Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Argument with husband tonight

87 replies

colourPink · 23/11/2022 20:35

So my husband and I have a joint bank account where both of our wages go into the same account each month. We essentially earn the same (I do earn slightly more but my pension outtake is so high we take home about the same).

Today, my sister text me and asked me to borrow some money (£50) and I agreed. My husband is now fuming that I didn't check in with him about it and that I lent her money in the first place. He's super anti (and always has been) lending money and we've had a row about it as it's "our money". He's not wrong and we always check in before big purchases but this wasn't that to me.

I feel that I don't need his permission to spend my money. Of course it's our money but I should be able to do this without having to ask first. I also think that she is paying us back on Friday, so two days time. We will not miss that £50 in the next two days. I tried to explain to him that IF we were struggling or needed that money he would have a right to be annoyed but as long as she pays it back when it's due - what's the problem?

He feels that my sister has got herself in a financial mess and she's not our responsibility. She owes my other sister quite a substantial amount which she's paying back monthly. I told him that agreement is between the two of them and nothing to do with us. My sister is 45 and we're both 27 so he also feels like shes built this kind of life for herself and shouldn't even be asking us. I've always had the impression he doesn't particularly like her.

She's a single mum that wanted to go for dinner and drinks with her friends tonight - she doesn't go out much and I didn't want her to miss out. He doesn't know why I lent the money as he didn't ask but I know if I tell him he'll just be angrier as it wasn't even essential.

I hate that he's kicked off and stomped around like a toddler and I don't feel like I can back down as I genuinely didn't mind lending the money. We've had quite a heated argument about it so I'm feeling rubbish now.

But AIBU?

OP posts:
SkylightSkylight · 23/11/2022 22:59

ConnieTucker · 23/11/2022 22:50

Because she owes her other sister a lot of money yet borrowed more to go out with friends. Of course that is feckless.

@ConnieTucker

No, it's not necessarily feckless, otherwise everyone with a loan, car on loan, mortgage etc is also feckless. She has an agreement with someone else & is paying them back k. That's completely separate to borrowing £50 off the OP.

Rosie22xx · 23/11/2022 22:58

I recommend you both have sole accounts. Have your wages in your own account. Keep the Joint for bills only and both transfer the same amount from sole to joint every month to cover the bills. You do not need to justify what you spend your money on. Just causing arguments and is very controlling behaviour on his part.

SkylightSkylight · 23/11/2022 22:54

I can assure you I am 100% my own woman and have 100% freedom to spend my money as I wish. The joint account is not the issue here

@colourPink
just think about this ^. You clearly do NOT have the freedom to spend money from the joint count as you wish.

you're right, the joint account isn't the problem here, the problem is your DH who has 'told you off' for lending £50 to your sister. If you were struggling to buy food/pay the rent etc then I could understand him being pissed off, but you're not. YOU have earned that money, you can lend it to whoever you want to, hell, you could give it away to the local dogs home if you wanted.

ConnieTucker · 23/11/2022 22:50

Dotcheck · 23/11/2022 21:41

How come your husband thinks she has ‘ built her life?’

There is a lot of judgement on this thread- we have no idea what the sisters circumstances are, but everyone is assuming she is feckless.

There are many many threads on mumsnet about women being left with kids/ being responsible for childcare/ having fewer options for work. OP’s sister may be one of these.

OP- perhaps a discretionary amount where ‘no questions are asked’ would be useful

Because she owes her other sister a lot of money yet borrowed more to go out with friends. Of course that is feckless.

Jenny3412 · 23/11/2022 22:45

He’s being soooo annoying. You can always say it’s an early Christmas present 🎁 and you did not want her to miss out on a good time.

mediumbrownmug · 23/11/2022 22:44

Meant to add— if he’s against lending in general, substitute “loan” for “gift” in these small amounts. Very good luck to you, OP.

mediumbrownmug · 23/11/2022 22:40

I think that, given your financial arrangements seem to work for you both and he doesn’t normally question your spending, your DH is likely concerned about you lending money to your sister when he feels there’s a possibility that she might struggle to pay it back. He may worry that it could cause family friction, he may not be able to articulate why he has a weird feeling about it, he may not know your sister or her financial situation as well as you do— there are plenty of reasons why he might be feeling “off” about it but have a hard time putting it into words. But, as in any healthy relationship, the words should be found.

