it's our money but I should be able to do this without having to ask first. I also think that she is paying us back on Friday, so two days time. We will not miss that £50 in the next two days. I tried to explain to him that IF we were struggling or needed that money he would have a right to be annoyed but as long as she pays it back when it's due - what's the problem?

He feels that my sister has got herself in a financial mess and she's not our responsibility. She owes my other sister quite a substantial amount which she's paying back monthly. I told him that agreement is between the two of them and nothing to do with us. My sister is 45 and we're both 27 so he also feels like shes built this kind of life for herself and shouldn't even be asking us. I've always had the impression he doesn't particularly like her.

She's a single mum that wanted to go for dinner and drinks with her friends tonight - she doesn't go out much and I didn't want her to miss out. He doesn't know why I lent the money as he didn't ask but I know if I tell him he'll just be angrier as it wasn't even essential.

I hate that he's kicked off and stomped around like a toddler and I don't feel like I can back down as I genuinely didn't mind lending the money. We've had quite a heated argument about it so I'm feeling rubbish now.

But AIBU?

OP posts:
RealBecca · 23/11/2022 21:46

We've had a joint account for 6 years and it's never been a problem. It's what works for us so each to their own.

His only issue is lending the money to my sister - nothing else.

Well obviously it doesnt work now does it. So either back down and agree not to lend her money or do as many others have said and set up a seperate account for fun money that you can do what you want with.

notdaddycool · 23/11/2022 21:42

It might piss me off but we wouldn’t be having an argument about it.

Dotcheck · 23/11/2022 21:41

How come your husband thinks she has ‘ built her life?’

There is a lot of judgement on this thread- we have no idea what the sisters circumstances are, but everyone is assuming she is feckless.

There are many many threads on mumsnet about women being left with kids/ being responsible for childcare/ having fewer options for work. OP’s sister may be one of these.

OP- perhaps a discretionary amount where ‘no questions are asked’ would be useful

mumto2teenagers · 23/11/2022 21:39

If my sister asked to borrow £50 for 2 days then I wouldn't think twice about it, I definitely wouldn't ask DH's permission and we have a joint account. He probably wouldn't even notice, but I would mention it to him.

MsCactus · 23/11/2022 21:39

What me and my husband do is put most of our wages into a joint account for joint bills, then we have a few hundred pounds each in our personal accounts as spending money.

Completely avoids situations like this. You both should do the same

RhondaD · 23/11/2022 21:36

Aside from whether it should be discussed with him or not I do wonder if you are helping your sister in the long run by doing this just so that she can go out on the town when her poor management of money has already lead to her owing another sister a substantial amount of money. It is not really nurturing a responsible attitude toward money in her when she already owes one of you. Perhaps both sisters would be better off encouraging her to sort her priorities out.

Oysterbabe · 23/11/2022 21:29

I agree that you need your own accounts too. We have a joint account for bills and joint purchases and our own for personal spends. What I use that on is none of his business.

LadyJoannaScroop · 23/11/2022 21:28

My husband and I only ever had joint accounts, and didn't scrutinise them. However, I would not have been happy if he had lent money to a sibling who already owed a lot of money to another sibling, because I'd be wondering how much it would be next time, why his sibling couldn't manage her own money, etc, etc, etc. FWIW, I would have been very reluctant to lend money to one of my own siblings for a night out, if they had a history of borrowing money and being crap with finances.

MuggleMe · 23/11/2022 21:24

We have agreed monthly amount for spends which go into a personal account. Sounds like you need something similar assuming you're not spending all your combined income on essentials.

maeveiscurious · 23/11/2022 21:23

Joint account for bills etc, just set up your own and agree to pay over something each month.

It will avoid arguments

Shouldershoddy · 23/11/2022 21:23

Flamingogirl08 · 23/11/2022 21:10

Yanbu and I disagree with other posters who are sitting in judgement about the reason for needing the money. £50 for 2 days so your sister can have a bit of downtime with friends. No issue with that at all

Exactly this !