Since he’s usually fine about money, I’d give him the benefit of the doubt. If all he wants is to be made aware of these loans (not prevent them) and you’re not uncomfortable with that, I’d just make sure to tell him when you do it in the future. If you are uncomfortable with that, I’d tell him so and suggest an amount/frequency over which you should make each other aware.

Dotcheck · 23/11/2022 22:35

gogohmm · 23/11/2022 22:19

I'm kind of with him, at 45 you shouldn't be needing to help her out, yes in an emergency but this was for drinks.

She really needs to sit down with a debt counsellor to help her learn to budget

Gosh that’s patronising.

Perhaps going out is not/ should not be a priority. However- plenty of people are on low incomes , or have high rent/ childcare costs, and no amount of debt counselling will help.

healthadvice123 · 23/11/2022 22:32

Why your sister wants to borrow money and what she owes is irrelevant really as you had a choice to say no.
But why pool all your money and not just pool it for bills etc , then you each have own spending of which you can do what you like
I wouldn't want to be told what I can spend my money on
Different if bill money etc

Mojoj · 23/11/2022 22:27

Whether your sister pays you back or not, or whether or not you should have lent her the money, it's none of his business. And get separate accounts. I never understand why couples have a joint account. No man has ever told me what I can do with the money I've earned.

Onnabugeisha · 23/11/2022 22:26

Since your DH is fine with everything except giving money to your elder sister who is old enough to be your mother, I think this isn’t a financial control issue at all.

And given the context of a 40 something sister that owes a substantial sum to another sister and she wanted £50 to go out drinking on a Wednesday night….but apparently will have the money by Friday. I think your DH is right to be concerned and wanted to have a say in this because you have set a precedent of being willing to spot her £50 if she feels like going on a drinking spree midweek because it’s hump day. It wasn’t for anything necessary at all. She didn’t need the money. You may be enabling alcoholism for all we know. I am sure she will be back asking for more money.

dapsnotplimsolls · 23/11/2022 22:24

How confident are you that you'll actually get this money back in 2 days?

gogohmm · 23/11/2022 22:19

I'm kind of with him, at 45 you shouldn't be needing to help her out, yes in an emergency but this was for drinks.

She really needs to sit down with a debt counsellor to help her learn to budget

RhondaD · 23/11/2022 22:19

mumto2teenagers · 23/11/2022 22:13

Yes, from what OP has said, she is paying her other sister back monthly and that is between them. I wouldn't care what she wanted the money for and I would be happy for her to use it on a night out. If I needed the money before she was planning on paying it back then it might be different, but if I wasn't planning on spending it before Friday then I don't see any reason not to.

You don't think it might set up an unhealthy dynamic of regular borrowing from both siblings then? That would be my concern that it wont be a one off as 8 said I certainly wouldn't feel I had to discuss it with my DH but I would be questioning the necessity of it.

RhondaD · 23/11/2022 22:16

rwalker · 23/11/2022 22:03

I’m with him your lending your sister who has form for not paying it back £50 to her out on the piss

if it was for food or electric I wouldn’t mind but going out on the piss it a no

This agreed for essential needs yes. To go out on the piss with mates when already owing other sister a shed load of money no. I think she has her priorities all wrong here. Especially leaning on the younger sister to subsidise a boozy night out

mumto2teenagers · 23/11/2022 22:13

RhondaD · 23/11/2022 21:53

Even if she already owed your other sister a substantial amount of money and just wanted it to go out on the lash with her mates?

Yes, from what OP has said, she is paying her other sister back monthly and that is between them. I wouldn't care what she wanted the money for and I would be happy for her to use it on a night out. If I needed the money before she was planning on paying it back then it might be different, but if I wasn't planning on spending it before Friday then I don't see any reason not to.

Whenisthisgoingtoend · 23/11/2022 22:08

I’d do it too if my sister was a single mum and never asked you for anything before.
She has an agreement to pay back monthly with your sibling, which I assume is happening without any problems.

Being on her own (presuming she has children) or not, and on a tight budget and wanting time out with her friends is understandable.
Your DH is not at all sympathetic in this situation.
If all above is correct he’s not in her position and can’t relate. 🤷‍♀️

Your a good sister helping her 👍

rwalker · 23/11/2022 22:03

I’m with him your lending your sister who has form for not paying it back £50 to her out on the piss

if it was for food or electric I wouldn’t mind but going out on the piss it a no

user627494927 · 23/11/2022 22:03

In answer to your actual question I think you are not being unreasonable.

if you had discussed it with him then he would have shot you down straight away and made it clear he did not agree to lending money. But realistically who is he to demand how money is spent by you when the ampunt is insignificant in the bigger picture. Basically, an argument would have ensued regardless of asking him before or afterwards. He sets precedent by not having an opinion on any other spending you do.

Your husband is hugely unfair towards your sister. Her circumstance are nothing to do with him and plenty of people end up in similar situations like your sister due to reasons out of their control. I think you did the right thing to allow your sister some fun. So many people struggling right now and to have the opportunity to enjoy yourself is much needed. Good for you for being a good sister. Your husband, however, needs a lesson in empathy and care/understanding for others.

ComfortablyDazed · 23/11/2022 22:01

Clearly it’s your sister that’s the sticking point, not the fact that you lent someone a small amount of money.

So she ‘needed’ it to go out with mates for drinks? She literally doesn’t have £50 to her name? But - will in two days’ time….?

And she’s mid-40s, while you’re in your 20s and subsidising her…?

She sounds like she needs to take a bit of a look at her priorities. I’m not surprised he’s not a big fan.

Why not just go out with the mates in a couple of days’ time or next week - when she has the money for it…?

Otherwise, it’s a case of - because she wants to go out, she gets to go out? Most people over the age of 19 have to balance wanting to go out with being able to afford it, or having other things the money might be better directed towards. Hmm

superdupernova · 23/11/2022 21:57

mumto2teenagers · 23/11/2022 21:39

If my sister asked to borrow £50 for 2 days then I wouldn't think twice about it, I definitely wouldn't ask DH's permission and we have a joint account. He probably wouldn't even notice, but I would mention it to him.

My older sister.. no, my DH Wouldn't question it at all or even care if the money came back. She's sensible but struggling and wouldn't ask unless it was needed. My younger (but still well into her 30s sister) who is feckless with money and constantly in debt? My DH absolutely would question it if I expected the money back. Hell would freeze over before she got on top of her debts so it would be a question of my sanity rather than generosity.

RyanReno · 23/11/2022 21:57

50% of the money in that account is yours, and you can do what you want with it.

He has very valid points, but doesn't have a leg to stand on trying to tell you how YOU spend YOUR money. As long as the bills are paid, you have everything you need as a family, then anything on top of that you can spend how you wish, and him likewise.

My husband is very funny about lending people money, it's came up a few times where I've said what do you think and he's said no. However, if I chose to lend someone money because that was a decision I'd made he wouldnt argue it with me, he would just say he wouldn't have lent them it.

MrsClatterbuck · 23/11/2022 21:55

determinedtomakethiswork · 23/11/2022 21:49

So if your husband was at work and someone needed to borrow £10 to get home because they had forgotten their wallet or something, you'd be furious?

Was thinking this as well. Bit controlling is it not.

RhondaD · 23/11/2022 21:53

mumto2teenagers · 23/11/2022 21:39

If my sister asked to borrow £50 for 2 days then I wouldn't think twice about it, I definitely wouldn't ask DH's permission and we have a joint account. He probably wouldn't even notice, but I would mention it to him.

Even if she already owed your other sister a substantial amount of money and just wanted it to go out on the lash with her mates?

determinedtomakethiswork · 23/11/2022 21:49

bigfamilygrowingupfast · 23/11/2022 21:12

I'd be absolutely furious if my DH had lent someone, family or not, money without talking to me first about it. Whether it was £10 or £10,000! It would be the same the other way round too. We have a joint account for bills etc, and then our own separate accounts for savings etc, but most purchases we discuss with each other

So if your husband was at work and someone needed to borrow £10 to get home because they had forgotten their wallet or something, you'd be furious?