Moon22 · 23/11/2022 21:22

It would annoy me tbh. My experience with these people is that they always want to borrow more and more- and it gets out of hand. But that's why I don't put all my money in a joint account. Would you not consider having your own account?
I can see both sides, but not a huge deal if she pays you back friday on this occasion.

redflowerbluethorns · 23/11/2022 21:21

I'd be unhappy if my DH lent joint money to somebidy without checking with me first, especially if it was for non-essentials.
You should have separate accounts so that you can keep a small amount of spending money per month rather than use money from the joint account.

AllotmentTime · 23/11/2022 21:20

Who else has he been anti you loaning money to?
Because tbh his judgement sounds better than yours when it comes to this sister. Already in debt and trying to borrow more for non essentials does not exactly scream reliability and it’s understandable that he’s worried you might be the next cash cow.

colourPink · 23/11/2022 21:18

@bigfamilygrowingupfast interesting as this is how he feels. I'm just trying to take a step back and not let emotions take over!

If it was anything more than £50 I think I would have had a chat with him out of respect but as it'll be in our account in 48 hrs (hopefully lol) I didn't even think about it.

OP posts:
ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 23/11/2022 21:16

This is a major wake-up call.

It would be a cold day in hell before I'd ask anyone's permission to spend, lend or squander my own earnings.

You need to set up your own account. Each contribute X to the household account each month to cover outgoings, and then use the surplus as she/he sees fit.

colourPink · 23/11/2022 21:16

Just to clarify - he wasn't checking up on what I was spending, we have a joint account and when discussing what bills we still had to come out he noticed it as well as me telling him that had happened (we are very honest with each other).

I can assure you I am 100% my own woman and have 100% freedom to spend my money as I wish. The joint account is not the issue here.

We've had a joint account for 6 years and it's never been a problem. It's what works for us so each to their own.

His only issue is lending the money to my sister - nothing else. I'm not asking for opinions on how we distribute and store our money just on whether you think I should have checked in with him first. She's always skint and struggling FYI - this is not uncommon behaviour for her. I just don't usually lend her anything.

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 23/11/2022 21:12

I think having a ‘no lending from joint funds’ policy is OK.

I also think if you want to lend your sister money you should be able to do so, so you should each have some discretionary money every month that’s yours alone.

bigfamilygrowingupfast · 23/11/2022 21:12

I'd be absolutely furious if my DH had lent someone, family or not, money without talking to me first about it. Whether it was £10 or £10,000! It would be the same the other way round too. We have a joint account for bills etc, and then our own separate accounts for savings etc, but most purchases we discuss with each other

beAsensible1 · 23/11/2022 21:11

If she is reliable and will pay you back then thats fine.
A bit weird that he's questioning why you transferred £50 for anything really, i would start separating some of your money for yourself.

I also don't think its fair to judge your sister, if she's taken out a family loan (because thats what it is really, same as bank but no interest ) and is making payment weekly that is proving responsible behaviour. Maybe she's come up short at the end of the month and would like to participate with her mates for once.

Probably feeling really shitty that she has to ask her 27 year old sister for money as well. Help your family and tell him find something else to do other than judging your family.

Flamingogirl08 · 23/11/2022 21:10

Yanbu and I disagree with other posters who are sitting in judgement about the reason for needing the money. £50 for 2 days so your sister can have a bit of downtime with friends. No issue with that at all

CrystalCoco · 23/11/2022 21:10

You both earn and you both should be able to spend (within reason) on things of value to you - each will have different values and should essentially 'butt out' on each other's purchases / spends / whatever.

I suspect the dislike of your sister is what's causing this argument rather than the principle of lending 50 quid to be repaid in two days time.

sheepdogdelight · 23/11/2022 21:09

I wouldn't be keen if DH lent money for non-essentials to a family member who already owed money to another family money. If she can pay it back in 2 days, why not wait until then to go out?

But I suggest you each need some money that isn't joint money, and then you can spend it how you each wish.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 23/11/2022 21:04

I suspect the plan would be repay the first amount (and probably stir you up about how dare DH tell you what to do with your money) and then ask for more next time.

She's run out of funds from her latest mug (wonder if she's borrowed from other family or her own friends as well?) And she's now moved on to you.

CaptainMyCaptain · 23/11/2022 20:59

I wouldn't lend the money either but I'd make my own decision about it and not be told by DH.